News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by michaelchisari on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:41PM (#2734976)
Given their social networking dominance, their swimming pools filled with vc money, and the top engineers working for them, does anyone else feel like Facebook are underachievers?

Considering they had to have known about G+ for a while before it launched, you would think they would really hit something out of the park in terms of competitive features. These are all pretty lackluster, imho.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by wccrawford on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:43PM (#2734986)
G+ launched with Group video chat (in the Hangouts feature) with no fanfare at all, as it if was nothing.

FB's announcement today has spent a lot of time talking about how much work it was to implement...

It's got to be a huge kick in the pants to them. I kind of feel bad for them.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kenjackson on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:59PM (#2735063)
Apple does this every release. Marketing is important.

Facebook is now the ubiquitous video chat social network, built on Skype. Google+ is Circles on your Gmail. Everything else you say requires some level of convincing.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by nextparadigms on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:14PM (#2735149)
Except that Hangout is a lot more social than the Facebook/Skype integration. Google+ has out-social'ed Facebook.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by bonch on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @05:01PM (#2735872)
"A lot more social" is pretty vague.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by sunchild on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:26PM (#2735205)
Facebook is showing the signs of its alliance to Microsoft in more ways than one here.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kenjackson on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:27PM (#2735213)
I see one way (using Skype, although apparently that started some time ago). What are the other ways?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by cryptoz on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:50PM (#2735329)
Downloading .exe files to Linux computers seems to be a very Microsofty thing to do.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kenjackson on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:08PM (#2735395)
I SERIOUSLY doubt MS was giving them architectural guidance on how to make this work. Probably would have more to do with the architectural experience of the devs.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by cryptoz on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:18PM (#2735425)
I wasn't suggesting that MS told them to do that. To my knowledge, this first time that Facebook has left the Web and launched a feature only available to specific OSs by way of desktop applications.

Remember that this video chat is not a web page. It's a Microsoft (and Apple? I don't know) desktop application that integrates into their web page.

I'm suggesting that Facebook is showing their alliance to Microsoft by ignoring some other OSs and launching Microsoft-powered features. If you include video chat as an integral part of Facebook, then you can no longer call Facebook a web site.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kenjackson on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:21PM (#2735436)
Thanks. That wasn't clear from your earlier post (and I didn't know that this was a desktop app either).
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by cryptoz on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:23PM (#2735446)
:) To be fair, G+'s Hangouts is also currently a desktop app (requires the Gtalk plugin I think). I suspect Google will move away from that and go towards a full web page. We'll see. This is all so exciting.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by shoota on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:34PM (#2735491)
Yes but they at least provide the appropriate plugin for Linux users.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by cryptoz on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:36PM (#2735499)
Yep! I was Hanging Out on Ubuntu with 6 friends on about day 2 of G+. Facebook doesn't even support my OS, so there's absolutely 0 chance I'll use their video chat.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by contextfree on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @05:58PM (#2736115)
Did Google show their alliance to Microsoft when they released Chrome for Windows well ahead of other platforms?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by sunchild on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:19PM (#2735670)
Things I see them both doing: playing catch-up, stumbling on user experience, appealing to the lowest common denominator rather than the leading edge.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kin on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:09PM (#2735124)
Hangouts is group video. Huddle is group text chats, which for some reason is mobile only and has no web interface. No one uses it 'cause not everyone has an Android device.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by wccrawford on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:26PM (#2735203)
I meant group video chat. Thanks for catching that. I've updated my comment.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by yhlasx on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:47PM (#2735315)
I've used this video chat feature, well, looks like something done in hurry. Quality kind of sucks
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by ssclafani on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:55PM (#2735046)
Facebook doesn't need to have competitive features they only need to have comparative features. Google+ has video chat, now Facebook does. It doesn't matter that Hangout is better. People don't switch social networks based on any single feature.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by vannevar on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:25PM (#2735196)
Facebook didn't have to be very good when their main competitors were MySpace and Friendster, two poster children for incompetence who blew early leads in quick succession while at times appearing to be run by circus clowns. Fortunately for Facebook success is relative: for a site whose primary purpose is to manage your social network it's been sorely lacking in any credible tools to manage social networks. Facebook is basically Geocities with comments and photo-sharing. Now Zuck and Co are going to actually have to put some thought into it.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by Apocryphon on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:29PM (#2735221)
One of the reasons for FB's victory was that its design is staid, standard, but stable compared to the script injection nightmare that MySpace's customization turned into. For all of Zuckerberg's youthful personality (at least as portrayed by the media), it almost feels like Facebook has had a dry corporate juggernaut type ethos from the beginning. FB didn't so much innovate as much as it dominated by creating a cleaner, better-ordered social network. No wonder its color scheme is big blue.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by adrianwaj on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:13PM (#2735409)
FB became quite awesome when they integrated Friendfeed's technology and the stream became quick and much more transparent in terms of usability.

At the same time, when Buzz came out, it was even faster and cleaner. Just not placed in the right context. There must have been some lessons and technology learned from Buzz.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by tesseract on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @11:52PM (#2737070)
I agree with what you said, but: remember when the Facebook "Wall" was just a graffiti wall, a big text box that any of your friends could edit?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by michaelchisari on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:57PM (#2735056)
Do you really think that attitude will allow them to maintain their dominance?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:57PM (#2735350)
IMO it won't be their tech or attitude that will bring an eventual end to their dominance but shear fashion. Trend following. If Google position themselves and look cool and capture the "cool kids" then FB will lose out to them (to some extent). FB is already getting a little taint, it's run a good innings in internet time.

Whichever, G+ or FB, manages to capture the buzz of "hangouts with famous people" will probably take the current round. This to me is the iteration of one of Twitter's big wins; the chance to rub shoulders with "stars".

For me, and I suspect most here, such things don't really matter. I'll stay with FB as long as most of my friends are there and it works reasonably well.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rapind on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:19PM (#2735427)
This.

I sent my wife the intro link for Google+ when they launched and she couldn't even be bothered to check it out. Why? Because everyone she knows is on facebook.

If her friends move, then she'll move. It'll probably annoy her to have to switch too.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by muuh-gnu on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:12PM (#2735645)
> If her friends move, then she'll move.

And every of her friends will move if the other friends move, etc. But in reality, it is enough if only one of her friends, the most influential one moves, and then all the worker bees will follow.

> Because everyone she knows is on facebook.

But why is everyone on facebook in the first place? Because one of them, the group leader, the early adopter, the trend setter, decided first, then the rest passively followed. If the trend setter again decides to go G+, the effort to move off Facebook will be less then losing the queen bee, so they will follow again.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rapind on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:12PM (#2736561)
I totally agree.

I'm wondering what made the group leaders adopt? Was it features? Trendy name and logo? Did it seem like the hip thing to do? Exclusivity / scarcity?

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by salemh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:37AM (#2737322)
Large marketing firms dedicate resources to finding "trend setters" and "cool kids". http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8...

Older video: "Merchants of Cool" http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/cool/

Or look at a Goog search "marketing trendsetters | "trend-setter"

Lots of noise. The Merchants of Cool is a good relevant watch.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rapind on Thursday July 07, 2011 @05:45PM (#2740449)
I heard about that "Merchants of Cool" video but never got around to watching. Thanks for the reminder, it's back near the top of my TODOs.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by grandalf on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:05PM (#2735101)
What do you think Facebook should have built/announced?

Pretty much all of the really useful features are also big privacy violators, and with the uncertainty around how the public views social networking privacy, FB is smart to wait and let Google make the first move.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by nextparadigms on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:11PM (#2735140)
Those who don't innovate, fall behind. Who was it that said companies kill themselves, and it's not the competitors that do it?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by kin on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:08PM (#2735116)
You know logic says they won't be able to maintain their dominance but history shows that things don't always follow logically. It's going to be super interesting what plays out next.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by pvarangot on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:04PM (#2735098)
I think the proper question should be "For how long do you really think that attitude will allow them to maintain their dominance?". Maybe Facebook is in the positions where playing catch-up is good enough for them in the midterm.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by brudgers on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:17PM (#2735166)
>"It doesn't matter that Hangout is better."

From a technical implementation perspective maybe Hangout is better. However, from a social networking perspective 3/4 of a billion Skype users is clearly better. And from a marketing perspective, giving Skype users worldwide a reason to choose Facebook over competing products is brilliant.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by joelrunyon on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:45PM (#2735302)
The presentation seemed a little lackluster. It's like FB + Skype were planning a big surprise and then Google dropped a bigger one with G+ last week and FB/Skype were left standing, shouting "us too!" but with a smaller product + feature set.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by jdp23 on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:31PM (#2735481)
great summary, you nailed both the content and the tone
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by benbscholz on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:43PM (#2734989)
The video features built into gchat have served my needs perfectly. Between hangouts & youtube video sharing, I think google+ is out-shining them at this point in time.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rokhayakebe on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:05PM (#2735100)
The video features built into gchat have served my needs perfectly

1) The average person knows more people on Facebook, then people with a Gmail account.

2) You, and your other geeky friends live in Gmail. The rest of the world lives inside Facebook.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by Ryanmf on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:12PM (#2735408)
The rest of the world lives inside Facebook.

For now.

To me, there's exactly one compelling thing about Facebook: It illustrated that normal humans will join and use a social network.

Beyond that, I don't see any reason why their adoption patterns will differ from those we've already seen with other humans on other "social" web properties (Hi Livejournal/Facethejury/Friendster et al!). Which is to say, the enthusiastic folks eventually get those who joined begrudgingly involved, everyone has fun for a while, then everyone gets bored and moves on.

It's not as if nerds who have SRS PRIVACY CONCERNZ and talk about things like data portability are the only people growing weary of Facebook. An approximate majority of the musicians/DJs/artists I know in real life and on the internet say they hate Facebook but maintain an account for promotional purposes. But they all seem to have really warmed up to Twitter. (Specifically, most in the music crowd seem to have adopted a combination of Twitter and Soundcloud as their primary internet residencies, filling the void where MySpace once resided.)

To assume that Facebook will remain the social network of note just because they're Facebook, or just because they got there first (sort of) seems naïve.

The network effect will be the primary driver of where we all—geeks and normies alike—end up next. Facebook doesn't really have any control over that. And we've seen that the network effect can linger even after the product has effectively failed (Hi MySpace!), so having the network now may not be a reliable indicator that they'll keep it, even in the very near term.

And that leaves the product. Which is fine, I guess. Not that bad, not that great. But when Google announces their first real crack at a genuine social network and it has features no one's even talked about yet, and it's cooked directly into their mobile platform running on about 180 Mm devices worldwide [1][2], Facebook's "awesome" reply, "We've got video chat now," falls flat. To me at least.

[1] http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=1622614 [2] Android/Google+ and some of the new iOS 5 features along with Apple's Twitter partnership have me semi-convinced that we're moving towards the transparent social network, where membership has much more to do with which smartphone you buy than anything else. I predict that in a competition with Google and Apple/Twitter, Microsoft/Facebook will turn out to be also-rans. Also, poor RIM.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rokhayakebe on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:25PM (#2735457)
Livejournal/Facethejury/Friendster

These never reached the audience Facebook has today. 750M users and growing, FB won social networking. Game over.

It's not as if nerds who have SRS PRIVACY CONCERNZ and talk about things like data portability are the only people growing weary of Facebook.

I guarantee you this is a very tiny portion. I live with someone who spends lots of time on FB ("Oh, look at this pictures from XYZ"). They don't even know there is a discussion going around privacy.

To assume that Facebook will remain the social network of note just because they're Facebook, or just because they got there first (sort of) seems naïve.

It will just as Microsoft has dominated the OS space. Another desktop OS is not going to kill MSFT, but maybe mobile will. Same for FB, it will take a different experience to get people to stop spending as much time on the site. Something like Instagram or With with a few added features/mechanisms.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by Ryanmf on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:04PM (#2735612)
I don't have the time this afternoon to find hard stats on this, but if you were to plot active userbase over total internet users worldwide for, lets say, AIM & Livejournal c.2004, Friendster c.2006, MySpace c.2008, and Facebook and Twitter currently, I suspect Facebook would appear much less the unstoppable force/immovable object you're making it out to be.

I'm acquainted with hundreds of people like your roommate, and I'm aware that normal people don't give a shit about our geeky critiques of Facebook. What I was trying to communicate is that they likely won't bail on Facebook for those reasons, but they might because there are too many annoying people on Fb, or they don't want to get Faceskyped by their mom, or something that's more interesting or lower friction comes along, or other people move for a variety of reasons and they just follow.

FB won social networking. Game over.

I hate to put it this way, but what are you doing on HN? Seriously. I thought we'd all read The Innovator's Dillema. Nobody wins anything for long, the game's never over. That's sort of the point of capitalism.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rokhayakebe on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:33PM (#2736456)
I hate to put it this way, but what are you doing on HN? Seriously.

I apologize if I offended you, Ryan. All I am asking for is for an example of one company that had reach the sort of mass FB has (coupled with a total dominance in its vertical)and ended up loosing to a competitor. Enlighten me.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by wonnage on Thursday July 07, 2011 @03:37AM (#2737627)
Yahoo
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rokhayakebe on Thursday July 07, 2011 @03:12PM (#2739883)
Yahoo was a portal that was made "irrelevant" by Google. Google was not in the portal business. This is what happens when a company comes in and changes user behavior. In other words Google did not build a better portal, they build something that made portals irrelevant over time.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by matwood on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:44PM (#2735802)
FB won social networking. Game over.

Youngsters today and the lack of history being taught in schools. History is full of winners, who after a period of time became losers (or at least not the same level of winning).

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by muuh-gnu on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:19PM (#2735429)
So what is your point exactly? That the only reason people will stay on Facebook is that they already are on Facebook? By this logic they never would have gotten on Facebook in the first place, because Facebook started out empty, and everybody already was somwhere else, say MySpace, and ICQ/AIM/YIM/MSN before that.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by rokhayakebe on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:36PM (#2736468)
So what is your point exactly? That the only reason people will stay on Facebook is that they already are on Facebook

Yes. Your neighbor's mama was never on Myspace, ICQ, AIM, YIM, MSN, and chances are she is not on Gmail video chatting.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by jarek on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:24PM (#2735450)
I'm not convinced. I caught up with a couple of friends recently, not the geekiest crowd, but all but one have Android devices. The Android owners now live in googleverse, and none are on Facebook more often than they check their gmail. I also know a fair amount of people who check Facebook once a week or rarer. My aunt, who is just discovering that she can forward me funny pictures via email, contacts me from her Yahoo account. The rest of the world? Not quite.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by smackfu on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:00PM (#2735075)
The bigger question is still whether people will actually use these things. Where people means greater than 5% of the userbase.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by MartinCron on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:15PM (#2735158)
Facebook just works pretty darn well, though. The application is almost always responsive, it's extremely polished, and it's always getting a bit stronger in what it offers.

If that's underachieving, sign me up.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by RobAtticus on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:07PM (#2735387)
You're a lucky one I guess, or I'm unlucky. Facebook has constant little issues, whether it's just plain slow, the back button doesn't do anything, clicking a link doesn't do anything, chat is always on the fritz, or some other annoyance.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by clarkbox on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:25PM (#2735195)
"Facebook just works pretty darn well" i guess you have never interacted with their platform/api?
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by MartinCron on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:32PM (#2735241)
Shallow api integration (like button, send button) just works pretty darn well.

You are correct, though. I, along with most people who use facebook, haven't had to do any deeper platform/api integration.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by ipince on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:46PM (#2735811)
I certainly does _not_ work pretty darn well. A couple examples of high-impact bugs:

- Repeated posts in the news feed. The first ~10 posts or so in the news feed are repeated as you scroll down.

- In the news feed, if I see and play a video, it plays. Great. If I continue going down the feed and then click on a photo, it goes into the "theater" mode, and for some obscure reason, it plays the video again (except I cannot see it; I can only hear it). The only way to stop it is to exit theater mode. This keeps happening over and over again every time I enter theater mode. I am then forced to refresh the entire page if I want to see some pictures without distracting noise in the background.

These are just a couple examples; there are many more. After talking to some friends, it seems I'm not the only one experiencing them. Now, nobody's perfect. It's OK if these bugs got into production for a few days or even weeks before getting fixed. But it's been months now... For a company full of brilliant engineers, that is unacceptable.

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by smackfu on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @05:28PM (#2735961)
Yes, it's odd. I agree with you, from my perspective, Facebook has 100% uptime and virtually no bugs. It's as good as Google (maybe better since GMail is often crappy for me.) It's clear that others see very different things. I wonder what the difference is?

(Now the Facebook iPhone app is really buggy, I will give you that.)

Re:Facebook's Three New Products by masterzora on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:42PM (#2735522)
I'm curious as to what set of the features you use, because I seem to have chosen a set with the opposite experience: responsiveness is often spotty, polish is lacking, and the offering seems to be getting weaker if anything. That said, maybe the new offerings will help fix some of that, but I'm not particularly sanguine.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by phillco on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:23PM (#2735191)
Facebook's quality seems to be directly linked to their need to acquire users. When they started out they were excellent — I remember being very impressed that a social network could be this nice. Now that everyone uses them, they have no hunger for quality.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by nextparadigms on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:10PM (#2735130)
I've always thought Facebook was a mediocre looking product at best.
Re:Facebook's Three New Products by goatforce5 on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:10PM (#2735134)
You can call 'em what you want, but I imagine running the second most popular site in the world must feel pretty good.