News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by nanis on Saturday May 01, 2021 @08:47PM (#27011338)
I don't think one can talk about Shabbas and elevators without mentioning Feynman's take[1].

[1]: https://old.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/ev3gy/excerpt_from...

PS: I am linking to where I easily found a good quotation with enough context. It is not an argument for atheism.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by null_deref on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:34AM (#27012379)
It doesn't really matter whether electricity is fire or not, many of the Jewish religious rules (Halacha), are there to keep the cultural and the day to day life in a certain way (like any other religion).

Allowing electricity in Shabbat will completely change the Jewish life, and the amount of impact the community has on the individual.

There's another rule in the Halacha that says you must keep Shabbat different from any other day, that rule for example is one of the reasons you can't turn on your TV prior to Shabbat, and watch it without pressing buttons.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by iso1631 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:56AM (#27014032)
> Allowing electricity in Shabbat will completely change the Jewish life, and the amount of impact the community has on the individual.

That's fine, I can respect that.

Jewish life 1000 years ago did not have people getting in elevators, so with this "hack" Jewish life has changed. I find working around the spirit of the law to keep within the letter hilarious.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by null_deref on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:48PM (#27016673)
https://oukosher.org/passover/articles/selling-leaven/

In Passover you aren't allowed to own certain foods, you arrange a sale to a non-jewish person, you may still keep the foods locked in your house, at the end of Passover you purchase them back (You both know the sell was fictive).

Jewish traditions have fascinating ideas and principals, but also those ridiculous hacks.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by TchoBeer on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:26AM (#27016073)
>Allowing electricity in Shabbat will completely change the Jewish life, and the amount of impact the community has on the individual.

you only think this because electricity was _already_ prohibited. Imagine a world where electricity was not prohibited on shabbat (as could very well be our world if the rabbis decide it so). We would not say "electricity destroys the spirit of shabbat" because not using electricity on shabbat is only part of the spirit after it's prohibited. The reason why it was banned in the first place, as far as I could tell, was that when electricity was new incandescent lightbulbs were basically its only common application (and those are obviously ma'avir [lighting a fire]), so the rabbis of the time gave a very generalized ban on electricity which stuck.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by sevrinsky on Monday May 03, 2021 @11:32AM (#27026378)
The grounds for probihiting electricity usage on Shabbat have gone through something of a metamorphosis, as rabbinic scholarship on the nature of electricity has expanded and the mechanisms used by electrical devices have evolved.

Given my digital-oriented profession and lifestyle, if it were not for the fact that all electronic devices are forbidden, I would find myself drifting back to work-related tasks ("oh, let's just see if this gets it to compile") to the point of losing Shabbat entirely. The blanket ban has saved my Shabbat and is part of the day's special distinctiveness.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by cheese_van on Saturday May 01, 2021 @09:22PM (#27011536)
Of course a professor would be pleased by a culture that valued teachers. I hope anyone would. I did some mentoring for an Asian student once. I was embarrassed by how much deference I was shown, and tried to dissuade it. "But you are my teacher!" I was a little humbled by it, and pleased, to be honest. There's an obvious downside to elevating academics to too high a moral perch, but there's a positive element that you can't discount.
Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by jandrese on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:05PM (#27011767)
It’s certainly better than denigrating them as out of touch ivory tower types.
Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by vxNsr on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:20PM (#27011831)
> While I was at the conference, I stayed at the Jewish Theological Seminary, where young rabbis--I think they were Orthodox--were studying. Since I have a Jewish background, I knew of some of the things they told me about the Talmud, but I had never seen the Talmud. It was very interesting. It's got big pages, and in a little square in the corner of the page is the original Talmud, and then in a sort of L-shaped margin, all around this square, are commentaries written by different people. The Talmud has evolved, and everything has been discussed again and again, all very carefully, in a medieval kind of reasoning. I think the commentaries were shut down around the thirteen- or fourteen- or fifteen-hundreds--there hasn't been any modern commentary.

This is mostly wrong as other have pointed out.

JTS is not by any estimation orthodox. At most it would be considered Jewish-conservative. I’m surprised to learn they are concerned with not pushing elevator buttons, if that was true then it’s certainly not true today. Additionally, the Talmud absolutely has commentaries from the modern era, you can find commentaries from even the 1950s. Though it does take a few years for those to make it into the book. Maybe not directly in the margin but likely sub-noted to the back of the book.

I also find it hilarious that he calls it medieval logic and then admits they out foxed him at every turn in any logical debate he tried. Not to mention I could likely take down the arguments he proposes without much trouble and I’m no rabbi.

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by TchoBeer on Saturday May 01, 2021 @10:01PM (#27011749)
Lol the Jewish Theological Seminary is definitely not Orthodox. I'm surprised they even know enough halacha to know how to explain it; maybe it's gotten less orthodox over time.
Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by jsmith99 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:01AM (#27012947)
Which is why they did not know the actual answer to his question!

The answer is that God is universal but the commandment to rest on shabbos was addressed only to Jews. https://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/13447/is-it-a-di...

Re:Elevator Sabbath service mode (SHO) by TchoBeer on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:27AM (#27016079)
It's funny how that's not even close to a difficult question. Feynman is so impressed with their logic when a teenager could answer that question in one sentence.