News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:16PM (#27278726)
An artist doesn’t owe the world anything. If he didn’t want to be associated with it, then leave it alone. Have some respect for the way a person chooses to present themselves to the world.

The greediness of the contemporary public is really off-putting. It reminds me of how we dig up mummies and place them in museums; completely disregarding the actual human beings that lived and their cultural-religious beliefs, all so that we can stare at them in a museum for 30 seconds.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by echlebek on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:48PM (#27279930)
John Steinbeck is dead, and the world doesn't owe him anything either. No need to scold people who are interested in history.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by cwyers on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:05PM (#27283910)
Yeah, he is past the point of having feelings to hurt.

You know whose feelings are probably hurt right now, though? Like, picture yourself as a budding werewolf novelist, the sort of person who went to the University of Kansas and got a Bachelor's of Fine Arts in English Literature with a minor in Werewolf Studies, and you've just finished your first werewolf novel, and you're really proud of it, and you have a stack of rejection letters saying that the market isn't really interested in this sort of thing right now. And now, all of a sudden, you see everybody losing their mind over John Steinbeck's werewolf novel. He didn't even want to write it! He didn't want it published! But the world is clamoring for it, and your novel sits in a file drawer. I'm sure there's someone out there like that right now.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ng12 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:04PM (#27284878)
Sure, but you could extrapolate that to some sort of butterfly effect where every action undertaken could be potentially harmful to someone else.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:22AM (#27289041)
Exactly, and that's why we must do absolutely nothing.

Wait, no, that's exactly what it takes for evil to prevail! Rats, I suppose there's nothing we can do, then.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by setr on Thursday May 27, 2021 @03:36AM (#27300377)
> Wait, no, that's exactly what it takes for evil to prevail!

You need to additionally be part of the good men cabal. Simply be bad and do absolutely nothing

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:48PM (#27279933)
If you don’t have any respect for the past, don’t expect the future to have any respect for you.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ALittleLight on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:30PM (#27280450)
Correct. I would understand if archaeologists two thousand years from dug me up and used me in a display about burial rituals. I don't think there's any expectation of privacy from that kind of thing.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:33PM (#27280495)
That’s mostly because you live in a society which doesn’t value burials or the afterlife and which worships information, which must be acquired at any cost.

No ancient Egyptian Pharaoh would be happy with being dug up and placed in a glass box in a museum. They didn’t build the pyramids because they were bored or wanted people to visit them as tourist attractions. To the very real human beings of ancient Egypt, becoming an anthropological exhibit would be deeply troubling, a massively negative outcome.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ALittleLight on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:59PM (#27280883)
But I also wouldn't mind if future archaeologists entombed me in a pyramid, used my body as a comedic prop, burnt me for fuel, etc.

At some point after death we should acknowledge we no longer have moral claims on the world.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by grenoire on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:04PM (#27281900)
You're reinforcing OP's point: You don't care about afterlife. Don't have to, but recognise that many do, and have been for a very long time.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ALittleLight on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:41PM (#27282345)
The Pharoh might be incensed we let his slaves go free, educated women, didn't worship Ra, etc. We don't respect any of ancient Egypt's beliefs except we should respect their reverence for the dead? Doesn't make sense to me.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:22PM (#27282848)
Is it really that difficult to just leave the Pharaohs in the pyramids and not in a glass box at the museum? Doesn’t really seem too much to me. They built the pyramids, after all.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by codyb on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:47PM (#27285601)
Having historical artifacts in museums that millions of people can visit is a valuable social good which embiggens curiosity, exacerbates mental well being, and strikes fear into the very heart of boredom.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by edgyquant on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:20PM (#27284047)
Why should people who lived thousands of years ago have an indefinite claim to a piece of land and the materials upon it? Why should we leave the pharaoh in the pyramid?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ALittleLight on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#27283735)
Yeah, it is that difficult. Huge numbers of people want to see the mummies and will pay for the privilege. The people with legal claims to the mummies make significant money.

Denying the owners profits and the curious the chance to indulge their curiosity for the benefit of people a thousand years dead is a derangement of moral priorities. We should care more about the living than the long dead. We can learn from and about them.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by klyrs on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:21PM (#27283486)
Point of fact, they did not build the pyramids. Their slaves did the work. Maybe let's split the difference -- what proportion of the slaves would want to see the pharaoh's corpses defiled?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by WalterBright on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:42PM (#27283699)
> slaves

That's the Hollywood narrative. Archaeology points to them being free men. Though nobody knows for sure.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by klyrs on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @11:24AM (#27291733)
Regardless, the Pharaohs didn't build 'em, did they?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by strken on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:14PM (#27284532)
At some point moral values clash. The Egyptian Pharaohs kept slaves, fought wars of aggression, and had their living retainers sacrificed so they could continue to serve after death. We haven't kept sacrificing people, because we agree that it's just outright wrong.

He and I think it's also just outright wrong to hide archaeological details from future generations for the sake of the long dead. It sounds like you disagree with us, but the argument that we should respect their wishes just because they wished them is not a strong one, given that we reject some wishes on a case by case basis as morally repugnant.

What is it about this wish in particular that should be respected more than other wishes?

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by Ekaros on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:35AM (#27286772)
Now how long time is that? Second? Minute? 5 minutes? Hour? Day? Month? Year? Decade? 50 years? Century? Makes one think. Also is there levels of these moral claims?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:28AM (#27289094)
I reserve all rights to the atoms that make up my body ad infinitum, which means my estate will be able to claim copyright on your descendents for selling work that contains said atoms!
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by codyb on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:45PM (#27285588)
Sure, but weren’t the pyramids built by slave labor?

I feel like there’s enough massively disappointing outcomes to go around.

I mean, after all, everyone ends up dead at the end of the day and we can barely take care of the living.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @04:00AM (#27287680)
> Sure, but weren’t the pyramids built by slave labor?

No, they were prestige products.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:26AM (#27289080)
> That’s mostly because you live in a society which doesn’t value burials or the afterlife and which worships information, which must be acquired at any cost.

Even if I was, I'd be dead when it actually came about. The implication of time-travelling morality is an interesting but problematic one. There's no one actually suffering from the act of desecration, since suffering requires one to be alive.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by havelhovel on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:32PM (#27283588)
Surely you can’t simultaneously support cultural relativism (misplaced as it may be for an American author being discussed by mostly Americans) and also speak for an entire group of people who existed thousands of years ago. The only thing we have empirical proof of is that the deceased don’t complain about the treatment of their remains or estates.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by SuoDuanDao on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:39PM (#27284697)
Well now, a cultural relativist would definitely disagree with your lat statement. Most cultures would say there's ample evidence in the other direction and that it's bad luck to build on ancient burial grounds.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by titzer on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:10PM (#27281958)
Just declare bankruptcy and realize the future is full of psychos. This is why you should want to be cremated and have all semblance of your existence erased, because you have no idea what insanity they'll come up with for their own amusement. Also, don't upload your brain.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:41PM (#27283070)
I don't, and I don't. Why do I need respect if I'm dead?

I mean, people are going to go through my stuff. They'll find sex toys, for example. Maybe my family will be able to be comfortable if they are able to profit from my stuff, or someone in the future find my stuff and get some satisfaction.

Again, though, I'll be dead.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by m00x on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:54PM (#27280007)
The only people for whom it really matters is their descendants or people who cared about them.

The dead is gone, there is no difference for them if their image, or their bodies are disrespected.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:58PM (#27280058)
Well, luckily the people who died fighting in World War 2 cared about their society’s descendants, otherwise why bother fighting and dying? If your future society doesn’t care about you, why risk anything for them?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by NineStarPoint on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:06PM (#27283338)
To care for the state of future generations is worthwhile, because it is to give hope and happiness to them while they are living. I want all of humanity to live in as ideal a world as possible, and it’s worth fighting in the present so that future humanity has a better world. And society should care for those who have sacrificed for it, while they are alive.

Once I am dead though, there is no me here to respect any more. Death is complete separation from this world. The vast majority of people who have ever died are completely lost to memory, whether they wanted that fate or not. And for those we do still remember, they’re long past having the ability to care at all what happens to what they left behind. Whether through nothingness or an afterlife, they are no longer here.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by WalterBright on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#27283725)
Fighting for the future is very different than fighting for the past.

We've evolved to care about our descendants, not our ancestors.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by watwut on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:02PM (#27282613)
A lot of them were nazi. Many nazi fought that war. They have seen themselves as fighting for future.

Majority of people dying were civilians.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:29AM (#27289102)
Don't think they had much choice in the matter, seeing as there was a punishment for defection.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tomc1985 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:47PM (#27280700)
All the norms around burial culture are contrivances made up by humans and have little basis in the natural world. That the dead even deserve respect is similarly made-up.

One's involuntary submission to the whims of the living is part of the process of death. If one does anything even remotely notable you can be assured that society will want something to do with it. There's no point in chastising the entire world because of it.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by Andrex on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:59PM (#27280895)
> All the norms around burial culture are contrivances made up by humans and have little basis in the natural world. That the dead even deserve respect is similarly made-up.

Not sure elephants, among other species, would agree.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tomc1985 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:03PM (#27280956)
Culture rears its ugly head once again.

The elephants might not agree but I'm certain that the cheetahs, tigers, hyenas, and all the other predators of the world would

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:49PM (#27280729)
If that’s your line of thought, then why stop at burials? All human culture has little basis in the natural world.

Unless you’re a Nihilist and Darwinist, I assume you think some values are more important than others?

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tomc1985 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:00PM (#27280909)
There are some such values, but I recognize their fragility in the face of actual human behavior.

And indeed, I think a lot of aspects of culture are dumb and that society would be better off without. It would be better if the world returned to the basics instead of endlessly wrapping itself around an axle of contrivances.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:35AM (#27289131)
Well, burials only matter if others care about it. Other values, such as "do not harm others", etc., matter even if others don't care about them, because they concern actual suffering of living people.

If you follow Parfit, you choose that the latter kind is the only kind to care about, and so caring about burials for the sake of the one buried would be nonsensical to you.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by msla on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:46PM (#27285177)
> Darwinist

I think you have some odd definitions.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:45PM (#27279133)
As a huge Steinbeck fan, I do not want to read this book. I don't want to think of him as someone who wrote a warewolf novel - and he probably didn't want to think of himself that way either. At the time he would have written it he was very desperate for money so he would have written it in the hope that he might make a bit of money to keep going.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by dfxm12 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:11PM (#27279466)
Whether you read the book or not, whether the public gets the chance to read the book or not, he is someone who wrote a werewolf novel. You can choose to ignore that fact if you want, but it makes no difference; it doesn't make him any worse of a writer. It doesn't make Cannery Row any less of a novel.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by UncleOxidant on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:26PM (#27279670)
People do things when they're desperate for money that they're not proud of. They certainly don't want to be remembered for those things. The fact that he wrote it under a pseudonym indicates that he didn't want to be associated with it.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by shard on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:37PM (#27281497)
Writing under a pseudonym can be seen as brand management, so that the brand of one name does not leak to the brand of another. For example, Nora Roberts, the romance novelist, uses the pseudonym J.D. Robb when writing futuristic suspense novels. It may be as you said that he doesn't want to be associated with it, or it may be that he wants to keep the brands separate.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by WalterBright on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:47PM (#27283750)
Women also used to write under male pseudonyms in order to get published.

https://theculturetrip.com/north-america/usa/articles/12-fem...

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by Beldin on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:35PM (#27283617)
Out of curiosity, why do you use the word "novel"?

I'll happily concede he wrote a werewolf story, but since it was never available as a book, I would not call it a novel.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by sjansen on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:10PM (#27280210)
I’m not opposed to sharing an author’s unpublished works after death because their is value in allowing certain readers access.

But after reading Douglas Adam’s, I’m personally hesitant to read unpublished item from any other authors. After finishing The Salmon of Doubt I felt vaguely embarrassed, like I’d barged into his house and found him relaxing on the couch in his boxers. I’m a fan, not a scholar, and there were reasons he wasn’t ready to share the material yet.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by vidarh on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:07PM (#27281932)
I liked A Salmon of Doubt.

If he'd published it himself in that state, I'd have found it embarrassing.

But as a posthumous memorial that I knew from the outset would be unpolished, it was fine and a bit sad knowing it's never be finished.

I think comes down to how well you're able to keep focus on that what you're reading is unfinished, and enjoying the glimpse of something raw.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by iggldiggl on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:09AM (#27288086)
> ...there were reasons he wasn’t ready to share the material yet.

Not saying that the parts of the story that have been published might not have needed some additional polish, too, but wouldn't the major reason simply be the fact that the whole thing wasn't yet finished as in "the story just stops mid-way"?

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ghaff on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:44PM (#27281598)
Are there any truly great posthumous novels other than maybe ones that were in essentially a final polish edit state? Hemingway's True at First Light wasn't bad but by Hemingway standards pretty so so.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by handrous on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:21PM (#27282081)
Austen's Persuasion is easily my favorite of her novels, and I believe it's understood to have been not just a polish-edit away from ready for publication, but one or two content and punch-up passes, too (which reveals to me that I probably don't really like the stuff she added to her other books in that stage).
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ssully on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:13PM (#27279491)
Whether it is released or not, he is still someone who wrote a werewolf novel and if it is released it's not something that would detract from his other works or legacy.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by preordained on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:40PM (#27279848)
> if it is released it's not something that would detract from his other works or legacy

We don't know that. It could be a viral laughingstock that becomes the new primary association the public holds for the author (I doubt it, but never say never). If he didn't want it released, I'd say honor his wishes.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ssully on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:02PM (#27280114)
I don't know, there are plenty of prolific and well regarded authors (Stephen King comes to mind) that have plenty of stinkers in their catalogue.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tomc1985 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:49PM (#27280721)
Why is writing a werewolf novel such a stain on his reputation?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by booleandilemma on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:17PM (#27283437)
Why does it matter?

Anyway, wait until you find out what he used to do in the bathroom.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by josephorjoe on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:28PM (#27279710)
> The greediness of the contemporary public is really off-putting.

Well put.

This feels like some bizarre end game of "information wants to be free" where instead of railing against content owners expecting to be paid for content people are railing against the idea that content creators can have any control over their creations whatsoever.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tomc1985 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:51PM (#27280767)
But they can't. Once the work is out there, any control that the author is given is an affordance. Trying to fight it is why we live in a world of draconian DRM and licensing-not-ownership

To be clear: an artist's control of a work ends once it is in the hands of their audience.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by sincerely on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:46PM (#27283127)
Well, the work in question is not "out there".
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by duxup on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:57PM (#27281805)
I suppose everyone wants to control how they're remembered / their public image.

I'm not sure that is a right that anyone has.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by curtis3389 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:21PM (#27278790)
What about Kafka?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:24PM (#27278842)
Difficult case but I still think the rights of the creator are more important to respect.

There’s also something kafkesque about the way his stories weren’t destroyed, which makes me think that the story isn’t as simple as it seems.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by tiahura on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:32PM (#27279761)
and Marcus Aurelius?
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by jonny_eh on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:19PM (#27278766)
> all so that we can stare at them in a museum for 30 seconds

So that we can study them, learn from them, and let them tell us their stories, so that they truly live on after death.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ResearchCode on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:26PM (#27278865)
Societies with high human capital respect the dead and won't seize upon the first opportunity to rob their graves (rationalizing as "learning" or whatever doesn't cut it). There's plenty of other material that was willfully published to learn from.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by riversflow on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:42PM (#27279094)
I disagree. I have extremely high respect for human capital, and genuinely feel disgusted that especially western society isn't working hard to improve the human condition at it's most basic level, i.e. Automation first.

To me the long dead are meaningless, and the recently dead are mostly so. I have the utmost respect for the living, and those who are recently dead have people who care about their legacy. But the farther you go back you go, the less direct connection the dead have with the present, and the simple fact is that the dead are gone.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:45PM (#27279131)
Pretty much the entirety of the modern world is built on the accumulation of ideas and knowledge acquired over thousands of years. Unless you are a hunter gatherer, you have a direct relationship to the long dead.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by riversflow on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @01:21PM (#27279610)
Oh I agree 100%, I'm fully of the belief that we stand on the shoulders of giants, and that Social contract theory has merit; we owe society for the world we are born into. But owing society isn't the same as owing respect to individuals. We can't be burdened by the wishes of those long dead, they no longer exist and as a society we have to move on.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by bredren on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:17PM (#27280310)
They respect _their_ dead. There is relatively minuscule respect paid to dead native people that lived in their land before they arrived.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by exikyut on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:58PM (#27279312)
What does "them" refer to here though?

Our preferred projection of them in our own image?

Or a meeting-in-the-middle between you and an individual's preferred presentation of themselves?

One of the reasons the Git version control system caught on is that it lets you rewrite history...

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:22PM (#27278799)
From their perspective, none of that would be relevant. They had certain beliefs and rather than respect them, we treat them like objects to gawk at.
Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by anbende on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:39PM (#27279062)
Except that the mummy in the museum isn’t a person. It’s a collection of inanimate organic matter. There are no beliefs there to respect. They ended with the person’s life thousands of years ago.

I could see an argument made for modern remains as there are living people/descendants who have a strong connection with the burial beliefs and practices. But make no mistake, even in that case it is about the living and not the dead.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:42PM (#27279095)
Sorry, but this is a modern anachronistic statement. To the people that lived, their remains were extremely important. They even built dozens of pyramids to house them, which again, have been reduced to a tourist attraction.

The modern world has no respect for anything.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by anbende on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:06PM (#27280173)
Those people are also gone and no longer have any beliefs or ideas that can be violated.

Nothing we do today affects those people or their beliefs in any way. Those people no longer exist and cannot be harmed or protected. Ideas about respect and proper behavior around their landmarks only affects people who are alive. It is only important to the extent that it is important to us. It is clearly important to you but not others. So why should it matter to others if it doesn’t?

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:11PM (#27280225)
Because it’s a simple matter of recognizing other human beings and respecting their cultural achievements and desires. Just because they don’t exist anymore doesn’t mean they weren’t humans worthy of our empathy.

I hate to use this example, but your argument would also basically say a genocided people is completely unimportant and unworthy of respect, as they no longer exist either.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by anbende on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @06:39PM (#27283665)
Thanks for your response. I'm trying to understand your position here, and I'm really not getting it.

Aside from the obvious problem of their being living people who experienced the holocaust (so they still exist), this example seems to imply that I'm saying that there's no need for empathy and respect for the people who came before us. I don't think that anything I've said implies that. Instead what I'm saying is that the dead need no protection and can receive no pain or insult. Anything we do for "them" is really for "us", because they do not exist.

>Because it’s a simple matter of recognizing other human beings and respecting their cultural achievements and desires. Just because they don’t exist anymore doesn’t mean they weren’t humans worthy of our empathy.

You seem to be implying that not honoring the wishes of the dead is an empathic failure. How so? I can empathize with someone's wishes, understand where they are coming from, and even respect who they were. None of that implies that I owe their desires a place in the world now. And in fact as modern people we MUST make choices about what pieces of the past to revere, revise, or pave over. Otherwise the world becomes a mausoleum to the past.

Re:John Steinbeck’s estate urged to let the world read his s... by rimiform on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @07:40AM (#27289179)
The person you're disagreeing with agrees with this idea about morality: (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Person-affecting_view). You, on the other hand, (I think) believe something can be bad even if it is not actually bad for anyone.

Case in point: the people who've actually died in said genocide cannot have any feelings about what we do about them, so to consider those feelings would be nonsense (according to the person-affecting view).

Of course, if someone living (such as yourself) cares about this, then it would still make sense to care about it, since the feelings of an actually living person are concerned.