News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by isaiahg on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:13PM (#26782964)
The message I'm getting from Google is that flutter is the future and will get more support eventually. You can also see it in their fuchsia os which is heavily focused on the ecosystem.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by Illniyar on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:38PM (#26783297)
I'd be surprised if this actually materializes. Most likely google will abandon the project (whether by killing it or just moving all the talent to something else.

Keeping up to date native Android/iOS functionality by basically reimplementing it bugs and all is an endless demanding work requiring strong talent that will never be good enough for all your use cases and will churn anyone who works on it both from the work itself and the constant complaints of the community.

No other programming powerhouse would be willing to partake in this or even be able to keep up - you won't see an AirBnB, Microsoft or Wix commitment like you did with React-Native, where these companies were active contributors to the core and have low-level libraries of their own.

Google is the last company I'll put my money for doing long term maintenance on an open source project, let alone one with no prospect for monetization or search market-share.

There's really only one way that Flutter survives - and that's if somehow Android moves to it as a first class citizen.

This is immensely unlikely. And probably will doom Android. And in the impossible case where it will - it means iOS will become second citizen.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by schmorptron on Tuesday April 13, 2021 @03:19AM (#26789077)
What do you mean by "and that's if somehow Android moves to it as a first class citizen."?
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by coldtea on Monday April 12, 2021 @03:20PM (#26783862)
>The message I'm getting from Google is that flutter is the future and will get more support eventually.

Google has said the same thing for tons of things, and then stop caring for them and supporting them.

Including Dart as a JS alternative, the very same technology now relegated to Flutter backend.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by Turing_Machine on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:09PM (#26784519)
Right. Google has a long history of scrapping major projects the moment it becomes convenient, even products that have millions of active users (Reader, Wave, Plus....).

I would think long and hard before betting my company on any Google product.

Are there many third-party contributors to flutter? If so, that would make me feel a little more confident. If it's all (or almost all) Google staff, yeah... no. Wouldn't go there.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by sebe on Monday April 12, 2021 @09:42PM (#26787290)
Ubuntu is doing work on desktop flutter, I recall hearing that they are working on hooking up flutter to accessibility bit of ubuntu.

https://ubuntu.com/blog/flutter-and-ubuntu-so-far

tidbit - there is early support to build linux flutter apps on the raspberry pi. Would be good if android team offered arm builds of their tools, then it would be possible to build for android on the pi.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by codeptualize on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:27PM (#26785959)
I still miss Google Inbox, such a great product. They just killed it for no good reason. Really sad.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by alasdair_ on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:20PM (#26784646)
Google always has two projects that cover “the future” - one is undocumented and the other was just deprecated.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by JamesSwift on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:27PM (#26783148)
There is absolutely no way flutter unseats java/kotlin unless it abandons dart and adopts kotlin as its language. Its much more likely that flutter gets absorbed in some way by the android ecosystem.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by chairhairair on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:51PM (#26783490)
I don't see how it would make any sense whatsoever for Flutter to be "absorbed" by Android, it is entirely independent.

Also, I'd be curious to hear what major advantages Kotlin would have for Flutter. The Flutter team has commented heavily on Dart's useful properties for Flutter's goals (small comment here, there are well written full articles as well: flutter.dev/docs/resources/faq#why-did-flutter-choose-to-use-dart).

The internal investment in Flutter is well beyond the average tech project at Google. I don't expect it to be abandoned any time soon.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by robocat on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:25PM (#26784696)
From the FAQ “the LICENSE file is 54.3 KB (compressed)” - that is pretty large amount of uncompressed text! I couldn’t find the full licence file (presumably containing all the licences of library dependencies).
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by pjmlp on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:50PM (#26783470)
Jetpack Compose was definitely a counter attack from Android team, with Ads being a big Flutter sponsor and the only reason Dart did not die when Chrome withdraw their support.

So if Ads, Pay and Search keep their support, Dart and Flutter are here to stay.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by schmorptron on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:11PM (#26784539)
Just to understand this correctly, are you talking about internal debates at google? Like the different teams embracing different technologies for building apps?
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by eddiegroves on Monday April 12, 2021 @09:57PM (#26787379)
Yes, Flutter is “sponsored” by other money making teams inside Google. It is why resources have been spent on Flutter for Web, which no one asked for - the Ads team essentially bought the feature for their usage. This was also how React Native got its start in Facebook.

So my read of Flutter is it’s a way for talent to “ship and get promoted” inside Google or to support other Google product teams. Everyone else is a secondary priority.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by dragonwriter on Monday April 12, 2021 @10:03PM (#26787414)
> It is why resources have been spent on Flutter for Web, which no one asked for - the Ads team essentially bought the feature for their usage.

“the Ads team at Google” is a very strange thing to treat as equivalent to “no one”.

Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by karmakaze on Monday April 12, 2021 @07:30PM (#26786436)
Flutter does away with all the idiosyncrasies of the many Android APIs that differences between Dart and Kotlin seem relatively superficial.
Re:Why you should NOT use NativeScript by mkrishnan on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:29PM (#26784746)
+1 to the dart part.