News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by cute_boi on Sunday May 23, 2021 @05:21AM (#27253573)
Is UK police so dumb that they suspect people solely based on ipv4? A malware can always attack a computer and set up vpn etc. There can be many thing so UK police please stop your nonsense. Do they even realize how much tragedy those innocent people had to face due to their silliness?
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by pilif on Sunday May 23, 2021 @05:26AM (#27253602)
> Is UK police so dumb that they suspect people solely based on ipv4?

It’s not dumb. It’s very practical. Very easy conviction and it entirely turns the burden of proof over to the accused who now have to prove their innocence which is much harder to do especially as they probably lack the resources to do so.

If success is measured in amount of convictions and/or arrests, going with just the IP address is the easiest road to success.

Articles like this are incredibly important to make it clear to judges that an IP address is not sufficient evidence. This is not common knowledge yet

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by exhilaration on Sunday May 23, 2021 @05:47AM (#27253718)
On might consider disabling the WiFi password entirely so there's plausible deniability if this happens. Pitch it as a public service. Maybe set up a separate router or VLAN and cap the bandwidth.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by foobar33333 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @08:05AM (#27254435)
Sure, but you still end up with all of your devices seized for months and data dumped while you explain that you run an unprotected wifi router.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by pilif on Sunday May 23, 2021 @08:05AM (#27254436)
If your WiFi is entirely unprotected, depending on jurisdiction, you can be treated as an accessory which too can have serious consequences.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by dannyw on Sunday May 23, 2021 @11:54AM (#27255925)
Surely they'd have to prove intent?
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by pilif on Sunday May 23, 2021 @03:54PM (#27257990)
It depends on jurisdiction. See for example https://www.itsecurityguru.org/2020/10/06/french-cafe-owners...
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by fnord77 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @07:51AM (#27254362)
has this ever been tested in court?
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by hhvn on Sunday May 23, 2021 @07:09AM (#27254149)
Then you would have to prove that it's someone who used the service not you. The burden of proof is not on the accusor.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by quicksilver03 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @07:46AM (#27254332)
And yet, GDPR considers IP address personal data. As long as there are stupid things written in laws and directives, we can expect the judicial branch issue stupid rulings.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by Ensorceled on Sunday May 23, 2021 @07:58AM (#27254393)
My name is personal data. A bank robber can say "Hands up, this is Ensorceled, hand over your money or die." but that should not be proof I did the crime.

Same with IP addresses, THEY ARE PERSONAL DATA. Ad tech companies routinely use IPs for tracking and identification.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by ad404b8a372f2b9 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @08:03AM (#27254416)
This is a completely different matter with entirely different goals and implications. GDPR takes the hardest stance on what is and is not personal data for the sake of consumer protection. If a company had the IP of this couple they could link their online activity (most of which is their own) with their name, that's sufficient to spy on them.

If you'd eaten chips this morning and there was a database of chip-eaters, eating chips would be considered personal information.

It's tiring to see these uninformed hot takes on GDPR on completely unrelated subjects.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by quicksilver03 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @09:28AM (#27254864)
> If a company had the IP of this couple they could link their online activity (most of which is their own) with their name, that's sufficient to spy on them.

If "most" of their online activity is their own, then some of it coming from "their" IP address isn't. You can pretend to be able to identify a person behind an IP address, but that doesn't make it true.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by IanCal on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:39AM (#27255282)
My name is personal data even though it's not unique, and my physical address is too even though I don't live alone.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by pbhjpbhj on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:43AM (#27255310)
IP address might be part of a proof based on balance of probabilities (used in Civil law cases, torts like copyright/trespass) but is unlikely to be useful in proving 'behind reasonable doubt' (ie in a criminal case), IMO, it might lead to something that provides such proof though.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by dpwm on Sunday May 23, 2021 @05:42AM (#27253692)
UK Police are interested in finding non-exculpatory evidence and securing convictions.

Computer forensics usually means software bought from a vendor and operated by a technician sometimes with no deep technical knowledge beyond the tool they use. It probably even works well for the common case, but breaks in cases where something unusual has happened.

UK ISPs mostly use an IP pool – meaning they have to keep records about who was assigned which IP at which time. Some may run carrier-grade NAT. Those records are obviously trusted, but may not necessarily be accurate – and even if they are, human mistakes occur, especially when working with things like IP addresses, dates and timezones.

But if not for following IP addresses, how else do you investigate this sort of thing?

I would argue the fault is in a mentality that suggests presuming guilt based on an IP address, then looking for the confirmatory evidence as an "icing on the cake," and a mentality that the investigation process should be so harrowing that the guilty will always go punished even if there isn’t enough evidence for an attempt at conviction. This is long after several such scandals around the same type of crimes.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by pjc50 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @07:39AM (#27254293)
They arrested Cliff Richard a few years ago in a highly publicised case that eventually they had to pay him for. This stuff tends to swing between "not investigating at all" and "jump on the first easy lead". Mind you, it is pretty difficult to investigate; if you have a seized messageboard and an upload record from an IP address, and that's all you have, how do you investigate?

(It's also interesting to compare the amount of sympathy these wrongly accused people receive versus other victims of police action ...)

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by Closi on Sunday May 23, 2021 @08:09AM (#27254457)
> If you have a seized messageboard and an upload record from an IP address, and that's all you have, how do you investigate?

I would say you search the computers, but do this in a very timely manor so that you do not have to involve employers and social services.

These searches should take minutes or hours, not months, and shouldn’t ruin people’s lives if they are innocent.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by kingosticks on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:16AM (#27255135)
> and shouldn’t ruin people’s lives if they are innocent.

Yes. The searches are not designed to ruin anyone's life but informing other parties, like what happened in this article, is sometimes necessary and and can have life ruining consequences even when entirely innocent. Things could leak out from the school to parents, to other work colleagues, limit career progression, etc. These leaks may even be intentional when stupid people are involved. Doing the searches quicker and being innocent or not doesn't help avoid either of the below (from the article) from happening:

> The police needed to unlock Matthew's work laptop, which was encrypted. He had to tell his boss about the case in order to get the decryption key.

> And the police had also informed social services and the children's school about the investigation, meaning Kate was suspended from her role as a governor there.

The first one could be unavoidable. The second one is technically avoidable but it is going to happen (in UK society, at least).

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by Closi on Sunday May 23, 2021 @11:52AM (#27255905)
> Doing the searches quicker and being innocent or not doesn't help avoid either of the below [...]

It could definitely have avoided the second.

I think there is a moral duty to carry out investigations in a way that protects the lives, reputations and livelihoods of the innocent, and this example has fallen short of that in my opinion (although a reasonable person could disagree).

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by kingosticks on Sunday May 23, 2021 @01:22PM (#27256732)
It sounds you think the UK police are able to perform a sufficienty thorough search in a matter of hours. That sounds ideal and of course theoretically feasible but maybe not realistic. For anything longer than hours they are always going to (and IMO should) remove a suspected person from a position that directly involves children.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by Closi on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:48PM (#27270095)
> For anything longer than hours they are always going to (and IMO should) remove a suspected person from a position that directly involves children.

This is the bit I disagree with personally, as I think it conflicts with 'innocent until proven guilty' when a person can be removed from their position and have their reputation destroyed by the police without sufficient evidence to convict (remember - no charge was ever made from the police).

It's pretty feasible to do an initial scan of a few devices within a few hours - and if you don't find enough evidence after a few hours of looking then IMO you don't have enough evidence to ruin someone's life (go get more evidence first in that case!).

The 'blast zone' of this investigation was ultimately two innocent people's reputations ruined in an attempt to find one guilty person (who wasn't found).

(Again, reasonable people will disagree on how far an investigation should be able to go prior to charge - my own view is clearly more on the 'protect the innocent, even if it means investigation is harder and a few baddies escape justice' side than some others might be!)

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by iso1210 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @09:05AM (#27254748)
> if you have a seized messageboard and an upload record from an IP address, and that's all you have, how do you investigate?

If I ran a message board, not only would I not capturing the upload IPs in any log files (hello GDPR in any case), I'd be tempted to put fake upload IPs in instead -- change the first two or three octets so the logs point to a government owned range.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by dm319 on Sunday May 23, 2021 @05:30AM (#27253630)
It's not surprising that people are suspected based on their IP address - most of the criminals involved in these kinds of crimes are unlikely to be tech-savvy enough to gain access to someone else's wifi router.

The problem with suspicion is that collateral damage to those who are innocent, but I don't think the answer is to not investigate.

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by actually_a_dog on Sunday May 23, 2021 @06:38AM (#27253987)
I don't think what happened to these people can be reduced to the phrase "collateral damage."
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by IanCal on Sunday May 23, 2021 @10:41AM (#27255297)
Collateral damage covers people getting blown up, it does not suggest mild outcomes.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by actually_a_dog on Sunday May 23, 2021 @06:24PM (#27259195)
As I said, I don't think an overly reductive euphemism intended to make people feel less bad about blowing other people up covers it.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by goatinaboat on Sunday May 23, 2021 @06:03AM (#27253786)
Is UK police so dumb that they suspect people solely based on ipv4?

The police aren't really interested in catching criminals or helping people. There's no promotions in that. Meeting a quota of number of arrests however, you'll be chief inspector in no time!

Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by dehrmann on Sunday May 23, 2021 @01:50PM (#27256985)
In the US, I'd expect an IPv4 address to be enough for probable cause unless the ISP is doing carrier-grade NAT. IPv4 shouldn't be enough for a conviction since there's obvious reasonable doubt.
Re:Did a weak WiFi password lead police to our door? by tzs on Sunday May 23, 2021 @11:05AM (#27255458)
How would you suggest that police investigate this kind of crime?