Re:Welcome to Libera Chat
by wrycoder on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:59PM
(#27213710)
Out of curiosity, why did HN bury that last one, with 555 points and 262 comments, eight pages down within twelve hours? Freenode and irc are of considerable interest to the hacker community.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Did you read the first comment in the thread? It pointed to a draft announcement that was not intended for public release.
I do not think HN should be the judge of whether a public webpage is intended as a draft. Certainly if it stays up after being covered.
Seems tricky. Surely the 262 comments were intended to be public.
I mean, clearly they are public since we are all looking at them.
I think this is a good reaction to accidentally publishing information that was intended to be private. Nothing is deleted, but you stop telling new people about it. People who already know can keep reading and talking.
In that case, I'd say bury it right away, not many hours later after it had collected hundreds of comments.
Yes, it was an unintentional leak. That was obvious.
What was more interesting - as is usually the case - was the HN discussion, from which I learned a lot.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat
by floatingatoll on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:28PM
(#27214058)
When something that isn’t final or certain reaches the FP (such as rumors, predictions, or leaked drafts), the mods will often quash the post for being such, even when for example it’s an Apple rumors post with hundreds of comments. I’ve seen occasional exceptions to this, primarily when it’s lawmaking or RFC-type work, as those drafts are quite often newsworthy. A leaked FYIQ draft from an IRC admin wouldn’t have registered to me as newsworthy, not until it was published, so I would have made the same decision the mods did.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat
by ineedasername on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @09:41PM
(#27216447)
Once it's out of the bag, all over reddit etc., might as well let the conversation continue.
We downweighted the thread as soon as we became aware that the text was a draft that wasn't intended to be public. There were two possibilities: either (1) it would become public soon enough, in which case there would be the chance for a big HN discussion then, and there's no harm in waiting (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...) or (2) it was a false alarm, in which case it probably didn't count as significant, besides which none of us would want our private drafts on sensitive topics circulating on internet forums.
Life took path (1) as we all know, and so this has been the most-discussed story on HN in the last couple days, including being at #1 on the front page all day today, and still.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat
by randomcoward on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @11:09PM
(#27216938)
Oh honey....do you not know who is behind Hacker News? Peter "fascist" Thiel. You think this apple is free n far from the tree?