Paying for labor is absolutely as transactional as paying for other inputs to your business. Because you (hopefully) create marginal value on top of that comp doesn't mean the total comp is your value creation.
You can't just add total employee comp to your "value created" pile. There's maybe some marginal value creation you could kind-of claim in that your presence increased employee comp over some hypothetical world where you didn't exist—but that's getting well into bullshit territory, since there's no way to know some competitor you crushed wouldn't have ended up creating more total value and paying their employees even more. It's pure fantasy.
>In a typical transaction, no value is created.
As I explained, in typical transactions value is created for both parties.
The value created in a transaction is orthogonal to the total sum of money exchanged in the transaction. That was the meaning of the criticism.
You are correct though in that the author worded it very unfortunately, which undermined the critique.
From my econ 101 high school days I remember a super simple example of 2 islands, 1 with only oranges and 1 with only pineapples. Simply by trading 1 orange for 1 pineapple (and vice versa) value is created since both parties get to experience different resources which offer them economic utility.
In rare edge cases it can be argued that trade doesn't create value for consenting stakeholders:
(1) Information asymmetries that don't rise to the level of fraud, which cause one counterparty to make an uninformed decision.
(2) Trades that appeal to the dopamine system but otherwise work against the individual, e.g. with social-media doomscrolling, gambling, drugs, fast food. In this case the individual has diminished agency to make the best decision for themselves in all cases.
Anything else? [I'm ignoring externalities here]
To use the pineapples and oranges island metaphor, imagine that on island A (which has lots of oranges but no pineapples) pineapples are valued at $1.1 and oranges are valued at $1, and v.v for island b, where oranges are $1.1 and pineapples are $1.
If you and I trade an orange on island A for a pineapple on island B, we both went from having $1 in fruit to having $1.1 in fruit on our islands. The value created by that transaction isn't $1, $1.1 (or $2.1 as Amazon appears to be double-counting some of the value between revenue, profit and wages), it's $0.2, which is the value we added to the fruit by moving it between islands.
In your example, the value creation is $0.2 ($0.1+$0.1) due to the existence of a perfect substitute.
In other cases the value creation may be 10x the turnover or higher. For example, if there's a single surgeon that can give me a life saving procedure that costs me $50k when I would've happily paid $500k, then the value creation for me is $450k and perhaps $20k for the surgeon.
In the case of Amazon, their numbers are probably an exaggeration, yes. They've assumed that the turnover = value creation, which is false reasoning, as we both recognize. It might be higher or lower. The real number might be 0.4x of what they stated, if I was to hazard a guess.
But since the whole idea of value creation flies over the heads of so many people (and this misunderstanding of basic economics has profound policy implications), Amazon's exaggeration here is not a point I wish to focus on.
The blog post says that "no value" was created which is the false claim we were discussing/debunking above.
Amazon also made a false claim. Yes. So it doesn't seem like we're disagreeing about anything.
The value to employees is tricky. Without Amazon they might make more from a competitor with less market power. Without the industry, they might make more selling or transporting things directly.
The worker does not get value in that arrangement. The employer is (often but not always) a price maker, the worker is (often but not always) a price taker. This can change depending on whether there are inelasticities of supply or demand.
You prefer a transaction at a higher price to one at the reservation price. Satisfying that preference is valuable.
I can't find technical fault with your comment, but I think we should be clear, very desperate people will work for nearly nothing.
[EDIT] Ah, I think I see, you don't like their assigning zero value to changes in distribution of goods. That makes sense.
Statements like: "In a typical transaction, no value is created."
> If I pay $10,000 for land and $50,000 in materials and pay $90,000 in labor to produce a building that I sell for $200,000, did I create $50,000 in value? $140,000 because for some reason my labor costs count as value creation?
In terms of production (value creation), we consider separately short-term inputs (e.g. materials) compared to long-term resources (capital, labor). In this example i would say that organization as a whole created $140000 in value using its capital and labour and used $90000 to compensate its labor (some other part to compensate capital, pay taxes and so on). This is essentially how GDP is computed, and also how VAT (value-added tax) is taxed.
He gives his socialist credentials away later with the art example, only a worker making something can possibly add any value. It's the classic theory that managers and investors are all parasites and only workers create value. Again, value can absolutely be created by identifying an imbalance in supply (labour) and demand (products and services) and then working out how to resolve it. Somebody has to do it.
I'm not saying Bezos' sums are credible or accurate or even mean anything, but this critique is crazily off base.
1) it's an axiom that "Somebody has to do it". You can't demonstrate that this is anything other than a feature of the political/power structure within the society where this putative imbalance happens. You can't demonstrate that the imbalance is inevitable, nor that it requires action by a 3rd party to resolve, only that these things happen a lot in our current society.
2) You make the remarkably naive assumption that the receiver of said orange and sausage have somehow freely computed the value of the exchange to them, compared it with the cost they incur to the merchant, and found the result to create value for them. In the real world, they may not have sufficient information to even begin this computation. They may not be in a position to do the computation at all.
“ If equivalents are exchanged, no surplus-value results, and if non-equivalents are exchanged, still no surplus-value. Circulation, or the exchange of commodities, begets no value.”
He makes the distinction so that he can special privilege the value of labour as productive “use value”, but the value of all goods derive from their use. The job of a merchant is to buy something from someone who has no or little use for it, and sell it to someone who has greater use for it.
In the same text he claims that no value can be created by converting a currency note into change, but this is trivially not true. With coins I can buy things from people who can’t change a note. I can also buy things from a vending machine that won’t accept notes. In some circumstances coins are more useful, in others notes are. That’s why people expend time and effort to go to banks to exchange one for the other.
Marx cannot accept any of this though, because if he does his entire economic analysis of capitalism comes crashing down.
For Marx distribution of goods creates no value. Seriously, read the text. He had no answer to the question why anyone would ever pay to transport a product from a factory to a purchaser. No value can possible be created by doing this. Really.
> but the value of all goods derive from their use
That's the definition of value economists adopt today following the marginal revolution, just as artificial as Marx's definition of value, which he qualifies as use-value or exchange-value. Marginalism is a great descriptive explanation for situations like the diamond-water paradox, but it is not really relevant to Marx's prescriptive project, as it concerns only what Marx calls use-value, and Marx's project very much relies on exploring this distinction he identifies between use-value and exchange-value. Whether that exploration is correct or important is another question, but I hate seeing this confusion of definitions and goals crop up all the time. Marx doesn't hold all these obviously stupid straw men views people ascribe to him regarding (use-)value, rather he thinks that the way we conceive of value should be rethought.
This is just wrong. The employer gets value because they make more (in expectation) from the worker than they pay; the worker gets value because they get paid more than the the minimum they'd be willing to work for. There's surplus on both sides in most transactions.
The article makes some correct points. But it's frustrating to see it combining those with nonsense.