Re:Maxwell’s Demon Continues to Startle Scientists
by thaumasiotes on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:58AM
(#27231250)
> a selectively-enforced barrier that lets hot particles through but not cold particles didn't obviously provably cost energy.
I think you're leaving something out of your description. We have passive selective barriers that will admit low-energy particles while reflecting high-energy particles. (Cotton, say, will reflect visible light while being transparent to infrared light.)
So what do you get by hanging a sheet between two rooms? Nothing.
I think Maxwell's Demon will only let hot particles pass through in one direction, but that's nothing new either; we have one-way mirrors.
Re:Maxwell’s Demon Continues to Startle Scientists
by Dylan16807 on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:26AM
(#27231387)
> I think Maxwell's Demon will only let hot particles pass through in one direction, but that's nothing new either; we have one-way mirrors.
We don't, actually. We have semi-transparent mirrors that allow a small fraction of the light through, and they appear "one-way" only when one side is vastly brighter than the other.
If that sounds like a cop out, remember that the Demon is a metaphor that's supposed to represent an as-yet-undiscovered technology. Like, instead of a literal massless door that opens and closes, something like, "What if we discovered a clever way of designing a little gap between two chambers and ionizing the particles such that only hot ones go through."