News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by DanielStraight on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:01PM (#2688645)
How do you deal with the inherent inefficiency of having a separate vehicle for every passenger (or small group of passengers)?

Publicness is not the only benefit of public transportation. Trains and buses are incredibly efficient per passenger mile. They also take up a lot less space than cars, and last longer and cost less per passenger to manufacture. Making a car driverless doesn't solve these problems.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by Cushman on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:19PM (#2688754)
The de facto standard in this country is one dedicated car per person, which spends 90% of its time sitting in a parking space. Communally shared cars will be massively more efficient than that, and, unlike buses and trains, will actually replace dedicated vehicles for a majority — some day 100% — of users.

The public transportation the public uses beats the one they don't.

Not to mention that communal vehicles would make electric cars suitable for any length of trip— Forget about exchanging batteries, just swap cars at the charging station.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by roc on Thursday June 23, 2011 @04:52PM (#2689831)
Communally shared cars would still have the problem that a large number of those personal cars are spending the same 90% of their time sitting in a parking space. Everyone's leaving for work at 8, leaving for lunch at noon and leaving for home at 5.

You'd still need roughly the same number of 'communal' cars during those peak times. Though people may be more likely to car-pool.

Even the trivial variation of most US 'flex time' starts wouldn't help much. The difference between 8 and 9 isn't great enough for very many cars to make it from a business park at 8 back out to pick up another passenger and then back to another employer before 9.

What might really help, is 'communal' cars augmenting the US's sparse transit system. e.g. The communal car takes you to the train/bus stop. A communal bus departs as soon as it can. The communal car takes you to your final destination.

That way the cars are doing shorter round-trips, serving more people (necessitating fewer cars) and people are more apt to use the public transport because they aren't worried about the current big problems of US transit: 1. parking at the transit stop 2. how to get from the transit destination to where they really want to go 3. what happens if you miss the train/bus time (the car can just complete the trip)

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by Cushman on Thursday June 23, 2011 @09:15PM (#2690570)
That's true currently— but I think you're neglecting the possibility that widespread use of robotic cars could effectively eliminate rush hour. If that hour and a half commute starts taking the twenty minutes it should, two hours is time for a bunch of round trips.

Of course there will be some limit to capacity, as with any public transportation. But having to wait a bit for a car isn't going to put off commuters who are used to spending hours a day waiting in traffic.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by varjag on Friday June 24, 2011 @07:28AM (#2691793)
That's not even mentioning you can actually do useful stuff sitting as a passenger during the commute.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by spoold on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:36PM (#2688851)
"The de facto standard in this country"

Which country? It's a global problem (and this is a global forum). Kudos to Nevada for having the presence and foresight to pass this legislation. It opens up a world of possibilities for future transport options, and whilst it will take a while for the public to catch up and accept both the technology, and the transport changes it enables, this is a huge step in the right direction.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by Cushman on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:16PM (#2689112)
What country is Nevada in?

I'm not blind to the existence of transportation issues in other countries, but insufficient (read "nonexistent") public transportation is often noted as a predominantly (while not uniquely) American problem. Certainly we represent the archetype of the "one car per person" catastrophe.

The emergence of communal, computer-controlled electric vehicles could turn that around completely, so I don't think it's too out of line to be talking primarily about America at this stage.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by spoold on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:35PM (#2689215)
"What country is Nevada in?"

Spain for one. I know which Nevada the legislation was passed in, but your comment made the implicit assumption that everyone reading it is in the US.

"insufficient (read "nonexistent") public transportation is often noted as a predominantly (while not uniquely) American problem"

As is egocentrism.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by Cushman on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:51PM (#2689291)
What are you talking about? There's no Nevada in Spain, GA. (Wait a minute... Oh. Gotcha.)

Seriously, though. "This country", as in, the country where I live, which is coincidentally the same one under discussion. You can relax a little with the righteous indignation.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by dkokelley on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:13PM (#2688713)
Theoretically, driverless cars could be programmed to behave in a collective fashion. Yes, a train is incredibly efficient when 300 people need to go from the same place to a different place. But in reality, 300 people are coming from 300 places and going 300 places. Driverless cars could calculate partial carpools or transfers to more efficient vehicles like trains depending on the needs of the commuters. A "smart car" could drop the commuter(s) off at the train station, and another car could pick the commuter(s) up for the final leg of their trip.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by graywh on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:22PM (#2688775)
This.

A few weeks ago, I left my house for the grocery 2 miles away. I followed a car from my subdivision to the grocery. After shopping, I followed the same car back from the grocery to my subdivision.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by groby_b on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:05PM (#2689043)
Of course, this points out a failure in public engineering, not the need for automated cars. (As much as I'd love to have them)

Urban sprawl is a gigantic problem that we need to address, and soon. It not only affects transportation - there's general maintenance cost, social effects, land use, etc.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by melling on Thursday June 23, 2011 @07:04PM (#2690299)
A car can't leave the station traveling west at 220 mph arriving at its destination in 30 minutes. Driverless cars will be great but we also need fast, efficient ways to move people too. I want mine to pick me up at the station when my train arrives.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by billybob on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:06PM (#2689048)
More likely, driverless cars will be programmed to make really, really long commutes.

How far would you be willing to commute right now? OK, what if you could sleep or play videogames en route?

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by dkokelley on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:10PM (#2689072)
I commute about 1:15:00 each way, each day. I carpool, so I can read my iPad for two hours a day. It certainly helps with the drive time.

But you can do the same on a train or bus already. I think part of why people don't use them as much is because of the inconvenience of working around their schedule, and first and last mile commutes (because the train doesn't go to your office). Networked, driverless cars could play a part in the larger public transport system to alleviate these two points of pain of commuters.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by checker on Thursday June 23, 2011 @03:49PM (#2689555)
Rush hour crowding on public transport is a big negative. If we embraced more flexible work hours, it would bring about its own efficiencies.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by bdhe on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:10PM (#2688694)
A country like the US, especially with vast suburban areas, it isn't necessarily a strict dichotomy between public transport and driverless cars. We can have both.

Especially in the west coast, American cities were built to be navigated by cars. Even today, the very fact that carpool lanes in most parts of California are designated for 2 people/car, not 3 implies we already have separate vehicles for each passenger. If we can take advantage of the road infrastructure and cut down on the need to own a car, it will be a huge benefit to lots of people. See how popular ZipCar is, precisely because of this sort of benefit.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by erikpukinskis on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:33PM (#2688838)
Google Transit already offers you choices when you want to go from A to B. It could do the same thing with driverless cars. Want to take one the whole way? That'll be 60 minutes and cost $12.50. Or you can can take the driverless car to the train, which will take you the rest of the way. $7.50, and takes 1h20 minutes.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by mkr-hn on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:38PM (#2688867)
I know someone who spent some time in one of Japan's smaller prefectures. He hated how all the trains stopped promptly at midnight, making late night things impossible. Something like this would let you take a train there and an automatic car back.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by checker on Thursday June 23, 2011 @03:51PM (#2689563)
This will definitely benefit bars. I would love to see drunk driving become a thing of the past at some point in my lifetime.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by mkr-hn on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:09PM (#2688687)
I think of this more as dealing with the present (and unpleasant) reality. I prefer buses and trains, but we haven't found a way to get people to fund and use them enough to make them viable outside big cities.

A lot of the gridlock in my city comes from people doing stupid things that force other drivers to slow down to avoid a wreck. Automated cars would reduce the impact of bad drivers by removing them from the equation.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by pavel_lishin on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:06PM (#2688677)
It wouldn't necessarily have to be the only public transit option. In New York, I can get to work by train much faster than by car - but if I need to go to, say, Ikea, it's two trains and a bus. A cheap, public car would be great.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by DanielStraight on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:09PM (#2688685)
I agree completely. I don't necessary think it's a bad idea, I just don't think it's a good idea "instead of big trains and buses."
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by afterburner on Thursday June 23, 2011 @02:06PM (#2689050)
I've always thought it would be neat to combine the public transport with the public car idea. Have parking lots full of public cars available at the station stops (and really big ones at the end of the subway line).

You'll have to be able to keep one of these public cars at your place overnight for it to work (unless it drives itself home empty!).

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by presidentender on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:45PM (#2688916)
More accurately, trains and buses can be incredibly efficient per passenger mile.

Anecdotes are not data, but our local buses (city of ~50k) rarely have more than one rider, and a plurality of those I see have zero riders. In our case, these autonomous cars would be a much more efficient solution.

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by InnocentB on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:50PM (#2688952)
"More efficient than a bus system nobody uses" is a pretty low bar. In your city's case, shutting down the bus system and having everyone currently riding the bus take (potentially subsidized) taxis would be way more efficient, both environmentally and financially.
Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by cma on Thursday June 23, 2011 @03:20PM (#2689409)
There isn't that much inherit inefficiency; if the cars are smart they can drive in a train configuration, imagine this without the mechanical linkages:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_train

Re:Nevada passes law authorizing driverless cars by rmc on Thursday June 23, 2011 @01:51PM (#2688960)
But people don't use them that much! In theory trains and buses are more effecient, but since they aren't used that much, that means people don't care about that.