Perfect branding lies in the sweet spot between unique and recognizable (or self-explanatory for domains, see my post on this http://t.co/ecbsWcp), but it depends on mindshare.
"GMail" is in the sweet spot between the faceless title "Google Mail" and the unrecognisable "Jabberwocky". YouTube won the mindshare landrush for consumer video and became a household brand name. Rebranding it would be dumb.
Picasa, on the other hand, is similar to "Google Reader" in that it solves a smaller problem in a highly crowded market. Smaller brands with multiple competitors strengthen the core "Google" brand by living under the umbrella as "GPhoto", "Google Brush" or "Google Reader", for example.
Would like to hear counter-points.
> From the prospect’s point of view, line extension works against the generic brand position. It blurs the sharp focus of the brand in the mind. No longer can the prospect say “Bayer” if he or she wants aspirin. Or “Dial” for soap. In a sense, line extension educates the prospect to the fact that Bayer is nothing but a brand name. It destroys the illusion that Bayer is a superior form of aspirin. Or that Dial is deodorant soap rather than just a brand name for a deodorant soap
Is this still relevant these days? I think their argument has some merit.
It essentially claims that a brand should not try to be all things to all people. Different brands, however, can. For a good discussion, see: http://www.codemyownroad.com/circumventing-the-law-of-line-e...
Edit: I see the book is written by the same author. Probably no coincidence.
The halo effect makes it so all the children products benefit from the main product's influence, but it can also work the other way around, so they have to be very careful not to brand a crappy product like that, because then it will end up affecting all the others in a negative way.
It's also very important that they keep re-inventing themselves at least every 10 years (like Google is doing now). Because otherwise they risk becoming "the product my dad used", or uncool like that. Who thinks Yahoo is still cool now? 13-14 years ago they were "the Internet".
They make the point that in long run you're diluting your brand. You can only occupy one particular place in someone's mind with a single brand. Owning that position is valuable. Owning 'they do everything' is not really a winner. That feels like 'they do nothing well.'
Large breweries often have many different brands that are perceived differently by people.
It's hard to build a strong brand name, but if you can pull it off and avoid line extension, it's the better way.
I think that Google and all the major tech companies are re-positioning themselves as technology companies rather than search, ecommerce, hardware, etc.
Joel Spolsky had it nailed the best, these sorts of moves are a "strategy tax" on big companies.
"Google has said that YouTube will remain as is."
I believe this would just make everything too complicated than it needs to be for the average user; besides, the likelyhood is that the user already uses Google, so there's no need for Google to try and reel users in via a search applet (that would probs make YouTube look ugly).
And, aren't Google Accounts already merged with YouTube Accounts ?
It would be more consistent, and would passively, but massively, promote Google+.
I would also gradually phase out the old brands in order to prevent the user revolt that's to be expected from such a brutal change.
{title:Picasa, theme:Picasa}
{title:Picasa, subtitle:Google+Photos, theme:Picasa}
{title:Google+Photos, subtitle:Picasa, theme:Google+Photos}
{title:Google+Photos, theme:Google+Photos}i want my google services with one brand and one design. i click through my services and everthing looks completely different, this is what is really wrong.
so: go on goole!
I'd argue that AOL failed despite that.
(i've never really used AOL)
While the multi-brand strategy didn't work for Yahoo, Yahoo had many other integration/prioritization problems.
The fact that YouTube had a different, more-market-appropriate name than 'Google Video' was important for its identity and success. (Or is Google going to rename YouTube to "Google+ Video", now?)
'Blogger' is a uniquely-interesting brand for them to throw away. If launched today, the word would almost be too generic for trademark protection. But its history practically grandfathers it in: its popularity was part of the mechanism by which 'blog' became a generic term.
'Google Blogs'? Blah.