Wouldn't it be a violation of the 5th amendment to be compelled to provide that passphrase, because it is an admission against interest and therefore would be admissible if you disclosed it? Wouldn't it also serve to waive 5th amendment privilege, and possibly put you at risk of being forced to take the stand?
If it were an admission of a different crime, a court could grant you immunity on those unrelated charges, but if it is relevant to the crime the government is investigating by asking you to reveal your passphrase... how can anyone, luddite judge or not, separate "key" from "testimony" in that circumstance?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use%E2%80%93mention_distinction
In the context of testimony, I'd argue (as a philosopher, not a lawyer) that a mention does not count as testimony and cannot be used against you. Obviously, an observation of the mention could lead the police to consider other avenues of investigation however.
You do have the right to remain silent, however. That might be a stronger defense.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Amendment_to_the_United_S...
"If the government gives an individual immunity, then that individual may be compelled to testify. Immunity may be "transactional immunity" or "use immunity"; in the former, the witness is immune from prosecution for offenses related to the testimony; in the latter, the witness may be prosecuted, but his testimony may not be used against him. In Kastigar v. United States, 406 U.S. 441 (1972), the Supreme Court held that the government need only grant use immunity to compel testimony. The use immunity, however, must extend not only to the testimony made by the witness, but also to all evidence derived therefrom. This scenario most commonly arises in cases related to organized crime."
There have in fact been a few instances where judges have determined that providing a password does constitute giving testimony.
http://www.easterndistrictblog.com/?p=57
and older
http://mises.org/Community/blogs/crypto/archive/2007/12/18/c...
Where did you put your ex-wife's body Mr Johnson, we know you killed her? Just point at the map, you do not even have to say anything.
You could have cat pictures encrypted with passphrase A and incriminating evidence (that stands up to the best forensic analysis currently available) encrypted with passphrase B and they wouldn't know which is which, if they unlocked ALL the data, or what.
Truecrypt is AMAZING and anyone holding onto stuff that might get them into trouble (esp. w/ foreign gov'ts) should use it.
The evidence is what it is, the court is there to judge it.
Does US law require me to open the door of my house to the police if they have a warrant?
In lots of countries a warrant allows the police to search your house, but it does not require your cooperation. You may not actively hinder the police from doing their task, but you, e.g., do not need to open the door.
Its a good question, you are required to co-operate with the authorities in the lawful execution of their job. The term 'lawful' is, of course, subject to legal interpretation.
Police have arrested people for filming them arresting others, typically the scenario is "They ask the person filming to stop while they are doing their job, person doesn't, they arrest them for interfering with an officer." (sister-in-law is a public defender, I get to hear all the excuses). So far the California lower courts are still fumbling around this issue. I expect it to make it to the ninth circuit sometime later this year or early next year.
The question of "Can you make a house that the police can't search without your co-operation?" is a good one, and I'll ask my lawyer friends if that approach has been taken yet. Generally a subpoena is the court ordering you to co-operate and generally you must (or be held in contempt of court).
So I expect such cases would go "give us your hard drive" followed by "give us the key", followed by a refusal, followed by a subpoena, followed by another refusal, followed by being in jail for contempt.
If you did shred your key so that you literally cannot decrypt the drive, then I would expect you to spend a few days in jail (so that the prosecutor could prove to themselves you are serious) and then they would return your drive after re-formatting it. How they would justify that I do not know but I know that they would try.
If I delete all of my email today, I'm not committing a crime. But if I find out that my company is being sued for breach of a contract that I was working on, deleting email becomes suspicious.
Then, do just that.
If a civil or criminal case is brought against you the law says you must stop any routine houskeeping tasks like that to preserve evidence, but the most you'd have then is 4 weeks worth. Much better than 4 years.
does not make much sense to me...
There are two ways to avoid this, either build a house with no doors, or don't have one.
[1] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/United_States...
I can see this as still incriminating himself no?
Plaintiff: "There was a dead-body in the toilet, but the defendant has been regularly flushing, thereby destroying the evidence and proving his guilt."
Judge: "Well, if you say it, it must be true!"
Since hidden volumes are an optional feature and - again, in theory - cannot be proven to exist, you can always claim that this is the only password. Even if the judge/attorney knows a thing or two about true crypt.
1: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Plausible_den...
You might also be missing something about TrueCrypt: plausible deniability. You can have different passphrases that unlock different things. You could provide them with a passphrase the only unlocks innocent documents when really you have CP stored using a DIFFERENT pass phrase -- any this would stand up to any cryptographical analysis -- they simply cannot PROVE that the CP exists or even that more encrypted data exists.
The analogy to a key isn't quite valid here; it's more like the doors in that hallway in the matrix. If you use key A in the door, you will get content A. However, you can use a different key, open the door, and it'll go somewhere else entirely. Also, if you rip the door off the wall, there is just the wall behind it. Crazy stuff, that.
Secondly, the fifth amendment of the US Constitution allows you to refuse to provide testimony which you feel may incriminate you. Generally encryption pass phrases do not count as testimony, the legal system treats them as keys. And that would be covered under the fourth amendment which says the government cannot compel to you to give access to your property for search unless they have probable cause.
If they do have probable cause, they get a warrant which gives them the power to do the search temporarily and only for what they think exists. So if you get a warrant to search your hard drive for something, you are compelled to give them the password just like you are compelled to let them into your house if they have a warrant to search for something like drugs or guns or counterfeit plush toys.
However sometimes the courts do see it as a fifth amendment issue [1] and that has been under debate for a while. (As far as I can tell the legal theory is similar to the police not being able to compel you to tell them where you left the body in a capital crime.)
Disclaimer I am not a lawyer this isn't legal advice, and I've not followed up the cited case to see if it made it to the supreme court or not. Any circuit level decision would not be binding on different circuits.
[1] http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-9854034-38.html
Follow up on the Boucher case: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/United_States...
Where the fifth amendment defense was overturned.