Reason for that is that Irc drama attracts brazillian hackers and script kiddies like flies, having an irc server is like having a huge DDoS magnet, having a irc server is an excellent way to make a whole ISP crumble under attack.
Last major irc network we had went bankrupt because of their DDoS protection costs rising and rising and rising until they went in debt to stay online and until they couldn't pay the debts.
IRC in Brazil was mostly born on university campi but, by the second half of the 90's it quickly attracted teens who simply wanted to chat. Our version of the Eternal September.
Most used OS at the time was win9x and most used IRC client was mIRC. Actually, most users didn't know the difference between mIRC and IRC. So, it was very very unsafe for illiterate users. Self-reproducing mIRC scripts and people trying to fool others with netbus and the like was extremely common.
One day, by the end of the 90's, both major networks joined. The service quality went deeply down. Operators of big channels lost their status, illiterate users flooded the network and traditional brasnet channels got filled with users from redebreasil who weren't used to the established netiquette. To make things worse, redebrasil had advertisements and such ads went together with them when they joined brasnet.
That day was one of the saddest days of my life, that day I lost my operator status on #programacao on brasnet, I was 15 and getting that status was no easy task. It was the day I stopped using IRC in Brazil.
The thing just went downhill from there. Getting IRCop status was reason to act arrogantly, attacks were rampant and winxp came along been not much safer than win9x. Netsplit was common because of the attacks, bots tryied to fool people to shady and phishing sites, there was no control to stop abuse from IRCops...
Then, by the beginning of the 2000's IM became more popular, then social networks. Actually MSN messenger and orkut popularity were major blows in brazilian IRC. New people buying computers to get connected no longer even knew about the existence of what was once a major entertainment communication medium.
The quality of the service didn't improve, and users started migrating away from it. It commercially devalued, ISP's didn't want to host it and, in 2007, brasnet was closed: http://www.brasnet.org/2007/05/era-uma-vez-o-irc-brasileiro....
Ha, ha saw what you did there!
So, apparently for freenode staff it's either "Lee's way or the hiway"?
For example many MMORPGs have Brazil-only servers, because brazillians tend to hack, cheat and troll, so many games have ip-banned the entire Brazil range and then made a server just for Brazillians.
When website defacing was all the rage, Brazil had the dubious hanking of having the most defacing groups and the most defaced sites, despite internet in Brazil being much smaller than US or EU.
According to Kapersky last year, Brazil is first place in cibercrime ranking in South America, and third in the worldwide ranking.
Brazil is also currently fourth place worldwide in the number of bot farms.
Citation needed. Most ISPs ban IRC ports due to having a large amount of customers that are members of a botnet via a virus.
Any community with sub-groups and a privilege system for ops/voice/... will generate drama.
It's not a fatality either, I've been on many smaller channels that were focusing on a specific topic and mostly used for technical discussions and the only moderator interventions were to kick spammers or update the /topic.
It saddens me a bit that IRC is so unpopular with newer generations, now the discussion has moved to proprietary, centralized solutions like Discord. Yet another nail in the free, distributed, decentralized, non-ad-driven, non-HTTP-based internet coffin.
The fact that anyone can start their own group limits tin god syndrome on those networks. IRC requires moderate technical skill and either running or paying for servers, which is enough of a hurdle that admins can get away with quite a lot of bad behaviour before being ousted.
Many internet users sure love complaining about "muh free speech" post-facto when they're more than happy to buy into closed ecosystems in the first place.
This is not aimed at you personally by the way, I'm just always frustrated to see this pattern repeating itself year after year and yet users keep hoping to new proprietary platforms. "No but we swear it's different this time you guys!!".
And back in its heydays there were enough big IRC networks that you could just hop from one to the other if the admins became a nuisance. Then you had an eggdrop bot synchronize both channels during the migration, good times.
Well yeah but with IRC you used to be able to perform hostile takeovers by knocking people offline strategically.
You can't really do that with Discord so the drama tends to stay as an argument rather than a DDoS battle
Surely this is selection bias, you don't hear about -no- drama.
I run an IRC network which hasn't had any real drama for 15 years... (Current global users: 322 Max: 1514)
I say that as an IRC user for at least 2 decades and a recent convert to Matrix.
Discord is probably the closest spiritual successor to irc (the types of communities using discord are the same types of communities that used irc in the past).
The whole point of Matrix is decentralisation and federation - which is closer to the spirit of IRC than what Discord is.
Also, Matrix is a protocol, not a centralised service like Discord.
It isn't really. I can't confirm this despite being part of the biggest rooms in the network on matrix.org.
It was slow (very slow) once (when Matrix grow and Synapse wasn't scalable), but that has been in the past for a while now
Uh, some locked down corporate please-read-your-terms-of-service closed-source crapware?
That's pretty much the exact opposite.
IRC is not a home. Discord is a home. FreeNode is (was?) a home. The admin and moderation team (and the corporate structure therein) makes a difference that technical details cannot replicate.
But with Discord users are locked in to use the closed source Discord clients, or reverse engineer the discord “protocol” and risk being banned because of it.
> You are not mistaken. We do not support 3rd party clients, and they are not allowed per our ToS/API ToS.
https://old.reddit.com/r/discordapp/comments/8tukek/ripcord_...
is not exactly the same level of supports third party clients that IRC or Matrix do.
Email is what makes it happen that systems can exchange messages with each other. Much like Matrix. Much unlike Discord.
> They want ... some ... service that gives them email.
Aren't these two statements contradictory?
"I have email" and "I have email service" mean the same thing to me.
Discord is out, as others have mentioned, for being controlled by a single corporation.
I've had no problems with either my homeserver nor with Element -desktop or -android.
It seems the whole business, filled with young opinionated people, really invites these kind of dramas.
Do something, or vote.
The political modus operandi of open source, to the extent that there is one, has generally been to opt out of existing structures and try to create new ones, rather than altering or dismantling existing ones.
Fixed that for you.
https://www.biologicaldiversity.org/news/center/articles/201...
I'd say it lasted.
But well, everything is political nowaday, and people apparently can't get political without creating drama. See: the last basecamp outrage.
I think you mean "polarized". And polarization is happening only in some societies, mostly in the anglosphere.
In many other places society was much more polarized 50 or 60 years ago.
But if I was to assume that you are talking about the US, both gender and racial discrimination around bathroom policies has been a hot discussion topic on-and-off for more than a hundred years.
Which apparently internet people have a hard time to handle.
I have parties at home with feminists and machists, cryto speculators and communists, vegan meditators and frat guys bbq body builders, atheist hedonists and muslim minimalists, yet they manage to have fun together.
When I read such title I can't help but thinking "what are they, 5 years old?".
Your parties sound like a blast!
They are, but they take a month to prepare for.
> Like the GP of this thread you might want to reread the actual post rather than skim the title. (see my other comment).
In retrospect, yeah.
IRC is a constant drama, all the way back to The Great Split[0]
Been involved with IRC a good 25 years, running a pretty popular blog about it "back in the days", i just couldn't be bothered keeping it up and updated because of all the constant fighting, arguing, bickering and people outright attacking each other all the damn time.
I'm not entirely sure what it is, but something about IRC gives people big egos, omnipotence fantasies which, again, leads to drama - i, myself, just concluded it wasn't worth my time anymore and moved on.
Mind you, this comes from someone who met his (former) wife on IRC, made great friendships with people all over the world - something i'm still grateful for to this very day.
But it wasn't made to last, sadly.
[0] http://www.irc.org/history_docs/TheGreatSplit.html