> support for broadband networks owned, operated by, or affiliated with local governments, non-profits, and co-operatives
Anyone know if it would work? Note that this is the bill getting criticized as not being about "real infrastructure" due to daring to have non-transportation infrastructure, like this.
[1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases...
Which means the biggest thing you need from the feds (and for that matter the state governments) is to get out of the way and stop actively interfering with cities that want to do this. Which doesn't seem like much to ask, but the incumbents have spent the last hundred years capturing every level of government in the US, and then we got the likes of Ajit Pai running the FCC, which was an impediment.
The other thing to watch out for is the classic regulatory capture move where the government is about to spend money on municipal infrastructure to compete with the incumbents and the incumbents lobby instead to give the money to them. In this context here you're looking for money that goes to "5G" instead of fiber. Because "5G" means incumbents who own wireless spectrum and/or want to "buy" it from the taxpayer using tax money and then sit on it to exclude any other competitors from having it. Or have the taxpayer pay for their privately-owned infrastructure, providing a permanent cost advantage so that no one else can ever competitively enter the market in the future.
First rule of the game is never give tax money to the incumbents. History has shown that it's a black hole that produces no results, and anybody who doesn't understand this is either captured or not paying attention.
Would love it for dinosaurs in politics to get with it and understand the implications of technological investment (or lack thereof).
More legislation from the federal and state level is not needed, unless it's literally "All local agreements are now null and void" which isn't even legal.
The problem is that in a city there's limited space to run the wires to each home.
Also if you want to have 10 competitors is really silly to expect having 10 fiber optic cables going to every home when majority of people wouldn't use more than one ISP at the time. Then 9 fibers will be then unused and degrading.
When Internet was reclassified to Title II, Wheeler specifically excluded Title II's provision that required existing ISPs to lease their infrastructure to competitors. Back in late 90s, early 2000s we had tons of ISPs to chose from, exactly because of that provision.
This needs to change if we want to get competition back.
Or we would need cities to build such infrastructure which is even harder and more expensive thing to do.
Either way it requires government intervention.
It seems to me that city-owned is actually the best option in this case. If it is optimal to have one set of infrastructure than it makes sense to have that infrastructure owned by the city which operates for the common good. As much as I am hesitant to trust the government to run the network I have no issues with my water or electricity utilities and the prices seem quite fair.
I actually would strongly support municipalities owning the last mile as part of their services, but I'm less interested in them actually providing service.
The problem is the monopoly still exists. My father lives in a small town ironically with a tiny little ISP not owned by one of the majors. But the water - they pay $200 a month for water (!), because they are making major expansions to the water stations to support new building. The town council was pushed to do this by the builders with a lot of wining and dining. So the local, fairly poor townspeople are paying ridiculous rates. Since amalgamation, the town does not have it's own mayor, they do 'regional' groupings, so the individual town can't punt the program.
Due to monopoly situation in the town, the townspoeple are stuck paying massive rates to subsidize a rich builders exploits.
These things are common and guaranteed to happen.
The idea is to have some degree of socialization where absolutely necessary, and then to try to provide real competition on that infrastructure. If the construction and maintenance of the infrastructure can be competitive (like roads) then great. For electricity transport, it can become a problem, as the semi-private agencies that manage the electrical grid are often very inefficient.
Every town should take control of the 'last mile gear' but I suggest your ISP actually should be one of many private players. Definitely more than the physically limited Choice of Comcast + 1 other.
Exactly. Municipalities should run fiber to the nearest meet-me room, and license at a defined rate to anyone who wants to light up that fiber.
Good luck with your "let everyone run their tiny wires wherever without the government being involved" plan. You've heard of NIMBYism, right? How many times do you think you'll be allowed to rip up the street?
It started with the government telco not being interested in Internet. So people started running Ethernet cables, first to neighbors, then to other buildings. It started as having local networks to share files. Eventually those network got connected to Internet. If the price or quality of service provided is not satisfactory they can switch to another ISP. The bad part as you said is the huge number of ugly looking wires[1]
[1] https://www.alamy.com/stock-photo-many-internet-cables-on-la...
The existing POTS and similar infrastructure are probably worth less now as a going business than if you were to just rip out all the copper and sell it for scrap.
On the other hand, they still have pre-negotiated entry into every house and business in town, and the conduit already sunk. It would probably be cheaper, and certainly faster, to buy a firm like Frontier than to negotiate a comparable footprint from scratch.
I suspect there's some significant legal continuity-of-service obligations that poison the proposal.
They add up, though. https://www.ecmweb.com/safety/media-gallery/20902083/crazy-w...
Anarcho-libretarianism isn't the solution here and neither is rejecting balanced legislation out of a force of habit.
I don’t think anyone is suggesting no laws at all, but perhaps we can have some foresight and not legislate ourselves into oversight which will only make more legislation which will only make more...
I’m happy to see municipal internet IF the service quality and price is competitive. While we’re dealing with the Verizon’s and Comcast’s of the world, this is usually working, what do we do when we’ve destroyed the market and the local service sucks?
"Constant government intervention" is incompatible with the definition (literally) of a free market.
I'm just saying that:
Oxford defines a free market as: "an economic system in which prices are determined by unrestricted competition between privately owned businesses."
Wikipedia defines it as: "a system in which the prices for goods and services are self-regulated by buyers and sellers negotiating in an open market. In a free market, the laws and forces of supply and demand are free from any intervention by a government or other authority, and from all forms of economic privilege, monopolies and artificial scarcities."
Investopedia defines it as: "an economic system based on supply and demand with little or no government control."
Words have meaning, god damn it.
How about paying random people to leave bad reviews for your competitors. Or paying shops so they don't stock competitors products. Or agreeing with banks that your competitor should not get a loan. Or making a deal with railroads where they will only transport your product, and not your competitors? Because all of the above have happened. Is that "unrestricted"?
Also, infrastructure isn't easy to build and is oftentimes not even profitable. Are you suggesting only places where an ISP can make money should have Internet access?
Ideally, at that point, the government would then step back and merely enact rules to keep the market fair and competitive.
Whether that actually happens is another matter. My prediction is that the past trend of the government never letting go of power that it has acquired will continue.
Not doing that would give you this: https://media.istockphoto.com/photos/cables-above-street-kat...
So sure, ISPs per one phrasing is "government-granted monopolies", but the only problem was giving it to one private actor, not that government was involved.
It's not that you're technically wrong, but that it's an incomplete and unfair portrayal.
Instead of just treating infrastructure like infrastructure.
More municipal and small internet providers could act as a bulwark against centralization and corporate dominance of the backbone of our communication infrastructure.