IVF is not creating a completely new, engineered organism. Not really what I am talking about.
And man, the idea that religion has no place in the modern world would be laughable if it weren't so tragic. Religion serves a veokry important role in society and we abandon it at our peril.
I am sorry to hear about your friend, but this is really not comparable to engineering a new unique organism. And I'm sure her pain would be just as great or worse without a god in her life. Christians realize that there are trials in the world. Re: the book of Job.
> Religion serves a very important role in society and we abandon it at our peril.
What "important role" might that be? I don't see the necessity of religion and don't think there's anything inherent of religions that can't be supplemented by the surrounding culture.
With Christianity supposedly in decline, especially in tech, how will we replace it?
I HAVE seen the state fail to help after burning through millions in many places.
> I HAVE seen the state fail to help after burning through millions in many places.
Sure, but that's a red herring. It's fair to say both have a checkered past.
Religion and charity are voluntary. You can choose to donate to charities that will most effectively utilize your donations. You don't have that choice with a state, and the outcomes are not always good. Even in Democracies, the state social services are often such inefficient massively entrenched institutions that they are resistant to change.
Religions also serve as bulwarks against increasing state power. Depending on your perspective this could be a good thing or a bad thing, but I'm more concerned about the great harm an unrestrained state can inflict on the world than what good it may be able to do.
That's what I'm referring to, you'd donate to professionals, but would you do any of it yourself?
So, learn from europe and other social democratic states. Stop believe in the dogma of the invisible hand, and that what makes money is inherently good.
I don't see a use for religion other than to allow people to skirt their responsibility in having/maintaining a mature line of empathy.
Truly though, any sect of christianity that abuses non heteronarmative people or women is not living by the law of the bible.
I know this sounds like a "no true scotsman" fallacy but really, If you read the bible, 100% of awful christian behaviour is in spite of the bible, not inspired by it.
Almost all of the worst atrocities in history have be committed due to faith/some other non-logical idealism. In this way relgion does very little to create a "hard line that can't be crossed" in fact it's often used as the justification.
Empathy can be derived from logic and is sufficient for deriving modern morality.
I'm not saying all religion is bad, just that it doesn't have utility over and beyond logic. Logic is more than sufficient to establish all of the perceived benefits of religion with none of the inherent risks/downsides of organised religions.
My practical argument is not that it encodes generational wisdom, necessarily, but rather that it is a source of moral reasoning that lies external to pure logic, which sacrifices what is right for what is practical, or expedient, in many cases
IVF seems pretty un-natural...
It's not too clear what "completely new, engineered organism" line you're taking here.
but your friends may also consider this:
any suffering in this life is rewarded in the next life (the life after death)
god doesn't give us tests that we couldn't possibly pass.
if you are compassionate, i hope you won't ridicule your friends for their belief but try to help them come to terms with their situation using their own belief to strengthen them
I get that you’re framing this in a context that OPs friend might take solace in, but when you put it like that it just sounds like a cruel joke to me.
it just sounds like a cruel joke to me
what would be the alternative?
when anyone suffers, they need help to end that suffering, but also hope and encouragement that they will get through it, because some things just can't be fixed with material means.
if you look at this as if there is a god out there that goes: hmm, this family needs a test. how about i mess up their baby?
that would indeed be cruel. but that is not what i believe is happening. i don't know what that particular child suffers from, but by now we can explain many birth defects to some humans mistakenly or intentionally doing something wrong, like poisoning water with chemicals or malfunctioning nuclear reactors, or what not. i don't believe that any of these are pure acts of god. but they could all be prevented if humans as a whole were more diligent. (i don't mean that any individual could have done anything by themselves, but that as humanity we need to work together to avoid and remove things that cause people to suffer[1])
this is a consequence of free will. bad things happen, because if god were to prevent them, then we would not have free will.
nevertheless on an individual level god does promise that whatever suffering we experience is rewarded in the next life, and that we are all given the capacity to pass the tests that we experience and get through that suffering.
[1] that is in fact happening. we have eliminated many diseases and quality of life on average is improving globally. there is more work to be done, but we are getting there.
'God' does this all the time already. Friends of mine recently had a baby girl; she is missing part of one of her chromosomes. The family is very religious, and is being torn apart trying to understand how their 'loving God' could have done such a thing. So this 'morality' you speak of is making a tragic and difficult event far worse.
You are also neglecting the 'unnatural' processes that allow many worthy people have children via IVF.
'Natural' science and medicine had it's place back in medieval times, but not now. Same goes for religion.