News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ssharp on Saturday May 15, 2021 @08:57AM (#27164775)
UBI isn't unemployment. You could collect UBI and still work.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:09AM (#27164869)
You could but no one would because they make more money not working. It equates to basically paying the company to work.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ItsMonkk on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:21AM (#27165471)
I find it fascinating that this community can both have this stance and find nothing wrong with the FIRE movement.

What is a $1000/month UBI? Using the 4% rule, it's equivalent to having investments worth $300000.

I have a feeling that a lot of people on HN have a portfolio worth $300000. Are you still working?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:33AM (#27165567)
It’s not just employees but my close friends. They refuse to work because they will make more on unemployment. Making less by working means they are essentially paying someone to work. What is FIRE movement?
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ItsMonkk on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:59AM (#27165763)
> Making less by working means they are essentially paying someone to work.

Note that this is one of the benefits of the UBI. As it is universal, if you get a job you will keep getting your UBI. So there will never be a time where this occurs if we switch. Work would always be incentivized.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:26AM (#27166033)
This would be true if it was actually universal, but as far as I can tell these UBI benefits are usually only for the poor.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by hollerith on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:43AM (#27165631)
"financial independence and retire early".
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by chii on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:36AM (#27165588)
> find nothing wrong with the FIRE movement.

because those that get onto FIRE earned it themselves, rather than off the backs of taxpayers like in UBI.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by ItsMonkk on Saturday May 15, 2021 @01:53PM (#27167359)
Well at least we both agree to 100% inheritance taxes.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by chii on Sunday May 16, 2021 @12:08AM (#27171153)
inheritance is already taxed when the income of the parents was taxed! So i'm 100% against inheritance tax. After all, the parents earned that inheritance at some point (or their parents did, if they inherited it).

Inheritance isn't a handout from the taxpayer to private entities.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by qwytw on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:15AM (#27164906)
You'd get both the UBI + wage/salary, I'm not quite sure how that translates to "basically paying the company to work".
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by jokethrowaway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:26AM (#27164999)
If I get enough money with ubi I won't waste my life working on something I don't care about.

The amount of people who would continue their job if it wasn't for the money it's slim

I definitely wouldn't waste my time building someone else product and creating value for society. I'd likely build something fun I want to build which is unlikely to be useful for society or make money.

A large part of the populatin on would happily paint, cook, read books, watch movies, play videogames until they die - if they had the money.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by danShumway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:35AM (#27165070)
You'll still get paid for your normal job. It's not like that money would be thrown away, you're not working for free. You go to your job and work because you want more money.

I think UBI is largely untested and its proponents should proceed with caution. But I also think people are overconfident in assuming that people wouldn't work; the reality is that we don't have a ton of data in either direction.

If the 20th-21st century has taught us anything, it's that consumerism is a very powerful motivator. People like to have money to buy luxuries, most people don't want to sit on subsistence levels of income their entire lives. People want things. They want to buy videogames, and XBoxes, and nice houses, and cars, and iPhones, and to go to fancy restaurants.

Whether consumerism is a powerful enough motivator... I just think people are very over-confident talking about what is definitely going to happen in a system that has basically never been tried before.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:59AM (#27165310)
Today’s stimulus is a perfect example of UBI. 33.8% of all personal income in the last year came from the government. It results in everyone having more money to spend but eventually as we see now shortages in just about everything, those shortages cause prices to rise and soon even though everyone has more money, everything costs more. The market settles prices in the end and trying to control the market by pumping cash only works for a short term. Take an example of say Las Vegas limit surge pricing limit for Uber’s. They said we don’t want Uber’s to be expensive so we’ll limit how much they can charge. So what happens, prices are low, great! But.... now drivers don’t make what they are worth and no one wants to drive uber. Now uber in Vegas wait times can be hours longs making the service essentially useless. Many would gladly pay more to actually get an Uber, but they can’t even if they wanted to. Giving everyone more money is the same as trying to lower the price of everything. It just can’t happen from an economic standpoint without unintended consequences.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by danShumway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:13AM (#27165405)
> Today’s stimulus is a perfect example of UBI.

> eventually as we see now shortages in just about everything

This is a pretty big jump in logic. We've had a ransomware account that shut down a gas pipeline, we've had mass business shutdowns in multiple countries that affected the entire economy, we've had a large shipping block. It's pretty hard to blame the current chip shortage on the stimulus.

I do not understand how people get so wildly confident about this stuff whenever UBI comes up. I would not be so confident to claim that supply shortages for materials/foods from other countries are being caused by a stimulus in the US, particularly during a period where our government policy was to specifically tell people that the responsible, social thing to do not to go into their jobs.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by smaryjerry on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:45AM (#27165648)
I’m not even talking about gas. I’m taking about chips, lumber, chicken, and much much more. All of them are having shortages and it has nothing to do with randomware but it is important to recognize that using stimulus is like using a budget, spending money in one spot means you can’t spend it in another, while we have gone all in on the pandemic we forget that other problems like ransomware and whatever else comes up still need to be addressed and take money to correct.
Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by danShumway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @11:25AM (#27166021)
> All of them are having shortages and it has nothing to do with randomware

But also it's relatively unlikely that any of them have anything to do with the US stimulus. We import most of our chips.

I'm not even saying that shipping/factory shutdowns are the sole cause of inflation right now. But it's really overconfident to say that the stimulus is the cause of all of those increases, I think that's pretty unlikely to be the largest cause. It's just a pretty large oversimplification -- do people seriously believe that if a stimulus hadn't happened that shipping costs would have gone down during a pandemic?

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by prepend on Saturday May 15, 2021 @09:53AM (#27165257)
> If the 20th-21st century has taught us anything, it's that consumerism is a very powerful motivator.

Or, perhaps, that there is much attention on consumers who spend significantly as they have “louder” lifestyles that are easy to show.

Poverty rates are high with 14% of the US under the poverty line [0] and I don’t think consumerism is motivating them very much.

And I think it’s risky to equate considering as a large scale motivator based on extrapolating mass consumer behavior to all.

[0] https://www.prb.org/usdata/

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by danShumway on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:03AM (#27165339)
Well, yeah, like I said:

> Whether consumerism is a powerful enough motivator... I just think people are very over-confident talking about what is definitely going to happen in a system that has basically never been tried before.

People are really eager to look at populations and make very strong assertions about what their intrinsic motivators are with (in my mind) little evidence.

> and I don’t think consumerism is motivating them very much.

Are 14% of the population below poverty levels because they like living there? Because our systems discourage saving money once you're on wellfare? Because of market pressures? We have basically zero large-scale experiments, but people on both sides of the UBI test seem really confident that they know what everyone will do.

Re:Universal basic income to be tested in Wales by Al-Khwarizmi on Saturday May 15, 2021 @10:32AM (#27165558)
Sounds like your work is worth more than you get paid for, then. You are only accepting to do it because you don't want to starve, i.e., it's a decision where one of the parties is under coercion.

A really free labor market would be one where your life is not at risk if you refuse the job offer (as with UBI). In that situation, how much money would convince someone to accept your job? That's the real value of your job.