News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Governments Fail by giantg2 on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:05PM (#26944117)
There's a lot in here. I was going to make some quotes and comment about some of this, but it's a pretty diverse set of topics.

The main thing is that I didn't see a solid definition on how a failing government is defined or a concrete connection between that and the topics covered. It seems to be Q&A about a bunch of loosely affiliated topics.

Re:Why Governments Fail by lbriner on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:12PM (#26944225)
> I didn't see a solid definition on how a failing government is defined

I was going to say the same thing!

I would be interested in breaking down the question into much more comprehensible chunks such as, "What does a Government do that they are unable to do effectively by definition?"; "Is there a balance between public and private sector providing services to the taxpayer and how do we decide the balance?"; "If a Government is necessarily slow-moving, what is the correct way to achieve fast-acting and tactical solutions that will be accepted by the public when the time comes to do them?"

I think a really common issue is that Governments are seen as a single entity, when in fact they are more like an ever-changing combination of ideals, abilities and pragmatism. The UK Government is not the same now as it was even 6 months ago, so learning lessons never really works. Any retired Politicians going to face the music for a decision made 10 years ago?

Re:Why Governments Fail by jonathannat on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:35PM (#26944538)
The discussion is a bit all over the place. The main points are that EU failed vaccination, and US failed covid testing (Statista disagrees https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104645/covid19-testing-...) , as well as having a decline of innovation and movement (disagrees here, people moved everywhere during covid, and US came up with tons of effective vaccines)

It's pretty hilarious both ignored discussing the current failing government: China.

- Came up with a 50% effective vaccine sinovac, and forces its citizens to take it

- Wolf warrior politics has infuriated almost every democratic countries on Earth, and alienated China. When Merkel steps down in Sept, the Green party candidate is most likely to succeed. And the newcomer will act tough against China and Russia

- Ballooning debt (they don't own global currency, unlike US), declining marriage/birth rate, middle income trap, unrest in many provinces

- The CCP is so insecure that they banned broadcast of oscars because of Chloe Zhao, because she mentioned CCP as failing one time in 2013

Re:Why Governments Fail by fossuser on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:59PM (#26944895)
> "The CCP is so insecure that they banned broadcast of oscars because of Chloe Zhao, because she mentioned CCP as failing one time in 2013"

They're even here downvoting you.

When they're willing to censor pooh bear there's nothing that doesn't cross that insecurity threshold.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winnie-the-Pooh#Censorship_in_...

Re:Why Governments Fail by MomoXenosaga on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:56PM (#26946512)
People have been predicting China's government to fail since 1948. If Mao couldn't do it with his disastrous communist nonsense it's going to take a lot. The CCP has cleverly pivoted to Chinese nationalism (the wolf warrior diplomacy is for internal consumption).

I think it would be best to have a backup plan for what happens if China doesn't implode.

Re:Why Governments Fail by imtringued on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:46PM (#26949272)
> Ballooning debt

What does the debt buy them? If it buys them increased growth why even care? Assuming you can grow forever, you can get into infinite debt.

Re:Why Governments Fail by hungryhobo on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:03PM (#26944954)
> Came up with a 50% effective vaccine sinovac, and forces its citizens to take it

is this worse than not having your own capacity to manufacture vaccine and having to beg other countries for vaccines? 50% efficacy is for transmission prevention, however when you consider effectiveness against deaths and hospitalization, it's >90%

> Wolf warrior politics has infuriated almost every democratic countries on Earth, and alienated China. When Merkel steps down in Sept, the Green party candidate is most likely to succeed. And the newcomer will act tough against China and Russia

oh god forbid a country standing up for its own interest.

> Ballooning debt (they don't own global currency, unlike US), declining marriage/birth rate, middle income trap, unrest in many provinces

something that's been touted for the past 30+ years. can we just wait until it happens?

> The CCP is so insecure that they banned broadcast of oscars because of Chloe Zhao, because she mentioned CCP as failing one time in 2013

funny that indian government asked twitter to remove anything critical of its handling over COVID, with 350k daily cases, but they are democratic so they get a pass. no this isn't whataboutism, this is pointing out the double standard.

Re:Why Governments Fail by nradov on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:12PM (#26945078)
The Indian government hasn't gotten a pass, they are being widely criticized in international news and social media. But there are significant difference in degree. China clearly is far worse on censorship and punishes dissent more harshly.
Re:Why Governments Fail by gtyras2mrs on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:58AM (#26952898)
> funny that indian government asked twitter to remove anything critical of its handling over COVID, with 350k daily cases, but they are democratic so they get a pass. no this isn't whataboutism, this is pointing out the double standard.

a. as the other comment pointed out - they aren't getting a pass on this. b. Multiple news agencies reporting on failures of the government's response to the second wave of COVID (and as usual the government is reacting by clamping down on the louder voices - as they did with the farmer protests) c. the religious nationalism that embodies the current right-wing government of India has been a subject of op-eds for the past couple of years (not criticised loudly enough IMO)