https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-05-11/crypto...
Case in point: I remember people glorifying veev making him sound like good guy and making his detractors sound like liers. Turned out differently.
They are a thief who just want money from people who can afford it.
It's still wrong and side-effect heavy, of course.
Governments in certain countries obviously tolerate this sort of hacking, if not outright support it. If you wanted to destabilize the US without directly starting a war, wouldn't that be a good way to go about it?
It might happen accidentally, as an unintentional side effect of efforts to extract a greater yield. (e.g, Colonial Pipeline.) But nobody wants to actually wreck the source of their livelihood.
And I don't think we have any reason to infer any other motive. This is certainly well outside my area of expertise, but their pattern of behavior doesn't really say, "state actor," to me.
This is the fascinating thing about Russian hackers to me. Maybe sometimes political favors change hands, but ultimately they're autonomous, self-funding, self-training, completely deniable assets. IMO Russia's brilliant in how they've managed their offensive hacking assets.
You could say the same for Afghanistan 20 years ago, but plausible deniability will only go so far..
If these hackers eventually end up hurting a lot of people, then who knows what happens next?
A US falling apart for real, would be bad for Russia as well as China. And vice versa. Because desperate people tend to do desperate actions - not a good thing with so many nukes involved.
So I also think, it is likely that at least some russian hacker groups have direct or indirect links to the FSB, and have to work for them occasionally - but most of them probably have indeed their own pocket as the main motivator.
We don't even need to go that far. A collapsing US would take down most of the world's financial system with it. In a place like Russia, where rich people with global financial holdings call the shots, that's not something they'd likely get behind.
So, pretty much like any other place, then?
From the article. So I guess it is the same principle.
You start small, learn, grow, expand, and after you've gained sufficient resources and the power that comes with that, then you get to do more.
> In Russia, for example, authorities there generally will not initiate a cybercrime investigation against one of their own unless a company or individual within the country’s borders files an official complaint as a victim.
Coincidence? Maybe at the start of organize technology crime, but not now.
Because of the `Russian Razor` principle:
It wasn't Russia
There's no way it was the Russians
It was the RussiansI don't think that was the case here, but... yeah.
I think the issue is people read that then add their own meaning to it, and then react to that instead of what was actually said. What they didn't say that people add of their own volition seems to be "and we're not evil", "and we're not criminals", "and we're the good guys". They didn't say those things. Their goal is to make money. That doesn't mean they think they're doing good in the world or innocent.
And 'apolitical' just means they're not choosing targets for political reasons, not that they're paragons of virtue or anything.
And to be clear, I'm not defending them, just observing the reactions to this. People seem desperate for there to be black and white morality decisions when everything is a shade of grey.
> What they didn't say that people add of their own volition seems to be "and we're not evil", "and we're not criminals", "and we're the good guys". They didn't say those things. Their goal is to make money. That doesn't mean they think they're doing good in the world or innocent.
What's funny about their statement is that it's such an obvious lie. They make money by creating problems for society; that's what they demand ransom for, removing the problem they created.
Bit funny how people read all kinds of stuff into their statement, but nobody so far has pointed out this discrepancy in what it actually says.
> It's just a variation of the Normalization of Deviance. See this[1] short talk by Richard Cook for a very good explanation of the mechanism that causes the transition from "robust" to "superfluous".
Not sure how that works, but is what I read.
Paying would make sense because if there was a vulnerability uncovered by the initial exploit (that is, account information compromised by the initial phishing attempt) then it is perfectly possible that the restored version will be easily exploitable by the same group.
I remember this being the case back in SQL Slammer days -- you could restore from backup but your backup would be infected within minutes.
It's not geopolitics if the victim lacks the will or technical firepower to punish the offender, right? ;)
To me, the most important aspect of this article is that you can make people think you are a Russian hacker signed off by Putin himself by adding these Commonwealth of Independent State checks to your code.
Reminds me of:
> Uncle Milton Industries has been selling ant farms to children since 1956. Some years ago, I remember opening one up with a friend. There were no actual ants included in the box. Instead, there was a card that you filled in with your address, and the company would mail you some ants. My friend expressed surprise that you could get ants sent to you in the mail. I replied: "What's really interesting is that these people will send a tube of live ants to anyone you tell them to." -- https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2008/03/the_security_...
> In a message posted to its victim shaming blog, DarkSide tried to say it was “apolitical” and that it didn’t wish to participate in geopolitics.
Yes but if destabilizing and disrupting a country's computer infra happens as a side-effect, you are still in the game of politics. Being 'apolitical' is paradoxically still being political, since if you are involved with large groups of people, you can't help but be political.