Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by Roboprog on Friday June 17, 2011 @04:42PM
(#2667000)
The irony of Greenspan worrying about Federal debt when he was pushing to NOT pay it off a decade ago -- tax cuts solved that.
And setting interest rates below inflation really killed off the idea of anybody saving money (cash) in the bank only to watch it evaporate. Cursed Fed. Printing money like mad does help generate inflation, though, which helps keep labor costs (our pay) down by effectively handing workers a little pay cut every year.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by Spyro7 on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:29PM
(#2667335)
"does help generate inflation, though, which helps keep labor costs (our pay) down by effectively handing workers a little pay cut every year"
You do realize that wages are adjusted for cost of living changes over time? (This is a gross simplification of the actual process, but the fact remains that wages are not constant in the face of inflation.)
Take a look at this please (using median wage here to make this more clear):
It is also worth noting that the average wage back in the '70s was roughly $8,000.00.
Edited in Response to Downvoting:
Inflation is caused by rising prices, and wages are one of these prices. Your wage is simply the price of your labor. In the long-run, wages are flexible just like all of the other prices. Admittedly wolfram|alpha does not have extensive historical graphs available, but I am not trying to write a book here.
If you are down-voting because you have not received a pay increase lately, then you should be aware of the fact that wages are usually a bit more sticky than other prices in the short run.
If you are down-voting this, I would appreciate engaging you in honest discussion about the point that I made above.
The parent post said that inflation gives workers a little pay cut every year. Painting this wonderful image of a worker sliding into poverty. This is demonstrably false. Yes, a 1% or a 2% rise in inflation will impact your real earnings, but wages are not a static process and they do reflect the actual costs of living changes that take place over time.
As an economist, I am constantly amazed by how poorly the press discusses inflation and how little most people know about what inflation is and how it interacts with other variables within an economy. Please read this pdf for some discussion on wages and price inflation:
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by Spyro7 on Friday June 17, 2011 @09:59PM
(#2667727)
What struck me as odd was being down-voted without anyone telling me what it was that rubbed them the wrong way.
The reason that I hang around HN is because I learn a lot by doing so. When someone down-votes something and then runs off, no one actually benefits in any way from that (unless the post that was down-voted was complete trash).
My extensive edit was an attempt to lure out the down-voters so that I could find out exactly where the wheels came off in the original post.
Looking back, I probably should have angled for a less confrontational tone in my edit, but I have a hard time getting tone across in these things.
You know, you spend less time typing each post than you would spend on a research paper or an email but more time than a text message. It is a challenging thing to get the tone just right. I much prefer face to face conversation any day of the week, but I like this place a lot.
The thing is that this is my first time actually not lurking on a site in nearly 10 years, and HN has its own unique culture.
Look, you've been on this site for more than an order of magnitude longer than me. Do you (or anyone else) feel like helping a newbie out:
When anonymous down-votes strike, is it better to reply to yourself, keep your edits small, or just walk away?
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by anamax on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:37PM
(#2667351)
> The irony of Greenspan worrying about Federal debt when he was pushing to NOT pay it off a decade ago.
Some might argue that there's a qualitative difference between $160B/year when you owe $10T and $1.6T/year when you owe $14T.
> -- tax cuts solved that.
Did they? How much less revenue was collected?
Never confuse tax rates with tax revenues. The latter pays for things while the former has only a tenuous relationship with the latter. For example, the US got far more from rich people with low rates than it ever got with high rates.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by j_baker on Friday June 17, 2011 @05:29PM
(#2667160)
During normal times you'd be correct. But bear in mind that inflation is (or was) near 0% during the recession. A certain amount of inflation is necessary for the economy and is much less scary than getting stuck in a deflationary cycle like what we saw during the Great Depression.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by anonymoushn on Friday June 17, 2011 @08:17PM
(#2667567)
I expect much of the exposure is in the form of credit default swaps (CDS). A CDS is an instrument by which the insurer assumes the risk associated with some reference instrument in exchange for a cut of the revenue associated with that instrument. In the case of a 2-year Greek bond (currently yielding 20%), Alice and Bob might draw up an agreement that says that Alice can have 15% throughout the term of the bond as long as she pays Bob the defaulted amount in the case of default.
These instruments are, by themselves, not particularly dangerous. What is dangerous is that there is generally no regulatory requirement for the people who are selling these contracts to actually have any money, which means that the people who are buying these contracts might be greatly understating their exposure. If there are large numbers of outstanding unbacked CDS, the situation is similar to what occurred with AIG in 2008. Because CDS are not exchange traded, we don't have a reasonable way of knowing how much risk is out there.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by c2 on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:54PM
(#2667408)
Except most of the banks have paid back TARP. Most major banks are back to 10+ % profit margins (only one lower I found was BAC).
Out of the 700 billion TARP fund, only 51 billion remains outstanding (as of September last year), which is larger then the 41 billion number you were floating around:
I'm not saying all banks will be fine if Greece "defaults" (remember in this case "defaulting" implies restructed debt), but causing a US recession? Highly highly unlikely.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by c2 on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:44PM
(#2667373)
I've never heard any claims that the 41 billion will just disappear. The worst I've heard is that they will restructure the loans to extend pay back dates.
Also, from the article, the banks have a drop in the bucket exposure to these loans, which isn't even reporting in their annual reports as a risk. The highest exposure bank seems to be half a billion on BoA's balance sheets, and like I said, it isn't like that debt obligation is just going to disappear.
There's a lot of FUD around Greece "defaulting", and like I said, I think the main impact area will be the stock market, not necessarily bank balance sheets or the economy at large.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by dpapathanasiou on Friday June 17, 2011 @07:04PM
(#2667425)
"The real "defaulting" in this case means they will restructure the debt."
So far, all proposals to do that have been shot down by the ECB b/c even with longer and more generous terms, Greece is not in a position to service the debt, let alone repay it.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by ignifero on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:53PM
(#2667405)
It's that fearmongering that keeps greece from officially defaulting though, eventhough it's officially incapable of paying its debt for a year now. It's kind of irrational fear, too. I mean, japan's earthquake alone cost ~300 billion and there was no new crisis.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by blantonl on Friday June 17, 2011 @08:06PM
(#2667546)
There is no new financial crisis yet from the Japan earthquake.
But the problem with your assumption is that the real economic damage occurs just immediately after a disaster.
The reality is that the actual economic affects of the Japan earthquake will only begin to really show in the next five years. With what is happening at Fukushima now, and the associated supply chain disruptions that are already filtering down the creek, there should be serious cause for concern.
I personally made a long term bet in the Japanese market shortly after the quake, but you can "bet" that it won't pay off for a long time.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by WildUtah on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:46PM
(#2667382)
Greenspan says default because he doesn't think the Greek government will pay.
The Euro is in fine shape because investors don't expect to lose money on their Greek bonds.
What is the difference? Investors (and probably Greenspan) expect the Germans to bail out the Greeks and pay off their debts. So the Greeks will default and the investors will still keep their money.
The main problem in the whole situation is hiding the deal from German voters and taxpayers. Nobody wants to take responsibility for TARP.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by tatsuke95 on Friday June 17, 2011 @08:48PM
(#2667618)
Not sure why this is down voted. It's relevant. If Greece goes down, it will be a signal to the markets that what was previously unthinkable is now realistic. The PIIGS are deep in shit.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by ChrisLTD on Friday June 17, 2011 @04:44PM
(#2667009)
I was taught in journalism school to mention the subject's age when possible. It doesn't take a lot of space and can be valuable information in some cases.
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by gaius on Friday June 17, 2011 @05:05PM
(#2667075)
It's important context. It tells you a lot about the events that a person has lived through that inform their opinions. I'm too young to have any real memories of stagflation and Reaganomics, for example, but I can tell you all about the NASDAQ meltdown of '01...
Re:Greenspan Says Greece Default ‘Almost Certain,’ May Trigg...
by anamax on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:41PM
(#2667363)
> US problems have nothing to do with Greece.
The argument is that US banks hold a fair amount of european bank paper and that european banks hold a lot of greek debt. If the greeks default, then those european banks are in trouble, which puts the US banks in trouble.
We saw a variation on this at the beginning of the "great recession". US banks held too much Fannie and Freddie stock because the regulators gave it special status. When fannie and freddie went down, those banks became technically insolvent.
I don't know what triggered Lehmann Bros' specific problems, but when it went under, that caused problems for its counterparties.
And setting interest rates below inflation really killed off the idea of anybody saving money (cash) in the bank only to watch it evaporate. Cursed Fed. Printing money like mad does help generate inflation, though, which helps keep labor costs (our pay) down by effectively handing workers a little pay cut every year.
You do realize that wages are adjusted for cost of living changes over time? (This is a gross simplification of the actual process, but the fact remains that wages are not constant in the face of inflation.)
Take a look at this please (using median wage here to make this more clear):
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=all+occupations+median+...
However, here is median wage too: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=all+occupations+mean+wa...
It is also worth noting that the average wage back in the '70s was roughly $8,000.00.
Edited in Response to Downvoting:
Inflation is caused by rising prices, and wages are one of these prices. Your wage is simply the price of your labor. In the long-run, wages are flexible just like all of the other prices. Admittedly wolfram|alpha does not have extensive historical graphs available, but I am not trying to write a book here.
If you are down-voting because you have not received a pay increase lately, then you should be aware of the fact that wages are usually a bit more sticky than other prices in the short run.
If you are down-voting this, I would appreciate engaging you in honest discussion about the point that I made above.
The parent post said that inflation gives workers a little pay cut every year. Painting this wonderful image of a worker sliding into poverty. This is demonstrably false. Yes, a 1% or a 2% rise in inflation will impact your real earnings, but wages are not a static process and they do reflect the actual costs of living changes that take place over time.
As an economist, I am constantly amazed by how poorly the press discusses inflation and how little most people know about what inflation is and how it interacts with other variables within an economy. Please read this pdf for some discussion on wages and price inflation:
https://www.clevelandfed.org/research/policydis/pd1.PDF
It is an academic piece, but it is one of my favorites for illustrating the interaction between wages and the greater macroeconomy.
Why couldn't you let your original post stand as you posted it?
The reason that I hang around HN is because I learn a lot by doing so. When someone down-votes something and then runs off, no one actually benefits in any way from that (unless the post that was down-voted was complete trash).
My extensive edit was an attempt to lure out the down-voters so that I could find out exactly where the wheels came off in the original post.
Looking back, I probably should have angled for a less confrontational tone in my edit, but I have a hard time getting tone across in these things.
You know, you spend less time typing each post than you would spend on a research paper or an email but more time than a text message. It is a challenging thing to get the tone just right. I much prefer face to face conversation any day of the week, but I like this place a lot.
The thing is that this is my first time actually not lurking on a site in nearly 10 years, and HN has its own unique culture.
Look, you've been on this site for more than an order of magnitude longer than me. Do you (or anyone else) feel like helping a newbie out:
When anonymous down-votes strike, is it better to reply to yourself, keep your edits small, or just walk away?
Some might argue that there's a qualitative difference between $160B/year when you owe $10T and $1.6T/year when you owe $14T.
> -- tax cuts solved that.
Did they? How much less revenue was collected?
Never confuse tax rates with tax revenues. The latter pays for things while the former has only a tenuous relationship with the latter. For example, the US got far more from rich people with low rates than it ever got with high rates.
I fail to see how a Greece debt restructuring would negatively impact the US economy except to cause a little more fear on wall street.
Also - anyone else notice that the only people who seem to give praise to Greenspan are his ex-colleagues in the central bank?
These instruments are, by themselves, not particularly dangerous. What is dangerous is that there is generally no regulatory requirement for the people who are selling these contracts to actually have any money, which means that the people who are buying these contracts might be greatly understating their exposure. If there are large numbers of outstanding unbacked CDS, the situation is similar to what occurred with AIG in 2008. Because CDS are not exchange traded, we don't have a reasonable way of knowing how much risk is out there.
Is $41 billion at risk insignificant?
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/greece-poses-41-billion-ris...
Compared to my personal holdings, I'd be willing to consider even half of that amount significant. Send my bailout as a check or money order, please.
Plus the $41 billion number is just an estimate; the real total won't be known until all the derivative contracts are unwound.
Either way, it would be a mistake to dismiss a Greek default as irrelevant to us.
Out of the 700 billion TARP fund, only 51 billion remains outstanding (as of September last year), which is larger then the 41 billion number you were floating around:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870343160457552...
I'm not saying all banks will be fine if Greece "defaults" (remember in this case "defaulting" implies restructed debt), but causing a US recession? Highly highly unlikely.
But even according to the article you posted, bank balance sheets are still weak.
Losing $41 billion (or more, possibly, given the nature of these derivatives) is not going to be good news for them.
While technically not in recession, the economy is not thriving, either, and so one blow like this may indeed push it back into recession.
Also, from the article, the banks have a drop in the bucket exposure to these loans, which isn't even reporting in their annual reports as a risk. The highest exposure bank seems to be half a billion on BoA's balance sheets, and like I said, it isn't like that debt obligation is just going to disappear.
There's a lot of FUD around Greece "defaulting", and like I said, I think the main impact area will be the stock market, not necessarily bank balance sheets or the economy at large.
What do you think default means?
It has happened before, most recently with Argentina in 2002, and with Russia in 1998, which triggered the LTCM crisis.
"The worst I've heard is that they will restructure the loans to extend pay back dates."
That is just default in everything but name.
The reason the so-called seven year Vienna plan has so much resistance is that ECB members know they'll never get paid back.
It is a credit agency's definition of "default", but it won't be as adverse as the money disappearing from balance sheets.
So far, all proposals to do that have been shot down by the ECB b/c even with longer and more generous terms, Greece is not in a position to service the debt, let alone repay it.
But the problem with your assumption is that the real economic damage occurs just immediately after a disaster.
The reality is that the actual economic affects of the Japan earthquake will only begin to really show in the next five years. With what is happening at Fukushima now, and the associated supply chain disruptions that are already filtering down the creek, there should be serious cause for concern.
I personally made a long term bet in the Japanese market shortly after the quake, but you can "bet" that it won't pay off for a long time.
The Euro is in fine shape because investors don't expect to lose money on their Greek bonds.
What is the difference? Investors (and probably Greenspan) expect the Germans to bail out the Greeks and pay off their debts. So the Greeks will default and the investors will still keep their money.
The main problem in the whole situation is hiding the deal from German voters and taxpayers. Nobody wants to take responsibility for TARP.
The argument is that US banks hold a fair amount of european bank paper and that european banks hold a lot of greek debt. If the greeks default, then those european banks are in trouble, which puts the US banks in trouble.
We saw a variation on this at the beginning of the "great recession". US banks held too much Fannie and Freddie stock because the regulators gave it special status. When fannie and freddie went down, those banks became technically insolvent.
I don't know what triggered Lehmann Bros' specific problems, but when it went under, that caused problems for its counterparties.