> eventually as we see now shortages in just about everything
This is a pretty big jump in logic. We've had a ransomware account that shut down a gas pipeline, we've had mass business shutdowns in multiple countries that affected the entire economy, we've had a large shipping block. It's pretty hard to blame the current chip shortage on the stimulus.
I do not understand how people get so wildly confident about this stuff whenever UBI comes up. I would not be so confident to claim that supply shortages for materials/foods from other countries are being caused by a stimulus in the US, particularly during a period where our government policy was to specifically tell people that the responsible, social thing to do not to go into their jobs.
But also it's relatively unlikely that any of them have anything to do with the US stimulus. We import most of our chips.
I'm not even saying that shipping/factory shutdowns are the sole cause of inflation right now. But it's really overconfident to say that the stimulus is the cause of all of those increases, I think that's pretty unlikely to be the largest cause. It's just a pretty large oversimplification -- do people seriously believe that if a stimulus hadn't happened that shipping costs would have gone down during a pandemic?
Or, perhaps, that there is much attention on consumers who spend significantly as they have “louder” lifestyles that are easy to show.
Poverty rates are high with 14% of the US under the poverty line [0] and I don’t think consumerism is motivating them very much.
And I think it’s risky to equate considering as a large scale motivator based on extrapolating mass consumer behavior to all.
> Whether consumerism is a powerful enough motivator... I just think people are very over-confident talking about what is definitely going to happen in a system that has basically never been tried before.
People are really eager to look at populations and make very strong assertions about what their intrinsic motivators are with (in my mind) little evidence.
> and I don’t think consumerism is motivating them very much.
Are 14% of the population below poverty levels because they like living there? Because our systems discourage saving money once you're on wellfare? Because of market pressures? We have basically zero large-scale experiments, but people on both sides of the UBI test seem really confident that they know what everyone will do.
I think UBI is largely untested and its proponents should proceed with caution. But I also think people are overconfident in assuming that people wouldn't work; the reality is that we don't have a ton of data in either direction.
If the 20th-21st century has taught us anything, it's that consumerism is a very powerful motivator. People like to have money to buy luxuries, most people don't want to sit on subsistence levels of income their entire lives. People want things. They want to buy videogames, and XBoxes, and nice houses, and cars, and iPhones, and to go to fancy restaurants.
Whether consumerism is a powerful enough motivator... I just think people are very over-confident talking about what is definitely going to happen in a system that has basically never been tried before.