News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by dahfizz on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:21AM (#27117745)
The language here rubs me the wrong way. Everything is stated as being "incredibly harmful" with no explanation beyond

> ...directly harms visually impaired individuals due to lack of visual clarity.

I am also not sure how "Elements lack unity" is related to the UI causing harm.

I don't use discord, so I have no idea how good the UI is. If the UI is bad and hard for the visually impaired to use, there is definitely a better way to communicate that.

This is how they end their post:

> This is not good UX design. It is the opposite. It harms end-users. Revert the changes.

The whole thing reads like a bad tumblr post.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by silicon2401 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:44AM (#27118038)
> The whole thing reads like a bad tumblr post.

It's exactly the kind of demonizing language that has unfortunately become common in recent years. By using dishonest wording to make your target look like an inhuman villain, it's easier to make the readers accept whatever the writer says. The writer then tries to sneakily shirk the responsibility to justify their claims. Just like at your quote:

> This is not good UX design. It is the opposite. It harms end-users. Revert the changes.

This wouldn't have passed my high school writing class. It's 3 arguments, 1 conclusion, and 0 evidence to support the conclusion. Instead of justifying their claims, people nowadays like to just throw out extreme words like "harm" and make it sound like Discord is installing keyloggers or something

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by dancemethis on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:09AM (#27118994)
While in a general sense I agree with the excessively demonizing language all around, Discord is an inhuman villain in the world.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tobr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:05AM (#27118938)
Speaking of 0 evidence, I’d like to stick a [citation needed] on this:

> It's exactly the kind of demonizing language that has unfortunately become common in recent years.

It reads like a thinly veiled “kids these days”.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:24AM (#27119216)
This comment does the best job of explaining it:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27118267

Writing like this is meant not to persuade, but to incite and coerce using emotion.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tobr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:41AM (#27119458)
The question is, has it really become more common?
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @12:38PM (#27120246)
Sure. I don't really know what you're looking for in terms of citations, it's a general writing style. There's no database to query.

Personally, I see it all the time on Twitter, and more broadly online in left-of-center political discussions.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:04AM (#27118930)
For people like you and I, this is bad rhetoric - not well written or argued. But I feel like this is how the younger generations communicate and persuade with online messages. Be short, make bold claims, and make a call to action based on a sense of justice.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by 1970-01-01 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:31AM (#27117853)
It should rub you the wrong way because the language is wrong! The author has used the wrong word to describe the problem. If you replace the word harm and harmful with difficult it makes sense.

harmful:

of a kind likely to be damaging

difficult:

hard to deal with, manage, or overcome

I've done it for everyone:

>Saturated dark colors against dark backgrounds are hard to read and difficult to parse

>White mentions lack visual clarity and are incredibly difficult for individuals with visual impairment

>Color redesign lacks contrast and are difficult for individuals who are colorblind and/or visually impaired

>Elements lack unity

>Saturated, mid-value colors covering large fields are difficult for end-users

>Text contrast with new colors fail the WCAG test

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by falcolas on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:37AM (#27117956)
For the visually impaired, it's not "difficult" to use, it's closer to "impossible" to use.

By toning back the language, you've made it sound like whining and not a legitimate concern. You make it easy to ignore.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by dahfizz on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:40AM (#27117996)
"X elements are impossible for me to see because of Y condition" is a perfectly legitimate piece of feedback. "X element being the wrong color is causing catastrophic harm" is insane feedback. By using silly language, they are making themselves easy to ignore.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tobr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:47AM (#27118071)
“Catastrophic harm” is a phrase you came up with. It’s fair to phrase accessibility concerns in terms of harm, because being denied access to something other people can use is a type of harm. “Catastrophic” is very common hyperbole for something you think is highly unfortunate.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by ry4nolson on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:42AM (#27118653)
first paragraph of the article:

>These are catastrophic design failures for the new UX, and directly harms both end-users due to eye-strain, and directly harms visually impaired individuals due to lack of visual clarity. It makes the app less accessible, and is not only visually displeasing, but actively ableist in nature.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tobr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:58AM (#27118853)
Yes, what are we supposed to take from this quote as a reply in this context?
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by dataduck on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:34AM (#27119352)
> Speaking of 0 evidence, I’d like to stick a [citation needed] on this:

> being denied access to something other people can use is a type of harm

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tobr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:55AM (#27119666)
What do you want a citation for? That being prevented from being an equal participant in society is negative?
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by thatguy0900 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:44AM (#27118031)
I think it's easier to ignore when it comes across as typical internet flame war hysteria rather than someone trying to have a conversation about a issue
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:11AM (#27119018)
I'd like to think that, but this kind of rhetoric is becoming more and more common. People will utilize wild hyperbole, stretch the meaning of words, and declare that people are being harmed or oppressed as a call to action. I mean, at the end of the day this is about a user interface on a messaging app. But the post makes it sound like there is some willful negligence that borders on criminality.

But in a twisted way, maybe this kind of argument works. We are talking about it after-all.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by corobo on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:52AM (#27118121)
It's on public feature request software it's already easy to ignore
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by no-dr-onboard on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:34PM (#27121742)
By that logic, everyone should use caps and shout. Ad absurdum.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by spicybbq on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:50AM (#27119612)
It is disappointing to see that the comments here are dominated by tone policing and semantics. We ought to be able to look at the substance of the criticism and not get distracted by some of the word choices. The post makes several concrete claims in clear language that are worthy of discussion.

I use discord, I have a mild color anomaly in my vision, and have had problems reading low-contrast elements in the UI. Discord's update gives us a useful example of a major release that violates some dark mode design best practices.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by no-dr-onboard on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:31PM (#27121704)
> It is disappointing to see that the comments here are dominated by tone policing and semantics.

I agree, but I'm afraid the argument that the post is making is not based on a logical series of steps. It doesn't follow the typical convention of observation, problem, evidence, conclusion. The post is substantially an emotional outpouring and a call to action. This changes the dialectics.

If you're going to create a central claim that is solely Pathos based, the tone and semantics of how you do so become the most important thing in your argument and, to your point, this is why this post comes off so _wrong_. The post author failed at convincing this audience in large part because of their tone and semantics.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:28PM (#27120845)
Accusations of tone policing are themselves tone policing, so there's disappointment all around. How we use language is important to plenty of people; there's a reason OP is the top comment.

There are indeed discussion-worthy claims in the post, and they're discussed elsewhere in the comments. Why hijack the top comment to change the subject?

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by faitswulff on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:49AM (#27118098)
Well, if we’re just talking about unwanted opinions, then a sighted person tone policing a visually impaired user rubs me the wrong way. What if they use discord to keep in touch with their family and the product is unusable to them now? Why do you care how emphatically someone expresses how they cannot even properly see the product in question anymore? Imagine stepping into a car and the windshield is completely painted over. You need it to go somewhere. You would be irate! Do you need someone else telling you “you aren’t saying how, specifically, it affects you?” or “why don’t you ask nicely?” Have a little sympathy and the problem is clear. Discord doesn’t need your sympathy. They have an obligation - possibly even a legal obligation - to keep their products accessible to their end users.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by dahfizz on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:46AM (#27118696)
I agree that Discord should maintain accessibility in their products, and I can sympathize with how frustrating it is when services you rely on break.

I think we are in agreement here - this post is an emotionally charged person venting. I don't have any problem with that, but maybe there is a better way to vent than on the discord support page. If you want to actually effect change, this is not the way to do it.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by faitswulff on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:02AM (#27118901)
What you're doing is called tone policing and it's not helpful. Would the post have gotten as much attention if the poster had been meek and polite? Probably not.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by adamrezich on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:07AM (#27118970)
people are allowed to have opinions on how other people express themselves. where does the policing come in, I don't understand
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by faitswulff on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:55AM (#27119669)
The policing comes in when the top comment criticizes how the poster presents themselves instead of addressing the content of the post.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by kevingadd on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:27AM (#27117810)
A person who uses Discord posting on the Discord forum about how the changes (in their opinion) make the product worse to use is not exactly a good comparison to a "bad tumblr post", unless what makes it a bad tumblr post is that it's a downer or you feel it doesn't meet your quality bar for Good Forum Content.

By my reckoning, the post clearly enumerates their complaints with the new design, it provides some references that they believe support their argument, and suggests a remedy (revert the design). There is no cursing in it and it does not contain any personal attacks. It doesn't contain any conspiracy theories or memes or sarcasm or other markers you might associate with "bad posts".

It's kind of baffling that you are willing to decide that the poster is some sort of tumblr reject based on not liking how they argue their points when you haven't even used the product.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:35AM (#27117920)
The language people use to express themselves is important; forming reasonable arguments is an important skill.

Falling back on strong emotional language like actively harms is a crutch - unless well-supported by facts or reasoning.

Also they don't "suggest" a remedy, they demand it, and their demand is backed by their unsupported claim of "actively harms".

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by cwilkes on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:43AM (#27118028)
> Also they don't "suggest" a remedy, they demand it

Would this post have been better if they said “it might be a good idea if you considered going back to the previous way?” I’m not sure how soft pedaling the ask makes it more reasonable.

The post is pretty clear in what is wrong and how to fix it. If anything Discord is the aggressor here with a forced change without an “use the old UI” button.

If the posts included screenshots to show how bad the UI change is that would have made it better. Maybe the support forum doesn’t allow it.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by Closi on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:47AM (#27118075)
I think they just mean turn down the language.

> White mentions lack visual clarity and are incredibly harmful to individuals with visual impairment

"Incredibly Harmful" is hyperbole, and for instance could be rewritten as:

> White mentions lack visual clarity and are hard for individuals with visual impairment to read.

Otherwise what does harmful mean? Here are some examples of things that I perceive as incredibly harmful:

* Huffing glue

* Stabbing yourself

* Lead poisoning

Not being able to read a mention without highlighting it, or selecting a different theme, probably doesn't quite class on the same level as these things, even if it should be fixed.

Similarly, Catastrophic means "involving or causing sudden great damage or suffering" - which isn't meant literally, it's hyperbole, but the problem with hyperbole is that writing containing can come across overly exaggerated and emotional.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:53AM (#27118785)
I guess one person's soft pedaling is another's common decency. But that doesn't get nearly as many clicks or views, or HN comments for that matter.

And seriously? "Aggressor"? It's not an attack, for god's sake.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by tarboreus on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:20AM (#27119151)
If you need to use Discord to communicate and now you can't, that's kind of a big deal.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:52AM (#27119636)
I take anyone claiming this at their word. But it doesn't make Discord an aggressor. That word has a specific meaning.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by disgrunt on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:37AM (#27119399)
Isn't eye strain a form of harm?
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by listless on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:31AM (#27117866)
I think it’s the “harmful” rhetoric that signals “I have an agenda”. We really need to get passed this charged way of conveying perfectly valid feedback. Because come on. It’s a chat app.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by kevingadd on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:34AM (#27117896)
Of course they have an agenda. Discord is harder for them to use now, and they want it fixed. When did "agenda" become a negatively charged concept that only bad actors possess?

Slack and Teams are chat apps too. Why would chat apps not be important?

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by kodah on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:53AM (#27118131)
Using emotionally charged language is usually pretty off-putting. Some people are used to using emotionally charged language any time they feel some way, but I think that ends up wearing people down for when they hear it in the future. That's probably why you have so many people here commenting about the use of "harm".
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by listless on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:43AM (#27118666)
By “agenda” I meant it in the sense that this isn’t about accessibility as much as it is this person getting points for a call out.

That’s a bad faith interpretation. So not presenting that as irrefutable fact.

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by mpalmer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:06AM (#27118950)
"actively" and "directly" really are the new "literally".

Seriously, what is it to be actively ableist as opposed to passively ableist? Are words just emotional signifiers now?

Exaggeration has become the bare minimum for getting your point across.

EDIT: don't get me started on "blatantly"

Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by nathanaldensr on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @06:29PM (#27124406)
It's YouTube Face, except written.
Re:Discord's new UX design is harmful to the visually impair... by ffn on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @10:07AM (#27118267)
Yeah, the phrase "cause harm" carries a lot of affect (e.g. urgency, impatience, panic, outrage, etc.). If we were to have a graph of common word usage and association, the words "cause harm" would be strongly linked with other phrases like

- morally repulsive

- life or death

- fix immediately

All of which is just one step away from the affect-saturated words like "hitler / mao / stalin", "genocide", etc.,

As such "cause harm" is one of those magical phrases in our common lexicon that has gained the power to turn an "is" to an "ought", and the author uses it as the logical glue to connect the relatively descriptive phrase of "This is not good UX design" to the proscription of "revert the changes"

But by using such an affect-laden phrase, the author is implicitly asking the reader to assign more weight to feelings (e.g. impatience, outrage, disgust, etc.,) and less weight to calculated executive thought.

This attempt through language to subvert the executive portion of our brain in favor of more primal processes makes me feel the whole article is suspect. After all, if the author's argument can be one that stands up to executive scrutiny, than what is the intention when the author attempts to by-pass executive scrutiny?