Re:Complexity is a source of income in open source ecosystem...
by asdff on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @12:48AM
(#27272683)
I think these tools hurt beginners a lot, personally. You have to learn R no matter what you use to plot, but if you want to use tidyverse you have to now learn that too, and the logic you learn there might not transfer over to the rest of R that you are gonna have to learn no matter what, and can lead to confusion. It doesn't help that stackoverflow uses R or tidyverse code interchangably and its up to the beginner to spend time figuring out what is what. I think it even adds to the notion I see, even here on HN in this thread, that R is some awkward unlearnable monstrous thing that has no place. It is that, when you start adding all these different packages and syntax conventions without thinking if your solution can be implemented trivially with base R. I find base R pretty similar to python with small caveats like you don't use loops and you apply functions instead.
Re:Complexity is a source of income in open source ecosystem...
by roenxi on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:43AM
(#27274022)
I completely agree, in opposition. This is all true, and makes strong case for deprecating base R and replacing big chunks of the language with tidyverse equivalents. I would certainly encourage the people maintaining the language to reflect on your points with that in mind as an option.
Well, yes, but that is part of the reason why it is so popular. R may be written by world-leading language design experts - but it doesn't show!
> ...relying on it handicaps you versus spending...
There is almost no reason to drop out of tidyverse if the problem domain is visualising data. Most people could go an entire career as an analyst using just ggplot + tidyverse.
If something needs to be plotted and ggplot won't work it probably makes sense to drop out of R and go straight to TikZ or OpenGL.