News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by rvz on Sunday April 11, 2021 @06:57AM (#26769375)
From [0]:

> This is misleading and false. Clubhouse has not been breached or hacked. The data referred to is all public profile information from our app, which anyone can access via the app or our API.

So just like what happened to Parler and LinkedIn. A so-called 'data breach' of its public data via scraping.

But last time I checked on the private API in a GitHub repo, Clubhouse is using integer IDs which are not random alphanumberic strings for its users.

This can essentially be scraped by a while loop, incrementing all the way to whoever last signed up.

Did Clubhouse even implement rate limiting to combat this?

[0] https://twitter.com/joinClubhouse/status/1381066324105854977

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by sschueller on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:20AM (#26769479)
Does anyone remember the ATT "Hack"? These two just used curl to get e-mail address and ICC-ID of ATT iPad users which where publicly accessible. [1] It was still labeled a hack and went through the brain dead media that way. Instead of ATT getting in trouble Auernheimer got a 41 months sentence and the judge also ordered him and Spitler to pay $73,000 in restitution.

[1] https://www.wired.com/2013/03/att-hacker-gets-3-years/

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by soulofmischief on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#26771922)
weev had a lot of friends come forth to defend his actions, but then he went full neonazi in prison and all of that support disappeared.

He now runs admin for The Daily Stormer and somehow finds a way to keep popping up in the worst places, can't seem to shake the guy.

Additionally, he didn't even do the legwork for the AT&T op, but really wanted to take credit for something for cool hacker cred, and it came back and bit him. I keep company with several people involved in that ordeal.

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by FDSGSG on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:28AM (#26769520)
If this wasn't a hack, would a SQL injection have been a hack? Where do you draw the line?

What if they had exploited the heartbleed bug, would that have been a hack?

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by sbarre on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:46AM (#26769969)
I think this comes down to an oft-repeated discussion of what we (society) consider the "proper" securing of data.

If a company leaves data available in a manner that is accessible without using any kind of vulnerability, but rather allows the unintended (ab)use of a poorly implemented service, then that's not a "hack", that's on the company, and they should be held accountable.

Personally I think an SQL injection still falls under the above. Securing public endpoints against long-known and easily mitigated vulnerabilities is 100% the company's responsibility..

There is no "we couldn't have prevented this" bullshit defense in that case.

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by FDSGSG on Sunday April 11, 2021 @12:09PM (#26771338)
The company probably deserves punishment for negligence, but that should have zero impact on how we view the actions of the "hacker".

>If a company leaves data available in a manner that is accessible without using any kind of vulnerability, but rather allows the unintended (ab)use of a poorly implemented service, then that's not a "hack", that's on the company, and they should be held accountable.

Is it "theft" if you leave your keys in your car and I take it?

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by strogonoff on Sunday April 11, 2021 @01:30PM (#26771957)
IMO the “car with keys inside” analogy is not great for poorly implemented infosec. The latter is both more benign (no physical property directly stolen) and at the same time worse (the scale means multitudes of people will become vulnerable to further attacks, identity theft, doxxing and so on, rather than just one person losing the means of movement). It’s just different qualitatively.

What should have impact on how we view the actions of a hacker is the context of said actions, not just the “hacking” part.

If the hacker exploited company’s infosec negligence to profit in some way (say, by selling the data), or irresponsibly disclosed the data or the vulnerability possibly causing harm to affected users, it is one thing.

Otherwise, the same sequence of hacker’s actions that exploits the vulnerability does not compare to stealing a car with keys inside—it is (another faulty analogy warning) more like looking at a car through some magical looking glass that highlights the keys left inside by the owner.

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by sbarre on Sunday April 11, 2021 @02:04PM (#26772185)
It certainly is.. but now let's go talk to your insurance company and see how they feel about covering the loss.
Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by Kye on Sunday April 11, 2021 @07:24AM (#26769492)
It's only a problem if you think it's a problem for someone to trivially build a social graph for every person on your exclusive social network with lots of high profile people.

So...it's a problem.

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by eswat on Sunday April 11, 2021 @08:16AM (#26769793)
Not a great response on their part since the article they reference in the tweet does not say that they have been breached or hacked. Only that there's a limited dataset of users out there and that Techmeme reached out to Clubhouse to know if they are aware of any breaches of their systems.

Pretty bad optics if the other stuff is true: incremental IDs, no rate limiting, tokens that don't expire.

Re:Clubhouse data leak: 1.3M user records leaked online for ... by mvanaltvorst on Sunday April 11, 2021 @04:19PM (#26773054)
Correct, and judging from someone else in this thread, it was even possible to use wildcard matching to get access to an entire list of users at once.