News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by optimiz3 on Monday April 19, 2021 @09:57AM (#26862801)
Banks shouldn't be put in the position of public policy making. If society thinks certain activities are desired/undesired, this can be accomplished via taxes and regulations. Financial cancel culture is a road to hell laid with good intentions.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by MereInterest on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:03AM (#26862862)
Except then people come out of the woodwork to say that government shouldn't be legislating morals, and that if it's really an issue investors would avoid investing in funds they find immoral. Which is exactly what's happening here.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:28AM (#26863810)
Why is that a problem?

If there's not sufficient voter support for legislating morals then democracies shouldn't be legislating morals. The voters should get what they want even if it's stupid.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by MereInterest on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @10:21AM (#26875037)
I wasn't trying to imply that there was. More that any push toward long-term stability gets a ridiculous amount of pushback on the methods. If it is done through legislation, the free-market libertarians come out in droves to say "No! Let the market decide!" If it is done through market forces, the free-market libertarians come out in droves to say "No! The market should be amoral and profit-oriented! Let legislation decide!"

I recognize that these may be entirely separate subsets of free-market libertarians, but it's enough to make me grow frustrated at the entire group.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by bradleyjg on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:12AM (#26862952)
The right answers are leaf nodes—-either voters or consumers. If consumers act, intermediary institutions like banks will naturally follow. Ditto if the laws change.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by nullspace on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:22AM (#26863043)
I think it’s kinda weird that you exclude investors out of the leaf node, which is what is happening here.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by bradleyjg on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:35AM (#26863183)
The big investors in this case are themselves intermediary institutions.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by fakedang on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:24AM (#26863054)
Except in this case, consumers can't act. Can consumers vote with their wallets to prevent using technologies that are excessively polluting, say a necessary chemical which they use only indirectly, one that has a polluting manufacturing process? Can poorer car buyers opt for any thing cheaper than the currently available options? Or rather, because there are no options available for them, should they simply not use cars instead of using the polluting gasoline cars?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by bradleyjg on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:36AM (#26863196)
Should that choice be taken out of their hands by non-elected intermediary institutions? Because that’s what’s going on here.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:55PM (#26864999)
> choice be taken out of their hands by non-elected intermediary institutions

Why can't they go to a different bank if they feel so strongly about it?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by fakedang on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:25AM (#26863778)
There wasn't even much of a choice in the first place.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gruez on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:15PM (#26864436)
>Except in this case, consumers can't act. Can consumers vote with their wallets to prevent using technologies that are excessively polluting, say a necessary chemical which they use only indirectly, one that has a polluting manufacturing process?

Pesticides are a necessary chemical to industrial food production. Consumers can opt to prevent that from being used/manufactured by buying organic[1]. Organic goods are widely available in US supermarkets. The fact that organics haven't outpaced conventional foods tells you all you need to know about consumer preferences.

>Can poorer car buyers opt for any thing cheaper than the currently available options? Or rather, because there are no options available for them, should they simply not use cars instead of using the polluting gasoline cars?

So according to you, poor car buyers are forced to choose between a gas guzzler or no car at all, because the fuel efficient cars are too expensive. Clearly the right thing to do is... stop gas guzzlers from manufactured in the first place so they're forced to not have a car?

[1] organic allows certain kinds of "natural" pesticides, which might or might not be worse than their banned counterparts, but this is another can of worms

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:44PM (#26864839)
> Clearly the right thing to do is... stop gas guzzlers from manufactured in the first place so they're forced to not have a car?

Or tax gas guzzlers more? Provide tax incentives for fuel-efficient and electric cars? Both?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by bradleyjg on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:31PM (#26865555)
Both of those are things elected governments can, and maybe should, do. But what the article is talking about is having banks refuse to do business with e.g. Ford unless it stops making gasoline cars. This does nothing to help the poor but environmentally conscious person. It simply removes a (perhaps non-ideal) option that currently exists.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:20PM (#26867520)
> Both of those are things elected governments can, and maybe should, do.

Agreed. And what banks do has (or should have) little bearing on that.

> This does nothing to help the poor but environmentally conscious person.

That's debatable.* But in any case, banks aren't charities. Modern capitalism holds that they have no obligation to anyone except their shareholders.

*For actually "poor" people, car ownership is a burden. They have to pay high interest rates and tie up a significant portion of their capital just to get around. Whereas most developed countries (and even a great many developing countries) have efficient public transportation, which doesn't have these downsides for poor people. Also the poor have more to lose from climate change, so arguably these banks are serving them better in the long-term by divesting from carbon.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by bradleyjg on Monday April 19, 2021 @05:38PM (#26868235)
If I say action X hurts the poor and you say if we lived in an entirely different society then action X wouldn’t hurt the poor, have we actually disagreed?

—-

For the other part I agree companies aren’t charities. My entire point here is that people should quit trying to pressure them into acting like charities. Let companies make money, that’s what they are good at. If you want to eliminate ICE engines pass a law.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:17PM (#26869321)
> people should quit trying to pressure them into acting like charities

You keep saying "pressure" as if it's a magic word. How can you pressure a business to do something against what it believes to be its own (or its shareholders') interest? All kinds of people lobby companies and government to do literally everything under the sun. Companies don't listen to all of them. They only listen to the ones they think are good for them. And if they choose wrong, the market will punish them. Right?

On a separate note "companies shouldn't be woke" people also tend to be among the most ardent worshippers of the free market. Somehow their faith is shaken when companies do something they personally disagree with - then they fall back to "they're just giving in to activist pressure". I'm not saying you're like that. Just pointing out the irony.

Re: more expensive cars hurting the poor in North America, I'm honestly skeptical. If anything more expensive cars will be a forcing function towards developing more affordable housing close to work and better public transportation systems. Kind of an inverse Jevon's paradox. This will save the poor money in the long term.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:54PM (#26864986)
Consumers and investors are free to find different banks if they disagree with these policies. These banks believe this is what their customers actually want them to do.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:30AM (#26863137)
How is this different than a bank denying a loan to someone with bad credit? Giving money to polluters is financially risky, because they destabilize the economy and shrink your customer pool.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:39AM (#26863224)
Because they don't have bad credit. This is more similar to how some banks reuse service to pornstars. If banks are making decisions for non financial reasons that seems problematic to me.

If they really see it as a risky investment, that's fine.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:20AM (#26863717)
I can only find news articles about this, not a release from IIGCC itself, but financial risk is clearly at least part of their rationale:

> Bruce Duguid, head of stewardship at Federated Hermes’ EOS division, said there was a need for “dramatic shifts” in bank financing in order to meet the Paris goals and “avoid the looming systemic risk of a ‘carbon crunch’ hitting their balance sheets”.

It seems pretty straightforward that investing in something that violates a global UN agreement is not a financially sound decision.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:46PM (#26864853)
> If they really see it as a risky investment, that's fine.

Climate change threatens to devastate hundreds of millions of lives. It will disrupt the global economy for decades. So, yes, fossil fuels are a risky investment.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:46PM (#26866496)
We're not talking about that kind of risk to humanity here. We're talking specifically financial risk to the bank.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:49PM (#26866537)
The financial well-being of banks is inextricably tied to the financial well-being of their human customers and employees. Until they can find a new species to take over, "risk to humanity" is relevant.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:48PM (#26869526)
Not to the bank. The bank's actions won't make one iota of difference either way to climate change. All the banks acting together could - but each individual bank, much like each individual person can do nothing that will matter. It's a tragedy of the commons. So it's not an actual risk to the bank acting alone in its own interest - despite the fact that the risk to humanity as a whole is very real.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @06:15PM (#26882574)
> The bank's actions won't make one iota of difference either way to climate change

How do you know these banks aren't betting that being seen as climate-friendly will make them more attractive to customers and investors? And thereby increase pressure on competitor banks that aren't similarly climate-friendly to follow suit? This would result in the type of coordinated action that actually can make a difference to climate change at a macro level. Mission accomplished.

At the end of the day banks are businesses doing what they feel is right for themselves. If you disagree with how they run their business, you should divest yourself from them and end your business relationship with them.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:06AM (#26875670)
I disagree, climate change is not an on/off switch. There is a spectrum of possibilities, and marginal changes can have marginal effects.

Of course group action is more meaningful, and that's why this group of investors is pressuring a group of banks.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:23AM (#26875906)
> There is a spectrum of possibilities, and marginal changes can have marginal effects.

That marginal effect is exactly that, marginal. It makes as much difference as adding a single drop of water to the ocean. If you're doing a risk calculation, which is what we're talking about - not a moral calculation - then adding zero to any term in the calculation doesn't change the result.

I know where you're coming from, your heart is in the right place, but your mathematically wrong here.

> Of course group action is more meaningful, and that's why this group of investors is pressuring a group of banks.

That's the only way it can work. I wish them luck.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gremlinsinc on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:34PM (#26869071)
How does the bank profit if all shareholders, board, CEO, and their progenity are wiped out by the end of mankind? Seems money REaLLY becomes worthless at that point.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:49PM (#26869543)
Climate change is not the end of mankind. Your point is valid without the hyperbole, but see my comment above for why it doesn't necessarily matter to the bank.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:24PM (#26867556)
The global economy tanking due to climate-driven catastrophes isn't a financial risk to the bank? Why not?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by ForHackernews on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:59AM (#26864245)
What about refusing service to marijuana businesses? There's both a real and perceived regulatory and reputational risk in giving money to these types of companies.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by elliekelly on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:35PM (#26865619)
That’s a bit different because, for now at least, a bank knowingly doing business with a marijuana company violates BSA and AML regulations. The adult entertainment industry is also frequently refused banking services by citing the same laws and regulations but those aren’t flat-out prohibited where marijuana is because it’s a criminal enterprise in the eyes of the federal government.

Funds coming from adult entertainment are (1) high risk (in theory) for being proceeds from a crime (prostitution) and (2) high risk for money laundering because those businesses are often high cash or cash-only.

You can see how designating a business as #1 necessarily creates the situation that gives rise to #2 and so it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy: the business is high risk because it’s high risk.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:25AM (#26863786)
I think the banks are far more worried about medium term "the government de-facto prohibits the business your customer is engaged in and they go bankrupt en-mass" than long term climate driven macroeconomic problems.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:32AM (#26863888)
Agreed, should have mentioned that too, and these investors do seem to be focused on meeting Paris Agreement commitments.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by elliekelly on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:07AM (#26862898)
I don’t disagree but money is speech and corporations are people so why wouldn’t banks and their investors flex their enormous spending power to influence public policy? Banks aren’t victims “put” in this position - they’re largely the beneficiaries of it.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by belorn on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:24AM (#26863061)
On that note, society should really stop subsidizing fossil fueled power production. Any action that the financial industry do has limited power if government simply gives the biggest carbon emission players more money in order for them to continue emitting carbon in the name of stable and cheap energy.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by mistrial9 on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:28AM (#26863108)
there is a middle ground in the Western finance system -- willing participants declare themselves and band together with market positioning and customer information.

Agree here that soft-rules to exclude finance will cause a lot of negative results, expected and otherwise.

People that complain finance will not voluntarily comply are right, most finance activity specifically and actively "does not care" and this also must be exposed publicly. Sunlight is a strong disinfectant.

ps- per piketty [0] the finance system is currently self-perpetuating, no longer solely an expression of real value. Humans are proven dangerous, so, take care with "laws"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_in_the_Twenty-First_Ce...

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by Analemma_ on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:02AM (#26862858)
Climate change from burning fossil fuels is also a road to hell laid with good intentions. Have you done the cost-benefit analysis on which is worse?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gremlinsinc on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:31PM (#26869043)
This is literally the path that capitalism laid out.

Either you're for or against the system. Capitalism's end game was not to be counted a citizen but to become the oligarchy. Congress has a lot of power but only what the people give them, well the people have lost most of their voice/power so now congress is fueled by the power that money can buy from the companies that fund them.

Thus it is we've entered late-stage capitalism. The federal government won't ever do anything about it as long as they're allowed to control congress by the wallet.

Short-term as myself a libertarian-socialist I see this as a positive - because the alternative is lots of death from climate change...

Long-term as a libertarian-socialist, I see this as a scary power grab by corporations. In some movies/shows/books you see companies that govern and have whole worlds and solar systems named after them.

When you take away regulations, when you move to allow companies total freedom to do whatever you want you have to be willing to take the consequences of whatever those freedoms bring, whether that's polluting the water supply or encouraging MLB to pull out of Georgia over voter rights.

You can't have your cake and eat it too!

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by Gadiguibou on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:25PM (#26864578)
I don't think that's really what's happening here.

Banks have been choosing who they fund and who they don't for a while and it hasn't really been decried so far. This only highlights that we live in a society that is both democratic AND capitalist: decision making power is distributed, on the one hand, "equally" to each citizen via voting rights, and, on the other hand, to whomever holds the most capital.

You could even argue that the proportion of the power that goes to capitalists is inversely proportional to the amount of state actions in the form of redistributive policies, market legislation, etc.

Once you take this into consideration, your initial observation doesn't reflect a new financial "cancel culture". Rather it reflects how much of the decision making power is now in the hands of capitalists in the US.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:43PM (#26864818)
Banks are doing what they believe their customers and investors want them to do. If they're wrong, they'll lose market share and profits to banks that don't do this. It's not cancel culture, it's capitalism.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by ForHackernews on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:05AM (#26862877)
They already are: Banks fund certain things and don't fund others. There's no 'neutral' choice on offer here.

I'd much rather banks and investors were explicit and public about the values driving their choices.

If your hypothesis is right that the big banks are leaving money on the table, I'm sure somebody will start a tobacco/child labour/fossil fuels ETF investors can buy if they can stomach it.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by fakedang on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:25AM (#26863069)
> If your hypothesis is right that the big banks are leaving money on the table, I'm sure somebody will start a tobacco/child labour/fossil fuels ETF investors can buy if they can stomach it.

The optics of such a nonsense ETF would itself drive investors away. Like seriously?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by tzs on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:07AM (#26863539)
Tobacco companies and fossil fuel companies have no trouble finding investors, so it doesn't seem all that nonsensical that an ETF based on those industries would have no trouble getting investors.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by thinkcontext on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:05PM (#26865148)
The existence of several vice ETF's undermines your thesis.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by nickelcitymario on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:14AM (#26862963)
Every person and institution has a right to decide what things they're willing to support with their money. That's why we have the expression "voting with your wallet".

If a bank decides not to invest in some given company or sector, that's not "public policy making". That's just the bank exercising their right to decide where to put their money. Indeed, they can't do anything less. Whether they invest or not, they are making a decision that has social impacts.

If the bank instead paid lobbyists to persuade politicians to create new rules (and I'm sure they do), that would be closer to "public policy making".

Also, this concept of "cancel culture" is absurd. People and companies have always risked falling from public grace if they say or do things that go against the values of the majority of the public.

Was it "cancel culture" when Studio 54 got shut down? Or when Tim Leary got fired from Harvard? Or when Ellen's sitcom got cancelled?

Right or wrong, each was merely the result of going against the grain. Today, the cultural middle has shifted, and so some groups are finding themselves in a position they're unaccustomed to: being in the minority. (Or more accurately: not being _consistently_ in the majority.)

But the consequences are no different than those faced by any minority, and this is healthy for society. It's never a good thing when one group has so much social leverage that they get to dictate the terms for everybody else. I would argue that today, there's no such thing as a majority group. We're all minorities to varying degrees, and we all need to learn how to get along. I think that's a net positive, albeit a very messy one.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by BitwiseFool on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:21AM (#26863027)
There is a big difference between an individual "voting with their wallet" and foundational institutions like banks pursuing activist policies.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by nickelcitymario on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:42AM (#26864021)
Is there? Institutions are just organized groups of individuals. Is the difference that one is more effective than the other?

Also, why does THIS count as an activist policy, and not literally everything else banks have ever done?

There's no such thing as a neutral way to invest money. Every investment sends money towards one group and away from another. We give control of our money to banks with the trust that they are being intentional about how to use it.

Why is this an "activist policy" more than anything else?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by Pfhreak on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:23AM (#26863761)
You've labeled this an "activist policy", but it seems to me that label actually means "a policy I personally disagree with."

If banks decided to invest in carbon producing companies, is that an activist policy? What about if they invest in US companies? Or invest in developing countries?

What makes this (avoiding investments in polluting firms) activist investing while the opposite isn't in your view. Seems hypocritical.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by cortesoft on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:49AM (#26863337)
But how is this different than any other investment choice they make trying to maximize their profits? Investors and banks are looking at the data and thinking, “if we don’t do something about climate change, it will really hurt our long term profits”, so they use their power to prevent the thing that will lower their profits.

Isn’t that what a corporation is supposed to do?

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by BitwiseFool on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:23AM (#26863765)
For some corporations, yes, that is what they are supposed to do. However I make a distinction when it comes to the size of the company and the type of service they provide. There are some businesses and industries that I believe need to act like impartial utilities. Banking is one such sector.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by nickelcitymario on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:45AM (#26864064)
There's no such thing as an impartial utility. Every move impacts some groups positively and others negatively.

You might be able to argue for the existence of a naive utility, one that doesn't bother being aware of the impacts of its investments. But that seems kinda silly in my books.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by admax88q on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:20PM (#26864506)
If banking is a utility, are they required to invest in anyone who asks?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:47PM (#26864874)
So then you also oppose banks being able to lobby politicians? Fund political campaigns? That's also "activist", right?

Should they stop advertising too? Advertising also has a viewpoint, after all.