News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by spking on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:21AM (#2709766)
Possibly. However, I've found that it's fairly easy to identify who is saying what based on writing style, grammar and punctuation habits. Any HR person will tell you that's how they identify respondents to "anonymous" employee surveys.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by bugsy on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @01:41PM (#2710389)
This is a good point. To date I have not had an anonymous survey in a small group that hasn't bitten me in the ass afterwards.

I also find some anonymous surveys interesting when they are placed in my mailbox and come with a unique identification number. When asking about this uid, I am always told it is for quality control purposes or such. Yeah right.

Anyway, the proposed idea is interesting. I could see it being abused though. Someone from management, A, who wants to know what you really think of them could set up a fake discussion using several other sign ins from coworkers B C and D (and of course management has their passwords, that's required per the corporate contract), puppets who then ask "What do you think of boss A?" followed by puppet accounts B-D saying A is a jerk and then listening to see your response. This is the sort of thing that happens with the sort of jock management that infects many workplaces.

Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by yuhong on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:52PM (#2712472)
Of course, in the long term these problems needs to be fixed. That will of course take time though.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by terio on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:36AM (#2709836)
Perhaps you can try translating the message to another language and back. Then present the resulting text to the user for corrections. The resulting grammar and punctuation could be very different than the original.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by rl41 on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:40AM (#2709848)
This could easily mangle the original meaning of the message, as www.translationparty.com gracefully demonstrates.

I suppose that the user could take a second to approve the recycled message before sending it though.

Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by icey on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:44AM (#2709869)
Auto spellcheck + auto grammar adjust would help some, but you'd still have troubles because of habitual use of colloquialisms.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by qjz on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @02:28PM (#2710599)
I've worked in environments where it would be trivial to get an email of your SSN the moment you visit an HR online survey, let alone complete it.

It's possible to promise confidentiality, but you should be extremely suspicious whenever someone guarantees anonymity.

Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by jabo on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @12:00PM (#2709963)
You could probably strip all punctuation and capitalization from any user input so that the style remains fairly obfuscated. IMO it's punctuation and capitalization that usually gives away the IDE identity especially on a chat medium.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by hammock on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @12:22PM (#2710045)
I suppose it depends on the size of the company, but I can't imagine any HR person at a co with >20 ee's that could identify someone based on their writing style unless it was particularly idiosyncratic.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by bricestacey on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @02:14PM (#2710547)
I imagine the answers would allow you to shrink the sample down to a few select individuals. E.g. This anonymous survey complains a lot about a supervisor, let's start with his/her direct reports.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by ericmoritz on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @02:17PM (#2710560)
How about each message has to be rephrased by another person in the room in order to scramble the original author. It suffers from the telephone problem and general misunderstanding however.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by akharris on Wednesday June 29, 2011 @11:26AM (#2709786)
Agreed that you can probably find commonalities within the individual comment threads, but I feel like you'd be hard pressed to do it within a large group.

Though I guess those semantic specialists from HR could do some damage.

Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by kahawe on Thursday June 30, 2011 @04:50AM (#2713172)
Could you elaborate on this with some real world examples? Unless it is something very obvious like using "..." or "-" a lot while nobody else does, I am wondering how this can be done reliably and efficiently especially considering that what HR knows about your writing style is most likely only from business emails, your application and other business correspondences where one would likely use a different writing style than in an internal anonymous discussion.
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by JoachimSchipper on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:37AM (#2713262)
I find it funny that you use a 66-word sentence to express this sentiment. Just how common are those, I wonder?
Re:Show HN: Can anonymous chat within identified groups crea... by kahawe on Thursday June 30, 2011 @05:43AM (#2713268)
Good point - then again, how many 66-word sentences do I usually write and is that enough to "identify" me? And see bugsy's reply, there is a looong sentence there too.