I agree that QoL in NYC is awful, but it's not "more dangerous than ever". Like in every other US city, the crime rate is near an all-time low[1]. Murders spiked during Covid, but they're still low compared to previous decades.
> Add to that the “you’re not paying you’re fair share attitude” which I’m definitely getting
Where do you get this attitude? I have never experienced that in the city.
In fact, it's one of the places where the rich seem to be the least scrutinized, because most of them pay lip service to liberal values while still being 100,000x richer than a middle-class person living a few neighborhoods away.
1. https://www.factcheck.org/2020/07/giulianis-misleading-attac...
--------
[1] - https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/01/us/new-york-budget-nypd-1-bil...
Re where I get the attitude, our mayor and local representatives (like AOC) have both said this. There’ve been numerous marches down 6th Ave and the West Side Highway as well.
It's not, though. Do you have any data to back it up?
All cause mortality has been very steady (with the exception of Sept 11 and Covid)[1]. Murders are near an all-time low[2] and are at nearly half of what they were when you moved to NYC.
Felonies are lower, muggings are lower, everything is lower. So what does "dangerous" mean to you and where can we see something to back up the idea that the entire city is more dangerous?
1. https://twitter.com/joe_pickrell/status/1248721149233713153/...
2. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0c/NYC_murd...
Those statistics focus on murder and 'major' crimes, and it's great that they are down. However as a city dweller the crimes that I actually worry about and the thing that makes a city feel "dangerous" are 'minor' crimes like pick pockets, muggings, vandalism and 'minor' assaults.
Those are also down[1] in NYC, as they are across the country. If you can find any statistics that show otherwise, please share the link.
1. https://www.cityrating.com/crime-statistics/new-york/new-yor...
How do you know there is more manipulation of the stats now than there was at any other point in the past?
If you're saying the official stats can't be trusted, you're just saying that no one knows how bad crime is. Or maybe you're saying no one knows except you?
Regardless, you can't argue that crime is going up based on anecdotes, regardless of whether the official stats are trustworthy or not.
> If you do insist on reporting, they make you pay for it, you could be at the station for 5 hours, which happened to my mother after her car was broken into by a homeless man. They're encouraged to not report specific kinds of crimes.
So you're saying that's true in every city in the US? There's no city that's trying to do honest crime reporting?
Because this isn't just a trend in NYC.
Yes, I am talking about NYC. I'm sure every other city is a relative statistical utopia. But I have no information on those cities, given I don't live there, except for the official stats.
They could be shaving off exactly 10% every year, and the trend lines are fine. Or they could shave off enough to make crime go down slightly every year, which is what I'd do if I were a chief who had to answer to a mayor, and didn't really care about statistical fidelity.
Just because you're looking at a chart, doesn't mean the chart reflects reality. And it doesn't matter if you don't have a nice other chart to look at. Sometimes you can't answer questions accurately from your chair 500 miles away.
Then why did you add an anecdote about crimes you heard about?
> Or they could shave off enough to make crime go down slightly every year, which is what I'd do if I were a chief who had to answer to a mayor, and didn't really care about statistical fidelity.
It seems implausible that thousands of chiefs and mayors are doing exactly this, all across the country. You would also expect to see downward jumps when new mayors came into office, which anyone fudging the numbers would do to make sure they stayed in office.
You're talking about, essentially, a conspiracy that runs from the bottom of local police departments all the way to the FBI (who also collect these stats).
The story of this instance of crime is that they're not collecting data the way they should. The way they opted not to collect it shows that it's part of their standard MO. They could be making up crimes they're not solving, but there's no incentive for them to do that. And it's impossible to see that in action, it would just look like someone entering things into a spreadsheet.
You should respond to claims people are making, instead of responding to claims you want people to have made because they're easier to argue against. It makes discussion a waste of time.
[1] https://www.curbed.com/2020/11/upper-west-side-homeless-hote...
perhaps b/c they think it would make the problem worse, not better - there is a trend whereby places with better facilities for homeless will attract more homeless (ala San-fran). NY has as such payed homeless to relocate elsewhere. The fact that the MTA is so poorly maintained is perhaps evidence that shelters are likely to be poorly run too?
> I think at this point if anyone sees anyone doing this behavior the person witnessing it should run up to them while they're squatting and start kicking them as hard as they possibly can. Maybe if people start being super aggressive and act very violently these vagrants will stop, or at least realize they may get attacked. And I don't mean just kick, I mean kick with bad intentions and they [sic] intent to injure. Kick them in front of a bus if possible.
> Forget pepper spray or mace. Use Hornet Spray and shoot at the eyes. Will give you time to run away.
[1] https://gothamist.com/news/angry-upper-west-siders-wanted-ho...
I don't even associate homelessness with black. I associate it with crazy white dudes shitting everywhere - but maybe that's because I'm on the west coast where it seems the majority of homeless guys getting attention are white. I guess there's also the fact that if you were black, homeless, and crazy - you'd have been killed by the police already. Black and homeless - probably keeping lower profile as to avoid police killing you.
Posts, comments and/or views expressed in this group represent the thoughts of individual members and may not necessarily represent those of the group, other members, or the Group’s moderators and admins.
This appears to be the same guy: https://nypost.com/2020/01/21/lawyer-for-ex-ballet-benefacto...Quite frankly, I don't trust this reporting, especially since it reports someone "flashing a white power finger gesture" which was clearly the "OK" gesture. The "noose" is also ambiguous - a loop of rope on scaffolding - but I can't tell if it tightens when pulled or not.
I don't think it's a stretch to describe the "OK" sign as a "white power finger gesture" when the person making it is wearing a Trump visor and shouting "white lives matter". And I don't see how the noose is ambiguous, either — what do you think a noose is if not a loop of rope hung from somewhere?
Because OK is otherwise a common and totally neutral gesture, infact it only became a symbol of "white power" after essentially a hoax to that effect: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/ok-sign-wh...
> what do you think a noose is if not a loop of rope hung from somewhere?
I think it's a rope knotted in a specific way to tighten when pulled. Being "the shape of a noose" is irrelevant unless it bears this quality. I have loops of string/rope all over the place, none of them are nooses.
If you've been here 18 years, crime is still way below what it was when you arrived. We're at about the level we were 10 years ago. Not great but not the worst we've seen. I've been here since the 90s and it was pretty bonkers then but people flooded in anyway.
Also I'm hoping this tax rise is a prelude to statewide single-payer healthcare which is also on the legislative agenda. You can move your business to Florida or Texas and you'll be sending your tax dollars to Covid-deniers and insurrectionists.
Funnily enough, "fair" is often subjective.
Consider this article: https://www.thejournal.ie/guess-how-many-irish-tax-exiles-ha...
that quotes "refusing to pay tax like ordinary citizens" - yet the tax they are not paying is explicitly not one that ordinary citizens pay in the first place.
The truth is some places behave like anyone with money obtained that money only with assistance from their place of residence, when a lot of the time the assistance was minimal. When people relocate, this proves that point, but it's a shame it has to be that way.
I think those tax statistics about the few rich residents contributing a great share says more about inequality than unfairly high taxes.
b/c it seems the startup special sauce are the founders, not the cafe they meet up in. And other than a meeting place, how else do they benefit from the university, without the university having some stake? Even if they are students, they pay for the privilege.
> maybe the initial assistance
initial assistance in the form of a loan? Or something more subjective?
> the enabling factor
The local water company also enabled those founders to meet, but I don't expect their compensation to go further than the cost of the water bill. What kind of skin-ion-the-game do you expect the local government to have? Also, if a bunch of founders foster a startup culture ultimately benefits the area, are they owed compensation, or is culture free for the state?
> says more about inequality than unfairly high taxes
Unless you inspect the reason why that inequality exists, it says nothing beyond raw speculation.
> So what costs a lot of money to run? The university, or the hotspot?
The startup scene around a university is directly influenced by it. It created the environment the founders were meeting in. They were not moving there for the coffee place but for the university, which put a lot of resources into the founders.
> Even if they are students, they pay for the privilege. I don't believe that anywhere in the western world the university education is fully covered by the fees.
> initial assistance in the form of a loan? yes, in form of a loan or other financial assistance, legal advice, mentorship etc. Every startup I know uses some small form of initial, external funding (including bootstrapping ones). It may be only enough to pay for the cost of living of the founder and cofounder for a year, but the small initial assistance is important. It is often a public program coordinated by the startup-program at the university. I include the financial support you get if you're a student focusing on your startup.
> The local water company also enabled those founders to meet A lot of infrastructure you use if massively subsidised and is not covered by the cost (it might not be affordable by many).
> Unless you inspect the reason why that inequality exists, it says nothing beyond raw speculation. I don't think so, because you can criticise inequality itself without inspecting the reason. Can society be fair with such a massive inequality? This is a valid argument.
I think a problem is that a lot of successful people when evaluating their life attribute all their success to their personal abilities. I think this is a massive problem and not recognised enough. I see every people as an interaction between their character and their environment. The environment forms the character and the character influences the environment. You are not an isolated agent just interacting with the world, born some way and destined to success. For example, many poor people are working hard with multiple jobs to finance their living, hard work itself is not an excuse to explain away success.
Also I was arguing that if the enabling factor is the important part then moving away does not prove anything, which is still my point.
Hidden within this comment (in my reading) is the implicit assumption that you are paying your fair share. How exactly are you calculating this?
Even had you made any of the myriad good arguments (which you didn't), going the idiotic "confiscationist" route destroys any shred of credibility or objectivity you may have potentially had. You simply cannot be taken seriously when you're using such ideological flame bait to describe your positions, or more accurately, your misunderstanding of your opponents' positions.
It does not justify charging businesses a blanket amount regardless of whether they use those services, and bundle in a bunch of unrelated spending and priorities, and calling that their "fair share." If the problem was really that people who build businesses were taking advantage of public services, the answer would be to charge them for the services rendered (and when possible, give them the opportunity to obtain them elsewhere). Yeah, there's a few public goods (in the strict economic sense) that this doesn't work for, like national security the like, but if you're just talking fire protection and tractor-trailer access to roads and the like, assessments for these are eminently straightforward.
There are much better ways to justify the existence of taxes on businesses.
I've been in Texas over a decade now and presently live in Dallas. The homelessness problem is just as bad. Train infrastructure is probably worse consider there are only five lines in the entire city, and the interiors often have puke and shit all over the seats. Combine above ground power lines with constant high winds and we get power outages probably once a week, at least once a month. The city never fixes sidewalks or potholes. A quarter inch of rain results in half the traffic lights going out. I live within spitting distance of AT&T world headquarters and still can't broadband service from anyone but Spectrum, which is terrible (they once shut down my service and terminated my account because someone else gave them the wrong address and claimed to be moving into my house). Code inspectors literally sleep on the job and shoddy contractors and builders are all over the place, so you need to be extremely careful shopping for a place to live and you can expect to be making some extremely expensive repairs and upgrades within a few years of moving in, somewhat negating the advantage of lower purchase price.
It's a bit of a cultural wasteland, too, which many people won't care about, but if you're from New York, you're probably going to miss it. Dallas is thankfully pretty good for live music if you're into 70s through 90s era punk/metal/industrial type stuff, which thankfully I am, but if you're more artsy, well, the city tried to build an arts district after losing out on Boeing headquarters 20 years ago supposedly because executives wives didn't want to live in a city with no culture, but I can't say it worked out well.
Space is the saving grace. The one thing I still love about this city compared to New York is I've got a downtown townhouse five times the interior floor area as my sister-in-law in Queens at about a quarter the price of her place. But again, we've also sunk a ton of money into fixing nonsense poor craftsmanship that would have never gotten past a city that does real building inspection. My neighbor successfully sued the city for his furnace being installed upside down because the inspector was 84 and he was somehow able to prove the guy was unwilling to walk up the stairs to actually look at what he was signing off on.
I'm not trying to say it's terrible here or anything or that New York is paradise (which I wouldn't know anyway since I've only visited and never lived there). Just beware. Low taxes aren't the end all be all of life. The government still manages to be terrible in a lot of other ways besides, largely with horrible infrastructure and no maintenance, but also in smaller ways like selling your information when you register to vote or get a driver's license, making it effectively impossible to not be slammed with nonstop spam no matter how careful you otherwise are about privacy hygiene.
I wasn't the one that downvoted your comment but as fyi...
Increasing taxes doesn't automatically mean government gets increased revenue because the economic actors affected can _change_ their behaviors to circumvent that tax. So NYC probably would not get $16 billion in extra revenue.
E.g. An excerpt from an article[1] about that real life game theory playing out:
>In recent weeks, the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ have both discussed moving their data processing centers out of New Jersey in response to reports that New Jersey may impose a stock transfer tax. Technology has made processing trades away from New York’s physical trading floors simple, and the tax may provide incentive to shift stock transfers from one exchange to another. Nations such as Sweden and Germany experienced business relocation and diminished trading levels after enacting a stock transfer tax, subsequently leading them to repeal their taxes.
EDIT reply to : >They didn't have the political power to outright abolish it. What should happen now is that rebate should be removed.
Yes, you had already mentioned that proposal in your first message but your next message really didn't explain why stock owners and exchanges would simply pay the extra tax instead of changing their behavior to avoid the tax*.
[1] https://www.cityandstateny.com/articles/opinion/opinion/dont....
The STT was first imposed in 1909. They started rebating it at 100% in the 80s. They didn't have the political power to outright abolish it. What should happen now is that rebate should be removed.
The STT is a 0.5% sales tax on the value of stock trades, 0.1% on debt and 0.005% on derivatives.
"I'm taking this (goods, property, residence in a place) and I'm going to give you this (payment, lease, rent, tax) for it"
"Okay. As the owner, the price of (goods, property, residence in a place) is this."
"That's nice of you to think that but I'm not going to pay it. I'm giving you what I said I was going to. Maybe you should be nice, or I'll take the thing and give you even LESS for it"
I think in some contexts that's called extortion, not 'game theory'. Seems like the bottom line is the question of whether the owner of a thing has any property rights over the thing through owning it. If in practical terms they are obligated to sell at whatever terms the buyer demands, they're not much of a property owner.
Are the goods in this example NYSE's processing of data? Are you saying that, for example, the NYSE/NASDAQ should not be able to move data processing out of NJ in the event NJ implement a stock transfer tax?
It is however becoming harder to defend. The tax rates are out of control high, the quality of life is getting lower (subway infrastructure is disgusting; homeless out of control), apartment maintenance fees are ridiculous and it’s more dangerous than ever (while I lived here). Add to that the “you’re not paying you’re fair share attitude” which I’m definitely getting... there are days I feel like I should move our company to Florida or Texas. I can’t see myself living in a city that isn’t happy to have me.