News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by peytn on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:00AM (#26708424)
Did anyone call this early on? Would’ve been nice to hear a free and open debate from the start—I don’t recall seeing one. There are costs to doing things everywhere on the planet “just in case.”
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by stinos on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:19AM (#26708559)
Did anyone call this early on

Not in my area. That is, scientists here would beasically say: we don't know yet how well surface transmission works, so better take precautions. Which in hindsight still is the best approach in my opinion. Took a couple of months (IIRC) before it became well-accepted that chances (while existing) were fairly low. Not sure, but 'free and open' debate sounds like you want to have laymen have their say in things like this which is, again in my opinion, a bad idea. Only biologists/chemists/virologists/... have the fundamental knowledge it takes to reason about this without making mistakes. And between them there definitely was a debate, and they came to the same conclusion.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by Gibbon1 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:58AM (#26708868)
I remember trying sort things out early on. Unlike most people I used to work in the contract sterilization industry. Need 100 pallets of catheters sterilized a week? No problem we got gas chambers the size of bus. So I know a little little bit about killing bugs.

All that really bought me was seeing the 'debate' was between people that knew far less than the little I knew. Worse what most of what they thought they knew was wrong.

The big mistake was assuming that this new virus is just like this other virus they were more familiar with. Lay people and a lot of doctors used influenza as a model. Wrong. People who knew better thought the virus would behave like a not as bad SARS-Covid1 or MERS. Also wrong[1].

My conclusion a year ago was the best strategy was to take all the precautions until further notice. I thought of the doctors quip that the problem with medicine is half the treatments we give patients doesn't work. The real problem is we don't know which half. Taking all reasonable precautions then is always the correct answer.

[1] Public heath officials in the west[2] assumed that SARS-Covid2 only spread between symptomatic people like MERS and SARS-Covid1 does. That bit them on the ass but hard.

[2] Public health officials in China highly suspected asymptomatic transmission early on. But western officials categorically dismissed Chinese researchers opinions. (Big mistake #2)

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by _Microft on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:35AM (#26709113)
Asymptomatic transmission was indeed suspected but a german doctor actually discovered a case and published the first paper about it. A chinese business woman with no symptoms had infected co-workers while visiting the company's headquarters in Bavaria. She developed the disease only after returning to China (but had reported jet-lag which might have covered up some early symptoms).

Paper: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2001468

Story: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/27/world/europe/coronavirus-...

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by peytn on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:22AM (#26708596)
I never said laypeople. All biologists/chemists/virologists came to the same conclusion?

How is that possible?

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by mlyle on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:27AM (#26708626)
Easy. You end up with accumulating evidence showing that it is difficult to pull off surfaces in normal cases, and from contact tracing with the vast majority of spread explained by droplets. As evidence accumulates, people get less and less worried about fomites.

And I'm sure that not all came to the same conclusion. You can probably find some that think 5G is a major contributor. But a broad consensus forms, where people start to think of surface sterilization as somewhere between "not important at all" or "only mildly important" as a measure to prevent COVID spread.

But the precautionary principle means, until the evidence is in--- maybe using protective measures that are effective against other viruses is a sane thing to do until we know more.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by stinos on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:27AM (#26708629)
I never said laypeople

No, but you also didn't specify the people taking part in the debate. So I just tried to interpret it and suggested 2 possibilities.

All biologists/chemists/virologists came to the same conclusion?

How is that possible?

Because it makes most sense. Note that the conclusion was not "the virus spreads by surface all the time". It was: "we don't know for sure (which was completely correct at the time), so better safe than sorry".

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by peytn on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:33AM (#26708663)
It sounds like you’re assuming I’d want unqualified people to comment freely in an open debate, and also assuming that every biologist/chemist/virologist came to the same conclusion.

Those two assumptions don’t make sense to me, sorry.

I wanted to have heard from the biologists/chemists/virologists who had it right from the start. I don’t recall hearing all sides of the issue. Somebody out there surely saw this coming.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by stinos on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:00AM (#26708883)
It sounds like you’re assuming I’d want unqualified people to comment freely in an open debate

Actually I am not assuming anything. I clearly said I wasn't sure, which leaves the possibilities open.

assuming that every biologist/chemist/virologist came to the same conclusion

Not really, because I don't know every single scientist. I am still talking about the ones in my area. A couple of which I've talked to and those all agreed. And again: the conclusion at the start was not "there is high risk", it was "we do not know how high the risk is". The default mode of scientists is "we do not know" so I hope you see it's pretty easy for a group of scientists to all agree on that. Much, much easier than agreeing on something else because that requires thorough research. But basically you are right on this one: I obvisouly do not have hard evidence all possible scientists agreed they didn't know the actual risks for surface transmission, I just assume they all admit that.

I don’t recall hearing all sides of the issue.

There are many factors which influence that of course. Media in general can be problematic passing through everything.

Somebody out there surely saw this coming

Of course, but that still doesn't mean those people wouldn't agree with "we do not know for sure".

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by kevml on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:08AM (#26708473)
Debate? I’d rather rely on scientific guidance and updates as more information becomes available. Within the first few weeks we received updates that it was highly unlikely to be transmitted through surface contact. That information became more and more detailed as time went on.

There is little debate in the matter.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by garmaine on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:37AM (#26708690)
> Debate? I’d rather rely on scientific guidance and updates as more information becomes available. Within the first few weeks we received updates that it was highly unlikely to be transmitted through surface contact. That information became more and more detailed as time went on.

How do you think the science is done? The first step is to debate these things, to figure out possibilities and design experiments.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by jjk166 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @11:57AM (#26713453)
No, scientists don't debate what is true and come up with experiments after, they hypothesize and then test their hypotheses. As results come in, alternative hypotheses are proposed and likewise tested. There might be some debate as to how some data ought to be interpreted, but the data must come first.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by garmaine on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:05PM (#26715242)
And how do you think we come up with hypotheses?
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by jjk166 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:52PM (#26715816)
Curiosity.

A hypothesis is just a testable prediction - it only makes sense to have a hypothesis where you don't know the answer ahead of time. Debate is trying to convince someone else of a truth, which requires someone to know the truth (or at least believe they know the truth) beforehand.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by garmaine on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:25PM (#26719498)
Your definition of debate is overly restrictive. I can assure you that scientists debate unsettled and speculative things all the time, and precisely one of the things being debated is “what should we test for?”
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by jjk166 on Wednesday April 07, 2021 @09:55AM (#26724998)
Your definition of debate isn't the one that is relevant to this conversation. We're not referring to speculative thought, we're referring to decision making for public policy. Scientists discuss, evaluate, question, and probe, not debate. True, the people who are scientists might debate from time to time, but that's not a part of the scientific process.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by peytn on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:09AM (#26708484)
> There is little debate in the matter.

I don’t agree with that as a way to run policy that affects real people living their lives.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by afterburner on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:17AM (#26708551)
He's not literally saying there wasn't any debate. It's an expression. It means everyone already agrees.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by BoorishBears on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:17AM (#26708543)
You prefer laypeople debating to scientific consensus?

Because scientific guidance already involves debate within the scientific community, just with people actually qualified to debate it.

It seems some people are taken aback by their exclusion, but no one is stopping you from becoming a virologist and partaking in the debate.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by peytn on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:20AM (#26708572)
I never said laypeople. How did the debate amongst virologists go down?
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by BoorishBears on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:16AM (#26711388)
The comment you replied to is saying there's little room for debating scientific guidelines, and you're insisting there is.

Who were you thinking would be left to debate those guidelines when the guidelines are based on the debate of experts?

Guidelines change because the experts are still free to debate them, where there is little room for debate is following the results of said debate.

-

And what on earth are you asking me how the guidelines from virologists went for when you're the one arguing for leaving room for debate against them?

One would imagine you'd have some very clear pictures of missteps that can't be excused by the fact we were trying to fight an unknown virus killing people at an alarming rate if you're saying there's room for debating if we should follow their guidelines.

I mean go look at the evolution of discussion on COVID fomite transmission yourself.

In March we were getting studies showing long lived presence of COVID in some form on surfaces for weeks, but there was debate on if those were actually infectious amongst experts.

By April here's a virologist pointing out that the results showing weeks didn't mean it was infectious:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/coronavirusfrontlines/2020/04/0...

And for those who will not read the article but will try to respond based on the url... the conclusion was still supporting possible transmission, just for days instead if weeks. And it was still recommending aggressive disinfection:

> This suggests that risk of infection from virus on objects or surfaces in the environment can be minimized by diligent cleaning and disinfection practices.

-

The very nature of the guidelines is including the fact no all experts are going to agree, which is the point of an organization like WHO.

There is little room for debate in following what their guidelines. It's very easy to come up with armchair opinion showing how misguided that is where they were wrong, but their recommendations are based on accounting for the fact we had a global pandemic to deal with.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by refurb on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:09AM (#26708482)
Well considering every public places seems to be disinfecting every possible surface every 5 minutes, seems like the message wasn't received?
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by brundolf on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:17AM (#26708546)
I get the sense that's happening more for show: businesses want people to feel safe coming in; bragging about thorough cleaning procedures is a way of conveying that, whether it works or not
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by snakeboy on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:48AM (#26708798)
Why doesn't this reach a better equilibrium though? Consider store A who brags about disinfecting everything every half hour, and store B down the street who does the bare minimum to pass government regulations.

Shouldn't store B then be spending less money on "sanitary theatre" and can theoretically provide a marginally better service in ways that matter?

The federal government can spend however many billions of dollars for new TSA staffing and equipment, but that's because they're a monopoly in airline security. Not sure why in a free-market we'd have obviously sub-optimal outcomes like this.

(Sorry if this is naive, feel free to weigh in with harsh realities about how the real world works :) )

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by rainyMammoth on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:40AM (#26708721)
you nailed it. It is virtue signaling. A theater to display to everyone that you are on the right side of the debate and that you are taking covid seriously.

I would even bet that most people issuing the cleaning guidance know that it is almost useless, but we live in a world in which it is more important for your actions to make you perceived the way you want rather than being effective.

[dead]
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by Dma54rhs on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:22AM (#26709032)
Excessive disinfection of surfaces to fight against covid despite the evidence - what else it is then? Well maybe marketing then as well.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by flukus on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:28AM (#26709070)
I think they're right for the wrong reasons. It wasn't that it was done to be "on the right side", it was done because it was cheap, visible and allowed everything to continue as it was with as long as we all "just wash our hands". Instead of being a method to control the spread it became "the" method and other far more effective measures (masks, WFH) were ignored.

Months into the pandemic they were deep cleaning public transport in my city several times a day but not mandating masks. The cleaning probably wasn't a waste, but it was by far the less effective option. A year on the opposite is true because it took so long for science/guidance to update and for that to filter through to public policy.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by adrianN on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:15AM (#26708526)
It makes people feel safer and is relatively cheap, so public spaces are incentivized to do it.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by Roark66 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:35AM (#26709115)
>Debate? I’d rather rely on scientific guidance and updates as more information becomes available.

And how this new information is supposed to reach everyone without being twisted? I heard so much crap being said by doctors, scientists, professors etc. Not just hyperbole, and assumptions, but downright misinformation. I'm in Poland and since the beginning of the pandemic there were multiple lies coming from both government ministers and all the people representing "science" I mentioned. Some examples of lies:

"Masks don't work to protect normal people",(later)"a piece of cloth is all you need", "children don't transmit the virus(then when a new wave of infections was partially caused by children returning to in person learning - ok we fucked up, children were infecting people all along, but we need parents at work not sitting with their children at home) ", "incidence of infection in the workplace is low (then after few months data came out showing 40% of all infections are in the workplace) etc etc.

Now a year later same" leading scientists" are still being invited by the media to answer questions. All available media lie more or less. In this environment how a "typical" person is supposed to know the truth?

I can find published research articles in reputable journals, and actual data to find out what is true, but I have no idea what advice to give to my friends and family who don't have that capability. When they ask me how do you know what is true. All I can say is "read everything and make up your own mind" which is pretty poor.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by fsloth on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:18AM (#26708552)
One in 10k per contact is still non-neglible imo.

Everyone can do the math. With 100 contacts to contaminated surfaces the chance of infection grows to 0.01. If the chance to become infected per contact are just 1/2000 with 100 contacts the chances of getting infected are now 40%.

It makes perfect sense to maintain surface hygiene since those contacts accumulate statistically.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by AstralStorm on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:35AM (#26708677)
Mind you, this 1 in 10k risk is an estimate, and for safety reasons, a maximum estimate.

Actual risk is likely much lower, as you have to touch contaminated surface, then transfer the virus to nose, mouth or eyes. For public areas, properly worn masks help prevent part of the transfer too, by making it mechanically less likely, and giving more time for evaporation to inactivate the virus (e.g. by airflow)

Fomite infection risk would be higher if a contaminated surface is brought to a presumed clean area, with low ventillation, with no additional precautions taken by people.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by twooster on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:36AM (#26709125)
You're right on your first estimation:

P(getting infected per touch) = 1/10000 = .0001

P(not getting infected per touch) = 1 - P(getting infected per touch) = .9999

P(not getting infected after 100 touches) = P(not getting infected per touch) ^ 100 = .9999 ^ 100 =~ .99

P(getting infected after 100 touches) = 1 - P(not getting infected after 100 touches) =~ .01 = 1%

Or, in other words:

1 - ((1 - .0001) ^ 100) =~ .01 = 1% chance of infection

By the same logic, your second estimation is a bit off:

1/5000 = .0002

1 - ((1 - .0002) ^ 100) =~ .02 = 2% chance of infection

That's a far cry off 40%.

To think about it another way, if the chance to get infected per touch is 1/10, and you touch a surface 20 times, is your chance of infection 200%? No, that doesn't make sense. It's 1 - ((1 - 1/10) ^ 20) =~ 87.8%.

That's the problem with statistics -- "everyone can do the math", but it's pretty easy to mix it up and reach the wrong conclusions and spread misinformation.

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by fsloth on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:49AM (#26709203)
Yes, my 40% was actually with 1/2000. Thanks for checking the numbers :). Agree it's very easy to fumble numbers.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by sixstringtheory on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:05AM (#26709305)
> the chance to become infected per contact are just 1/5000 with 100 contacts

This sounds like gamblers fallacy to me. The number of trials doesn’t change the probability of individual trials in this case because each trial is statistically independent, I saw no mention of e.g. accumulating viral load via successive surface contacts.

From the article, emphasis mine:

> each contact with a contaminated surface has less than a 1 in 10,000 chance of causing an infection

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by acqq on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:57AM (#26709644)
That thought, that "the number of trials doesn’t change the probability of individual trials in this case because each trial is statistically independent" is based on a false assumption that the mathematical statement, observed alone, is all we know about the issue.

And it isn't. We know that the infection happens when enough active viruses appear on the mucosa cells of the host. We know that there are a lot of viruses in every droplet from somebody's nose or mouth. Imagine how much viruses somebody leaves on the surface if he wipes his nose with a hand, for example, and then uses that hand to handle some item.

Finally, we know how much time it takes for half of the viruses to become non functioning (half life) -- something like three days, it is, they remain in the similar numbers for quite a while on the surface. Multiple touches of the same surface on which there is certain number of viruses is nothing like a series of "independent trials."

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by jjk166 on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @12:12PM (#26713676)
You missed the if at the start of the sentence. They're not saying that the 100 contacts increases the odds, they're worrying about the effects of 100 contacts if the odds are were underestimated.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by mantap on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:48AM (#26708791)
If you took all the money spent on sanitising things and instead spent it on buying higher quality masks you'd see a much bigger effect. And this works from the individual, private enterprise or public health perspective.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by pugets on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:21AM (#26708585)
It's very unofficial, but I heard a debate last fall after city officials uprooted a children's playground over concerns of COVID spread. It lead me to an article which mentioned health officials who were advocating for opening children's playgrounds, with the CDC stating that surface transmission is "not thought to be the main way the virus spreads."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/goingoutguide/playground-safe...

Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by nostrebored on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @02:22AM (#26708594)
In the early months it was very well documented that there were no confirmed cases of surface to surface transmission.
Re:Contaminated surface has under 1 in 10k chance of causing... by cblconfederate on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:39AM (#26709153)
Yes, check out michael osterholm's joe rogan interview. He called out hand washing as basically security theater