I agree that we probably can't stop them from doing it short of government regulation, but that doesn't mean it's not a fucked-up thing to do.
The Big Problem here isn't that Hover has decided that user convenience warrants storing passwords insecurely. That is a problem, of course, but it is not as big a problem as The Big Problem here.
The Big Problem is the grafs spent defending the soundness of Hover's password storage strategy. Hover does not appear to understand that they have conceded user security. They believe that a combination of their network security and physical security† mitigates these flaws. If you're going to sell out user security to minimize customer support costs, I'd at least like to know that you know that's what you're doing.
That Hover does not appear to know what they are doing suggests that there is much more badness to be had in their systems, which is a problem that will burn them much more painfully than password hashes.
† Notably, not application security --- no external auditor would let "user passwords appear in plaintext in a database column" slide.
But the audience for this blatant nonsense are the people who want Hover.com to mail their password to them, so they think they can get away with telling us that "a combination of their network security and physical security† mitigates these flaws." You know this to be false, I know it to be false, and I suggest they know it as well.
(I know neither of these things to be true for a fact and am just making a rhetorical point.)
That is not how I read it. You could argue the other way:
If they have to send password reset URL:s anyway, they can just as well send the password itself.
That makes sense. It's just that by storing the passwords at all, you risk losing them if someone gains access to your database.
https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Password_hash...
And you'll still be able to brute force "cat" in under a day.
And I want a pony, they gonna give me that too?
A business transaction is a negotiation between seller and client. You don't always have to give them what they want, and if you are good enough, people won't leave you over that one thing.
If you are going to only use sites that store your password in plaintext because it is so damn convenient, you are not going to have much Internet left.
So we draw a line somewhere and say that those products and services over there, caveat emptor. These over here, OTOH, must have a minimum standard of safety.
I am personally not convinced that domain registration should be left up to the marketplace. What if someone gets a user's password and then redirects their web addresses to a site that dispenses malware?
The victims in this case aren't even the domain registrar's customers, they're people who had absolutely no say in the question.
But any ways, I wasn't really trying to suggest we regulate it so much as suggest that laughing at Hover.com is looking in the wrong direction. There is a large social problem isomorphic to the "disable your security software if you want to see a video of dancing babies" problem. That problem is far more interesting and important than the "greedy businesspeople are greedy" problem.
Win/win.
I believe this is the scenario most people here think is happening.
First off, nobody chooses their domain registrar because it provides plain text lost passwords instead of something more secure. That is such a silly claim that I would hope you don't actually believe it. However, people will certainly leave a domain registrar based on an insecure password policy. This is especially true of the people who frequent domain registrar services.
Second, you claim the market is failing. It's doing exactly the opposite. You are commenting on a widely read post with hundreds of comments and many thousands of views that is in the process of putting a black mark on this stupid company as we speak. They will get a nontrivial number of emails and cancellations referring to this post, and I guarantee they change their policy within the month. This is exactly how the market is supposed to work.
As for being what the customers want, not this customer. I'll definitely never become their customer if they are this insecure.
So.
You either live with it and do your business with someone who has decided to offer a "premium" service and has a business model catering to educated customers,
Or:
You look for the government to regulate the marketplace as a public good. We do this with things like the safety of cars, we've decided that the marketplace cannot be left to decide this for itself. We attempt to do this with things like the content and handling of food, we've decided that the marketplace cannot be left to decide this for itself.
Perhaps the security of your account is not important enough to impose regulation. Perhaps it is. But as long as it's left up to the marketplace, the existence of companies like Hover is inevitable, and waggling our fingers at them is not going to do anything except make us feel smarter than the average bear.