It's about hiring hitmen, buying drugs, buying child porn, stealing wallets from naive fools, stealing power by illegally hooking hidden mining centers to the grid, stealing power through mining malware, and so on and so on.
Crypto is a pyramid scheme for idiots, and on top of those idiots is propped up an entire ecosystem of illegal activity.
Since we already have enough currencies in the world, and decentralization only means theft can't be stopped at all and regulated, I'd say this mythical "value" of coins will never happen. The use case for regular law-abiding citizens buying shit online is already addressed. The use case for regular law-abiding companies doing large financial & asset transactions is also already addressed.
What wasn't addressed is anonymous cash transactions for criminals online, and that's what coins addressed. We don't need that.
So why shouldn't we ban it too?
> decentralization only means theft can't be stopped at all and regulated, I'd say this mythical "value" of coins will never happen.
You just explained the exact value proposition. Just because right now most westerners are able to have a reasonable degree of trust in their financial institutions doesn't mean that privacy "backstops" like strong encryption and cryptocurrency aren't beneficial.
Encryption has good uses, and some bad uses.
Cryptocurrencies have only bad uses.
See the difference?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NSA_cryptography
Yes, AES, SHA and so on, that's all the NSA.
If instead by "government controlled" you mean the government has a backdoor, then two things:
1. Most governments already have a backdoor in many major companies' cloud services.
2. The actual algorithm can't have a backdoor because there's no way to design it so it's "government-only". It'd be one key away from becoming every criminal's backdoor.
So as you see, everything actually makes sense there.
With point 2, I think you will see how the same line of thinking applies to cryptocurrency. The government is just one particular institution and there's no reason to expect them to be better stewards of the ability to sniff our encrypted messages than anyone else. Therefore, nobody should have that ability. I don't see why the same argument doesn't apply to encrypted "value transfers".
Who do you trust with your wallet? Mt. Gox? Altsbit? Upbit? BinDAX? Bitpoint? GateHub? Bitrue? Binance? DragonEx? Bithumb? CoinBene? Coinbin? Coinmama? Cryptopia? Oh yeah they all got hacked and lost their clients millions.
It's a useless comparison because encryption has been around for decades more than cryptocurrencies. The point is about the format of the argument. It doesn't make sense to say it's OK to ban a technology just because many people don't use it properly.
Protection against bad government(s), or at least bad actors in (good) government:
If you supported something like a ban on encryption or government issues Internet ID, I would honestly be contempt and respect your principled view, but I doubt you do.
As for outlawing cryptocurrency, that's a very narrow minded approach and it's very similar to banning encryption because criminals use it to evade law enforcement. Crypto asset networks are protocols so don't expect applications to produce end user value over night, just like TCP and HTTP didn't produce value over night.