You identified the reasons of outflows and neglected to identify the reasons of inflows, or the magnitude of either.
Any supply and demand system is negative sum by your standard.
Remember to always ask “Did I just make a separate fictional higher standard for an asset class just because I don't like it?” If you create a criteria for crypto assets that no commodity, currency, equity, or property can meet, the question is why? Is it ignorance or intentional?
This is not the case commodities, currencies, equities or property. Those things have value outside of the market itself, while cryptocurrencies basically do not. They are in practice only used for trading.
If not, can you give it to me as it apparently has no value?
That's not necessarily true. It's the same as the stock market. I could buy a stock or crypto token/coin for $1 and sell it for $2, while the person I bought it from paid less than $1 and the person who bought it from me sold it for more than $2. In other words, all three of us made money.
There's also the possibility that the other two parties lost money. But there's nothing unethical about buying something for a price someone is willing to sell it for or selling at a price where someone else is willing to buy it. I mean, not unless you think capitalism as a whole is unethical.
Yes, the three of you made money, but you're forgetting about the fourth investor. The fourth investor won't make money until a fifth investor comes and buys the coin. And so on, and so on. The revenue received by each investor always comes from a subsequent investor. So the OP was right. This is not true of stocks, as stocks do generate income.
I didn't forget. That fourth investor is not part of my transaction. The point of my comment was that OP's claim that all crypto profits come from someone else's pocket is false. Just like non-dividend stocks, sometimes that's true, and sometimes it's not. As I stated, it's possible that my seller and buyer could lose money too. The same is true for stocks.
> This is not true of stocks, as stocks do generate income.
Yes, dividend stocks generate income for their investors, but not all stocks pay dividends. On that note, some crypto coins/tokens pay distributions and interest too (let's call them dividend crypto for simplicity). Are non-dividend stocks equal to non-dividend crypto? In both cases, profit can only be realized by the investor when the share/coin/token price goes up. Is that ok? I think any Capitalist should say yes.
I'm not advocating for stocks or crypto, but there are some similarities that we have to acknowledge to avoid hypocrisy.
Yes, but your comment didn't contradict the OP's claim. The fact that an investor in cryptocurrency may not make a profit doesn't contradict the claim that all profits made by crypto investors come from later crypto investors.
And this is only similar to stocks superficially. Yes, some stocks don't generate an income, but a stock is claim on the company's equity and non-distributed profits are automatically integrated into equity. In a well-functioning market, the market price of the stock will adjust accordingly. Therefore it makes no difference whether the profits are distributed or not. What makes a difference is whether the underlying business is profitable. This is not to say that the stock market isn't susceptible to bubbles and speculation. Of course it is, but what sustains a stock's value is not speculation but an underlying business activity.
I mean, you can buy a business with a coin, or you can buy an investment product, but that wouldn't be the coin.
Whenever someone buys a stock someone else sells it, one's loss is the other's gain. That would make it zero sum but the company has the option to issue new shares, akin to the fed printing money or a new bitcoin being minted in a block, that makes both games positive sum.
For cryptocurrencies, there is no such underlying value.
Cryptocurrencies are essentially distributed ponzi schemes (which are also illegal), with a side order of immense waste of electricity, waste of advanced manufactured goods, and enablement of ransomware.
Its getting to the point now where we need to begin contacting our democratic representatives and requesting that they ban them, and submitting citizen's petitions and direct ballot actions.
The problem, to me, isn't that people are allowed to invest their money freely in digital markets (regardless of asset). The problem is that so much money has been injected into assets that people feel (correctly) that they are falling behind if they don't try to play the game. The hidden inflation tax really harms people who lack a high degree of financial literacy or who lack the discipline required to make balanced, long term investments (i.e. a vast majority of people). For most of human history, saving was the key to building upper middle class wealth. Now, good luck with that as M2 grows by 20+% in a year and CD's are paying record low interest rates.
I think the problem is rather the fact that many people have unrealistic expectations. If the economy is growing at a rate of 1% annually, meaning the entire wealth produced in the country during a whole year grows by 1%, why do people think that their personal wealth should grow by 10%, 20%, 30% or more? It's not gonna happen.
Asset inflation benefits the wealthy, while bear markets improve wealth inequality, and printing money and QE reduces the corrective measure to wealth inequality to instead reduce the short term pain [1]. Consumer inflation is a tossup.
[0] https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/gasoline-prices-adjust... [1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/dataviz/dfa/distr...
Okay, then what is it? Obviously you have taken the trouble to measure inflation because you know it's not 2%. So tell us, what is the inflation rate? And show us your calculations please.
Cryptocurrency is a negative-sum game. There is an inflow of cash into the markets, and two outflows: Regular traders cashing out, and miners cashing out. The market caps, the supposed dollar value of your holdings, it is all imaginary. The only thing that is real is money being paid in, and money going out.
And unless you sell and take your profits, that outflow is not going to you. It is going to someone else. And if you do, the money comes from somebody less fortunate.
The only ethical thing is to not get involved.