Re:How Fake Money Saved Brazil (2010)
by imtringued on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @03:58AM
(#27127860)
>This is my fundamental disagreement with libertarianism: your statement "I want the free market to thrive and the state entirely out of everyone's lives" is a complete paradox.
The most extreme thought experiment of this is anarcho-capitalism. You quickly realize that without a security force it boils down to the law of the jungle. Someone else with a gun has better "security" than you and they can make you bend to their will.
With a privatized security force you still run into the problem that paying them doesn't obligate them to protect you. Military coups are common in nation states, it can only get worse if the only reason someone protects you is money, because they can just take your money. Having soldiers believe in their nation and all it's people is much harder to break. Having no loyalty is a problem. What do you do if your enemy simply hires your security force?
What if everything goes well but you simply run out of money?
Similar events happened in the Roman empire from 235 to 284. Armies declared their own leader the emperor. Most of them only ruled for 2 years until they ran out of money or simply died in battle. A lot of the ruling emperors had to devalue their currency to pay for their military.
There was even a case of someone outright buying the position of emperor in 193. [0]
>Julianus ascended the throne after buying it from the Praetorian Guard, who had assassinated his predecessor Pertinax. A civil war ensued in which three rival generals laid claim to the imperial throne. Septimius Severus, commander of the legions in Pannonia and the nearest of the generals to Rome, marched on the capital, gathering support along the way and routing cohorts of the Praetorian Guard Julianus sent to meet him. Abandoned by the Senate and the Praetorian Guard, Julianus was killed by a soldier in the palace and succeeded by Severus.
>When news of the public anger in Rome spread across the Empire, three influential generals, Pescennius Niger in Syria, Septimius Severus in Pannonia, and Clodius Albinus in Britain, each able to muster three legions, rebelled. They refused to accept Julianus' authority as emperor and instead declared themselves emperor.
Ah, yes, the free market. What really happens is that a replacement government will always fill the gap and you only get to choose between a good or bad government, not between government and no government and the only thing that protects you from bad foreign governments is a good domestic government and the ability to kick out bad domestic leaders via democracy.
The most extreme thought experiment of this is anarcho-capitalism. You quickly realize that without a security force it boils down to the law of the jungle. Someone else with a gun has better "security" than you and they can make you bend to their will.
With a privatized security force you still run into the problem that paying them doesn't obligate them to protect you. Military coups are common in nation states, it can only get worse if the only reason someone protects you is money, because they can just take your money. Having soldiers believe in their nation and all it's people is much harder to break. Having no loyalty is a problem. What do you do if your enemy simply hires your security force? What if everything goes well but you simply run out of money?
Similar events happened in the Roman empire from 235 to 284. Armies declared their own leader the emperor. Most of them only ruled for 2 years until they ran out of money or simply died in battle. A lot of the ruling emperors had to devalue their currency to pay for their military.
There was even a case of someone outright buying the position of emperor in 193. [0]
>Julianus ascended the throne after buying it from the Praetorian Guard, who had assassinated his predecessor Pertinax. A civil war ensued in which three rival generals laid claim to the imperial throne. Septimius Severus, commander of the legions in Pannonia and the nearest of the generals to Rome, marched on the capital, gathering support along the way and routing cohorts of the Praetorian Guard Julianus sent to meet him. Abandoned by the Senate and the Praetorian Guard, Julianus was killed by a soldier in the palace and succeeded by Severus.
>When news of the public anger in Rome spread across the Empire, three influential generals, Pescennius Niger in Syria, Septimius Severus in Pannonia, and Clodius Albinus in Britain, each able to muster three legions, rebelled. They refused to accept Julianus' authority as emperor and instead declared themselves emperor.
Ah, yes, the free market. What really happens is that a replacement government will always fill the gap and you only get to choose between a good or bad government, not between government and no government and the only thing that protects you from bad foreign governments is a good domestic government and the ability to kick out bad domestic leaders via democracy.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Didius_Julianus