News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by DiNovi on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:02PM (#27032909)
so they:

- Announced a new company policy publicly before telling the staff

- Deleted internal threads that would go against their narrative of why they did so

- Had a conservative senior employee go off about politics on the call discussing the new no politics policy.

- refused to reprimand said employee on the call

- had one founder take this extremely sensitive call from his bed with his camera off and on mute.

- After the employees resigned, did not send any sort of public message thanking them for their time at the company.

Can't believe only 21 employees walked. What idiots these founders are. There is no way to defend this poor management even if you agree with the rule they tried to put in

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by nate on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:24PM (#27033061)
When they DHH+Jason laid the 7 of us off from Highrise (the Basecamp CRM spin-off) no one even showed up online to say anything to us on our last day. Just the Head of Devops to turn off our access to things. (That guy at least apologized for no-one else being there) :/
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by rsanheim on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:25PM (#27044115)
The way a company deals with really difficult things like lay-offs speaks volume about the character, empathy, and skill of leadership at the top.

This is really sad hearing about how crummy DHH and Fried are at one central piece of management: having very hard conversations with people while still treating them with respect and dignity.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by fatbird on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:02PM (#27044428)
one central piece of management: having very hard conversations with people while still treating them with respect and dignity.

I'd like to highlight this. I'd like to frame it and tape it to the head of every founder and entrepeneur so they have to look at it constantly. Hell, everyone who ever has to oversee other people. This is absolutely the heart and soul of good management and being a good person, and everyone who thinks they're created a great workplace, but doesn't know this, needs to chant this 1,000,000 times.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by whitepoplar on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:27PM (#27033086)
Could you speak a little more about your impression of the company while you were there? I know you didn't want to talk about it after you left, but so many of us are/were curious, especially as to how Basecamp's private image compares to its public image.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by nate on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:59PM (#27033280)
It's tough to get it all down here in a comment. Maybe now this is all out I'll share more in some channels soon. I will say that last comment in Casey's article: “They don't want to deal with people, which is something you have to do as a manager … Jason and David just threw us away.” That could easily have been written from someone at Highrise. (It wasn't. But it could have been) We killed ourselves to turn that thing around. And it hurt. Some of this coming out I can definitely empathize with and concur with what people experienced. Thanks for asking.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by kondro on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:33PM (#27045085)
I appreciate all the work you did at Highrise, but after DHH+JF announced they were going to sell it because it was a distraction & renamed 37 Signals to Basecamp, it was difficult to keep using the product… even when they decided they didn't want to sell.

The way in which DHH announced the _conversation_ he had with Salesforce was a thing of amazement all of its own.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by nate on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:42PM (#27045152)
Thank you. Oh for sure. (for people not familiar) So we took Highrise over a bit after that announcement, and that was almost an impossible thing to overcome. It was hemorrhaging customers. It was always a turnaround project. Our biggest task for the first couple years was just trying to erase the "marketing" that we had shut down already.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by whitepoplar on Monday May 03, 2021 @11:27PM (#27033761)
Thanks Nate, I really appreciate the reply, and just want to say how much I appreciate your (and your team's) work on Highrise. You poured everything into it and it's sad to read what happened at the end.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by jf on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:32PM (#27044614)
Thanks for sharing your viewpoints Nate. I appreciate that you’re willing to tell stories in public that most people would only tell over beers
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by 1123581321 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:26PM (#27044122)
I really enjoyed reading about and watching your videos about your turnaround of Highrise as it was happening. Tons of work. Hope you'll publish what happened at the end someday.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by nate on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:12PM (#27044928)
Thank you!
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by indemnity on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:28PM (#27033090)
Shit, that sucks. What a classless way to go.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by giglamesh on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:51PM (#27044346)
Just the opposite really. In a classless society people will not be treated like commodities.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by sbarre on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:24PM (#27044562)
Words can have multiple meanings.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by dools on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:43PM (#27044700)
"Hey Buster I thought you had class"

"I thought YOU had class!"

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by SrslyJosh on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:02PM (#27044867)
Ugh, that's definitely a relevant data point.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by Trasmatta on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:05PM (#27033309)
> Can't believe only 21 employees walked

The article said they extended the buyout offer indefinitely, so I wouldn't be surprised if more people leave over the next few weeks.

Even if you weren't thinking of leaving, 3-6 months severance would be really hard to turn down, especially if you know you can get another job quickly.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by freddie_mercury on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @11:01PM (#27045706)
If that many employees think they can get another, comparable, job quickly then that is implicitly saying Basecamp's overall compensation package (including how interesting the work is, extra time off in summer, profit sharing, etc, etc) isn't actually especially unique or valuable. Which kind of says something not great about Basecamp in and of itself.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by etchalon on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @11:37PM (#27045892)
They also made their overall compensation package a lot loss less attractive with 10% profit sharing as a replacement for lifestyle subsidies.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by shagie on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:13AM (#27050066)
So... hypothetically... (these may or may not be actual basecamp things - I don't know)

> 50% off a gym membership

But I already have a home gym. Will the company give me a check to help pay for my next piece of equipment? Why do I have to go into town to the gym to make use of this benefit?

> Reimbursement of 25% off of Community Supported Agriculture

I've got an orchard with more apples and pears than I know what to do with each year. I consider rhubarb to almost be a weed at this point. I get free eggs from my neighbor (and honey too - helps with the aforementioned apples and pears). Could I get 25% off my next fruit tree purchase instead?

---

Such benefits are entirely missed on me. I wouldn't take advantage of them and so they're not serving the purpose of the company to entice me to stay. They also are a little bit disdainful in that other people (yea, I know... the "someone else is getting something I'm not" is a hard thing to excise from the mind) are getting extra benefits/bonuses/perks that I'm not able to take advantage of.

A 10% profit sharing? Even if its worth "less" than those are previously offered - it's worth more to me.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by comp_throw7 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:27AM (#27046522)
Do you mean a lot more attractive? I would be shocked if the aforementioned lifestyle subsidies were valued by the median employee at even $1000/year; if the profit sharing came out to less than 5 figures in a normal year (again, for a median employee) I would likewise be surprised.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by etchalon on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @08:50AM (#27049214)
Humans are weird. I’ve found most employees seem to be be more attracted to guaranteed subsidies than to profit sharing. Not all, but most. Just my experience though.

Obviously, both is better.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by dudul on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:34PM (#27044200)
Absolutely. At this point you start interviewing for a new job and get the extra 3/6mo of cash.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by ashtonkem on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @01:55AM (#27034454)
It seems like most of these attention hungry founders have extremely poor impulse or emotion control. I’m increasingly of the opinion that a “thought leader” CEO or founder is a red flag for a company, as tales of these people’s greatness always seems to diminish with distance.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by ilrwbwrkhv on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:12PM (#27044490)
That's why Bob iger of Disney is such a good leader. We need more like him instead of the Elon musk's.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by cbsmith on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:20PM (#27044985)
What's always funny to me is this phenomenon generally has nothing to do with the actual people involved. It's just a story telling phenomenon. None of the people who know these thought leaders imbue them with qualities they don't have.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by ashtonkem on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:50PM (#27045619)
That does not seem correct to me. It’s not a “story telling phenomenon” that DHH and Jason Fried are perceived as industry thought leaders, it’s the result of both repeated actions on their part, plus some luck. Those two didn’t accidentally end up in the public conversation, they wrote five books about working, plus god knows how many blog posts, talks, and more.

That is explicitly attention seeking behavior, and it’s a hard prerequisite to becoming a “thought leader” or even just famous enough that a three letter initial is enough to identify yourself.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by cbsmith on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @10:59PM (#27058687)
I don't think choosing to share your thoughts/critiques on what has & hasn't worked for you in industry connotes any kind of assumptions about being a flawless leader. One can have some interesting thoughts worth sharing without being some idealized technical leader. Hell, I'd argue a lot of the thoughts that were shared betrayed some points of concern.

There's a LOT of projection that has gone here.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by antoniuschan99 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:52AM (#27046325)
It’s also content marketing (both the blog and books)
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by ashtonkem on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:38AM (#27046579)
Yes, it can be that too. I’m just saying that you’ve got to take positive steps towards where they’re at, culturally. It’s not an accident, even if there is certainly some luck and mixed motives.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by antoniuschan99 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @09:53AM (#27049802)
In their case though, their Books, Company (and lesser extent Rails), and Personal Brand are all intertwined.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by indemnity on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:32PM (#27033118)
Even if your heart isn’t 100% in it, the least you could do is acknowledge and thank the people for their contributions while they were there.

Kind of gives the lie to the progressive, all-in-it-together environment they portray with their public image.

So, just like any other company really, except due to the excessive power of the top two execs, no recourse if you have a problem they don’t perceive as a problem.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by ilrwbwrkhv on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:17PM (#27044525)
I hope people detach themselves from their offices a bit more. There is too much of worship of these companies like basecamp faang etc. Thing to remember is this is just a job and not to take moral guidance from companies.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by fallenfromgrace on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:59PM (#27033279)
for what it's worth, I find the picking on DHH for taking this call from bed unnecessary

If he was sick, whether physically sick because of their own actions or otherwise...sick is sick. Seemed like a no-win for him whether he could either refuse to show up because he is sick, or show up to at least listen to what's going on (assuming recording it wasn't an option).

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by Trasmatta on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:13PM (#27033358)
This might have been the most important meeting in Basecamp's history, so it just feels odd that the co founder was apparently so sick he couldn't sit at his desk for an hour or two. Or even just during the initial introductions before he turned his camera off.

Maybe he was that sick, but I would be kind of pissed if I were one of the employees. The power dynamic is weird, because if a regular employee were sick they would definitely feel the pressure to show up at a desk, on camera, if they were trying to make their case in this meeting.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by devoutsalsa on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:12AM (#27046112)
After experiencing a pandemic, if someone says they are sick, I’m going to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by philosopher1234 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @01:24AM (#27046506)
I, on the other hand, do not feel the need to participate in DHH apologia.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by DiNovi on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:05PM (#27033314)
he had over 10 retweets and tweets the same day after this call. And did not use those tweets to thank his old team, just more "apple bad" stuff as if nothing had changed.

Color me skeptical.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by Trasmatta on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:15PM (#27033374)
DHH has one of the most annoying Twitter feeds. He picks a hobby horse every few months and tweets incessantly about it, until something else grabs his attention. Surely they shouldn't have been surprised that many of the people they chose to hire would be likewise strongly opinionated, and not take kindly to those policy changes.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by nmfisher on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @08:07PM (#27044461)
I had to unfollow him for precisely this reason. It’s just a relentless torrent of negativity. Maybe his feed isn’t a great indication, but he seems like a very unhappy person.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by fallenfromgrace on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:19PM (#27033399)
Hear you, but not knowing the exact timeline of events here...and seeing how this is a disaster on so many other levels...I find there is value in showing him grace for being...sick. (There is already so much bad, that his absence/presence is a moot point)

But totally hear what you're saying and appreciate your skepticism!

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by predaking on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @01:24AM (#27034316)
The timeline of events is pretty evident from DHHs twitter feed + this article. They had the meeting in the morning, and by the afternoon he had mustered up the energy to go back on Twitter to fight with Apple. :)

> (There is already so much bad, that his absence/presence is a moot point)

This dude is one of the two founders of the company and has a leadership/ownership responsibility. I don't think his deciding to duck out is a moot point at all. It's that exact attitude that led to what's happened there.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by dantemoose on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:49PM (#27045611)
He probably doesn't post most of those tweets himself. Still, bad work by his social team.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by antoniuschan99 on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @12:54AM (#27046335)
He was on cnbc the day before or something (it says 6 days ago right now on youtube)
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by mbergal on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:34PM (#27033474)
> - Announced a new company policy publicly before telling the staff

Bad

> - Deleted internal threads that would go against their narrative of why they did so

I am not sure where you are getting this, but I might have missed it.

> - Had a conservative senior employee go off about politics on the call discussing the new no politics policy.

Yes, on 90th minute - we are not sure what was said before that.

> - refused to reprimand said employee on the call

For what? I don't understand.

> - had one founder take this extremely sensitive call from his bed with his camera off and on mute.

We all can be sick sometimes, certainly would be better to it in some other way, but maybe he was just that sick?

- After the employees resigned, did not send any sort of public message thanking them for their time at the company.

Pretty bad, especially considering comments from Highrise employee in this thread.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by FireBeyond on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:55PM (#27045669)
> We all can be sick sometimes, certainly would be better to it in some other way, but maybe he was just that sick?

He was busy hitting Twitter pretty hard during the day, throwing some shade at Apple. No mention of company, employees, anything.

That's bad optics, regardless of how you're feeling. If you're sick, you're sick. If you're too sick to deal with the most pressing issue your company is facing, you should consider yourself too sick to devote chunks of time to Twitter feuds.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by freewilly1040 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:35PM (#27044202)
The bit about deleting the emails is discussed in the article.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by rodgerd on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:08PM (#27033335)
> - Had a conservative senior employee go off about politics on the call discussing the new no politics policy.

Ironically it seems that, contra to the narrative existing in the minds of quite a few HN posters, it was the Brietbart quoting, "white people are the real victims of racism" guy who had spend over a decade being unable to shut up about politics in the workplace.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by SvenMarquardt on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:38PM (#27042601)
Where's your evidence of that?
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by FireBeyond on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:56PM (#27045678)
The quote in the article? And the fact that the author gave Singer a chance to respond, and Singer did so in some depth, and did not deny or rebut the claim that he said that?
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by SvenMarquardt on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @11:26PM (#27045833)
Which quote?
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by azangru on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @07:33PM (#27044183)
> - Had a conservative senior employee go off about politics on the call discussing the new no politics policy.

The article really doesn't tell us whether that senior employee just went off on a political tangent for no reason whatsoever, or he was responding to an earlier made political statement that he decided to disagree with.

What the article does suggest is that that contribution by that senior employee was preceded by a discussion of the funny names list that involved the mentioning of the "pyramid of hate". That pyramid is already a political statement and should not, if the company were true to its new policy, have been brought up in the discussion.

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by rst on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:32PM (#27045078)
I'm not sure the context of the Singer's remarks matters much -- they were clearly against the newly announced policy that the meeting itself was about. And as a senior employee and member of the company's leadership, it was more incumbent on him than on others to follow the policy, in order to set the tone and be a good example.

(NB even David and Jason seem to have recognized this -- after the meeting, Singer was suspended; he's since resigned, but this is likely the only one of the several recent resignations that was not entirely of the employee's own volition.)

Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by faizmokhtar on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @10:38PM (#27045553)
Based on what I followed from Twitter, that senior employee is the one who regularly posted articles from Breitbart to the internal thread that was deleted.
Re:How Basecamp Blew Up by itsdrewmiller on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @09:42PM (#27045156)
The discussion of the "funny names" list including the pyramid of hate discussion was what led to the "no politics" rule - it didn't happen in violation of it.