News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by mikecane on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @06:52AM (#2733313)
Everyone hailed Minitel in the 1980s. It was touted as an example of what gov't should do (these were also the days of Japan, Inc. kicking everyone's ass, also showing what gov't "should" do for industry). Yet along came the Black Swan of the Internet to slay it. Central planning never works.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by LaGrange on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:50AM (#2733438)
Except the cases where central planning works, like (DUH!) Minitel (until the internet came, it didn't fail, it just got upgraded, duh), going to the Moon (distributed attempt at reaching the moon, also known as the living pyramid), justice system (as soon as you introduce the ability for appeal), the Internet, DNS system (it may be not centralized, but it is centrally planned), Google, Apple, and your own consciousness.

Central planning never works.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by randallsquared on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:15AM (#2733501)
[...] and your own consciousness.

I can't tell if the "central planning" you refer to with respect to consciousness is supposed to be a homunculus or an intelligent designer, but either way I disagree.

Brains are pretty well distributed, and various degrees and kinds of brain damage have shown that no specific location is an inherently privileged "command center" of the brain; [different] people have continued to be thinking people without each part of it.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by LaGrange on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:53AM (#2733641)
I agree, I actually meant "central planning" as in "your behavior is centrally planned by your brain". "Consciousness" was a pretty awkwardly chosen word, obviously.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by iwwr on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @09:31AM (#2733766)
The problem is not that central planning fails to build a certain thing (like a bridge or a road), but that it diverts resources from more productive uses. Things that are built or created are visible, but they obscure the things that might have been created otherwise. We never actually get to know the ways resources might have been allocated otherwise; and indeed these other things may be mundane and boring, yet they are the consequence of the free choices of individuals.

Of course, it can be argued that governments don't just do investments, that they can provide services that may be impossible to obtain otherwise. But when we wonder into real investment territory (like a particular bridge), we have to be able to produce a R.O.I.

What we have to consider is that the alternative uses of the capital will contribute to economic growth and in a longer timeframe, the glamorous visible things like a space program may actually pay for themselves. Not only that, these expenditures will be self-sustaining and long lasting. Or otherwise said, money spent on space (and other visible things) without a R.O.I. is actually detracting from future growth and delaying actual practical space exploration.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Duff on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @10:49AM (#2734125)
Problem is the wrong word. It's different.

In central planning, the dynamics are different. Whomever influences the planners ultimately makes the decisions. The quality of those decisions depends on your perspective and the motivation of the influencers.

In a pure capitalist model, you follow the money. Whomever has money influences the decisions.

There's no right or wrong answer. Oftentimes valuable things appear as unintended consequences of government or commercial projects.

It's hard to declare the internet to not be an example of central planning -- it was built to connect Federally funded labs at universities with Federal dollars. The labs existed to provide (indirectly or directly) research to serve defense and space (which i consider to be a subset of defense) interests.

The difference between the French thing and the Internet is that key stakeholders in the government and academia saw the potential of computer networks as a driver of commerce at an opportune time. If that conclusion was made in 1978, we'd have the French thing on a terminal leased from AT&T or a baby bell.

Equating a telecom system to a railroad, bridge, road, etc from a government POV was a big leap -- but the timing was probably more important and less obvious.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @11:20AM (#2734271)
More productive is subjective. There is a lot of private capital spent on inane stuff.

Also "central planning" is too broad a stroke. Are we talking about national central planning, i.e. government programs or are we also going to include central planning in corporate hierarchies, household hierarchies, software design or even things like activities directors in retirement facilities. All valid ways of describing centralized planning. Centralized planning is neither big nor small, you can have it at almost any level & it's success depends on the people involved. Which is why the vague statement made by the OP is somewhat confusing.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:09AM (#2733336)
Central planning never works.

But the Internet was the spin-off of a centrally planned government network. I am not sure it's accurate to say the failure of "competing" services was due to the failures of central planning, but more related to the onward march of technology(cheaper & faster). Even now the Internet is far from decentralized & some of the biggest services on the Internet are centralized and proprietary.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by nodata on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:44AM (#2733421)
The Internet became the success it is now once it escaped from being a centrally planned government network.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:15AM (#2733502)
I know! Agencies like ARPANET, NSFNet & CERN were real drains on the Internet. All they provided was huge initial monetary outlays for building the initial backbones & tech like TCP/IP & HTTP. It also appears that the government made the choice to open the network up for commerce. So I guess these centralized agencies setting up the initial infrastructure & later opening it up when personal computers were becoming affordable was a failure?

Concepts like ICANN, root DNS servers, Tier 1 providers & Client/Server... Yes all very decentralized concepts..mmm hmmm.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by nodata on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:50AM (#2733630)
What? Just because a lot of the stuff started off as government research projects doesn't mean they centrally planned the migration from what it was to what it is now.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @09:19AM (#2733731)
Did Apple plan to build the iPod back in the 80s? Did Google plan that they'd build Android back in the 90s?

Just because the government didn't initially plan for the Internet to envelop our lives 30 years later, doesn't mean that it wasn't a successful centrally planned project that benefited society. Most things are centrally planned. Much of private industry relies on centralized chains of command. I am not sure what the OPs point was, but seemed more like a veiled jab that suggested centralized government programs are always failures. When the facts are that Minitel shouldn't be classified as a failure & the Internet shouldn't be classified as a poster child for decentralized initiatives.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by mikecane on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:30AM (#2733386)
>>>some of the biggest services on the Internet are centralized and proprietary.

Which all tend to eventually fail. The Source, CompuServe, Delphi, AOL, all failed.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:20AM (#2733515)
Firstly, suggesting dial-up ISPs failed because they had a centralized business structure makes no sense. That's like saying horse & buggy manufacturers went out of business due to their centralized business structure rather than the introduction of the car. Also for the record AOL is still around & those companies were successful for their time.

Second, I was speaking about things like ICANN, root DNS servers, Tier 1 providers & Client/Server architecture as being non-decentralized. Additionally some of the biggest services on the Internet are indeed centralized. Google, Facebook, iTunes. ISP options have also been drastically reduced over the last two decades.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by mikecane on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @09:57AM (#2733897)
I think we are talking at cross-purposes here, in different perspectives, so let's stop.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by Klinky on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @11:29AM (#2734320)
Well perhaps your point was that those services were walled gardens & incompatible with each other before the Internet took off. The Internet opening up with it's low cost ISPs & flexibility was the end of those walled garden services & many BBSs, true.

That doesn't really have anything to do with the Internet being centrally planned or not. It was just planned to be more open than those other services.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by mikecane on Thursday July 07, 2011 @06:16AM (#2737935)
Yes, that's closer to my perspective: The strangling walled garden.
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by ugh on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @10:52AM (#2734139)
Central planning is how humans organize cooperation. It’s everywhere. To argue that it never works is ridiculous on its face.

Central planning probably gets harder the more humans want to cooperate and market mechanisms are very likely superior in those situations but that doesn’t mean that central planning doesn’t work.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by galactus on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:00AM (#2733328)
Wasn't "the internet" created by the gouvernment too?
Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by jgrahamc on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:13AM (#2733343)
The early days of Internet were funded by the US government but not in the same way as Minitel. The French government massively subsidized the deployment of Minitel by giving away millions of terminals (in exchange for not giving the subscriber the white pages on paper) and that helped launch it.

But if you ignore the arguments about who funded what there are lots of aspects of Minitel that are interesting because it helped to kick off the wide use of smart cards, the underlying network was packet switched (X.25) and the servers handling Minitel were distributed through the network (so service providers ran their own services).

It wouldn't view Minitel as a failure, however, just because it was replaced by the web. The French were years (probably 10) ahead of the rest of the world in terms of electronic communication and commerce. They had a large internal market online in the 1980s handling a huge amount of commerce.

Re:France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshoppi... by madflo on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @08:51AM (#2733636)
I may add that that after all, all the money granted for the Minitel program by the gouvernement has been recovered with taxes on Minitel minutes.

I would consider the Minitel as a success of central planning. 20 years of e-economy and quite a lot of money moving from French citizen to French corporations or smaller businesses.