News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:30AM (#26863137)
How is this different than a bank denying a loan to someone with bad credit? Giving money to polluters is financially risky, because they destabilize the economy and shrink your customer pool.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @10:39AM (#26863224)
Because they don't have bad credit. This is more similar to how some banks reuse service to pornstars. If banks are making decisions for non financial reasons that seems problematic to me.

If they really see it as a risky investment, that's fine.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:20AM (#26863717)
I can only find news articles about this, not a release from IIGCC itself, but financial risk is clearly at least part of their rationale:

> Bruce Duguid, head of stewardship at Federated Hermes’ EOS division, said there was a need for “dramatic shifts” in bank financing in order to meet the Paris goals and “avoid the looming systemic risk of a ‘carbon crunch’ hitting their balance sheets”.

It seems pretty straightforward that investing in something that violates a global UN agreement is not a financially sound decision.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:46PM (#26864853)
> If they really see it as a risky investment, that's fine.

Climate change threatens to devastate hundreds of millions of lives. It will disrupt the global economy for decades. So, yes, fossil fuels are a risky investment.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:46PM (#26866496)
We're not talking about that kind of risk to humanity here. We're talking specifically financial risk to the bank.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:49PM (#26866537)
The financial well-being of banks is inextricably tied to the financial well-being of their human customers and employees. Until they can find a new species to take over, "risk to humanity" is relevant.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:48PM (#26869526)
Not to the bank. The bank's actions won't make one iota of difference either way to climate change. All the banks acting together could - but each individual bank, much like each individual person can do nothing that will matter. It's a tragedy of the commons. So it's not an actual risk to the bank acting alone in its own interest - despite the fact that the risk to humanity as a whole is very real.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @06:15PM (#26882574)
> The bank's actions won't make one iota of difference either way to climate change

How do you know these banks aren't betting that being seen as climate-friendly will make them more attractive to customers and investors? And thereby increase pressure on competitor banks that aren't similarly climate-friendly to follow suit? This would result in the type of coordinated action that actually can make a difference to climate change at a macro level. Mission accomplished.

At the end of the day banks are businesses doing what they feel is right for themselves. If you disagree with how they run their business, you should divest yourself from them and end your business relationship with them.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:06AM (#26875670)
I disagree, climate change is not an on/off switch. There is a spectrum of possibilities, and marginal changes can have marginal effects.

Of course group action is more meaningful, and that's why this group of investors is pressuring a group of banks.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @11:23AM (#26875906)
> There is a spectrum of possibilities, and marginal changes can have marginal effects.

That marginal effect is exactly that, marginal. It makes as much difference as adding a single drop of water to the ocean. If you're doing a risk calculation, which is what we're talking about - not a moral calculation - then adding zero to any term in the calculation doesn't change the result.

I know where you're coming from, your heart is in the right place, but your mathematically wrong here.

> Of course group action is more meaningful, and that's why this group of investors is pressuring a group of banks.

That's the only way it can work. I wish them luck.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by gremlinsinc on Monday April 19, 2021 @07:34PM (#26869071)
How does the bank profit if all shareholders, board, CEO, and their progenity are wiped out by the end of mankind? Seems money REaLLY becomes worthless at that point.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by eloff on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:49PM (#26869543)
Climate change is not the end of mankind. Your point is valid without the hyperbole, but see my comment above for why it doesn't necessarily matter to the bank.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by triceratops on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:24PM (#26867556)
The global economy tanking due to climate-driven catastrophes isn't a financial risk to the bank? Why not?
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by ForHackernews on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:59AM (#26864245)
What about refusing service to marijuana businesses? There's both a real and perceived regulatory and reputational risk in giving money to these types of companies.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by elliekelly on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:35PM (#26865619)
That’s a bit different because, for now at least, a bank knowingly doing business with a marijuana company violates BSA and AML regulations. The adult entertainment industry is also frequently refused banking services by citing the same laws and regulations but those aren’t flat-out prohibited where marijuana is because it’s a criminal enterprise in the eyes of the federal government.

Funds coming from adult entertainment are (1) high risk (in theory) for being proceeds from a crime (prostitution) and (2) high risk for money laundering because those businesses are often high cash or cash-only.

You can see how designating a business as #1 necessarily creates the situation that gives rise to #2 and so it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy: the business is high risk because it’s high risk.

Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:25AM (#26863786)
I think the banks are far more worried about medium term "the government de-facto prohibits the business your customer is engaged in and they go bankrupt en-mass" than long term climate driven macroeconomic problems.
Re:Coalition of big investors pushes banks to defund carbon ... by burkaman on Monday April 19, 2021 @11:32AM (#26863888)
Agreed, should have mentioned that too, and these investors do seem to be focused on meeting Paris Agreement commitments.