News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by sorenjan on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:40PM (#27177747)
This is what the payment screen looked like in Fortnite which made Apple ban it. Why shouldn't it be allowed?

https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-stor...

https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/news/the-fortnite-m...

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by Spartan-S63 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:52PM (#27177872)
Regardless of the behavior of selecting "Epic direct payment," this is a flagrant violation of App Store rules.

I agree, it seems sensical to allow an app to mention that buying direct from their website might be cheaper than going through in-app purchases. It might even be reasonable to open that link automatically.

I do think that it's reasonable to restrict third party payment processors, though. It's inconvenient, dangerous, and provides little in the way of antifraud measures if you're dealing with every app's purchase processor (assuming they don't all just use Stripe).

I actually think Apple's, "only our payment system can be used," system is reasonable. The percentage is maybe steep and would be better served by a progressive scale. But I also don't think Apple should be able to prevent an app from advertising their own payment system out of the app.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by monocasa on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:57PM (#27177930)
> Regardless of the behavior of selecting "Epic direct payment," this is a flagrant violation of App Store rules.

Yep, because they needed to flagrantly violate the rules if they thought the rules were not something that would stand up to legal scrutiny. The US court systems (particularly on the civil side) try not to rule on hypotheticals. They want to be discussing actual damages. Because of that, flagrantly violating the app store rules (to then get taken off the store) is the first step towards getting a judge to rule on if they were legal in the first place.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:59PM (#27177948)
>this is a flagrant violation of App Store rules.

Rules that many believe are unjust, hence this making it to court.

>I do think that it's reasonable to restrict third party payment processors, though. It's inconvenient

Paying for goods has never been easier especially with all the payment app integrations like paypal, cash app, venmo, etc.

I want choice and I want Apple to compete by being a better product not by being the only game in town. If Apple opened up they would gain me as a customer.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by Nextgrid on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:01PM (#27177974)
> It's inconvenient, dangerous, and provides little in the way of antifraud measures

The major card networks have rules that give customers recourse in case of fraud or missing/faulty goods regardless of the processor and card type. Some countries have laws that strengthen these protections even more, though it's usually limited to credit cards.

The "antifraud" narrative about how the App Store is so much better at fraud protection is annoying (especially considering how many scam apps there are).

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by salamandersauce on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:59PM (#27177946)
But they already allow third party payment processors in physical goods retail apps e.g the Amazon app for example (and many other much smaller retailers). Is fraud a much bigger concern in digital only apps? Why should I trust a small retailer with an app over a big development house like EA?
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by Nextgrid on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:03PM (#27177990)
The fraud aspect is either a mistake or there are people intentionally promoting a particular agenda. As you rightfully pointed out, online payments have been done for decades outside of the App Store and fraud has never been a dealbreaker (turns out banks and card networks give you a lot of recourse against it even for debit cards).
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by jussij on Sunday May 16, 2021 @08:50PM (#27178831)
> I actually think Apple's, "only our payment system can be used," system is reasonable. .... But I also don't think Apple should be able to prevent an app from advertising their own payment system out of the app.

Aren't those two positions mutually exclusive?

You can't have your cake and eat it too.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by R0b0t1 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:35PM (#27177684)
This is about people advertising in their own apps. Apple wants to prevent that using their monopoly power over their devices.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by vlovich123 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:48PM (#27177823)
What about if Amazon prevented a seller from advertising “direct to sale at a discount” and bypassing Amazon on their product page?
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:51PM (#27177859)
uhhh....this happens all the time already. Lots of Amazon sellers maintain web stores and purchasing options outside of Amazon.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by enos_feedler on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:08PM (#27178040)
And do they link to those stores from their amazon product descriptions?
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:17PM (#27178122)
Can you point to an example of Epic doing that from an Apple-owned page (meaning, specifically, not from the app that Epic owns)?

You're moving the goal posts further away from this example making sense.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by ntr-- on Sunday May 16, 2021 @09:02PM (#27178927)
I think it's a bit disingenuous to imply that the example in question^1 is less extreme than Amazon allowing sellers to directly link to discounted options directly on their listings.

The app in question was built, packaged, distributed, installed and runs on Apple funded SDKs after all.

1. https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-stor...

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Sunday May 16, 2021 @09:06PM (#27178954)
The source of the app is owned and maintained by Epic.

The source of an Amazon seller page is made through Amazon's portal.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by enos_feedler on Monday May 17, 2021 @10:47AM (#27184054)
Its splitting hairs to break this down into who compiled the code. The “source” of both experiences is maintained by the developer/seller. In one case it’s some configuration and the other case it’s Apple platform bitcode
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Monday May 17, 2021 @01:59PM (#27186202)
> Its splitting hairs to break this down into who compiled the code.

It's not. The difference between building your store and getting a booth in someone else's.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by ntr-- on Monday May 17, 2021 @09:56PM (#27190527)
To extend your simile, in this case Epic appears to have accepted a booth in a marketplace where there is significant foot traffic, easy access and well tested distribution channels. They are quite content selling their wares there yet do not want to pay the asking price and are actively telling people to go to their own marketplace on the other side of town.

Doesn't sound like a vendor I would want in my market either.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:59PM (#27200236)
> in this case Epic appears to have accepted a booth in a marketplace where there is significant foot traffic, easy access and well tested distribution channels.

No, and again, these moving goal posts make this conversation more and more meaningless.

Epic wants to sell their currency outside of the app store. They're not allowed to do so by Apple's TOS. This is the same as Amazon saying a website cannot sell to users on the Seller's personal site if the buyer owns an Amazon account. It's just monopoly garbage.

If it were possible to buy from _either_ the App Store or Epic's store, Epic would certainly ablige and just include a 30% upcharge. Of course, nobody would use it (as has been proven over and over again), but they would absolutely include it.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by enos_feedler on Monday May 17, 2021 @06:13PM (#27189057)
This makes no sense. Both the app store and amazon is someone elses store wrt Fortnite
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by void_mint on Tuesday May 18, 2021 @03:54PM (#27200170)
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by gsich on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:38PM (#27178329)
That's an ebay thing. I haven't seen different product descriptions on Amazon. There is only 1, no matter which seller you buy from.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by oh_sigh on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:52PM (#27177870)
That seller almost certainly signed a contract with amazon saying that they would give amazon most-favored nation status with regards to product prices. So they could absolutely say such a thing, but in the end they couldn't contractually offer anything at a cheaper rate than what they list it for on amazon.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by vlovich123 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:38PM (#27178324)
That's identical to contracts Epic signs to be on the Apple Store in the first place.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by PeterisP on Sunday May 16, 2021 @08:37PM (#27178755)
No, that's definitely not identical - no one, including Apple, is asserting that the fact that Fortnite users could by the same thing cheaper directly was a contract violation, the contentious issue was only that this cheaper price was being advertised on the iOS app.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by vlovich123 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @11:49PM (#27179885)
Right. Just as with Amazon. You don’t necessarily see Amazon with the lowest price for an item (the most favored nation thing may happen but I don’t know that that’s standard SOP for everything on the store, eg PlayStation may have discounts through other channels and for certain types of vendors they view as fungible without a brand they may not care at all). But you don’t see advertising for the cheaper option on the Amazon page.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by wernercd on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:42PM (#27177768)
As opposed to Apple forcing you to go through their gated options? When better payment, ad, search, email, browser, etc, etc, options exist?

Apples OS is decent and their options are "solid"... but for each of their offerings, there are better options and their options aren't worth the 30% tax.

Tons of companies have better payment options and should be allowed to use them without anti-competitive restrictions placed by Apple.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by noT1 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:46PM (#27177803)
They forced developers to develop for iOS?
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by salamandersauce on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:50PM (#27177850)
No, but considering iOS is roughly 50% or more of the mobile market in the U.S, U.K, Japan, etc. any developer choosing to forgo iOS is essentially shitting away half the market in some very lucrative places.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by ethbr0 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:00PM (#27177969)
More than that in terms of percentage of actual app revenue, since Google Play is such a $+#$show.
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by no_wizard on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:46PM (#27178401)
This is the crux of the matter, for most developers. Its why Apple is the target and not Google, despite having remarkably similar structure for this. The one exception is around having alternative App Stores (if I recall correctly this is totally blessed by Google, see Amazon Appstore App For Android[0], though I don't think any alternative store that has been created this way has thrived, cautionary tale of whether consumers will care about alternative app stores). Its otherwise the same, as far as I can tell[1] structurally.

[0]: https://www.amazon.com/gp/mas/get/amazonapp

[1]: https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by ethbr0 on Sunday May 16, 2021 @07:51PM (#27178435)
The only way alternative app stores would stand a chance is if an app store lottery were foisted on Google.

(A) They can't bundle GApps with Play Store & (B) they have to present an app store picker instead of defaulting to Google Play.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by no_wizard on Sunday May 16, 2021 @08:00PM (#27178498)
Wouldn't this be true regardless of circumstance?

I think the happy medium everyone should be striving for is just third party payment APIs that are blessed by the platform. This isn't about distribution (I don't think Epic cares if it's hosted on the App Store, Google Play, or not). It's all about payment processing.

If Apple and Google had a blessed Payment API that let developers use alternative payment processors, this would go away I imagine. I know some users want more freedom, but this lawsuit really isn't about user freedom, it's about payments (and if users do get more freedom, e.g. able to install apps in alternative ways, it's a side effect of this, not the goal of the lawsuit)

I wonder if Apple is forced to cut their fees in payments if they'll raise the developer fees to compensate, tiered based on size of the org.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by wernercd on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:55PM (#27177905)
They forced people to use subpar options within their environment - just like Microsoft forced IE to be used on theirs.

If you want to reach millions of customers, you are restricted to the Apple Payment options... even when better options exist. Same for Ad and other subpar options.

Why? Because they are better options? No... because Apple FORCES you to use those options.

"but you don't have to develop for Apple" is a copout that ignores the anti-competitive and monopolistic behavior Apple is using to force people into subpar options for a 30% gateway tax.

Similarly, others can't put good browsers onto Apple because of restrictions... why? because webkit is the REQUIRED base... despite the fact that its restrictions mean you can't use webapps as real alternatives because of limitations with controllers, bluetooth, etc.

Google can make better alternatives to Safari? Firefox can? Microsoft can? doesn't matter... Apple FORCES you to use their subpar options because if there was real competition, they wouldn't get a 30% tax.

Spread that decision to email clients and all other corners of the Apple "ecosystem" and you have a company using monopolistic practices to limit competition to increase prices.

"but don't do business on their platform" doesn't change the fact that they are using monopolistic practices to fleece their customers.

I don't like EA and think they are an equally horrible company - and should be judged equally poorly for many bad practices... but EA (and netflix, steam, etc) should have the ability to not use Apples gated options and not pay for a service that isn't worth 30% - especially when they can host their own payment and ad services.

Stop with the bad arguments to defend a company using monopolistic practices to fleece their customers.

I say this as an iPhone owner and a programmer.

Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by ericwooley on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:35PM (#27177692)
Nonsense. No where has anyone implied that.

Apps should be able to offer a choice of how users can pay.

[dead]
Re:Apple-Epic judge asks why offering iOS users a choice is bad by Turing_Machine on Sunday May 16, 2021 @06:49PM (#27177835)
So, in your opinion, it should be legal to sell yourself into slavery? How about debt peonage?

Society has determined that certain things are not allowed because they are inherently abusive, "legal contracts" or not.