I didn't pay an absurd amount of money for my house because the market was super hot and I had to outbid everyone in a bidding war (though I did have to do that).
I paid an absurd amount because with interest rates so low, it was cheaper than renting in term of monthly payment + maintenance.
I'd obviously be willing to go as high as my current rent, and probably a bit higher (to be allowed to do whatever I want with it), and that just came up to the price I paid.
The only thing blocking you, financially, is the down payment. The lower the interest rate, the higher the down payment will be for the same monthly payment. That's the problem.
To live in the house, if you can afford 1500/month (including insurance, HoA, maintenance), it doesn't matter if the house is worth 100k, 300k, 600k, 1 million...if the math adds up to 1500/month, you'll buy it. Interest rates go down, house value go up. Simple as that.
Now if you add all the other factors, like how home ownership becomes a potentially profitable investment, alongside society's pressure that "it's what you're supposed to do", and of course prices will skyrocket, shortage or not.
In turn, it raises rent prices, which makes the math above work out even more, and it's a self reinforcing cycle.
Already in the high demand areas of the country, the land that a house sits on is appreciating at a rate faster than a lot of full-time wages.
There's a massive bubble in land prices that's happened due to suppressing building across entire regions, via downzonings decades ago.
At some point housing has to return to acting like a piggy bank, rather than an asset that rises in value in excess of productive economic activity.
30% of someone making minimum wage isn't the same thing as 30% of someone making 500k/year.
I'm fairly well off. If housing took 70% of my after-tax income, I'd still be able to live reasonably well (and would have one hell of a badass home to go with it).
My food, my phone, my electricity bill, my insurance, my transportation, they cost me the same as they cost someone else living in the same city making 1/4th of the money. Since real estate is wealth storage at worse and an investment at best, I can pour everything else I make it into it. It's not particularly optimal, but I -can- do it if I so choose.
The end result is that money available for housing goes up in a curve as you go up the income bracket. People below the threshold get screwed.
I honestly don't know any of my peers to be without work, ever.
The mothers are taking less than a year off work per child and then they are back to work too. I think dual income families are another reason house prices have skyrocketed, get two YUPPIE 'DINKS' saving for their downpayment and 1% interest rates and yeah they can afford to bid up the price of a house.
Carpenters are getting $75/hr CAD around here in house construction, and a plumber is $125/hr, so per my grand parent commment people are also simply earning a lot of money so they can afford a $5k monthly payment.
edit: grammar
If prices are set by the maximum that people can pay, rather than what the costs are to provide housing, then there's an easy solution: allow more housing to be built.
Nearly everybody can afford to pay for the costs of providing housing: the maintenance, the amortized cost of construction over the lifetime of the house.
What people can't afford to pay for are the increases in land prices due to the housing shortage. This sets up a two class system: those that own the land and see benefit from appreciating land prices, and continue to have the flexibility to move and own land becuase they bought early, and the unlanded, who are doomed to pay ever increasing land costs in their monthly rents, with all the benefit going to landlords and homeowners who reap the land rents.
It's a gigantic unproductive transfer of wealth from those with less to those with more. In addition to the human misery and poverty that this causes among working people, this also greatly increases inequality, which further reduced economic output of society.
And there's a simple solution to it all: allow people to pay to build housing rather than forcing them to bid up limited supply and pass off their stored labor to idle land owners.
However, the homeowners who benefit from this system are the ones with the political power to keep their rentierism enforced by law...
Check out this website: https://www.cheapoldhouses.com/ there are many houses on there for not much money but they are obviously not in desirable locations. Some need some repairs but that is just time & materials not buying expensive land. So there is lots of cheap land and cheap houses.
Increasing density by tearing down some single family homes and replacing with townhomes is probably a workable compromise - now there are three dwellings where before there was 1, and everybody still gets a garage and a yard, but each of those townhomes will still be priced up to what the market will bear because there will not be an infinite supply of them.
In my town of 20,000 about 1000 dwellings are coming online significantly increasing the supply - potentially increasing the populatiog by 2000-4000 people, (up to 20%!) but they were all snapped up for $800-900k and now there is only one available for $1.2M.
People want to live in desirable places, and will pay more to do so. Nice places are always going to be expensive.
If you don't have a house you can hack the system by moving to a place with cheap dwellings and making it desirable, which is a normal pattern: Artists and musicians move to cheap neighborhood, it becomes cool & desirable
Add that right now there's a timber shortage (insurance costs are spiking recently for that reason), and it's probably not helping.
The land value is the most actionable problem, but it doesn't solve everything.
Local small players, boutique mills if you will, can't even buy logs because the lots of logs that are put up for sale are so big only container-ship scale buyers are in the game.
I am 100% against exporting whole logs, we have lost so many jobs in the mills and supporting the mills.
But I wouldn't be surprised if the reason boutique mills can't buy logs as easily is because there are contractual agreements with larger suppliers. That isn't really anything new in any industry... guess you need the government to step in to prevent that.
Bay Area housing prices tend to appreciate at that rate or faster, and you can acheive much more leverage with better downside risk protection buying housing, since California is a non-recourse state. Plus, it replaces a rental expense you would otherwise have, which a stock market investment doesn’t: you can’t live in an ETF.
Risk is higher, too, so its not all upside.
Risk is priced in to both asset classes. Nothing is set in stone.
Yes there are maintenance items if you own and need to set aside money for those things.
Factors like:
- Can you rent the type of property you want
- For houses in particular, are you willing to put work in
- How mobile do you want to be
- How important is it to customize the property to how you want it
etc.
The catch is, I get to live in it. I made it awesome. I put a ton of money on the kitchen, the bathroom, etc to make it something I'll never be able to rent (without paying 9-10k/month anyway, and I can't afford that). I was able to do all that while still coming up only SLIGHTLY below renting + investing the extra.
There's a certain emotional value to buying a house that the math can't capture. Even JUST with the financial math, it's pretty close (and sometimes an amazing investment, in the right market). But once you tack on the emotional value, it shits all over the alternative (for people who want a home to call their own).
I can't think of any other purchase where you can get something you really want, AND have that thing be a mediocre or better investment at the same time. I can't live inside of my S&P500 position.
My taxes are about 25-30% of my mortgage payment (after a massive residential exemption, too), and if you have a slightly more expensive than average home in a low cost area (so things like school taxes will be higher to raise a similar amount of money per child), it can get reaaaaally expensive.
On the other hand, I chose to manage my own taxes instead of having the lender escrow it for me, so I get to see them separately. It helps putting things in perspective.
It's the rare market where rents are set according to how much it costs to provide the rental, as that would be a market that is oversupplied, and most governments work hard to prevent that from happening. In supply-constrained markets, rents are set by what the market can pay, not based on how much property taxes are or interest rates for mortgages or maintenance costs.
Think of houses like bonds that pay a coupon (rent). If risk free rate goes down, the coupon is worth more in comparison so house price goes up.
The only downside is that when you buy a house that is cheap with a high interest rate you can benefit from refinancing if the rate goes down (and deduct your mortgage interest, which used to be significant tax savings). When you buy an expensive house at a low rate, you get no such benefit (although if inflation does pick up, the fact that you are implicitly short the borrowed dollars might still work in your favor).
The other side of cash flow is income, and I'd be very interested to see if income has kept under this analysis too...
I have few friends that are in a saving vicious cycle, high rent and cost of living eat up saving so that they save little. This makes them resigned and depressed - so the spend money on stuff to make them happy.
Having 25 yr old tell you that they will be able to afford a down-payment in 20 years is a telling sign.
This was always the intent of very lower interest rates, so I think the question for all the crystal ball prognosticators out there is will interest rates eventually rise and change the math, or are savers the suckers because inflation will erode their wealth? I have to believe that we can have low, steady prices OR free cash, but the current situation of both can't last. What do you think?
No resignation for me anytime soon.
It's a pretty tricky situation, everybody knows that the market is overvalued but as long as supply is this constrained and prices remain high buyers are left with very few options.
If the interests go up to something reasonable again (5-10% or so) there will be a lot of people in trouble but it won't immediately lead to a price drop unless investors move away from the buy side. This is especially true for apartments which are going for crazy rates because investors buy them up as fast as they hit the market. A typical property is for sale less than two weeks, and usually on the day it goes up for sale there is already a waiting list.
https://www.thelocal.se/20160324/sweden-limits-mortgage-loan...
This is /before/ any additional stimulus (monetized by the Fed).
Additionally, the personal savings rate is also at an all time high [4] - and net worth of individuals has increased by >$12Tr (>50% of US GDP).
In one year...
[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1
[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2
When you look at real estate prices and everything else in last decade and a half here, you’d be forced to think real estate has been living in an entirely different dimension all this while. It just doesn’t make sense. I’m talking about urban India of course.
There are more trends at play in the housing market above and beyond office workers moving to or from WFH.
It only takes a minority of bad actors to ruin a good thing for everybody.
1. return to office
2. increase in interest rates due to inflation
3. effects from lifting eviction bans, rolling back unemployment covid provisions ect.
4. Biden govt encouraging more house building.
However, as we have seen in many densely populated cities the amount of red tape in development is absurd and probably results in an incredibly diluted impact
Are we due for a correction down or was the 15-20% overnight housing cost jump a correction of house prices being too low (yes, absurd but I’m serious). A perfect storm of Millennials finally buying homes with low interest rates (?). COVID just jump started it.
Who knows. Either way:
- Huge amount of people fleeing to suburbs regretting their new commute times is likely.
- Huge amount of people who can’t carry their new housing bill and find remote work like planned.
Seems inevitable. Either way, I think housing cost will be one of the best indicators if remote is here to stay or not.