News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by henvic on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:42PM (#27126337)
I'm Brazilian. It was not fake money that "saved Brazil". It was reducing / stagnating inflation (temporarily). The fact that they changed the currency even made poor people who had savings in cash (awful idea!), poorer when they forgot to exchange it.

By the way, I've recently posted this https://henvic.dev/posts/bitcoin/ where in the inflation section I explain how, with time, government tried to change the term inflation (to what is essentially a market basket) so they could... make it even worse and get away with it.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by kqr on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:43AM (#27127023)
Your story of the origin of money is one that anthropologists have been trying to debunk for decades, because there's simply no evidence that any group of people have gone through the timeline "self sufficiency--barter--money".

In most money-free societies, you'd simply go to your lentil friend and say, "Hey, I'd like some lentils. Come by any time you want potatoes." (Or more likely, you might let your lentil friend overhear you say to someone else, "Oh, what would I not do for lentils right now?" and the desire for credit is implicit.)

Barter only happens between complete strangers, and only under large doses of suspicion. (For what is barter if not trying to pawn off some worthless junk to a less suspecting person in exchange for something cool? It suffers from a perpetual lemon problem and is a business fraught with threat of violence.)

It's also important to consider separately money as a numeraire (in which capacity it has been around for a long time in e.g. legal codes) and money as a medium of exchange (in which capacity it's primarily been used imperially, to make the feeding of armies more efficient.)

I highly recommend reading about money and value from a historical anthropology perspective. Few things are what they seem in this field.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by henvic on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:29AM (#27128376)
Interesting. Do you suggest any specific material? Thank you in advance.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by casualrandomcom on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:39AM (#27128438)
Debt - the first 5000 years, by David Graeber

You can also find further references there

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by kqr on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:59AM (#27128555)
That is a good one. I'd also like to add (if my memory serves me right)

- Savage Money (Christopher Gregory, 1996),

- Indians, Settlers, and Slaves in a Frontier Exchange Economy (Daniel Usner, 1992),

- Money: the True Story of a Made Up Thing (Jacob Goldstein, 2020), and

- Lombard Street (Walter Bagehot, 1873).

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by wahern on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:00AM (#27126760)
> It was reducing / stagnating inflation

I think the point was that Brazil attempted multiple times to stop inflation. The problem in a cycle of hyperinflation is that it runs away from you--any measure you enact to stabilize prices is immediately out-of-date. Depending on your approach, that leaves various segments of the economy, e.g. consumers, screwed. If you have 100% inflation per month, if you freeze wages (e.g. through state-owned enterprise) one week but market prices continue increasing for another month because of momentum, you can only buy half as much. This creates enormous political pressures and animosities as you allude, which usually results in the government returning to money printing.

Ultimately, a government can't dictate prices even temporarily across an entire market, at least not instantaneously amidst hyperinflation. The point of the fake money was to prime market expectations, presumably especially in the supply chain. Because attempts to manage and slow the built-in expectation of inflation of the existing currency repeatedly failed, instead they created an alternative denomination against which people didn't have set expectations, notwithstanding shifting conversion rates. And it apparently worked. This seems notable because the usual fix for hyperinflation is to just adopt a foreign currency. The fact it worked highlights how the problem at hand was fundamentally a matter of managing market sentiment, not some intrinsic quality of a currency or its issuer.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by photojosh on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:11AM (#27126831)
> the usual fix for hyperinflation is to just adopt a foreign currency.

Or just peg your own to the USD. From the Wikipedia article another comment posted [0]:

> URVs were quoted in cruzeiros reais and its intrinsic value was pegged to three price indices and had a fixed parity of 1-to-1 to the daily U.S. dollar exchange rate.

I'm a tad confused as to how they pegged it both to price indices AND the USD exchange rate.

The problem with pegging your currency is that you get a disconnect between the official value and the private value. So introducing this new currency which was pegged, and transferring over only once the disconnect was resolved was the stroke of genius.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unidade_real_de_valor

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:59AM (#27127869)
This peg kind of worked because the government also introduced fiscal and monetary policy to contract the money supply at the same time. If you stick to old habits no one will believe the new currency won't inflate and you get stuck in the same cycle.

Pegs don't have a great history; the UK was painfully ejected from the ERM peg (which would be superseded by the Euro) and the 1998 Asian Financial Crisis brought an end to several USD pegs.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by I_Byte on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:22AM (#27126555)
But if it wasn’t the fake money that allowed them to stagnate inflation then what did? As someone not very well versed on economics I find this whole thing interesting and would like to get a good picture of what actually happened.

Edit - I just opened your website and I think I found a mistake.

> Quantum Computers - It won't affect Bitcoin in either a positive or negative manner

Bitcoin wallet addresses are based on the Ed25519 elliptic curve, and to my understanding, a quantum computer is able to break the current major forms of public cryptography that we use to date (RSA, EC). A quantum computer can be used to break wallets private keys and steal bitcoins. So a quantum computer would be pretty bad for Bitcoin in its current state.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by memorysafety on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @02:56AM (#27127499)
> [...] So a quantum computer would be pretty bad for Bitcoin in its current state.

Your reasoning is sound. But it won't be as bad. I'd claim, not much worse than dealing with leap seconds.

For 2 reasons: • Post-Quantum Cryptography exists. • The updated (quantum-resistant) Bitcoin will get renamed back to Bitcoin.

I agree your parent could use a review. I failed to read them any far.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by mrnotcrazy on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:36AM (#27126630)
Isn't bitcoin still being developed? So can't they just update the cryptography when we get to that point?

I guess I don't really how how much bitcoin can change over time

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by schoen on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:57AM (#27126745)
Smaller changes have resulted in hard forks in Bitcoin:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_Cash

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_Gold

So yes, it is conceivable to change the fundamental algorithms, but it would certainly be experienced as a fork to the extent that not everyone involved in Bitcoin participated.

Also, changing the digital signature algorithm is a bigger and more difficult change than the hashing algorithm in some ways, because you need a strategy to preserve people's existing balances, either one that requires, or one that works without, their active involvement (that is, generating signatures). If there is a feasible attack to forge signatures, then a method that can work without existing Bitcoin owners' involvement will leave them vulnerable to having their holdings stolen by forgeries in the future. You can think of this as somewhat akin to weak RNGs in Bitcoin clients (there have been a couple of these) generating vulnerable private keys -- if legitimate owners knew about the problem before attackers acted, they could act to protect themselves, but if not, not. A feasible signature forgery attack based on a quantum computer would put everyone who owns cryptocurrency wallets based on the vulnerable signatures in a position like that of people using a client with a weak RNG. :-(

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by cakoose on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @01:50AM (#27127051)
As others have said, changing the Bitcoin protocol can be tricky.

Another issue with replacing Ed25519: the best "post-quantum" asymmetric crypto we have so far is a lot less efficient and compact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-quantum_cryptography#Comp...

That'll probably make it more disruptive than, for example, swapping out SHA-1 for SHA-256.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by I_Byte on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:51AM (#27126715)
Bitcoin is still being developed yes. However, what are the chances that old stagnant wallets, like Satoshi’s, are moved to a new quantum proof wallet? Are we to trust whoever tries to move Satoshi’s fortune 30 years from now when all the old wallets are considered “broken”?
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by bogota on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:53AM (#27126726)
Not going to comment on the validity of your statement. However… if what you said was true the least of our problems would be Bitcoin.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by I_Byte on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:54AM (#27126728)
You’re right.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:51AM (#27127809)
It also made a lot of people richer.

> President freezes prices and/or bank accounts

People who saw this coming and withdrew their cash from the bank immediately became richer when it happened.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by rglullis on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:04AM (#27128249)
Wrong president and wrong economic plan.

(May I ask you how old you are? Seems like you are too young to actually have lived at the time.)

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:21AM (#27128332)
27. I remember the stories my parents told me about those times, especially the part I quoted about freezing bank accounts.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by rglullis on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:51AM (#27128499)
Well, your parents should know that it was Collor that confiscated savings accounts, on the 1990 plan (named Plano Collor) which failed to control inflation.

Plano Real is from 1994, when Itamar Franco was president, FHC was Finance Minister. No bank accounts were frozen.

So, to repeat: wrong president and wrong economic plan. Seems like your sources (your parents) are a bit biased?

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by matheusmoreira on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:55AM (#27128529)
They know. It's probably me who's wrong then. I saw that quote in the article and assumed that's what it was talking about.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by photojosh on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @12:59AM (#27126753)
> The fact that they changed the currency even made poor people who had savings in cash (awful idea!), poorer when they forgot to exchange it.

Given the inflation rate of almost 2000% in 1993 and 1994, if poor people had savings in cash they would very quickly have been worth nothing anyway. (I was a kid in Peru in the 80s-90s when they also had hyperinflation and 3 different currencies.)

Reading your article, while I agree with you on the absurdity of Bitcoin...

> that day when you wanted to eat lentils, you had to go through the trouble of exchanging potatoes for beans, then beans for rice, then rice for lentils.

Potatoes came over from the New World and weren't commonly eaten in Europe until the late 1500s. Lentils are likely from Mesopotamia. Rice wasn't common in Europe until sometime after the 10th century.

> Metals, even more so scarce ones, such as silver and gold, quickly emerge in your community as an answer to this demand.

No they don't. Metals at first only were used for long-distance trading, ie luxury goods, and it's not until the rise of states that metal currency becomes a common thing (required for taxation and military), and it was devalued constantly at the whim of the rulers anyway.

> the United States, the Gold Reserve Act forbid the Treasury and financial institutions from redeeming dollar bills for gold in 1934. It was the last remaining nation with a national currency to uphold the gold standard and one of the fundamental reasons, along with free trade, that made the nation prospered so much – not wars!

Huh? You have this precisely backwards. The fundamental reason the US prospered so much was that it was continually expanding its borders much later than other countries (through war!), right up until the 1900s. (See also: every empire in history prospers while it's growing.) The US also had high tariffs for a long time, and it wasn't until the period of the late 1930s and early 1940s when they actually started signing free trade agreements.

> The Keynesian party of state-issued inflationary currency might be over within the following decades. If I had to make a bet, I’d say stock from publically traded companies might be the base asset for the upcoming currencies.

Publicly traded companies... in which country exactly? The USD has its power and stability because it has the US economy and military behind it.

This is my fundamental disagreement with libertarianism: your statement "I want the free market to thrive and the state entirely out of everyone's lives" is a complete paradox. The "free market" is a creation wholly enforced through the power of the state (and ironically always requires a lot of regulation to stay that way). I will gladly change my mind if you can give me an example of where this is not true.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by ptsneves on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @04:54AM (#27128190)
> This is my fundamental disagreement with libertarianism: your statement "I want the free market to thrive and the state entirely out of everyone's lives" is a complete paradox. The "free market" is a creation wholly enforced through the power of the state (and ironically always requires a lot of regulation to stay that way). I will gladly change my mind if you can give me an example of where this is not true.

You are right and i think Thomas Hobbes would agree with you. The free market cannot exist without the sovereign. The sovereign is the deposit of people's will's, of their natural rights(violence and war). Thus there being a sovereign(state/regulations) does not mean people are not free.

Without the sovereign one goes to full on anarchy which paradoxically leads to the supreme evil: violent death. There is no liberty if you are dead.

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by imtringued on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:58AM (#27127860)
>This is my fundamental disagreement with libertarianism: your statement "I want the free market to thrive and the state entirely out of everyone's lives" is a complete paradox.

The most extreme thought experiment of this is anarcho-capitalism. You quickly realize that without a security force it boils down to the law of the jungle. Someone else with a gun has better "security" than you and they can make you bend to their will.

With a privatized security force you still run into the problem that paying them doesn't obligate them to protect you. Military coups are common in nation states, it can only get worse if the only reason someone protects you is money, because they can just take your money. Having soldiers believe in their nation and all it's people is much harder to break. Having no loyalty is a problem. What do you do if your enemy simply hires your security force? What if everything goes well but you simply run out of money?

Similar events happened in the Roman empire from 235 to 284. Armies declared their own leader the emperor. Most of them only ruled for 2 years until they ran out of money or simply died in battle. A lot of the ruling emperors had to devalue their currency to pay for their military.

There was even a case of someone outright buying the position of emperor in 193. [0]

>Julianus ascended the throne after buying it from the Praetorian Guard, who had assassinated his predecessor Pertinax. A civil war ensued in which three rival generals laid claim to the imperial throne. Septimius Severus, commander of the legions in Pannonia and the nearest of the generals to Rome, marched on the capital, gathering support along the way and routing cohorts of the Praetorian Guard Julianus sent to meet him. Abandoned by the Senate and the Praetorian Guard, Julianus was killed by a soldier in the palace and succeeded by Severus.

>When news of the public anger in Rome spread across the Empire, three influential generals, Pescennius Niger in Syria, Septimius Severus in Pannonia, and Clodius Albinus in Britain, each able to muster three legions, rebelled. They refused to accept Julianus' authority as emperor and instead declared themselves emperor.

Ah, yes, the free market. What really happens is that a replacement government will always fill the gap and you only get to choose between a good or bad government, not between government and no government and the only thing that protects you from bad foreign governments is a good domestic government and the ability to kick out bad domestic leaders via democracy.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Didius_Julianus

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by naveen99 on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:03AM (#27130432)
The modern answer is for the Emperor to be anonymous and pay his forces in bitcoin. or unregulated forex markets.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by jiofih on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:23AM (#27129444)
URV is what stagnated inflation in the first place. There seems to be a need by the new Brazilian right to downplay what happened for some reason, don’t get caught into it.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by ulzeraj on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:10AM (#27129919)
For someone to accused me of "having a stance" you seem to be very opinionated on political currents.

When you mean "the right" are you referring to economists like https://einvestidor.estadao.com.br/mercado/gustavo-franco-ro... who actually played a big role in Plano Real?

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by jiofih on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:47PM (#27134363)
Can you describe that “big role”? He is only a footnote in the story and later wrote a book about it. Revisionism at its finest.
Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by ulzeraj on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @05:00PM (#27135095)
https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustavo_Franco

I have no idea where you are getting your data but it seems to come from a very politically biased source.

And before you criticize "the right" I should note that both the stupid sides of the right _and_ the left opposed Plano Real:

https://veja.abril.com.br/economia/bolsonaro-e-pt-votaram-co...

Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010) by jiofih on Thursday May 13, 2021 @10:01AM (#27142181)
What am I supposed to look for in that Wikipedia page? Did you read it?

I did. The section on the Real is a generic article almost longer than the Real article itself, yet makes zero mentions of any of Franco’s contributions to it. Is that your source for his “big role”?

I’m not concerned with politics at the time, but now - he, or his party, whatever, are clearly capitalizing on his minor role to try and make him a stronger political force. At this point there are already three or four books and a movie by/about himself, while downplaying the economists who actually devised and implemented the plan (Árida and Resende). And trying to spin it as a success story for neo-liberalism and privatization instead of the economic policy play it was.

The fact you’re out here defending his particular role might give you a hint of whats going on.