I agree, it seems sensical to allow an app to mention that buying direct from their website might be cheaper than going through in-app purchases. It might even be reasonable to open that link automatically.
I do think that it's reasonable to restrict third party payment processors, though. It's inconvenient, dangerous, and provides little in the way of antifraud measures if you're dealing with every app's purchase processor (assuming they don't all just use Stripe).
I actually think Apple's, "only our payment system can be used," system is reasonable. The percentage is maybe steep and would be better served by a progressive scale. But I also don't think Apple should be able to prevent an app from advertising their own payment system out of the app.
Yep, because they needed to flagrantly violate the rules if they thought the rules were not something that would stand up to legal scrutiny. The US court systems (particularly on the civil side) try not to rule on hypotheticals. They want to be discussing actual damages. Because of that, flagrantly violating the app store rules (to then get taken off the store) is the first step towards getting a judge to rule on if they were legal in the first place.
Rules that many believe are unjust, hence this making it to court.
>I do think that it's reasonable to restrict third party payment processors, though. It's inconvenient
Paying for goods has never been easier especially with all the payment app integrations like paypal, cash app, venmo, etc.
I want choice and I want Apple to compete by being a better product not by being the only game in town. If Apple opened up they would gain me as a customer.
The major card networks have rules that give customers recourse in case of fraud or missing/faulty goods regardless of the processor and card type. Some countries have laws that strengthen these protections even more, though it's usually limited to credit cards.
The "antifraud" narrative about how the App Store is so much better at fraud protection is annoying (especially considering how many scam apps there are).
Aren't those two positions mutually exclusive?
You can't have your cake and eat it too.
https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-stor...
https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/news/the-fortnite-m...