News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:15PM (#26944266)
Did the government fail?

I don't know. We got a vaccine remarkably quickly and the governments (federal and state) distributed it efficiently. I don't blame the government for not taking the virus seriously to start with. SARS and MERS didn't pan out and people, on the left and right (including me), figured COVID would be the same. Some people predicted COVID would be bad but it wasn't crazy to think COVID wouldn't turn into a pandemic.

The countries that did well with COVID are mostly islands and East Asian countries. I doubt the "Chinese and Japanese are really obedient"-type expanations. I wonder if some East Asian countries had antibodies from similar viruses that flew under the radar and granted partial immunity. That's pure speculuation...but even if those countries suceeded due to law and order, that's a double-edged sword. Do we really want to build our society to survive viruses with the fewest causalities or are there perhaps higher ideals (freedom, self determiniation) that we should aspire to? And of course there's no freedom without the freedom to be wrong.

> And where the world needs to head is to establish new means of producing credibility and good reputation that are robust to current technologies. What we’re now calling “populism” might turn out to be the least of our problems.

In terms of populism stuff, I think there's some truth to the idea here that the internet has led to the unmasking of leaders/government as incompetent. To some degree, modern populism consists of people recoiling in horror after realizing just how dumb you can be while holding power. But it's easy to notice other people being wrong and quite hard to do any better yourself. Mostly, these populist movements seem bereft of ideas and are just expressing incoherent outrage.

It will be interesting to see if the internet makes it possible to have better, more accountable governments. I don't discount the possibility. The thing that worries me is that, in my opinion, more transparency is in some sense the problem. We learn about governmental incompetence via the internet but the internet also turns politicians into influencers, and that's a signiciant part of the problem too.

Re:Why Governments Fail by shadowgovt on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:20PM (#26944335)
I think the Internet (in particular, the social media a lot of people are consuming their news from) is really good at providing anecdata, but really bad at giving perspective to determine context and how to fit the anecdotes into a bigger picture. Because of, for example, correlation algorithms determining what someone reads in their Facebook feed and trying to maximize the topic for engagement, a person chasing a few threads of stories of incompetence can quickly end up with a wall that is nothing but such stories. And even if one doesn't use Facebook, other spaces are vulnerable to the same effects... Chasing Reddit karma involves posting stories that the majority will upvote, posting controversial-but-true content in many topic-specific fora will result in some form of moderation or loss of karma-equivalent, and so on.

The unmasking of incompetence is real, but much less clear is the degree to which it occurs and whether it's the exception or the norm. But it's very easy to assume it's the norm from what one sees on a Facebook wall (and on a different Facebook wall, or in a different group, it's very easy to assume it never happens or all reports of it are overblown).

Re:Why Governments Fail by yosito on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:32PM (#26944499)
> Do we really want to build our society to survive viruses with the fewest causalities or are there perhaps higher ideals (freedom, self determiniation) that we should aspire to?

I don't see why these have to be mutually exclusive goals. Arguably, there are better ways to get an entire society to cooperate toward a goal without resorting to authoritarianism. This sort of societal engineering is demonstrated in religions, cults, and political tribes all the time. If we can harness it at the scale of an entire country, or even a majority of the world, we could accomplish quite a lot. It's been done before, and today's technology could theoretically enable it at a level that's never been seen in human history. Though we currently seem to be experiencing more of the dark side of the whole phenomenon.

Re:Why Governments Fail by ryandrake on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:46PM (#26944707)
I don't understand the whole "freedom" argument against basic public health and safety guidance. Almost everyone wears their seatbelt in a car and doesn't complain about how their freedoms are being taken away in the name of safety. So why is this not the same with masks and distancing? Why is it that people think refusing to wear a mask transforms them into Braveheart, fighting for freedom against oppression? Sensible precautions against an airborne deadly pandemic are not attacks on self determination.
Re:Why Governments Fail by Mediterraneo10 on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:05PM (#26945814)
> Why is it that people think refusing to wear a mask transforms them into Braveheart, fighting for freedom against oppression?

1) In my country, some of the same scientific advisors to the government on the COVID response, are also criticizing the government for requiring masks to be worn outdoors in deserted streets, even though the science says that the risk of transmission there is negligible. They say that this kind of "hygiene theatre" can ultimately diminish the state's authority to mount efforts that truly matter to stopping the spread. A problem is that the outdoor mask law also appears to discourage outdoor exercise (even if people could exercise in a mask, the psychological barrier is real), and exercise is something public-health experts naturally want to encourage, even during the pandemic.

2) In some countries, the authorities have eased up on restrictions, or kept them on the books but ceased enforcing them, after the broad population flaunted them. Ruling parties are sensitive to what the population is willing to accept, lest unpopular restrictions cost them the next election.

Now put those two facts together, and people refusing en masse to wear a mask outdoors (while continuing to responsibly wear masks in crowded open areas and in indoor spaces like shops and other people’s homes) might be effective in ending a measure that even actual public-health experts say is pointless and oppressive.

Re:Why Governments Fail by ModernMech on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:08PM (#26945023)
It's just because masks are new. People had the same negative reaction to seatbelts when they were first introduced, citing inane things like "it might wrinkle my shirt" as a reason not to wear them.

https://www.businessinsider.com/seatbelt-car-habit-obligatio...

Re:Why Governments Fail by shuntress on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:18PM (#26945152)
>Why is it that people think refusing to wear a mask transforms them into Braveheart

Because that was the message in the echo chamber they didn't know they were in.

Re:Why Governments Fail by throwawayboise on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:57PM (#26945674)
Because masks were promoted as protecting others, not the wearer. This didn't recognize that people put their own needs ahead of others. Seat belts can protect me in an accident. So I wear them. With masks, (especially if I am young and not at much risk) I think "if someone is afraid of the virus, they can just stay home, why do I need to change what I do?"
Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:11PM (#26945067)
It seems clear to me that "religions, cults, and political tribes" that enforce uniform behavior are by definition restricting freedom.

Which is not to say that freedom is never worth restricting. My general point was that I prefer American notions of freedom to East Asian notions of freedom.

Re:Why Governments Fail by yosito on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:10PM (#26947429)
Plato's famous works were about this. One of his ideas was to create the perfect state in which good behavior didn't have to be enforced by laws, by instilling people with an internal sense of morality that they willingly want to follow. Early Judeo-Christian societies were built around this idea. If people are doing what they want to do, and that aligns with what society needs them to do, then their freedom doesn't have to be restricted.
Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:42PM (#26948570)
Yes, The Republic, and Plato's last dialogue is called Laws and it describes a state governed by laws. Judeo-Christian societies were and are based on deontology i.e. the ten commandments.

What you're talking about is the harmonization of all interests around a single ideal, something that never ends well (including Plato's attempt in Syracuse). It's been criticized to death by liberal philosophers, in my opinion rightly.

Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:21PM (#26945192)
This is a false dichotomy. We don't have only U.S. apathy and East Asian collectivism as our choices. We could invest in public health infrastructure. We won't, but that is another topic.
Re:Why Governments Fail by luxuryballs on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:08PM (#26948156)
Also didn’t they change the definition of a pandemic in 2009 such that it wouldn’t have even been a pandemic prior? I read that somewhere standby... https://www.who.int/bulletin/volumes/89/7/11-086173.pdf
Re:Why Governments Fail by giantg2 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:28PM (#26944446)
"To some degree, modern populism consists of people recoiling in horror after realizing just how dumb you can be while holding power. But it's easy to notice other people being wrong and quite hard to do any better yourself." italics for emphasis

I think this is true in some cases, but not necessarily in all the issues we today. We're all just human and we all make mistakes. I think the part where it is ok to think we can do better is in how we handle those mistakes. It seems that most leaders tend to be hypocritical, blame the 'other side' for failures, and even ignore failings. Of course, it seems that's the way people get to be in power in the first place in the current political environment, so the people who act differently rarely stand a chance at the federal level.

Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:01PM (#26944923)
Yes, the U.S. government failed.

We should have implemented testing at scale immediately, found the infected, and paid them to stay home. While this would have cost a lot of money, it would have been less than the PPP and stimulus efforts.

Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:07PM (#26945015)
I think this implies a historicist perspective. In other words, you tacitly demand that the government tell the future and act accordingly. Well obviously the government can't do that.

I think "failure" should be a question of incompetent administration. That is, once a policy is decided, how well or poorly was it carried out? It may be that the government failed at carrying out mass testing.

Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:10PM (#26945058)
I do not demand that the government successfully predict the future. In March 2020, it was obvious what was happening in other countries. We were informed by the past and the present to determine how to respond.
Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:13PM (#26945093)
> While this would have cost a lot of money, it would have been less than the PPP and stimulus efforts.

This quote is demanding that the government has access to future numbers, isn't it?

I don't agree that it was obvious what was happening in March. It's only obvious in retrospect.

Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:17PM (#26945148)
It was obvious to me and many others. I posted on March 11, 2020 that we should get our shit together and test at scale, as South Korea and other countries with effective government were doing. I was not demanding supernatural prognostication, just competence.

Now we pay the price.

Re:Why Governments Fail by 8note on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:37PM (#26947001)
It was obvious to the government what was happening.

They got rich off it

Re:Why Governments Fail by pessimizer on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:00PM (#26945728)
> In other words, you tacitly demand that the government tell the future and act accordingly.

This is a common excuse about every bad plan after the fact; that the critics are expecting decisionmakers to have been psychic. It scrupulously ignores that the critics were offering the same critique at the time.

It scrupulously ignores anything specific to the problem being discussed. It's the "no one could have known" or the "it's easy to be a backseat driver" defense.

> I think "failure" should be a question of incompetent administration. That is, once a policy is decided, how well or poorly was it carried out?

All people with responsibility agree with you, which is why they carefully avoid formulating a policy.

Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:10PM (#26945872)
Doing nothing is a perfectly fine policy. In medicine they say "first, do no harm".
Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:38PM (#26946250)
This is the most contrived apology for incompetence that I have read. I am quite amazed.

It would be different if we had never before experienced a pandemic. It would be different if we did not have the examples of countries and cultures with effective implementation of testing at scale while we did nothing.

This defense of inaction is like leaving potholes alone because doing the obvious thing might cause harm somehow.

Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:57PM (#26946522)
I'm arguing for a distinction between being wrong and failure. I don't see anything from you (or the other poster) besides rhetoric. Apparently we should have "just known" that this virus was going to be a disaster. And evidence of this was "I knew" or "other countries knew". Great, and half of HN "knows" there is imminent hyperinflation.

It may be fair to describe the lack of available tests a failure. All the PCR testing sites near me were 100% booked whenever I checked and the state did nothing (as far as I know) to tell us where we could get tested. Perhaps that could be described as a failure. But the rhetoric from you and the other poster is post-hoc silliness. Neither of you seem to be aware that you're expecting the government to tell the future or what the drawbacks of that might be.

For a taste, consider that citizens blaming the government for 9/11 plausibly led to a years-long illegal wire-tapping and at least one clearly unnecessary war.

Re:Why Governments Fail by mcculley on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:59PM (#26948054)
"post-hoc silliness"? In March, we had seen what had happened in China and Italy already. We were watching how other countries were investing. We chose not to invest.

When a government fails to do something about an entirely predictable outcome, that is not just an error, it is also a failure.

You have a really surprising way to view things: All governments can be excused for inaction or even the wrong action with this logic.

Re:Why Governments Fail by slibhb on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:44PM (#26948587)
Not excused but forgiven.