News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by pg on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @09:09PM (#2732197)
at some point, we will need to acknowledge that there is simply not enough work to keep everybody gainfully employed 40+ hours a week.

Seems unlikely. We've been eliminating jobs with labor-saving devices for centuries. In the past they've always created as many jobs as they destroyed. What are the odds that this moment is the point when that finally stops happening?

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by rjprins on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @05:02AM (#2733070)
It is save to say that in no point in time have so many people worked so little while being so rich. That contradicts that automation creates as many jobs as it destroys.

We are not talking about a 'point' where the 40 hour week stops. It is a gradual decline in the amount of human labor, which has been going on for centuries. Automation means just that.

Thinking that work can forever shift towards other areas is stated on the assumptions that: 1. Not everything can be automated. 2. Human need will always grow to accommodate supply.

Now more than ever, you should question nr. 1. And in the areas that prove difficult to automate (e.g. education, law, healthcare, design..) there really is only so much work. (Except for law, maybe.)

Regarding the second assumption, when I look at highly educated people (which in my eyes, represent what in the future modal educated people will be like), they recognize desire as something that should be limited. They know that more money does not make you happier. Some even find a lot of joy in living simple and frugal.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by pg on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @01:40PM (#2734970)
1 and 2 are true now and it seems they'll remain true for the foreseeable future. There may be bottomless demand in healthcare alone.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by groby_b on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:11PM (#2735641)
The cynic in me supplies that with "if there's bottomless money for health care, which there isn't".
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by neutronicus on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @11:10AM (#2734219)
2. Human need will always grow to accommodate supply.

It's been doing a good job so far. If there's enough of something, we tend to multiply until there isn't. You also seem to take it as given that "supply" is constrained by available human labor (and the efficiency of its application) and not by the power output of the Planet Earth. (You may, of course, be correct. I have absolutely no idea how one would even go about refining such an assertion enough to test it).

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by quandrum on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:47AM (#2732606)
>We've been eliminating jobs with labor-saving devices for centuries. In the past they've always created as many jobs as they destroyed

This seems dubious. The avg. work week has been decreasing for a long time. It was only a century ago that significant amounts of <10 year olds were working, and the average work week was twice as long. Now it's slipping towards 30 hours a week.

This seems to just to continue that trend. It's becoming less likely that <20 year olds will have ever held a job.

I can't see it getting any better as boomers get older and refuse to give up their jobs.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by cameldrv on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:22AM (#2732559)
The problem now is this: If you are a low skilled worker at this point in the U.S., you're likely to be either not conscientious, or dumb.

For very low skilled jobs, automation can do the job better than a poor quality worker, because it is predictable and consistent. For jobs that still can't be automated, many of them can be done remotely, and are now done in lower labor cost countries by ambitious, conscientious workers. Jobs that can't be done remotely are being filled by illegal immigrants who are also ambitious, conscientious workers.

If you are at the bottom of the American labor heap, you have never faced competition from machines, globalization, and immigration like you have now. The problem is not just that the alternatives to low-end domestic labor are cheaper, but that they are higher quality, and therefore push the price of low quality domestic labor to near zero.

In the long-term, as machines become able to do more jobs better than humans, people will simply not be willing to pay any price for an error-prone human to do a worse job than a cheap machine. Then, low skilled humans will only be employed in jobs that can only be performed by humans, such as prostitution.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by kingkawn on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:52AM (#2732617)
"If you are a low skilled worker at this point in the U.S., you're likely to be either not conscientious, or dumb."

This shows a lot of ignorance of the economics and sociology of poverty in America and elsewhere, including poor educational opportunities that are not created by laziness or stupidity by the students. The statement detracts from your other well-made points.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by djm on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @06:22AM (#2733242)
In the long-term, as machines become able to do more jobs better than humans, people will simply not be willing to pay any price for an error-prone human to do a worse job than a cheap machine

Actually I think they would. Being an employer of a human would be a sign of prestige for the wealthy.

Just imagine you're at a future cocktail party and your host unveils his pretty human waitresses. He's obviously wealthy to afford a real human instead of using robots like everyone else

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by netcan on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:37AM (#2733395)
Reality is that this has gone backwards. In poor countries, moderately wealthy people still employ household staff in the way that the European upper classes did 5 generations ago. Drivers, maids, gardeners, cooks. In most nova rich and even old money countries this is pretty uncommon. Wealth disparity (wealthy person can hire poor person with a small fraction of her income) doesn't seem to increase the instances of such things.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by zach on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @03:12PM (#2735407)
This is a development that fascinates me as well. Upper middle class families no longer employing a host of household help (i.e. the Mary Poppins household) seems like an effect of increased productivity and job opportunity.

It is difficult to overstate the increase in opportunity over the last hundred years for women in particular. Back then, there were so very few avenues to the middle class for even an extraordinary single woman. Today, Mary Poppins would probably go to a fine college and be able to land a job as a pharmaceutical sales representative at the very least.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by groby_b on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:37PM (#2734659)
Oh, it does - visit any Hollywood party :)

The point is, for a large class of servants, you need both immense wealth disparity and a large class of insanely rich people. We've increased a) and in the process, b) has gotten smaller.

Don't get me wrong, many people are rich - but only a few are rich enough that they can afford servants. This might change if the job situation gets worse, increasing the disparity so that more rich people now qualify as insanely rich.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by Duff on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @02:46PM (#2735310)
Ok, so a person who by fate grows up poor in a rural area is dumb, because the government allows farmers and industry to systematically ship in a lower class of labor to exploit?

The US discriminates against poor people. The fully-loaded cost of a US citizen is too high because the do-gooders require all sorts of expensive benefits and mandates. If a farmer pays a US citizen $12/hour to pick tomatoes, he also pays another $8/hr for code-compliant housing, workers compensation and unemployment insurance.

But, simultaneously, the government turns a blind eye if you ship in some Mexicans or Latin Americans and treat them like slaves.

Collectively, we share this psychosis where society wants to provide all of these great benefits and human rights for citizens, while treating this other class of person as something less than human.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by cameldrv on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:24PM (#2735706)
This is the #1 reason to stop illegal immigration and provide for a reasonable level of legal immigration. We create an underclass that either doesn't have legal rights or feels that they don't have legal recourse, and so they are ripe to be exploited.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by Confusion on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @04:59AM (#2733068)

  If you are at the bottom of the American labor heap, you 
  have never faced competition from machines, globalization, 
  and immigration like you have now.
That's begging the central question. The biggest leaps were made long ago. The invention of electricity, the steam engine and the combustion engine, those enabled automation on a scale that was truly never seen before. Then there was slavery: that's competition from globalization/immigration if there ever was. China, India and the other low wage countries are getting higher standards of living fast, so their wages go up and their competitiveness down.

I strongly question the assertion that we are currently losing lowskilled jobs to automation or competition at a faster pace than in the past.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by groby_b on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:34PM (#2734635)
Of course, the pace of loss is not that important - if there's sustained net loss, sooner or later, we will reach zero.

Also, I'd argue the biggest leap is computer technology, and it's having a lot of impact still. My guess is bio-engineering is next. If that happens (and it's a big if, in my book), there will be even more impact.

So, going back to the point, my original assertion was we're slowly running out of low-skills jobs. That's backed up by pretty much any look at employment figures. Manual labor has been wiped out to an insane extent (agriculture is what, 3% of the labor force now?). And the service industry is next, IMHO. Retail is slowly bleeding to death, for example.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by paulcedars on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:33AM (#2732578)
What happens when machines and outsourcing eliminate the need for most American doctors, lawyers, drivers, teachers, and other skilled professions. We can't have a prostitution-based economy.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by iaskwhy on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:00AM (#2733329)
It might take a long time to reach that possibility since public facing automations usually require a human near the robot for the comfort of the other humans using the service. Think: pilots on airplanes (mostly not necessary), trains drivers (not necessary at all), human ticket dispensers (not necessary at all). Just thinking out loud.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by nasmorn on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @07:42AM (#2733410)
I think a well done cyborg prostitute could make prostitution more mass market. No way to make it illegal, guilt free and 100% sanitizeable. And lets be honest, a for pay 15min intercourse just doesn't benefit that much from the human touch. Plus you can make em look like manga characters or whatever. Big opportunity ahead.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by neutronicus on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:19AM (#2732553)
Seems unlikely. We've been eliminating jobs with labor-saving devices for centuries. In the past they've always created as many jobs as they destroyed. What are the odds that this moment is the point when that finally stops happening?

Perhaps we're butting up against limits on the amount of energy per unit time available to the economy in a way that we haven't in the past couple centuries?

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by paulcedars on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:28PM (#2732367)
Yes, but these new jobs are often a long-term thing, and the economy must undergo enormous structural changes for them to form. The US underwent enormous economic and societal changes in its move from an agriculture-based economy to a manufacturing-based one.
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by Alex3917 on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @09:24PM (#2732228)
"What are the odds that this moment is the point when that finally stops happening?"

The problem is that the amount of value that could hypothetically be created isn't the limiting factor. Rather, there are at least a dozen different structural forces that are all aligning to prevent people who want to work from connecting with companies that want to create jobs. And while these problems could theoretically be removed with the stroke of a pen, they probably won't be for another few decades, at least in the U.S.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by danking00 on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:57PM (#2732422)
Could you elaborate on these dozen or more structural forces?
Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by Alex3917 on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @11:13PM (#2732450)
I'm working on writing this up in a blog post, but it'll take a while. I'm trying to take a data-driven look at the major structural problems with America, but there are just way too many of them. But specifically for jobs there are a lot of limiting factors that stem from the ways we currently approach education, parenting, infrastructure, healthcare, mental health, the criminal justice system, immigration, poverty, the environment, the military, etc.

E.g. if you look at the literacy levels in America, it should be pretty obvious why this is an issue: http://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/PDF/2006470.PDF

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by groby_b on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:28PM (#2734608)
This argument, IMHO, does not hold water.

If it's happening at all, it's bound to happen at some point. We're just the people who live at that point in time. So what you're asking is, "what are the odds we're living now". Since we're (presumably ;) alive, they're 100%.

Re:Youth unemployment: The outsiders by bbq on Wednesday July 06, 2011 @12:40AM (#2732590)
Perhaps we're moving too fast now.