News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by saurik on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:10PM (#27328635)
Phabricator had seemed to be the only good product in this space when I had looked; what are people even using instead? (I guess they just put up with GitHub :/.)
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by axk on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:12PM (#27328640)
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by kemayo on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:53PM (#27328930)
Gerrit is good, if opinionated in ways that we have to put work into onboarding for. That said, it only covers a small subset of what Phabricator does -- it's missing the entire issue tracker part, most importantly.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by quicklime on Saturday May 29, 2021 @07:21PM (#27329105)
If you're looking for an issue tracker to use with Gerrit, that's open source and developed by Google, you could try Monorail: https://chromium.googlesource.com/infra/infra/+/refs/heads/m...
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by lima on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:20PM (#27328686)
Ack! Recently moved from Phabricator to Gerrit and deleting Arcanist was a plus.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by geraldcombs on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:56PM (#27328956)
It'd be nice if it had a tightly integrated issue tracker and CI.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by saurik on Saturday May 29, 2021 @10:49PM (#27330203)
Yeah: the only feature I thought gerrit provided--active blocking code review--is actually the one feature of Phabricator that I had no interest in... I loved all of the other features.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by JoshTriplett on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:27PM (#27328748)
Does it still desperately want you to squash all your patches, or does it do a good job of handling an ordered stack of patches these days?
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by lima on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:29PM (#27328755)
It does an excellent job handling stacks! You may be mistaking it for Phabricator, which defaults to squashing.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by kemayo on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:57PM (#27328961)
I suspect that JoshTriplett is complaining about the `amend` workflow required to update a single gerrit patch with revisions.

If you're used to the GitHub pull request style, you'd be more likely to make a small commit and add it to the request. In gerrit that approach results in a separate patch for review, which isn't what such a person would want.

(Personally, I've come to appreciate gerrit's model for strongly encouraging building patches that are encapsulated single-reviewable-changes, in a way that lends itself to never having a commit that'd break the build if you landed on it e.g. during a git bisect.... But it's also something that surprises people who've not used gerrit before, in my experience.)

Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by JoshTriplett on Sunday May 30, 2021 @12:32AM (#27330617)
That's part of it. But also, if you start with a 4-patch series, and you want to publish a v2 that's changed to a 3-patch series, Gerrit doesn't seem to handle that very well. In general, I'd prefer if patches are kept together in one review, rather than a separate review for each.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by lima on Sunday May 30, 2021 @11:45AM (#27334034)
Gerrit handles this perfectly - you can just add the third commit to your stack (and even amend the earlier ones) and it works as expected, adding it to the relation chain.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by Jonanin on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:15PM (#27328668)
The UI is atrocious, unfortunately.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by lima on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:20PM (#27328690)
Check again - it got a serious makeover recently. It's still far from intutive, but so much better than it used to be.

It's a power user tool that has a slight learning curve.

Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by zdw on Sunday May 30, 2021 @12:32AM (#27330619)
Gerrit is a code review tool first, with code browsing not being a core focus.

GitHub and others are frequently code browsing tools first, with code review coming second. "Code hosting has look like GitHub" is unfortunately a common myopia.

Phabricator (from the little I used it) seems closer to Gerrit than other code hosting.

Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by Hamuko on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:59PM (#27328974)
Most of the stuff that Phabricator was used at our company is now done in (self-hosted) Gitlab. I think the only thing that's still actively there is credential management, and I can only imagine there are better solutions for that than Phabricator.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by saurik on Saturday May 29, 2021 @10:51PM (#27330208)
Is the issue tracker in GitLab a lot better than GitHub? I always was under the impression that they had simply been trying to copy GitHub, but I find most of GitHub's features toy-level unusable :(.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by boleary-gl on Sunday May 30, 2021 @12:46PM (#27334501)
GitLab employee here.

It started that way for sure, but we’ve evolved with boards, milestones, epics, swim lanes, burn down charts and a lot more.

We have a whole group in our engineering and product org focused on making it even better: https://about.gitlab.com/direction/plan/

Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by horstmeyer on Sunday May 30, 2021 @06:53AM (#27332256)
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by jazzkingrt on Saturday May 29, 2021 @08:55PM (#27329655)
I used reviewable.io at my last company, and now use phabricator. I actually still prefer reviewable, so give that a look.
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by woleium on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:31PM (#27328765)
gitlab is good and can still be self hosted
Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by addicted on Sunday May 30, 2021 @10:02AM (#27333311)
Yes but unfortunately Gitlab’s choice of features that go into the non free vs the open source version seem increasingly designed to deter use of the open source version.

Even on installing the self hosted Gitlab, the open source version is hidden, with the free yet closed source version being pushed.

Re:Phacility is winding down, Phabricator no longer actively... by acidburnNSA on Saturday May 29, 2021 @08:31PM (#27329534)
We evaluated https://gitea.com/ and really liked it.