News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @02:57PM (#27041438)
These aren’t either or situations. Acting as if the only options are an abusive marriage or prostitution is really misleading.

There are plenty of ways to incentivize monogamy, disincentivize divorce, and yet still allow for individual freedom.

Why haven’t these been tested? I’ll suggest because like all movements, the gender equality movement has been driven largely by extremist activists (who gain social power) and corporations (who gain more workers and consumers), not by average people.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by toyg on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:10PM (#27041596)
> Why haven’t these been tested?

Have they not? Marriage is widely incentivized in most societies. The UK reality at the moment, for example, heavily punishes singles: the housing markets optimizes for two incomes, pricing out singles; the taxing system favours spreading income over two individuals; and you have plenty of other marriage-related allowances. I'd be surprised if this was significantly different in the US.

The reality is that, as soon as you give people the choice, a good chunk of them will take it.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by ceilingcorner on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:13PM (#27041652)
I wouldn’t say that it’s incentivized at all. Weddings are expensive, divorces are financially disastrous (yet easy to initiate), and a sizable segment of the population thinks the idea of marriage is “uncool”, for lack of a better word. Things like adultery are nearly outright encouraged in Netflix shows and novels.

It doesn’t surprise me at all that many people look at marriage as it currently stands and just say, no thanks. This goes against pretty much every society, historically.

https://www.ranker.com/list/best-tv-shows-about-cheating/ran...

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by sokoloff on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @05:00PM (#27042838)
We spent around $700 on our wedding. Front yard ceremony, $150-200 for the justice of the peace, trays of food from the local BBQ place, more wine, beer, and drinks than our 25 or so closest friends could consume.

Getting married isn't inherently expensive. People make it so because an entire industry is optimized around convincing you to spend more on a dress than we spent on an entire wedding.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by ceilingcorner on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:10AM (#27046096)
Weddings are expensive because historically they were seen as extremely important. This is observable in almost every culture and predates modern consumer culture.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by paulryanrogers on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:53PM (#27044361)
Culture also instills in girls and young women that it must be their perfect day. Family obligations and expectations can add more pressure.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:28PM (#27045491)
You didn't have a friend do the internet church thing to become an officiant? Is that no longer possible?
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by sokoloff on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:36AM (#27049097)
It is a thing still here. The friend who we’d have asked to do that (and has done it before) was unable to attend our ceremony, so we just went down the city’s list and picked someone.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by toyg on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:49PM (#27042063)
I fear that words like "easy" or "expensive" in this realm are difficult to evaluate objectively.

Weddings, for example, are not expensive, if you consider them as a bureaucratic act: in most countries, it's just a few forms to fill him with minimal fees attached. However, if you impose on them oversized cultural expectations (which come from "netflix shows of the past"...) of white horses, diamonds, banquets and so on, then yeah, it's an expensive act. Maybe, if one wanted more weddings, one should support reducing some of these artificial obstacles...?

> a sizable segment of the population thinks the idea of marriage is “uncool”

That's always been true, as showed in literature of the past.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by RhysU on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:51PM (#27044767)
Comically, going from a one-income household to a two-income household to a three-income household to a ... one arrives at the flat tax.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by xiphias2 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:06PM (#27043966)
> Why haven’t these been tested?

They were tested and perfected a hundred thousand years ago when humans were living in tribes. In a tribe shaming people for being polygamous was part of the system to keep some checks and balances. With people moving to cities and dating online, those checks and balances are suppressed, and the market balance shifted towards polygamy (few high value man date many women).

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by kaba0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:19AM (#27047823)
That doesn’t even follow logically. Pairing one man with one woman will remove one of each from circulation. With polygamy being more accepted means that basically noone gets removed from circulation, a women can have more than one partner, increasing chances...
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by CRConrad on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:56PM (#27053284)
Yeah, theoretically. But because of remaining cultural / social mores, women in general probably tend to be less polygamous than male "players" are. So in practice, "polygamy" turns out to be one man having many women much more than the other way around. Therefore a few "Chads" remove disproportionately many women from "the market", and you get many more male incels than female ones.
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by kaba0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:32PM (#27054566)
Well, then it’s unfortunately just a fact of life. I’m sure similar disproportionate mating chances are apparent in many species of animals between sexes as well and it may even serve an evolutionary goal that the stronger gets to pass their genetic lineup.

Either way, the answer is most definitely not viewing women as objects that should be forcefully attached to a male to have any value and other misogynistic shit that incels make up. I do get their frustrations, but it’s a downward spiral. Many of them could very well find a partner if he would actually believe that he is wanted. But even if he himself doubts that, how can he reasonably think that someone else will want to do anything with him? And at this point we are very close to mental health issues, most likely depression, but then that should be treated.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by amznthrowaway5 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:27PM (#27055278)
> may even serve an evolutionary goal that the stronger gets to pass their genetic lineup.

This explanation can be used to justify a lot of human behavior, including genocide.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by kaba0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @04:43PM (#27055516)
I didn’t attribute any sort of moral value to said thing, but it is a biological fact.

And as a society we should overcome these biological “laws”, or at least what we find immoral. Like healing and caring for weak/ill children, etc.

But I don’t see any solution to this problem that would not infringe on women’s freedom, which should be upheld even at the huge price psychological harm of a few. And attributing this harm to women should similarly be condemned, because one gender having biologically favorable chances of mating is a fact just as much as males having more muscle mass on average.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by amznthrowaway5 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:04PM (#27055826)
How do you know if what women find attractive is a result of societal pressure or freedom? Again, do you think women's extreme racial "preferences" in dating are a result of freedom because men of some races are far less attractive and the women are just serving "an evolutionary goal that the stronger gets to pass their genetic lineup"? How do you know society isn't also influencing many other characteristics? Do you think the average 4'6 Cameroon Pygmy is just as attractive as the average US white guy, or are the Pygmy men just "biologically inferior"?
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by kaba0 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:48PM (#27056253)
I've just replied to another comment of yours, where I may have cleared up some things.

I don't believe for a moment that racial "preferences" are a result of some personal freedom without being influenced by culture. But women don't live in a women society, it is shaped by both men and women. My problem is with the framing/blaming of women. And racism is in every culture, interracial couples are looked down in most countries. There is improvements, but it is a slow process. One can hardly change personal views ingrained throughout decades, and it does gets passed down from parents, though hopefully less and less.

And the important thing is regardless of the source of her preference, at the end of the day it is a given women's inalienable choice who she finds attractive -- even if it is not "fair".

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by amznthrowaway5 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:54PM (#27056318)
Why don't I see almost any feminists fighting against this? Instead they are some of the most racist and hateful people in my experience.

> And the important thing is regardless of the source of her preference, at the end of the day it is a given women's inalienable choice who she finds attractive -- even if it is not "fair".

Sure, but shouldn't they be taking responsibility and criticized heavily on a societal level, I don't see that happening much.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by ceilingcorner on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:00AM (#27046038)
I haven’t studied the anthropology, but is it true that people in tribal societies tend to be monogamous?
Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by amanaplanacanal on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @05:57AM (#27048051)
My thought is that enforced monogamy came with the invention of agriculture, and wasn’t really a thing in Hunter-gatherer societies, but I could be completely wrong about that.

If true though, the fact that most of us don’t work in agriculture any more could mean that we are in the midst of a sea change in relationships. I’m too old to say I’ll be around to see how it ends up, but some of the youngest here might be around to see it.

Re:On incels, dead bedrooms and the hard problems of loneliness by xiphias2 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:41AM (#27046601)
The usual statistic that we hear from people who study genes is that about half of the men are fathers to women. It's a significantly different statistic from OKCupid / Tinder matches, which is closer to 80-20, and the fact that less young men are having sex than before suggests that it translates to real life.