EDIT: I get it - Schwab also had visible outages. Sorry for that. Maybe a good time to say I'm a happy Fidelity customer and have been for years :D
Sometimes, you have no idea if an order went through. With e-trade you get a sub-second push notification for trade confirmations, but with Schwab those push notifications come minutes or hours later. Meanwhile, if the website is down, you have no idea what exposure you have.
Taking a guess as an Engineer, they seem like load issues. Because page response times degrade from 2s, to 10s, to 30s, to timeouts.
You just need to cough up some $ and hire some ex-SF/SV folks who have done big sites -- something top-5 brokerages should be able to hire.
Yes they have. During one very red day they were down almost all morning (although StreetSmart Edge worked).
Point is, availability is important.
If that's not putting ones finger on the scale I don't know what is.
Wow... you really think the criticism is just because RH is better? What, is it jealousy or something?
Please. This isn't the case of someone being picked on by a schoolyard bully. RH is in the highly regulated, highly consequential consumer fintech space, and they are clearly gamifying trading.
All the subsequent criticisms follow from that fact.
If you want to make the claim RH isn't gamifying trading and therefore the criticisms are off base, please, I invite you to do so.
But to claim RH is the target of SEC investigations simply because they're good? Come on.
I have used RobinHood just a little bit, and it's not my main brokerage. However, I take issue with your phrasing. You start with the premise that whatever it is that RobinHood is doing is bad, it's impossible to argue against this where you are standing.
I hate the app that my main brokerage provides, but it was even worse before RobinHood existed. When I bought my first set of shares on RH, I was amazed by easy it was, and how well designed the UI was. IIRC, it is also super easy to find information on the stock that you're trading, so it's not like they are making the UI dumb.
I have read criticisms like how they make buying a stock seem inconsequential, but that's frankly pretty absurd to me. Do they need to make their UI flow less smooth, or give some big warning that people are dealing with real money?
If there are any parts of their app which encourages gambling, I agree it should be removed, but the actual criticisms I read are things like "they use bright flashy lights like slot machines" which seems very unconvincing.
That's quite literally what gamifying is: providing the kind of visual rewards/stimulus, combined with an extremely low friction experience, that's specifically designed to work in concert to encourage engagement.
In the case of a slot machine, that means putting coins in the machine and pulling the lever.
In the case of Robinhood, that means executing trades.
Maybe you don't believe those features of Robinhood actually encourage trading, but frankly, the psychology around RH's design is pretty well understood both in the technology industry and the gambling industry. Hell, there's an entire booked (Hooked!) written about it.
> Do they need to make their UI flow less smooth, or give some big warning that people are dealing with real money?
Yes. Absolutely. Why would that be a problem?
Ostensibly RH's mission is to provide people with free access to the markets to "regular folks" (read: inexperienced traders).
That's not the same thing as encouraging day trading.
I don't see why features that discourage excessive trading (which is unquestionably an anti-pattern for a typical retail trader, and therefore is not in the best interest of the folks RH is supposedly trying to empower) would be a bad thing...
... except, of course, RH's revenue is specifically derived from high trading volume, so it's not in their financial interest.
>Yes. Absolutely. Why would that be a problem?
Are you proposing that this warning can't be disabled or permanently dismissed? As an adult consumer I do NOT want this.
If so, a) you should reconsider, that's generally a good way to lose money, and b) you're probably classified as a pattern day trader, anyway, and you're already subject to a (very mild) speedbump:
https://robinhood.com/us/en/support/articles/pattern-day-tra...
> Pattern Day Trade Protection alerts you when you’ve placed three day trades and you’re about to place your fourth. You’ll have the option to proceed with your trade, or cancel it to avoid being marked as a pattern day trader.
Also, note even if you turn that alert off, you get another mild warning:
> Even if you turn off Pattern Day Trade Protection, we’ll still let you know when you’ve placed your second and third day trades in the five-day window. On your third day trade in the five-day window, we’ll remind you that you’ll be marked as a pattern day trader if you place one more day trade within the five days of your first day trade.
"you should reconsider, that's generally a good way to lose money" Some people make money off of doing this, you have no right to prevent people from day trading if that's what they want to do.
" you're probably classified as a pattern day trader, anyway, and you're already subject to a (very mild) speedbump:" This only applies if you have less than $25k in assets which most HN users probably have in excess of.
It seems like you clearly have a bias against robinhood without knowing the full reasons for why it's succeeded and how it's changed the brokerage industry for the better.
I don't agree with this. It's been a while since I used RH so maybe the current UI is different, but when I used it the stock price charts literally had no numbers on them. It was just a vague line that went up and down.
The options UI was also similarly dumbed down. It gave very light descriptions of different kinds of trades when purchasing, but very little concrete information about prices or risks. Plus the functionality was awful, you couldn't even sell options you held, outside of sending RH an email.
Stock and option flows are clearly designed towards appealing to users who know very little about investing.
You make it sound like this is outlandish, but it happens nearly every time a disruptive player comes into a heavily regulated market full of old players.
It is much easier to cry foul than to deal with the fact that the competition just got hard.
I think that is the issue. There is a tighter feedback loop that amounts to "gamifying" stock trading.
It's telling to me that the new investor cited in the article didn't take his dad's $1K, put it into a Vanguard index fund and call it a day. No, very much a day-trader type of customer is drawn to RH.
I'm not saying it's bad or good, but that seems to be the difference between RH and your Schwab brokerage.
During the GME debacle I decided to close my account and migrate entirely to fidelity and the transfer half-completed like described above, then failed entirely. It seems to me Robinhood was using my money to meet other obligations during a liquidity challenge.
Because they cant operate as a real brokerage as we saw with GameStop and manipulated the market as a result. I think that is the largest reason they are (rightfully) the whipping boy. They should not be allowed to be a trading platform because of that alone.
To be fair, I don't like RH. They are irresponsible, greedy and reckless. They have turned day trading into outright gambling - and quite frankly, if a gambling company gamified their UX the way RH did theirs, the gambling company execs would be rightfully raked over hot coals. Shitting on RH because they had to obey the clearing house rules is intellectual cowardice.
Disclosure: I work for a gambling company. And yes, I deal with compliance questions on an almost daily basis.
I think if you are going to operate as a brokerage you need to be able to fulfill all types of trades which in turn means you meet the needs of the clearing house, to limit investors to sells when you have funding from someone with a clear interest/holding/shorts (whatever) is a pretty stiff conflict of interest. This is just one of the reasons why they shouldn't be a brokerage. I understand that the clearing house changed the rules, but if you want to play in the game those are the rules. It is pure (even if it was truly non-intentional) market manipulation. They should have stopped all trading if they could not meet the needs of the clearing house (this can be debated as well). And if you cant meet the needs of the clearing house you do not deserve to be a brokerage IMO (I can see how this is also up for debate).
I agree your other points about gambling and gamifying, etc.... But the 'you are allowed to only sell and not buy a stock' is so grossly wrong I don't see how anyone can look past that unless you are 1) on the losing side of the coin (the shorts) and want to stop the bleeding or are heavily invested in RH performing a successful IPO.
The odd thing about the GameStop mess is that it inadvertantly exposed a lot of internal machinery of finance.
> But the 'you are allowed to only sell and not buy a stock' is so grossly wrong I don't see how anyone can look past that
I don't fall into either category, but I find myself disagreeing. These one-sided failure modes ("can only sell") are in fact common failsafes, although the reasons behind them are more generic. It may well be I look at things very differently because I operate on the other side.
Counterparty risks are real. When things start to fail, or there is a risk that an entity can not meet their obligations, the common fail safe is to limit/reduce exposure. Actions that would increase their exposure are not allowed, while actions that decrease their exposure, are.
When RH went into a one-sided failure mode with GameStop, they did what is required of them: they restricted their ability to increase exposure to a wildly imbalanced contract, only allowing trades that reduced the said exposure. Having these types of fail safes is, funnily enough, part of requirements for operating as a broker.
In effect, they were too poor to handle the outlier scenario. In the same way banks are too cash poor to allow all their customers to empty their accounts.
But oh boy, how they communicated that... now there's a lesson for future students.
If Robinhood seems like a whipping boy, it's because they've been earning negative press (like you said, they've made these mistakes) on a regular basis for the past 2.5 years.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/robinhood-gamest...
As other poster has noted, I think you have to apply on Schwab to trade options. I've never done that.
Vanguard is even more difficult. Application for a margin account requires mailing in a notarized form.
Robinhood makes it easy in order to profit off inept traders that have no business making these types of trades.
My point is this: RH has become the media's favorite whipping boy because retail trading has seen a spike in popularity not witnessed since the .COM Bubble. A lot of this critique is aimed at RH's interface/app because it is substantially better than the existing brokerages still using websites from the 1990s (this article criticizes it for being "slick" and complains about confetti).
The reality is that you can be a risky investor and lose it all on any brokerage, including Schwab, Fidelity, or TDA. RH has made some mistakes and isn't actually a good broker in my opinion, but dog piling them is just a proxy for arguments against retail investors being allowed to invest freely in the market (e.g. I've read multiple arguments for banning options trading for accounts under $25K for one example).