News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:25PM (#26719502)
> von Neumann proposed a description for a computer architecture now known as the von Neumann architecture

Well, he actually described an already existing design by Eckert and Mauchly under his name and this paper was illegally disclosed. For the ones interested in this and other fascinating stories about ENIAC, here is a good book: https://www.amazon.com/Eniac-Triumphs-Tragedies-Worlds-Compu... worth reading is also the review by Jean Bartik (here https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R3K2DSB6UE1X7H/re...) who was there and witnessed everything firsthand.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by jshier on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:34PM (#26719968)
This isn't really true. There was no existing architecture and even if there was, Eckert and Mauchly weren't the only ones involved. ENIAC itself encapsulated almost none of the Von Neumann architecture principles. While it's true Von Neumann's paper started as a summary of ongoing discussions on computer architecture for the EDVAC with a group that included Eckert, Mauchly, Arthur Burks, and others, Von Neumann's proofs of the architecture's viability within the paper were entirely original. Hence the name.

Jean Bartik was a hugely biased source who used personal recollection to quarrel with anyone who offered any view of computer history that didn't put ENIAC front and center. She seems to have spent the latter part of her life writing strident negative Amazon reviews of any book which didn't place Eckert and Mauchly and the ENIAC as the primary source of all computer innovation. Her reviews [1] of Who Invented the Computer? The Legal Battle That Changed Computing History in particular were extremely negative personal attacks on the author and her husband (Alice and Arthur Burks) for having written books which dared question ENIAC's supremacy.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R2MERA4EUZ8M17

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:09AM (#26722139)
There is not only Jean Bartik; there is a lot of recorded history, even court cases that left many files and affidavits. Bartik's commentary lent itself because it is with the book I referenced. Burks' case is also amply documented. He wanted to be registered as an inventor on the patent after the fact, which was denied to him, even by a court. In his bitterness, he then made many claims. The comment by Bartik you reference should be seen in this context.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by suifbwish on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @12:31AM (#26720623)
Fascinating when individuals of such advanced intelligence are not obsessed with immortality. Either They believe it is not possible or they are secretly a god trying to escape the boredom of already having long since achieved it.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by joelbluminator on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:20AM (#26721119)
Or maybe they are horrified with the idea of living forever...
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by beefield on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:20AM (#26720855)
Or they have realized that immortality is actually a dumb idea. Either you talk about real immortality where you live forever. And forever is a really long time. Or you talk about being able to decide when to die. In which case dying accidentally today becomes much more expensive so you become obsessed about avoiding accidental death today and miss the whole point of living a longer life...
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by krige on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:23AM (#26721133)
Quoting a character in one of Stanisław Lem's stories, "People do not really want to live forever -- they simply do not want to die." Always struck me as a rather profound take on the whole immortality deal.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by kgwgk on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @04:06AM (#26721726)
Von Neumann definitely didn't want to die. According to Wigner: "When Jancsi realized that he was incurably ill, his logic made him conclude that he would cease to exist, cease to have thoughts. The full content of this was incomprehensible to him and it horrified him. We all know this and try to accept it, but it is always difficult. It was heartbreaking to watch the frustration in his mind when the hope was gone. His fate was unavoidable to him, but it was still unacceptable."
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by dharmon on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @11:02AM (#26725936)
His friends and colleagues were very disappointed that at the very end he turned to religion to help him cope with his fears. He even had a priest visit him for last rites. (Source: A Beautiful Mind)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Schiphol on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:03AM (#26722084)
To add another source, Greg Evan's Permutation City is what drove home for me how profoundly inhuman immortality is.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by rowanG077 on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:33AM (#26722870)
I think it's incredibly arrogant to talk with such certainty about biological immortality. It's not something we can fathom at this time.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by suifbwish on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:19PM (#26727846)
You are suggesting that death is somehow less dumb when you don’t know anything about the true existential nature of what that is.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by beefield on Thursday April 08, 2021 @02:28AM (#26735722)
If you get philosophical, I don't think you can really know anything about anything. However, in practice I have every reason to assume that I have been practically dead i.e. non-existent for the vast majority of the lifetime of our universe (and whatever universes there may have been outside our one, whatever that may mean.) And I do not recall being non-existent that bad... Dying, that's another thing, that I know nothing about and am not looking forward for it - quite yet. But I know that the amount of things I want to do here is finite. And based on knowing myself and the feelings of quite a few old people, I am quite sure that when those would be done, I would be happy to let go. (Only small thing that I might want from approximately infinite life, would be to know how this life story here on earth/universe ends.)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by suifbwish on Thursday April 08, 2021 @08:22PM (#26745412)
Well said
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by copperx on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:17AM (#26720846)
Sometimes I wish von Neumann had gone into another field, such as genetics.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by mcherm on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:02AM (#26722623)
He basically did.

He was creating frameworks for understanding self-replicating systems before the nature of DNA had been determined.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by justicezyx on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:20PM (#26720243)
Now the water is really muddy...

Is there a defitive book or wiki page for the whole thing regarding: * Von Neumann's actual contribution to the so-called von Neumann architecture

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by SquishyPanda23 on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @12:03AM (#26720470)
Here is the wiki page on the report and the controversy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Draft_of_a_Report_on_the...

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by justicezyx on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @12:21AM (#26720569)
“““ The treatment of the preliminary report as a publication (in the legal sense) was the source of bitter acrimony between factions of the EDVAC design team for two reasons.[3] First, publication amounted to a public disclosure that prevented the EDVAC from being patented; second, some on the EDVAC design team contended that the stored-program concept had evolved out of meetings at the University of Pennsylvania's Moore School of Electrical Engineering predating von Neumann's activity as a consultant there, and that much of the work represented in the First Draft was no more than a translation of the discussed concepts into the language of formal logic in which von Neumann was fluent. Hence, failure of von Neumann and Goldstine to list others as authors on the First Draft led credit to be attributed to von Neumann alone. (See Matthew effect and Stigler's law.) ”””

This seems more vague than what have been disclosed here...

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by m_mueller on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:52AM (#26723036)
How does Turing’s work factor into this? Does Bartik also discredit his influence on computer architecture?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:24PM (#26719906)
According to J. Presper Eckert in his oral history interview [1] the Moore School was actually collecting patent applications, when von Neumann went public with the report. Which is why principal computer architecture is in the public domain. And, according to Eckert, this was done with a purpose and in von Neumann's self-interest. He also accused von Neumann of having done similarly at the IAS. (According to von Neumann, it was merely an oversight that his name was the only one on the report and it had been just an internal proposal for a draft of the final paper.)

Eckert summarizes this condemnatory as follows on p.35: "You know, we finally regarded von Neuman as a huckster of other people's ideas with Goldstine as his principle mission salesman. Now, if you don't believe this, talk to Julian Biglow at the Institute for Advanced Study(…) Von Neumann was stealing ideas and trying to pretend work done at the Moore School was work he had done."

[1] Oral history interview with J. Presper Eckert conducted by Nancy Stern, 1977: https://conservancy.umn.edu/handle/11299/107275

PDF: https://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/107275/oh...

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by devindotcom on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:43PM (#26720018)
Interesting if true but it seems odd to think that Von Neumann of all people in the 20th century perhaps would need to steal someone's ideas. From what I've read of him he was more likely to improve on them before the ideator had finished speaking.

But certainly those were days (if indeed we have left them) when 'great men' like him could and would take credit for something like that for reasons of pride and posterity.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:57PM (#26720104)
Eckert accused von Neumann specifically of doing so that he could consult for IBM on the matter.

However, there is a problem with this: As I understand it, IBM wasn't that interested in computers at the time and actually stumbled into (electronic digital) computing by a government contract for replicating Whirlwind for the Semi Automatic Ground Environment (SAGE). On the other hand, Eckert also pointed out some interest shown repeatedly by von Neumann in bringing in commercial third parties into the project, so it may have been concerning any third party which may be interested in his consultancy, and this then became historically IBM.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by adrian_b on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:29AM (#26721156)
IBM was not yet interested in electronic computers.

IBM was developing electromechanical computers and for a few years the electromechanical IBM SSEC (operating since January 1948) was the fastest computer with stored program, solving many important problems for the US government and for various companies.

After their competitor Remington Rand introduced the first commercial electronic computers (UNIVAC), IBM also entered this market very quickly with a few commercial models (IBM 701 & IBM 702), then also with the faster electronic computers made for the US military, in the NORC and SAGE projects.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by watwut on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:29AM (#26721154)
People dont steal ideas because they have to, they do it because they can and because they are ambitious. They steel them because it help build cult of geniality around themselves.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by TedDoesntTalk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:28PM (#26720279)
What a crime that such 22 year old memories are locked away in an amazon comment, to be lost whenever amazon deems it necessary to cull comments older than a certain age.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by dolmen on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @03:43AM (#26721554)
It appears someone (some machine?) asked the Web Archive to save it before I did.

https://web.archive.org/web/20210407045457/https://www.amazo...

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by echelon on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @12:28AM (#26720605)
The whole internet is like this. Everything is atrophying.

Remember personal websites and blogs? Barely anybody runs them anymore.

Archive Team is doing amazing work, and we need to support them.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by globular-toast on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:10AM (#26722149)
It's not locked away. Copy the text and save it on your disk if you think it's important to you. Publish it on your own blog if you think it's important to everyone.

People seem to forget about the "save" functionality included in every web browser for some reason. You should save anything you deem important enough if you fear it might be gone one day. This is no different from acquiring a copy of an important book for your own shelf.

Where would you prefer this comment to reside? Where would it have lived before the web?

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by ghaff on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @07:16AM (#26723202)
While I'm generally in favor of preserving digital history, I don't really disagree. In a world where so many utterances and video can be preserved--and just wait until a lot of people are wearing AR glasses everywhere and AI/ML systems can increasingly tag and organize all that recording and associate it with real world identities--I'm not sure we even want everything to be saved even if it were possible.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by croes on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:46AM (#26720963)
ENIAC the worlds first computer? What about Z3 by Konrad Zuse? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z3_(computer)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Hydraulix989 on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:28AM (#26721149)
The winners write history.

It's interesting that the Z3 was denied funding from the German gov't for not being war-important. It turns out they were ahead of the computing game and squandered it, as US and GB relied on computers for code breaking and performing calculations for developing the atom bomb.

It's not a blunder to the tune of invading Russia, but it's still interesting.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by mardifoufs on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:53AM (#26723040)
Yeah I disagree here. The general public's knowledge on WW2 and their perception of that war usually has been very disproportionately influenced and shaped directly by the post wars memoirs of german generals & other important figures of the 3rd Reich. Which is why there are so many myths and outright falsehoods on the war (pushed by those authors to rehabilitate/distance themselves from their own actions) that are still very very widely believed to be true. It's pretty fitting that "history is written by the victors" is one of those narratives.

Plus it makes even less sense when ww2 Germany is almost always believed to have been way ahead of the allies technologically. Way more than they actually were, so unless the allies were veryyy bad at rewriting history to erase Germany's contributions... I'd probably guess It's more due to it being a very obscure technology and had almost no "cool" factor, and v. little influence on the overall technology compared to the V-2 or jet fighters

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Hydraulix989 on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:45AM (#26748519)
So was the German Z3 not the first digital computer? Or were the Germans ahead of the Allies technologically in this case?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by aap_ on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:51AM (#26721261)
There was no first computer. The further you go back the less it becomes a computer, the further you go forward the less it becomes a first.

I can really recommend the book "ENIAC in Action" on this matter and of course on the ENIAC generally.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by jonstewart on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @08:56AM (#26724172)
It’s rather like the development of the automobile. The first computers—EDVAC, ENIAC, Z3, ABC—all had idiosyncrasies that reflect on them being transitional technologies.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by DonHopkins on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:18AM (#26722739)
But what was the zeroth computer?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Koshkin on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @07:47AM (#26723440)
Interestingly, “computer” was the term applied to office workers whose responsibility was doing calculations. Which is why the first machines were called “automatic computers”. (Fast forward to today, “computing” is perceived now mostly as “using a computer”, such as web browsing or reading email.)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by kyberias on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:15PM (#26727812)
It can be argued that Z3 was not as general purpose (Turing complete) as ENIAC.

"The Z3 was demonstrated in 1998 to be, in principle, Turing-complete. However, because it lacked conditional branching, the Z3 only meets this definition by speculatively computing all possible outcomes of a calculation."

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:13AM (#26722166)
The claim was the first programmable, general-purpose "electronic computer". Zuse's machine was "electro mechanic" (i.e. based on relays instead of tubes).
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by croes on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:39AM (#26722913)
That seems a little unclear. In the title it says "Eniac: The Triumphs and Tragedies of the World's First Computer" In the outline: "Presents a history of the world's first programmable computer, ENIAC" In the reviews once "Nobody doubts the pair designed and built ENIAC, the world's first fully electronic computer" and another time "This account of how an engineer barely out of college and a physicist with dreams of predicting the weather, conceived and built the world's first computer."
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @07:04AM (#26723138)
On page 3 of the book: "They built ENIAC, the first digital, general-purpose, electronic computer". It all depends on how you define the term "computer". Not to forget that "computers" at that time were the women who did the calculations; see e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer#Etymology. Nearly all computers today are electronic and digital; so ENIAC was one of the pioneers of this development (the Colossus was another one).
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by djmips on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:26PM (#26719510)
True but on the other hand, he kind of made computers 'open source'
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:40PM (#26719617)
> he kind of made computers 'open source'

The only "positive" (depeding on perspective) effect of his illegal and morally questionable action was that the patent was declared null and void due to the novelty-damaging effect of his report, among other issues supporting this outcome. The computers however did not become more "open source" because of this, just cheaper.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by eru on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:14AM (#26720832)
Declaring a patent null and void seems like a positive outcome.

Patents are legally enforced monopolies after all.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:58AM (#26822095)
So the end justifies all means? Consultants and employees who reveal trade secrets to sabotage patents are heroes in your eyes, not criminals?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by amilios on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:11PM (#26719826)
Still a semi-positive outcome no? Computers becoming cheaper?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:43PM (#26720024)
J. Presper Eckert (the Eckert in "Eckert & Mauchly") in his oral history interview [1], p.46f:

> "Originally we called ENIAC the "MANIAC" when it didn't work right. And later they borrowed that name for some other actual machine. But if you worked for von Neumann on the MANIAC, then if you invented something it belonged to you. Well, on some relatively short notice, like it might have been a week, or a month, or something, a short time before the deadlines hit, von Neumann went down and published all that stuff. All the reports of the engineers went to the Library of Congress which put a bar on any patents being obtained by any of his employees. And when they complained about it to him, he just said, "Well, that's tough; that's the way I think; that stuff should be in the public domain." Now there is a perfectly obvious reason for this. He was consulting with people like IBM. If the things weren't patented that would be a problem for IBM. The idea was he was selling ideas to other people...if it wasn't covered by patents, he would have been selling something they couldn't use. They would have come back and said, now, "what kind of a consultant are you, coming up with new ideas which are already patented by others and we can't use them." But if these ideas could come under the public domain, then he could go around and sell them to people. That was his game."

[1] Oral history interview with J. Presper Eckert (1977): https://conservancy.umn.edu/handle/11299/107275

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by adrian_b on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:50AM (#26720979)
For the humanity, the publication of the von Neumann report was certainly a very positive thing because it launched a large number of research projects with the purpose of building electronic computers, both in USA and in many other countries.

There is absolutely no doubt that without this publication and with a patent claiming the design of a computer with stored program, the evolution of the computers would have been much slower.

Whoever pushed the report to be published did a huge service to everybody else but Eckert and Mauchly.

Also, Eckert and his coworkers were deluded if they thought they could have gained anything by having a patent on the stored-program computer.

Nobody prevented them to build good computers even without a patent, but they did not have the intellectual and financial resources to do much until they were bought by Remington Rand, which lead to the introduction of UNIVAC in 1951.

If they had a patent, the result would have been that Remington Rand would have had a monopoly on the computer market, with inferior products, and all the great advances in computers that have been done in other places, like NIST, MIT or IBM, would have happened only many years later.

I have read both the von Neumann report, which is a model of clarity, and all the early documents that remain from Eckert, Mauchly et al.

It is likely that they already had some ideas about stored-program computers, but there is no doubt that their ideas were very confused.

Von Neumann distinguished what was right from what was wrong in their ideas, then clarified, organized and completed all those concepts and synthesized them in a coherent theory that could be easily understood and used by anyone else.

The contribution of von Neumann is much more important than Eckert tries to imply.

Moreover, while Eckert and al. were upset that their own contributions were not acknowledged as well as they should have been, they also failed to acknowledge the important ideas about electronic computers that they themselves have taken from Atanasoff, without ever mentioning him.

Unlike Eckert and al., but like von Neumann, Atanasoff was also someone able to express very clearly his concepts, so you could easily learn from him. For example a report about the classification of computer memories, written by Atanasoff at the beginning of WWII, was extremely advanced for those days (Atanasoff invented what is now called DRAM).

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by adrian_b on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:46AM (#26721237)
I want to add that the fast evolution of computers caused by the publication of the von Neumann report and the lack of "IP protection" is paralleled by the fast evolution of semiconductor devices after the discovery of the transistor, which was also caused by the lack of "IP protection" in the modern sense.

Even if the transistors have been patented, the patents have been licensed to anyone for negligible fees or even for free (e.g. for hearing aids).

If the essential transistor patents had been used like worthless patents are used today in preventing competition, the history of the computer and electronics industries would have been very different, with progress delayed by decades.

So both the publication of the von Neumann report and the generous handling of the transistor patents have been very influential in shaping the word of today, while many inventions where the inventors clinged to the patents have been either doomed or they began to be used only after the patents have expired, more than 20 years later.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @08:45PM (#26733669)
Regarding "very confused ideas":

To be fair, Mauchly proposed combined program and data storage in a mercury delay line, much like it was done on the UNIVAC I, in 1945, before von Neumann arrived. (Allegedly, there had been ideas for stored program in the ENIAC group even earlier than this.) Mauchly also invented Short Code (1949, originally named Brief Code), the first programming language used in production, and the Critical Path Method for automatic scheduling. The group around Maurice Wilkes attended his 1946 lectures on the design of digital computers and went from there to build the EDSAC, the very first modern computer.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by tpetricek on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:44AM (#26722970)
I was looking through the comments to see if someone mentioned Jean Bartik already! Just to add to this comment, she also wrote an autobiographical book, which is worth reading: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Pioneer-Programmer-Jennings-Compute...

It is clearly a very personal and biased account, but I think there are good reasons to believe many of the things she is saying, even when they go against the commonly accepted history "written by the winners".

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by smaddox on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:52PM (#26719701)
Wow... How is this not more well known? It's not like von Neumann doesn't have plenty of other important contributions to his name.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by gpanders on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:03PM (#26720136)
It is far from settled whether the GP’s interpretation is in fact what actually happened. I highly recommend The Innovators by Walter Isaacson. Among other things, it covers this “controversy” in great detail.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:36PM (#26825808)
History is not science. There will never be absolute certainty because human language is always open to interpretation. Even when the evidence is clear, the historiography that relates to that evidence is, again, open to interpretation. The interpretation of terms and situations changes over time, and facts can later be interpreted differently (even maliciously). Not even witness statements in a court case, of which there were several in the present case with hundreds of pages of legal reporting, are immune to interpretation. So yes, I can't prove to you that it happened that way because all of my sources are open to interpretation. There are enough other events in history that are considered sufficiently certain, and yet continue to be disputed by certain people for various motives. Some states even consider it necessary to criminalize the questioning of certain historical facts for this reason.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:26PM (#26719913)
Have a look the oral history interview with J. Presper Eckert, it's a long lasting controversy: https://conservancy.umn.edu/handle/11299/107275

PDF: https://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/107275/oh...

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by jshier on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:36PM (#26719976)
The oral history of the person claiming credit was stolen from him is not a reliable source.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:47PM (#26720042)
Mind that he repeatedly refers to Julian Biglow of the IAS as a (neutral) witness. There have been plenty of law suits regarding this… Probably, the same also applies to any commentary and/or writing by von Neumann.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by jshier on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:56PM (#26720097)
Lawsuits? Unless you're talking personal suits, the only one I know of, Honeywell v. Sperry Rand, did not go well for Eckert or Mauchly, personally or professionally, especially Mauchly.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:58AM (#26722588)
There was already a law suite in 1962 (Bell Telephone Laboratories vs. Sperry Rand) where the court upheld the validity of the ENIAC patent. There was another case in 1964 where Shaw, Sharpless and Burks required that their names would be added as inventors to the patent, which was not successful.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:08PM (#26720170)
My (moral) problems with von Neumann are of entirely different nature, namely his persistent advocacy for a "preemptive" nuclear first strike, before the USSR could roll out a thermonuclear bomb in production. Which might be regarded as attempted, cold-blooded genocide. So, not my personal hero.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by randcraw on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:00PM (#26728481)
"The second world war over, von Neumann accepted a string of commercial consultancies. But he was increasingly drawn into the defence establishment. An earnest advocate of the development of the H-Bomb, he later described himself as "violently anti-communist, and a good deal more militaristic than most". After his death, Life magazine reported that he had said in 1950: "If you say why not bomb them [the Russians] tomorrow, I say why not bomb them today? If you say today at five o'clock, I say why not one o'clock?"

Though frequently quoted as evidence that von Neumann favoured a first strike "preventive war" against the Soviet Union, this is a weak reed on which to build such a claim. It seems more likely it was characteristic - though tasteless and bloodthirsty - banter designed to emphasise his hawkishness. ...

Von Neumann was not an unthinking militarist: he believed that the world's only chance of avoiding destructive conflict was world government, but - since he could not see any practical way of achieving this - he was determined to defend his adopted country with as much armed might as possible. "

http://www.math.uwaterloo.ca/~hwolkowi//neumann1.html

Unlike Teller, von Neumann is not renowned for what you describe as "persistent advocacy" of nuclear first strike. AFAIK, von Neumann was not especially politically active in promoting US gov't aggression of any kind, again, unlike Teller.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by masswerk on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:32PM (#26728976)
As I understand it, there had been about two months during the Eisenhower presidency, where a group tried to urged the administration towards a first strike. And, again, as I understand it, von Neumann played a prominent role in this. At least, this is what I was referring to. (Compare Eisenhower's remarks on the military industrial complex in this context.)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by arethuza on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @07:40AM (#26723381)
I don't think there is any doubt that a "preemptive" nuclear first strike by the US would have morally and legally been regarded as genocide.

The last time we had a debate on HN on this topic a number of people seemed to think it would have been a good idea - which I found genuinely disturbing. Hopefully I was just being trolled.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Retric on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @09:45AM (#26724822)
Genocide is about destruction of a people not simply large numbers of deaths. The Holocaust is the model people assume, but China’s current genocide of the Uyghur is genocide based on intent even without large scale slaughter.

Now you might be overestimating the US nuclear arsenal at the time, remember he died in 1957. At the time a nuclear exchange could have killed a lot of people, but only on the scale of a major bombing campaign not glassing the country.

As such, assuming US attacked and occupied Russia after an early nuclear exchange, it would have been war but not fit the definition of genocide because the intent to destroy a people simply wasn’t there.

PS: One of the less well known examples, the US forcibly sending American Indian children to boarding schools to be Americanized actually fits the UN definition of genocide. That’s the heart of the issue, the intent to destroy a people or culture rather than say conquest or even retaliation.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by arethuza on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @09:55AM (#26724986)
In 1961 the Pentagon's own estimates gave the expected casualties at 600 million plus when it had ~20K weapons. In 1950 the US had ~2500 weapons so scaling that back proportionally still looks like 10s of millions dead.

Edit: I suspect maximum lethality of the US stockpile would have been during the 1960s when they still used large numbers of very large and dirty weapons.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Retric on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @10:27AM (#26725444)
1961 the US had ICBM’s and large numbers of vastly more powerful Hydrogen bombs and very accurate targeting methods. In 1950 the US was still limited to long range bombers, many or even most of which would get shot down and so they would have concentrated on the most critical military targets.

Thus, even 10 million dead in 1950 seems very high unless they simply tried to maximize civilian casualties which it’s self would reasonably qualify as genocide. And again Russia lost ~27 million people in WWII and it isn’t considered a genocide of Russia so numbers alone while horrific don’t qualify.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by arethuza on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @10:53AM (#26725800)
I agree that a "preventative" war in 1950 would have been a very different thing from 1961. However, von Neumann was active as a political adviser to very close to his death and I was unaware that he had rejected the idea of such an attack - there were certainly others who favoured such a thing well into the 1960s.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Retric on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @12:00PM (#26726820)
Sure, though my understanding was this was specifically about an attack before Russia started mass production of atomic bombs. First strike after that point would likely have been vastly more costly on both sides. He was very much aware of the idea, which is why he’s credited in the name and acronym MAD.

In the end the world avoided a large scale nuclear exchange, but when faced with a seemingly like war between two nuclear armed superpowers I can understand the argument.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Koshkin on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @07:58AM (#26723552)
On the other hand, there is still no universal agreement on the morality of the wartime bombing campaigns that lead to high numbers of civilian casualties.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by arethuza on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @08:06AM (#26723627)
I'm always reminded of the lines from Daniel Ellsberg in the describing his experiences in the early 1960s:

"The total death toll as calculated by the Joint Chiefs, from a U.S. first strike aimed primarily at the Soviet Union and China, would be roughly 600 million dead. A hundred Holocausts.

I remember what I thought when I held the single sheet with the graph on it. I thought, this piece of paper should not exist. It should never have existed. Not in America. Not anywhere, ever. It depicted evil beyond any human project that had ever existed. There should be nothing on Earth, nothing real, that it referred to."

https://apjjf.org/-Daniel-Ellsberg/3222/article.html

Edit: The staggering thing about the estimate of 600 million dead was that this was known to be an underestimate as the US didn't take the thermal effects of nuclear weapons into account during planning as they were regarded as too unpredictable. Actual 'real' estimates would be over a billion dead....

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by kalium-xyz on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:25PM (#26719907)
Most people who have a lot of things named after then wanted to have a lot of things named after them. Consider: why is more named after von Neumann then Erdos?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by eru on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:18AM (#26720848)
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by gcanyon on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @01:38AM (#26720940)
There's a large number of things named after Euler as well -- so many that sometimes things are named after the first person to prove them after Euler: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Leo...
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by ducktective on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:08PM (#26719805)
How come it's known as "von Neumann" architecture?
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by adrian_b on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @02:07AM (#26721065)
The name "von Neumann" is rightly applied to this, because von Neumann was the first who has written a complete and consistent description of this architecture, so that anybody could understand it and build computers based on this architecture.

The Eckert group had some rather vague ideas about the architecture of their future computer, the successor of ENIAC, and those ideas certainly included some kind of stored program (not necessarily stored in the same memory as the data; stored programs were not new, as they were common in mechanical or electromechanical computers).

However the Eckert group was secretive, because they hoped to start after the war their own company to make computers and become rich, so it is not known for sure how much von Neumann learned from them and how much of what von Neumann wrote were his own ideas.

In any case, I am more grateful to von Neumann than to the Eckert group, because all the other more important computer projects have started from the von Neumann report, while the work of Eckert and al. had quite a little influence.

The ENIAC computer was very important only as a demonstration that it is possible to make very fast electronic computers, otherwise it had much less influence on the structure of computers than the many other slower computers made around that time.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:23AM (#26722251)
They were "secretive" because they were obligated to do so. It was a secret, military project, and nothing could be published. Ironically, it was the security officer (H. Goldstein) who (illegally) circulated the Neumann paper; no one had expected it, least of all the actual inventors.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by adrian_b on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:52AM (#26722546)
You are right, but even after they were no longer bound by secrecy they never published anything important, which would help advance the computer technology as much as the publications of other computer projects, e.g. from Cambridge, IAS, NIST, MIT or even IBM.

I have not seen any document from them that could establish credibly how much von Neumann learned from them and how much they have learned from von Neumann.

At least in other cases where some people had secret knowledge that became public only much later, e.g. in the case of the public-key cryptography discovered by the British before Diffie-Hellman-Merkle, they could show some classified reports containing the secret knowledge.

The Eckert group has not shown any previous documents containing the ideas from the von Neumann report, but they just claimed that most ideas have already been communicated during the previous discussions of the group.

That might be true, or not, but it does not matter much.

Only the publication of the von Neumann report was really important, regardless who was the source for the ideas contained in it.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by Rochus on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @06:19AM (#26722744)
> but even after they were no longer bound by secrecy they never published anything important

There were a lot of publications; the first one in September 1945 (three month after Goldstein disclosed the Neuman paper) named "Automatic High Speed Computing, A Progress Report on the EDVAC" (see https://www.computerhistory.org/collections/catalog/10272462...), which was also prior to the patent and yet another reason for its invalidity.

> I have not seen any document from them that could establish credibly how much von Neumann learned from them and how much they have learned from von Neumann.

Having a look at the timeline Neumann was not aware of the project before the ENIAC design was completed.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by ducktective on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @05:42AM (#26722452)
Did von Neumann himself ever acknowledge that the whole thing originated somewhere else or did he cite any of that group's findings?

In all documentaries on the origins of computers that I've watched, von Neumann gets all of the recognition while many of us have heard about Eckert and Mauchly from a Wikipedia article or comment deep down a relevant article.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by mannerheim on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @04:27AM (#26721860)
This reminds me of the Newton-Leibniz calculus priority dispute, with Newton not publishing on calculus until after Leibniz had, although with that we now at least have the benefit of contemporary correspondence to refer to.
Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by madhadron on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:58PM (#26720445)
So a little bit longer version of the story: Eckert and Mauchly had designed the architecture. Herman Goldstine, the military liaison of the ENIAC project, and something of a social climber, sought out von Neumann to see if he was interested. von Neumann was, and came to a lot of design meetings and made contributions about what the instruction set should be. Then when he was heading out to Los Alamos on a trip, he had some downtime during travel and wrote up the design for the group. Goldstine typed it up and circulated it with just von Neumann's name on it.

It is a point of discredit to von Neumann that he did not disavow the naming of the architecture.

Funnily, Goldstine's wife was one of the early programmers and well respected in that area. Goldstine himself made no significant contributions to computing.

Re:The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann (2019) by jonnybgood on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:42PM (#26720014)
Stigler's law of eponymy?