I wouldn't throw the elder person under the bus on this one, the tactics are sophisticated, and honestly, just a precursor to what will happen with AR.
To give a bit more of how it's implemented (at least how I would propose it in iOS), Insta/FB/Whats queries available wifi SSIDs as a background process (or whatever they have for notifications/networking etc), and does the same to your therapist since you both have insta / fb / whats ... and based on the signal strength, can say with confidence you two were in the same room because XYZ Wifi strength is -Xdb just like yours (walls are strong signal augmenters), and you are both there for some time based on the background thread timestamp.
But, at the same time I've worked with FB SDK which was just one big shit show. It's hard even to describe it without turning a comment into an essay, so I'll pick the two I found somewhat amusing: sending data to FB before the developer could pass user consent (or thereof), sending hashes of the (non-FB) libraries installed on your phone to FB servers.
Minor tangent: The best thing about the web is that user agents are still pretty good at fighting some of the tracking practices (ETP/ITP, cross origin security, etc...). It's actually quite impressive. Then, native is just one big black hole. This is why the current browser changes, although positive overall (less $$ from 3p tracking), are a double edged sword (pushing people towards walled gardens).
It’s a cool thought experiment for nerds and paranoiacs to imagine how you might use relative wi-fi strengths, bluetooth beacons and complex interaction patterns, but it’s less sophisticated than that.
What's interesting thought (and I know that from my professional experience in ad tech) is that the "cookiegeddon" did push companies towards non-deterministic, more fuzzy ways of cross-device targeting (and we're talking about people who already think that fingerprinting is ethical).
The upside is that metrics are mostly bullshit anyway.
I'm honored to be called a nerd on HN... I'll ignore the latter ;)
Though while I agree the phone number is absolutely used, I don't think it's the only. Trying to get out ahead of the public's changing privacy tastes is a must for any advertiser that collects social-graph-like data. So strategically, if FB is not doing this, I would pull any FB investments because they aren't trying to do their job.
No, they dragnet every possible identifier and dump everything into a pattern recognizer.
certainly I would expect that a person who works as a therapist would be aware that the concept of client confidentiality exists and that they should not share their clients details
The problem is that someone decided to correlate them, not to mention without asking.
[1] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/Google-Maps-Wi-Fi-Location...
By the way, quoting from the article:
> "Specifically, this approach helps protect against others opting out your access point without your permission."
Oh, thank you for your kindness, Google. Yes, the idea of another person denying me the joy of having my WiFi data harvested by you is terrifying. Thanks, Google. You really know how to be helpful...
Changing one's SSID after the fact can be extremely annoying depending on the number of devices that need to be updated.
There has to be a better way.
I mean yeah, they _could_ do that, but thats a pain in the arse to do. Its far easier to do it on contact lists, interests and implied location from business page follows.
I don't think iOS allows you to track SSIDs, which explains the lack of wifi scanning utilities in the app store.
So every time you see a Google maps car ( or a Nuro car or a ...), your SSID is getting geomapped.
Now, your IP, SSID, geolocation, and who knows what else is now sitting in a lookup table somewhere.
So if they get all the other stuff that you just mentioned, they now know more about you than you do!
I love this typo.
GP visited their therapist's website, the website had FB/IG advertising tracker installed, the therapist had a campaign running that targeted all visitors from their site.
Most of the time the 'listening to me' conversations are based on origin IP to insta/fb/whatsapp servers. One person talks about idea X, another person looks it up (either in the room or later at home by themselves), and now everyone who was at that IP together will get ads for X.
What's more, Google maps uses Wifi SSIDs to get better location data when GPS gets a bit spotty... so, I'd venture to say it's a small step to associate accounts and make friends.
what's making it possible is the lack of privacy regulation. People by and large don't care enough about privacy,it's too diffuse, too complicated, the damage to oneself and others is too intangible etc.
Only way to end this is to destroy the business models that make it possible. What stands in the way of it is the mindset that this somehow harms innovation. (Innovating who can drive the titanic faster into the iceberg isn't innovation), that the government has no right to regulate private companies, and so on. The main problem is that people are trying to incrementally fix a broken thing, as Peter Ducker said
"There’s a difference between doing things right and doing the right thing. Doing the right thing is wisdom, and effectiveness. Doing things right is efficiency. The curious thing is the righter you do the wrong thing the wronger you become. If you’re doing the wrong thing and you make a mistake and correct it you become wronger. So it’s better to do the right thing wrong than the wrong thing right. Almost every major social problem that confronts us today is a consequence of trying to do the wrong things righter"
Not to play dumb or sealion, but what opportunities are they given to do so? How often have those opportunities been one-and-done, "if you don't do something to protect your privacy in this particular instance at this particular moment, it's gone forever?"
I don't think that question really captures it, because an easy response to that is "Why do I care? Why is my privacy so important that it's a problem that it's gone forever?" To some of us that might seem like an absurd question; we see privacy as an obviously valuable thing that we are struggling to maintain.
But I don't think that's the case for most people; I think most people adopt the "I have nothing to hide, so what does it matter?" attitude. Especially when they (likely correctly) believe that online services that are central to their lives (like GMail or GDocs or Facebook or Instagram or WhatsApp) wouldn't be free to use if they didn't give up their data (and privacy) in return for the service.
You can try to point to data breaches, but, even then, most of those don't have a tangible effect on people. 533M Facebook users' phone numbers and personal data leaked? Most of those 533M probably won't notice anything bad happening because of it, and any bad stuff that does happen... well, they probably won't be able to draw a causal line from the FB breach to the bad things.
I think when this comes up it's a rationalization when the question becomes personal, "what if YOU had your identity stolen." However, for large-scale stories like this, I think defeatism drives the response more than a sense of innocence. You can't fight city hall, a cultural principle that anything a business does is justified, and other "oh well!" type reactions.
I think that the existing incentives can be moved, but we will need a chance in mentality that might require a generational shift, or who knows what how many fucks-ups. I'm becoming more and more pessimistic wrt to the latter.
There should also be transparency of who has the consent right (data licensee and sublicensee)
And there should be a way to make easy consequences for people not having it
Release forms and licenses are used this way, data should inherit that. (Both systems should be better)
What about your phone number? Does your therapist have it? Maybe your therapist granted Instagram/Facebook access to her contacts?
Or maybe you yourself granted Instagram access and your therapist is in your phone's contact list?
If the web had made things easier, this would have happened less, but web developers didn't care enough, and FB ate their lunch.
An average HN reader is in a very comfortable situation compared to the remaining 99.9% of the population, who might not have time to think about this.
Unless, and I might've misunderstood you, by "us" you mean the people who work on those platforms, and have the time and resources to think about these matters, in which case I'd say that I agree with your statement. What's worse is how much brain power we're wasting on solving problems that shouldn't exist in the first place.
"The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads"
I'm no attorney, but isn't there a doctor-patient confidentiality breach (in the U.S.) if a psychologist/iatrist's rolodex gets Facebooked out to the ad tech bidding systems?
Exactly, the industry is built on a foundation of obfuscating the myriad ways in which they are using people's personal data. Uninformed consent is the cornerstone of their business model.
Regulation that forbids non-consensual data collection such as the GDPR ought to fix that, but its lack of enforcement means it didn't have any effect on the market. Once regulation starts being enforced, it will rebalance the market where paid services will start to be viable because free services would no longer be profitable.
I know it’s not easy if you are addicted to it but it’s doable.
Cases like yours is why we created https://yourdigitalrights.org/d/facebook.com, which makes its dead simple to send such requests. Free & open source.
We are working on automating the escalation to the DPA part as well.
Facebook:
> Thank you for contacting Facebook. We have reviewed your report and it appears you would like to delete your Facebook account.
>
> Please note, for security reasons, we are unable to delete accounts on behalf of users so you will need to log into your account and delete it yourself. We have put in place a very quick and easy process for people to schedule the permanent deletion of their Facebook account.
>
> Before permanently deleting your account, you may want to log in and download a copy of your information from Facebook. Once your account has been deleted, it cannot be recovered.
However, after back and forth with them for a few weeks, I got this:
Hi,
Thank you for contacting Facebook. Based on the information you've provided, it looks like you're trying to request the erasure of certain personal data under Article 17 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
If you wish to ask for personal data relating to you to be erased in accordance with the GDPR, please use the following form: https://www.facebook.com/help/contact/259518714718624?ref=cr
Additionally, as per your request, your account has been scheduled to be deleted.
Please keep in mind that you have up to 30 days to cancel the deletion. Once your account has been processed for deletion, it may take up to 90 days for all of your information to be permanently deleted.
For more details, please visit the Help Center article below:
https://www.facebook.com/help/224562897555674
We store data until it is no longer necessary to provide our services and Facebook Products, or until your account is deleted, whichever comes first. This is a case-by-case determination that depends on things like the nature of the data, why it is collected and processed, and relevant legal or operational retention needs. For example, when you search for something on Facebook, you can access and delete that query from within your search history at any time, but the log of that search is deleted after 6 months. If you submit a copy of your government-issued ID for account verification purposes, we delete that copy 30 days after submission.
Learn more about deletion of content you have shared (https://www.facebook.com/help/356107851084108?ref=cr) and cookie data obtained through social plugins (https://www.facebook.com/help/206635839404055?ref=cr).
When you delete your account, we delete things you have posted, such as your photos and status updates, and you won't be able to recover that information later. Information that others have shared about you isn't part of your account and won't be deleted.
If you have another question or concern, please visit Privacy Basics (https://www.facebook.com/about/basics?ref=cr) or our Help Center (https://www.facebook.com/help?ref=cr) for additional information.If you have more questions about our Data Policy (https://www.facebook.com/policy.php?ref=cr), please reply to this message.
Thanks, Privacy Operations
So what? What's the harm?
People sure like to write emotionally charged posts arguing for privacy, but they're always suspiciously low on details on what bad things (actually) happened.
Even in this case with phone numbers and other data leaked, so what? What harm do data leaks cause?
Seems like making a fuss about nothing.
> How are we still ok with this shit?
We're ok with a lot of shit. I think if we were to make a list of shit this would rank pretty low.
> they're always suspiciously low on details on what bad things (actually) happened.
- Hyper-targeted advertising
- Voter manipulation
- Surveillance of dissent
- Arresting dissidents
- Leaking sensitive medical data
- Leaking private pictures, videos, conversations
- Leaking your home and work address (hello stalkers and jealous ex-husbands!)
- Being refused medical treatment or having premiums skyrocket
But yeah, nothing serious, why are you so paranoid man? Conform, citizen!
As long as the legal justice system hasn't caught up with that (in the sense of efficiency and prevention of financial problems) every data point that's leaked about you is a potential threat.
> fuss about nothing
Ever heard about rape victims? Ever heard about stalkers? Ever heard about psychological threats? Ever heard about someone being forced to do something they don't want? Ever heard about the fappening? How do you think those things have happened in the past and literally ruined people's lives?
And that's the point: most people haven't, and many who have probably weren't able to link it to something specific like "Facebook vacuumed up all my data and then lost it". And "most people" are the people who influence and make policy.
Lets imagine a situation. You've got an officially looking letter, from unknown to you organization, claiming that for example, your lawn is infected by a grass variant of COVID-19 and must be disinfected, and this organization could do it in a jiffy for a mere $1k.
Probably it is a scam, isn't it? How do you judge it? One of the sign of a scam is a lack of personal information in the letter. But if you see that letter contains your name, address, phone number, lawn dimensions, then you probably shouldn't throw letter to a garbage bin, you should find some other kind of test to judge is it a scam. Isn't it?
So when you made your personal information public, scam detection is going to impose bigger costs on you. Even if we assume that you are perfect scam detector and will not let any of scam to pass you undetected, then the lot of people are not perfect in this regard. So the more difficult detection is, the more prey for scammers. It impose costs for a society overall, because society start to give money to scammers, to finance all that activity that is counter productive for an economic growth.
But as for me it is just a nuisance to decipher such letters trying to spend as little time on a scam detection as possible while having no false positives.
Two bad things (random selection, because the comments below already make some really good points):
1. targeted behavioural advertising is proven to increase polarisation, literally turning people against each other.
A single instance of violating someone's privacy doesn't matter as much as your single vote won't shift the result of elections. But a single vote does matter, because is a part of a bigger whole.
2. My family member suffers from PTSD acquired because of living in an abusive relationship for 2 decades. That person started a new life, but ads targeted at her and her partner more than once triggered actual panic attacks. I know this might sound ridiculous without the context. This is because that person didn't understand how clever the tech behind targeting was and assumed that the ads were related to their partner cheating on them. It's irrational, I know, but we're talking about someone who is psychologically vulnerable.
I'd still say that 1. is a more important argument here, 2. just follows the line of thinking presented in your comment. (the main problem behind 2. is that person's mental state and the actions of their abuser, yet the amount of suffering that could've been removed is not negligible.)
> Even in this case with phone numbers and other data leaked, so what? What harm do data leaks cause?
Cambridge Analytica, voter manipulation, bias in behavioural targeting, increased polarisation in media--please Google these queries and educate yourself. There's a tonne of resources on the subject, including peer reviewed academic papers.
Can you provide some evidence for this please? Certainly, filter bubbles make it easier for people to radicalise themselves, but I've not seen very much evidence that it's specifically the advertising.
And polarisation in (US) media has been underway since long before Mark Zuckerberg left elementary school.
And I expect that the majority of the population has not experienced the horror of your #2.
If the majority (in this case, likely vast majority) doesn't care about something, there probably is not going to end up being any public policy protecting against it.
Because you know, what does it matter, right?
Information security can be about trust, i.e. I trust that person A sent this message because of X, y, z. I also trust that the message hasn't been tampered with because of X, y, z.
Privacy is a sub/side topic of information security. E.g. keeping all network connection data about an individual obfuscated at all times i.e. All data is kept hidden in a way that cannot be made unhidden.
Privacy is part of information security, and serves to ensure certain systems could be considered secure in certain cases (depends on the threat model/requirements of the system).
Basically, you've got it the wrong way around. Privacy (as a purely technical idea) exists to keep some information secure in certain cases.
Recent Fawkes paper is a good example of privacy as a security consideration.
Now for a case where it doesn't matter...
Whenever you're asked to run an MD5 hash check of a file you've just downloaded, that's an example of authentication/verification.
Doesn't matter if someone has seen that you've downloaded the file, just that the downloaded file is correct (for you).
Good example is Linux OS distribution ISOs.
Privacy doesn't really matter in that case (depending on your threat model), what matters is that the file you've downloaded matches what you wanted to downloaded. No-one intercepted and tampered with the data in transit.
You can trust the data that you've downloaded.
It doesn't matter if Mr FBI saw that I downloaded it, because it's not illegal. So why waste energy and resources on solving a problem that's not a problem?!
Now on to protection of confidential data...
Facebook is actually a good example of this. Most people are not anonymous on there. You can search and find people (depending on settings). Privacy, in that sense, is not provided.
However, they do (or are supposed to) keep our data protected from external malicious adversaries, whilst not making it completely private to everyone.
I can see my friends information, it is not private. It is, however, supposed to be protected and kept safe e.g. a credit card number.
A credit card number can't be completely obfuscated because then it can't be used. Instead, that personal information should be protected.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_security
Now, in relation to the parent of the parent of the.....
The point of the comment, and I agreed with it, is that if personal information is leaked to the public -- that's not privacy, it is improper confidential data access -- really bad things can happen.
I can call that number every 2 minutes to perform a denial of service attack (eventually they'll turn their phone off, no more phone service!).
I could send horrific child porn to that number.
I could do X, y, z with a phone number.
I don't need passwords and encryption keys or zero day access to your hardened Linux box to fuck up your life.
I can do it with a phone number.
And here's the real kicker --- I don't even know who this person is! They're anonymous to me. Their privacy is mostly intact, but I've got access to confidential information which means I can fuck up their life regardless.
So your point of "well, why don't they just give out access to ALL the confidential information" was, actually, kind of on point!
That's exactly the kind of data we definitely do not want out in the wild. That's extremely sensitive data with which I could cause absolute havoc!
Where you fell down was the "leak all of it cos why not". One tiny piece of leaked confidential data can be massively dangerous. That was the point of the comment.
One tiny piece of data and I can ruin your life. I don't need everything, just one thing. One phone number.
Hopefully that was helpful. It's all a shade of grey depending on your threat model tbh.
The sooner we get rid of the cancer that FB is, the better. I didn’t share my contact book with FB apps either. It was probably her—a person in her 70s, not necessarily experienced with tech.
The main reason this company exists, or that ad tech can maintain a facade of not being a mainly bullshit industry with made up metrics, is the lack of informed consent.
It’s almost funny how we accept the current situation as normal. Because, I think that we’ll look back at these times with disbelief of reckless we were and how cheap we’d sell ourselves.