It wouldn't surprise me if the amount that is being sequestered is being overestimated in many studies, but the mechanism for it happening is pretty clear and that it is happening is pretty incontrovertible - it falls right out of the chemical math - and I would be much more likely to question any study that questioned that than to question that mechanism itself.
It's really frustating to me that what is being posted here is basically just a headline and not even an abstract unless you have a subscription to Nature.
Most fossil fuel carbon was originally sequestered in a world where very few things could break down dead trees. That world is millions of years gone, current natural carbon sinks are 99% temporary.
You could really go whole-hog into attempting to maximize the amount of timber you can stuff into a house -- start building double-stud walls with 12 inch on-center spacing just to triple the number of 2x6's used, fall in love with giant cross-laminated timber panels, etc etc.
There does seem to be increasing interest though in making large structures out of wood, so maybe that's a pretty good route for carbon storage.
It's like when you eat, you do not turn your food in pure gas, do you? And then the excreted/remaining mass will be buried etc (and will partly be turned into earthworms, nematodes, bacteria, moss, fungi, etc).
A person breaths out about 2.3 lbs of CO2 each day, which amounts to 0.6 lbs of carbon, all of which must have come from your food.
Meanwhile, a person defecates about 1 lb per day, about 75% of which is water. Of the residue, about 25-50% of it is bacteria, and the remainder the undigested portion of your food. Bacteria is typically accounted 53% carbon; the undigested fats, carbohydrates and proteins will vary a lot in percentage, but is 40% carbon for carbohydrates, 50% for proteins, and "more" for fats.
Which leaves a lot of variance, but something like 0.15 lbs of carbon exiting at as a solid seems like a reasonable estimate.
So the answer would be: you turn about 80% of the carbon in your food into CO2 gas.
Here:
> While this process naturally releases CO2 through the respiration (or breathing) of microbes that break down dead organisms, some fraction of plant carbon can remain underground for decades or even centuries. Together, land plants and soils hold about 2,500 gigatonnes of carbon—about three times more than is held in the atmosphere.
This was the point I wanted to make, probably worded awkwardly.
But after reading several times your calculation, it seems legit. Thanks.
Then, as a conclusion, when you eat you delay 20% of your carbon footprint, and a fraction of these 20% may well be stored for a long duration (in sediments, or back into the food chain, etc).
Then again, similarly, the fallen leaves of trees may store a fraction of their carbon for a long duration.
And as anyone that's been to western England knows, it takes a single generation for it to all blow away and leave you with nothing but a barren heath that's good only for grazing sheep.
So for that mechanism to work, the ground level in old growth forests would slowly rise over the centuries, and more and more soil with some carbon content accumulates.
Is that what actually happens?
The napkin strategy is to grow fast woods, kiln them into charcoal, spread some of it on the forest as a soil amendment, spread the rest on agricultural land, repeat.
Elemental carbon weatherizes into CO2 very slowly, on the order of centuries, the half-life is more than a thousand years. So-called "biochar" (it's just charcoal) is an excellent soil amendment, mitigates topsoil depletion, supports good microbiomes, adsorbs fertilizers and releases them slowly, it's a big win. If we manage to do this on the necessary scale, we might eventually hit the point where adding more char to soil isn't worth it from an ecosystem health perspective, and then we can just put it into the various large holes we've dug into the earth to extract minerals. There is something very tidy about filling an old coal mine with synthetic coal!
Short-term, where short-term is around 70 to 100 years [1], seems just fine to me. It'll buy us time to develop better technology for carbon sequestration and clean energy.
In fact, the problem with planting trees might be the opposite -- trees don't reach their maximum rate of carbon sequestration for a couple of decades, and by then it might be too late.
[1] https://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/pdf2011/fpl_2011_lippke00...
What happens when a tree dies and turns into a house?
> it is short term, at best.
If the house stands for 100 years, then you've successfully sequestered said carbon for over 100 years (because only after then will the rotting process start). Even then, a lot of carbon turns into humus (which btw: we're also running out of Topsoil for our farms). So creating more carbon-rich humus as a topsoil replacement for our farms is ALSO a priority.
Since humus is the final product of the rotting process, I'd argue that the carbon-content of humus represents the "permanently sequestered" bits of the carbon. Which IIRC, is still a substantial portion of the weight of the tree.
There's also all the leaves that fell off the tree and turned into humus. Probably not as much by weight, but its quite possible that the leaves themselves allow the tree to sequester MORE than its weight in carbon.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4p-kQ6D8aA
Edit: Soil as carbon sink https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2018/02/21/can-soil-help-c...
If the forests of said trees are self -regenerating, it’s going to be a decent sink.
In which cases is it not? Other than short term carbon sink we get more trees, wild life gets more trees allowing it to flourish, we get wood for building material, dead trees become soil.
This way, startups proposing forestry as a solution for carbon capture would be able to present accurate results and figures.
Also, the decay of fallen trees is very slow, and is not 100% into carbon dioxide (the carbon will remain a very long time in the body of numerous plant and animal species), whereas the combustion for human use is complete and on a much smaller scale of time.
And when you think about it, this makes sense. Trees aren't constantly burying themselves in their own leaves. The roots of trees stay about the same depth year after year, and they're not growing new root systems higher up the trunk.
So you argument would be: why then do trees not bury themselves in humus?
I think that a fair part goes away with rain and water systems, and a small portion circulates in the form of mobile organisms.
There was a time in the Earth's history where this wasn't the case. During the carboniferous phase plant life didn't decay and biomatter piled up on the forest floor in miles-thick layers. The CO2 levels in the atmosphere dropped so low that the planet was verging on an iceball at times. The carbon balance was only maintained via enormous forest fires in the oxygen rich atmosphere.
See my previous comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26935290
It's "short term" because the plants will release the carbon back into the atmosphere in a few decades.
So to combat climate change we need ways to sequester the carbon that will keep it out of the atmosphere permanently. There are no good solutions for this currently. Maybe at some point someone will figure out a way to economically create massive pure diamonds using CO2 from the atmosphere with renewable energy so we could use them as building materials or something. Thanks to the laws of thermodynamics we'll have to invest something like all of the energy we produced using fossil fuels to fix this problem. We can cheat a bit by going to a stable form instead of making it straight up crude oil again, but it's still an almost unfathomable amount of energy we're going to need. And our politicians still arguing if it is a good idea to stop digging the hole, and fighting tooth and nail against it. There are no jobs on a dead planet.
The caveat to the above is the extent to which dead plant matter gets permanently buried (turned into peat or whatever) rather than rotting. Under some conditions, forests really will work as a carbon sink, but it has never been as simple as tree planting == good, and I am glad to see research acknowledging that. As with everything, it is complicated.