News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by throwastrike on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:41PM (#26823698)
I strongly believe this is going to allow Intel to make a dramatic comeback. It will buy them enough time to catch up while everyone is stuck buying Intel still as a result of supply constraint.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by ajross on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:45PM (#26823766)
That seems unlikely, for the same reason that TSMC isn't able to put Intel down permanently. We're reaching the end of silicon scaling. Transistor densities might continue to rise with 3D techniques, etc... but the actual logic is reaching physical limits. So transistors per price and per power are hitting walls.

TSMC pulled ahead, but they don't have a lot of runway to pull far ahead. Likewise Intel can catch up, but they can't retake the kind of lead they had a decade ago.

Semiconductors are turning into commodities, basically.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by doikor on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:03PM (#26824036)
> We're reaching the end of silicon scaling.

For the next 2 shrinks at least TSMC disagrees.

According to roadmap of TSMC they are roling out 3nm risk production this year and they built a new research lab for 2nm last year and already picked a site for the new 2nm fab (Hsinchu, Taiwan). Beyond that I don't think anyone has any real plans (yet).

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by tedunangst on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#26824236)
I think the question is if anyone is going to refuse a 5nm product because 3nm is available.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by Miraste on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:52PM (#26824678)
Maybe not, but they might start refusing 14nm products.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by nine_k on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:06PM (#26828552)
Not car makers, I suppose.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by LdSGSgvupDV on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:45AM (#26829987)
Probably, Apple, AMD, and NVIDIA would pay for 3nm instead of 5nm. Apple may be the first one to use 3nm. If it gets lots of gain, there would be lots of followers.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by codezero on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:00PM (#26825438)
A valuable and strategic commodity I'd add.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by throwastrike on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:17PM (#26824220)
That’s an interesting take. I feel the chip space is driven by marketing a bit too much. At the data center level I don’t believe the performance difference is as dramatic in practical terms. For the most part, you’re not missing out that much by going Intel unless you are working on something time critical.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dvdkon on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:46PM (#26825288)
If we're talking AMD vs Intel, then the biggest difference I see is cost (when the CPUs are in stock, anyway). Intel's performance is fine, but the CPUs can cost multiple times that of the competition. With Xeon, a small municipality would never be able to say "You know what? Just go with the 32-core CPU, it's not that much more."
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by chasil on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:57PM (#26826018)
I would prefer a 2-core CPU, when Oracle Enterprise Databases run around $24k/core after discount, and SQL Server Enterprise runs around $15k/core.

From single-core performance and low core count, Intel appears to be the better choice.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by smegger001 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:29PM (#26827452)
not a DB guy so excuse my ignorance but at that price per core wouldn't it be more cost effective to hire a few more admins and buy more cores and use something like postgress or MariaDB?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by ajross on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:39PM (#26827961)
Because to non-technical businesses hiring competent database architects is a lot more expensive than buying an Oracle support contract.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by rblatz on Friday April 16, 2021 @02:39AM (#26830382)
These are likely systems originally built when the database was the application. So everything in stored procedures and shared across hundreds of individual jobs/apps/reports.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by chasil on Friday April 16, 2021 @11:43AM (#26835272)
My Oracle Enterprise databases were installed in the late 90s, and lots of systems that I support have grown around them.

I've raised the question of the Enterprise DB version of Postgres (because of the PL/SQL emulation, which would certainly be needed). Even this change would be a large engineering effort.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by cardy31 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:44PM (#26823750)
Intel seems to be multiple years behind at this point. They might make a bit of a comeback, but it would have to be a huge process size shrink to be competitive. Based on their previous years, I doubt that an extra year will help that much.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by axaxs on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:42PM (#26825878)
Behind on...what? Against the latest and greatest Apple or AMD? Maybe. I'd probably put it at a generation at most.

That aside, there's a -huge- market for chips that aren't the latest and greatest. Intel expanding into that, which if I read right is what they're doing, could be a huge moneymaker.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by dannyw on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:04PM (#26824053)
Intel is shipping 10nm superfin (I'm typing this on a Tiger Lake NUC). Density wise, this is comparable to TSMC 7nm (used by AMD).
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by adrian_b on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:26PM (#26825062)
While Intel 10 nm SuperFin might be comparable in density with TSMC 7 nm, it definitely is much worse for the yields of chips with large area.

Six years ago, in 2015, Intel had no problems to introduce the smaller Skylake U and the larger Skylake H at the same time.

Now, Intel needs more than half of year to increase the yields of 10 nm SuperFin enough to be able to introduce the larger Tiger Lake H after the smaller Tiger Lake U introduced last year.

This happens even if now the area difference between Tiger Lake H and Tiger Lake U is not so great as in the previous generations, because a good part of the twice larger CPU is compensated by the 3 times smaller GPU.

On the other hand, the previous variant of the Intel 10 nm process (non-SuperFin), which is still used for Ice Lake Server, has much worse electrical properties than the TSMC 7 nm, because at the same number of active cores and the same power consumption AMD Epyc 7xx3 can have a clock frequency up to 50% higher.

Moreover, the similar density of the Intel process means absolutely nothing when the competition using the TSMC process can deliver a more than 3 times greater L3 cache memory at the same price and in the same package size.

The density does not have any importance if you cannot deliver more transistors in a given package, because you cannot manufacture large enough chips and because you have been unable to predict that you will never be able to manufacture large enough chips, so that you should have designed from the beginning your product as multi-chip.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by philliphaydon on Friday April 16, 2021 @01:49AM (#26830017)
Why does everyone make this excuse for Intel? It really sounds like fanboyism. Not trying to offend.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by totalZero on Friday April 16, 2021 @05:28AM (#26831601)
Is it an excuse, or a fact?
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by freedomben on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:49PM (#26823831)
anecdotally two friends of mine wanted AMD but bought Intel because of availability. You may be right.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by ngngngng on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:09PM (#26824116)
That's just because no one wants Intel at the moment.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by tedunangst on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:21PM (#26824278)
Intel still gets paid even if the people buying their CPUs don't want them.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by throwastrike on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:22PM (#26824288)
I could get away with using my old 2013 Macbook Pro for 90% of my computing needs. I could run the rest in the cloud. Sure I have the latest AMD and I know the headline numbers but I wouldn’t be able to tell you that consumer chips improved all that much in the past few years purely from a practical pov.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by totalZero on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:25PM (#26825040)
Same here, but that last 10% of computing needs can complicate things.

Try running two 4k external monitors on a Haswell MBP.

They look about the same, but a Haswell MBP13 (Late 2013) is very much less capable than an Ice Lake MBP13 (2020). Not all of that difference is attributable to the CPU I suppose, but the graphics and thermal throttling under load certainly are.

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by KptMarchewa on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:12PM (#26825558)
Even 2019 i9 MBP can't do that without extreme overheating and throttling, measured with pmset -g thermlog.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by narrator on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:49PM (#26823830)
Intel has been trying to get their 5nm fab process right for sometime now. So far, they have not been able to make it work. This is not software. It's physics. It's chemistry. It's material science. These are very hard problems to solve and there's currently only one company that can do it and their machines cost $200 million dollars and have a several year backlog of orders.
Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by mschuster91 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @02:24PM (#26824323)
> there's currently only one company that can do it and their machines cost $200 million dollars and have a several year backlog of orders.

ASML has a market cap of 223 billion $, and their stock value has doubled in a year. That's a lot of growth...

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by agloeregrets on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:05PM (#26826098)
Not really, the limits you see from TSMC here are for the lesser of the important chip sales. Apple's orders that will put a hurting on Intel in the market and mindshare are still good. So Maybe Intel may sell more units in a small way by the M1X will still hurt Intel's lead by just existing.

Did I mention that Intel Xe uses TSMC as well?

Re:TSMC sees chip shortage lasting into 2022 by justatdotin on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:24PM (#26828670)
didnt someone here explain recently that intel has a huge warchest, such that their current sales have little to do with their future?