News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by Havoc on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:43PM (#27136060)
I’m still not quite following why people are looking at bitcoin for this. Surely one of the newer generation like eth is better suited? Or better yet a layer 2 on eth
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by gruez on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:47PM (#27136092)
>Surely one of the newer generation like eth is better suited?

What scaling technologies do they have? The ones I'm aware of are: "commit the global state every n blocks and trust that", and "have n parallel blockchains so it's not one big chain"

>Or better yet a layer 2 on eth

or layer 2 on BTC, aka lightning network?

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by vmception on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:29PM (#27136488)
Ethereum has 8 distinct active layer 2 technologies including things analogous to lightning network, as they are permissionless to build and deploy there.

Turns out nobody likes watchtowers which lightning style solutions require, the market is not choosing that

Bitcoin does not represent choice, it represents throwing all eggs in one basket and defending that with no competition (lightning). More like a state capital system.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:02PM (#27136730)
> Bitcoin does not represent choice

Why not? Anyone can use bitcoin for anything they want. And any other cryptocurrency can compete with bitcoin if they want (and clearly many try). Seems we have plenty of choice in the market at the cryptocurrency moment.

The difference is that in Bitcoin land, people cooperate to build standards. In Ethereum, far fewer standards are created, and instead people just build whatever Ethereum based project they want and try to sell that. So yes, there are more choice, but the quality of those choices is a lot lower. For example, in Bitcoin there's one lightning network standard, and many wallets that implement that stanrdard. By contrast there's a ton of layer 2 networks on Ethereum and none of them interoperate and each one has a single implementation (generally).

> nobody likes watchtowers

The number of bitcoin lightning nodes has been constantly growing since its inception, and pretty much every metric is at an all time high: https://bitcoinvisuals.com/lightning . So .. I think you're not correct there.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by vmception on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:12PM (#27136797)
There are many standards on Ethereum. There are also many people building their own things to try and extract value for themselves.

Bitcoin has some obscure things besides lightning due to the permissionless nature as well, but the limitations come from the block space and the smaller set of operations allowed

The comparison about what the market chose comes from TVL and volume metrics. see www.defipulse.com which also includes lightning

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by Ar-Curunir on Thursday May 13, 2021 @01:28AM (#27138735)
Decentralized cryptocurrency tech is in its infancy. Just like you wouldn't standardize on programming languages in the 50s, it makes no sense to already talk about standardizing things that are under active research.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by DennisP on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:55PM (#27136167)
Ethereum shards share security, so you can't just do a 51% attack on one shard.

Zkrollups on Ethereum have the same security properties as on-chain transactions, with no need for monitoring and no withdrawal delays. That can't be said for the LN.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:07PM (#27136765)
Sharding is fraught with issues. One fundamental issue is that by the very nature of sharding, you have fewer nodes on each shard, which makes it easier to perform sybil attacks on a particular shard. Shards aren't a pancia. Also, if you have, say, 10 shards - that isn't giving you 10x throughput. Its gonna give you maybe 2x throughput because what shards are doing is allowing lower-power machines help run the network, and those lower-power machines are not as effective as the rest, so they aren't contributing as much. I mean, its not cut and dry because there may be a lot of extra machines depending on the state of the network and resource requirements, but its generally not a linear relationship there.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CryptoPunk on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:57PM (#27137203)
All nodes validate the root hash of every shard, so no, a Sybil attack on one shard is no easier than on the entire blockchain.

It may even be harder, as there would be more nodes in total when the hardware/network resources a person needs to run a node decline from what's needed to validate the whole blockchain, to what's needed validate the fraction of the blockchain contained in one shard, or conversely, when 64X more economic activity, and thus more people, are utilizing the blockchain, as a result of the scalability boost provided by dividing the blockchain into 64 shards.

>>Also, if you have, say, 10 shards - that isn't giving you 10x throughput. Its gonna give you maybe 2x throughput because what shards are doing is allowing lower-power machines help run the network, and those lower-power machines are not as effective as the rest, so they aren't contributing as much.

They don't have to be lower power machines. If the blockchain is divided into 64 shards, then the total network throughput can increase by 64X with the power requirements of validating machines not changing.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CyberDildonics on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:54PM (#27136160)
Why? It has been in development for 7 years.

Why use this complicated hack solution when anyone can just use a different cryptocurrency and not have these problems in the first place?

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by wyager on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:57PM (#27136190)
> It has been in development for 7 years.

Good. They need to get it right.

> Why use this complicated hack solution

It’s complicated but not a hack at all. It makes perfect sense.

> when anyone can just use a different cryptocurrency and not have these problems in the first place?

There are 0 (zero) cryptocurrencies that scale better than Bitcoin that don’t also compromise on security or decentralization. Lightning is the best known option which keeps these properties which make Bitcoin desirable in the first place.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CyberDildonics on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:07PM (#27136298)
There is at least monero, bitcoin cash and ethereum. Bitcoin Cash and Ethereum both have more transactions than bitcoin already. Ethereum has four times the transaction throughput. Bitcoin Cash has 32x the max block size. There is no technical reason bitcoin could not increase their max block size, but then there would be no reason for their hacky second layer to exist.

The only way what you are saying makes sense is if you decide to for some reason define security as "bitcoin's hashing and has rate".

No one is doing any sort of mining attacks on bitcoin cash, monero or ethereum.

Like the "lightning network" the only way to pretend it is necessary is to pretend it solves a made up problem.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:09PM (#27136780)
> There is no technical reason bitcoin could not increase their max block size

You should read the paper this thread is about. It tells you tons of technical reasons that it would be a bad idea to increase the max block size very much if at all.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by topranks on Thursday May 13, 2021 @02:38AM (#27139134)
It doesn’t really though.

It makes laughable claims like miners have only 94KB of bandwidth.

It’s the same old fud that says SPV is unsafe for the average user, Moore’s law is nonexistent, and even then makes crazy lowball assumptions about what hardware and network connectivity people have.

It’s basic fallacy is the same old one that says every user needs to download and validate the entire chain and all transactions to use Bitcoin.

If that’s true it’s going nowhere anyway.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by zionic on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:35PM (#27137005)
Ethereum has increased its max block size 7+ times in the last 5 years and has had zero issues doing so. “Papers” from technically illiterate authors that ignore very real, tangible evidence contradicting them are about as useful as flat earth “math”.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by fsh on Thursday May 13, 2021 @01:56AM (#27138907)
Except that I can easily run a full bitcoin node on my desktop but not an ethereum node. What is the point of having a cryptocurrency if I have to trust someone else to run the software for me?
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by wyager on Thursday May 13, 2021 @07:58AM (#27141097)
Ethereum archive nodes are >20x larger than Bitcoin full nodes and notoriously hard to set up.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by wyager on Thursday May 13, 2021 @07:46AM (#27141010)
Yeah no shit you can just increase the block size. That doesn’t result in better asymptotic scaling.

Spinning up an ethereum full node (“archive node”) is way harder than spinning up a Bitcoin full node, partially because the eth blockchain is over 7TB vs about 300GB for BTC.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by tromp on Thursday May 13, 2021 @03:42AM (#27139441)
Mimblewimble improves on Bitcoin's scalability by allowing all spent outputs to be removed from the Initial Block Download.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by loveitmore on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:07PM (#27136296)
0 that scale better? XRP performs better at scale and I don’t believe for a second Bitcoin is anymore decentralized.

That being said, I don’t know enough about the security aspect - so your claim may end up being correct!

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:08PM (#27136772)
XRP isn't decentralized at all... Bitcoin is absolutely far far far more decentralized than a currency that is wholely controlled by a single company.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by tastyfreeze on Thursday May 13, 2021 @01:25PM (#27144750)
Define decentralized.

Ripple owns a lot of XRP(in escrow). That is the only claim of centralization that is true. The network has equal or greater decentralization than BTC.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by Havoc on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:36PM (#27136547)
>What scaling technologies do they have? The ones I'm aware of are

Not Eth, but you're missing one option - tree graph based. They've pushed 3000+ TPS through it already in testnets...and that's on layer 1. High level description:

https://confluxnetwork.medium.com/tree-graph-structure-of-co...

>or layer 2 on BTC, aka lightning network?

Indeed - that could work. I do think Eth has the edge though. Throughput only matters if you have an eco-system that needs it ultimately.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:57PM (#27136694)
> They've pushed 3000+ TPS through it already in testnets

Whenever someone says something like "they've tested it with X throughput", it usually means that they're not considering security properties. Sure, you can push throughput through on test machines in a test setting and it will happen. But in an adversarial environment, systems pushed to those limits can often be attacked. Its not sufficient to test throughput in normal conditions. You have to go through every attack vector and test the throughput during attacks and ensure the throughput you're pushing through isn't making those attacks easier to pull off.

Centralized systems can push plenty of throughput. The question is not: "How fast can we make this system run?", the question is "how fast can we make this system run WHILE keeping its properties of decentralization and resilience against attacks?".

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by Havoc on Thursday May 13, 2021 @03:13AM (#27139286)
>usually means that they're not considering security properties.

They claim they have managed security, scalability and decentralization. I'm in no position to evaluate this. However they've got Sequoia onboard, plus a Turing award winner, plus Shanghai gov and team is full of PhDs...so I figured good enough for me.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by wyager on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:00PM (#27136222)
You would think so, but there have not actually been any meaningful scaling improvements that don’t boil down to “trust a centralized authority”. Taking all factors into account, Lightning is currently the best known option (although it is fairly complicated).
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by billytetrud on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:50PM (#27136652)
What's better about Ethereum in this regard? People are still looking to Bitcoin because its substantially larger than Ethereum in pretty much every way (development, market cap, awareness, etc), its got a way better track record than Ethereum, its far more decentralized (Vitalik is still the god of Ethereum). There's lots of reasons people still look to Bitcoin.

> Surely one of the newer generation like eth is better suited?

Why surely?

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by zionic on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:36PM (#27137012)
Bitcoin is essentially dead development wise, virtually all exciting development is happening on ETH.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by smabie on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:08PM (#27137657)
I hear much more talk about ethereum than I do about BTC.

He'll, I don't even have a personal BTC wallet and no one I know does either. Everything is ERC20: if you want BTC exposure, you hold WBTC not BTC.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by axiosgunnar on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:08PM (#27136771)
Isn‘t ETH in the vicinity of an order of magnitude to Bitcoin's market cap etc?

Which is „pretty much the same“ in crypto terms.

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by CryptoPunk on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:33PM (#27137446)
There is substantially more development on Ethereum:

https://medium.com/electric-capital/electric-capital-develop...

There is also substantially more economic activity on Ethereum, with users paying 10X more fees to utilize it over the last 7 days:

https://twitter.com/iamDCinvestor/status/1392468184482164741

Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by somjeed on Thursday May 13, 2021 @01:07AM (#27138621)
I'm skeptical of a few things in the medium post, for instance if you compare the etherium's ERC20 defi ecosystem to bitcoin, you will get more git repositories because there are simply more coins. Secondly, more is not always better, and measuring developer activity by git repositories is like measuring lines of code as a metric for the amount of work being done.
Re:An analysis of Bitcoin's throughput bottlenecks by ButtSpark69 on Thursday May 13, 2021 @01:45AM (#27138837)
Because right now Bitcoin can only do currency, whereas Ethereum (and some other crypto's) can do anything a computer can do, since they are turing complete.

Granted there are projects on Bitcoin, like rootstock, that have the goal of adding the capability, but my personal take (and I think a lot of others) from being in the space many years, is that its unlikely these will ever get released and/or adpoted.