News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by midasuni on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:12AM (#26738882)
So operator (TUI) mis calculate estimated weight. Clearly nothing to do with the aircraft.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by richardwhiuk on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#26738902)
Struggling to work out the impact - no damage, and no injuries, and safe operation of the aircraft wasn't caused.

Surprised this classifies as a serious incident.

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by pwg on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:18AM (#26738974)
My understanding is that the amount of fuel loaded onboard the plane for takeoff by the ground crew is determined in part by this estimated weight figure.

If the weight estimate is too low, then it would be possible for the ground crew to load too little fuel, leading to a situation at the destination of nearly or actually running out of fuel.

So it may have been labeled "serious" due to the possibility of not loading enough fuel if the weight estimates are too low by too much.

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by tialaramex on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:47AM (#26739383)
Serious incident is the grade below accident, because nothing bad actually happened, but in other circumstances it might have.

For example if the aeroplane had been on a relatively short runway, and its passengers consisted entirely of overweight women who were miss-classified as much lighter children, perhaps it would have struggled to clear the runway at calculated power.

Flight crews are not trained to attempt to overrule the computer by explicitly commanding maximum thrust because humans are bad at figuring out if they're accelerating as much as expected - and so in the absence of a check that the plane is performing as anticipated † they are going to have a bad time if the calculations are badly enough wrong.

Why not just always use maximum thrust? Well if you're an aircraft carrier, or maybe even a military base you could definitely do that, but if you're a civilian airfield then the tremendous noise from jet engines at maximum performance is a constant problem and so you want jets to calculate a lower take off power that's still safe in order to reduce noise.

† [in some newer Airbus configurations the plane can work out its real acceleration and which runway you're on and conclude whether it will not successfully take off before it runs out of runway and so caution the pilots to abort before V1 when it's still practical - it doesn't matter why it isn't accelerating what matters is that you won't fly if you don't go fast enough, they can spend as long as they like to troubleshoot when they have stopped]

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by tyingq on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:16AM (#26738944)
Flawed weight and balance procedure, so a "nothing bad happened" situation, but "something bad could have happened". So serious in the sense that changes needed to be made to avoid a real issue in the future.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by midasuni on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:16AM (#26738948)
I’m surprised that estimated weight is used at all - surely the plane knows the actual takeoff weight, wouldn’t that be the number that’s checked before taxiing starts? Same with actual weight distribution
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by jjk166 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:52AM (#26739462)
How would the plane know it's weight? You could measure the forces on the landing gear, but that would be subject to huge errors (inflation of the tires, stresses from the hydraulics, etc.), much higher than the 1% error required to notice this discrepancy. They do have checks in place, which is how they noticed the issue, but it still comes from keeping track of what goes on the plane.

> As part of the prestart procedure, the flight crew reviewed the flight plan, which gave an expected takeoff weight (TOW) of 66,495 kg (Figure 1), and the load sheet, which gave a TOW of 64,889 kg (Figure 2). They noticed that there was a discrepancy, with the load sheet showing 1,606 kg less than the flight plan. They noted that the number of children shown on the load sheet was higher than expected, at 65, compared to the 29 which were expected on the flight plan. The commander recalled thinking that the number was high but plausible; he had experienced changing loads on the run-up to the temporary grounding as passengers cancelled and altered trips at short notice.

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by midasuni on Friday April 09, 2021 @04:55AM (#26748211)
I guessed the force on the landing gear would be able to be measured - Pressure in suspension perhaps.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by pwg on Thursday April 08, 2021 @03:49PM (#26742945)
The ground crew needs a good enough weight estimate to determine the proper fuel to add to the tanks, and to plan out the cargo distribution in the cargo hold so they can overlap that work (loading fuel, loading cargo) with the actual passenger boarding of the plane to save wait time for both passengers and the airline.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by nimbius on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#26738900)
or is that..Ms calculate?
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by Zagitta on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:19AM (#26738997)
One could say they miss-calculated :^)
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by pbrb on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:17AM (#26738956)
LOL, I choked on my breakfast laughing at this.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by _Microft on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:23AM (#26739059)
Fun fact: SpaceX had two marine vessels for recovering rocket payload fairings from the sea. One was called Ms. Tree, the other one Ms. Chief. They are being replaced by a new boat right now, so let's see if they come up with another funny name for her as well.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by krallja on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:35AM (#26739223)
My mother was on a softball team in medical school named Ms. Diagnosis.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by saargrin on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:15AM (#26738927)
is there a hackernews gold i can give you?
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by tyingq on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:15AM (#26738919)
Also, 737-800, not a MAX. Occured 21 July 2020.

And...

"Whilst an incorrect takeoff weight was used for aircraft performance planning, the thrust required for the actual TOW and environmental conditions (88.2% N1) was marginally less than the thrust used for the takeoff (88.3% N1). This meant the safe operation of the aircraft was not compromised."

So it was a "something bad could have happened" situation that called for a change in procedure to avoid a future, real problem.

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by anonu on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:20AM (#26739004)
under-estimate weight -> under-estimate fuel -> fuel exhaustion -> crash

While my armchair opinion is that ~1500kg mis-calculation of payload on a Boeing 737 is minor - this is one of those problems you should treat pretty seriously as it might have repercussions on other flights.

Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by seoaeu on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:53AM (#26739480)
Yeah, they intentionally include a safety margin in the amount of fuel to bring. Doesn't make it OK just to miscalculate the payload weight and assume the margin will save you.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by sidlls on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:19AM (#26738996)
It certainly did have something to do with the aircraft. The weight distribution in the aircraft is actually quite important, and a badly distributed weight can cause instability and a crash. These kinds of reports aren't meant to isolate a cause for the assignment of blame. They are meant to provide comprehensive information about the incidents, including identification of the root causes and the remedies for them.
Re:Flight incident: Passengers titled ‘Miss’ counted as chil... by ploika on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:15AM (#26738923)
I don't think anyone is confusing a 737 with a 737 Max. The issue here is that bad check-in software caused a serious incident.