The toy explanation for how it works is that we have people who take risks, and they have to be rewarded now and again, otherwise why would anyone do it? So it has to be possible to trade that risk too, so that the risk ends up in the appropriate place. It needs to be possible to run a business at a loss in order to search for profits (product-market fit, etc).
We seem to have taken this to an extreme that rewards people who haven't made something useful. If I have a great idea for new kind of lemonade stand, I can get it started at a loss, but if I can convince someone else to buy it, I can cash out with more than I put in. They can go and "develop" the idea and sell that up to someone else. Sounds fine, and should be fine, in theory. Most people could probably think of a few defenses: they're only losing their own money, losses impose a disclipline that forces them to listen to customers, and it's everyone's interest to make money in the end.
The downsides are not so obvious.
Everyone can start a lemonade stand, and sure enough there are loads of them all over. But who gets to try? People who can get access to the risk capital. It's not quite the same as the alternative world where ventures need to make money reasonably fast, or sink. It also means if you try on your own, you are competing with much more patient people who can afford to lose for longer. So now, you can't even try your own without giving a piece to someone else, who gets to decide who gets a shot and who doesn't.
Take Wikipedia for example. They lose money running a high traffic service (edit: see below reply for clarification), but it's plain to see they hold a huge asset in terms of goodwill, usage, knowledge base, and their contribution to research and knowledge growth. Despite its operating losses, its capital value (which may be in the form of social capital) is huge and will likely remain well financed into the foreseeable future.
The fact that the service is free is not relevant: a startup offering an invaluable service that is based on years of user research, development and testing has developed an asset which helps other companies and companies pay what they think it is worth (or at the beginning a subsidized rate to take a risk to try it). Operating losses at most start ups are from continued R&D; but if they were to just declare the product as "done" and have a sufficient moat/network, they could rent seek on the asset for years - yet in many cases that's not what is best for anyone (company, clients or shareholders) - we continue to want them to innovate for the good of the product and there will be stakeholders that would rather finance this research in perpetuity to grow the underlying asset and thus the value of the product and company.
Inductively, that's a company with negative NOL but positive NPV. In the physical world this might be the same as an apartment complex that's expanding (forever). They may currently collect $1M in rent, but they are spending $2M on new construction. The new construction may bring in $5M over its 30 year lifespan but it will never be enough to outpace the immediate outlay of continued construction cost. As long as the time value of money is correctly attributed, this isn't a new idea - just one that's been pulled to an extreme.
B) Wikipedia makes money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Fundraising_statisti...
VC Cash and donations are a finite resource constrained by their stock pool and their leverage.
Donations dont have these limitations.
The wiki (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikimedia_Foundation) tagline suggests the underlying truth. Wikipedia gets ~half of its revenue from the investment-based endowment managed by the Tides Foundation. The leveraged capital is largely at the charity of large organizations (like google, amazon, etc) who have donated to that endowment over time, plus the remnants of their initial investment portfolio afaict.
Wikipedia would inevitably scale back in size without the continued charity of individuals and organizations around the world.
The Wikimedia foundation brought in US$104.5 million (2018) and only spent US$81.4 million (2018) even as their funding many projects independent from Wikipedia.
In the end donations are just revenue.
My unpopular opinion is that the diversity push in tech ultimately comes down to everyone looking around nervously as they realize that who you are and what you look like counts more than how you think and what you can do - and what that means for the viability and sustainability of a space built on a mythos of meritocracy. There is an awareness that there are a number of perhaps raw, but good, products and potentially even careers (which may or may not require extra guidance to thrive) which are being passed over for gussied-up trivia and tripe, because the founders or team don't look the part.
That said, I don't know that profitability is ultimately the be-all-end-all of merit anyway. There are many services and institutions that should be run, even if merely at cost or in the red, because of the dividends they pay to society. I think we need to get better at identifying what those are, and especially at determining how much leeway to give them.
Do you mean the USA, or tech in general?
In the UK, whilst there is VC money, it tends to be less, and more focused. I believe the bankruptcy laws in the US vs the UK are significantly different to the point where attitude to risk influences business start ups.
In the US, from this side of the pond, venture capital investment appears very cavalier, with VCs throwing money left, right and centre, hoping that they'll land on the next unicorn. In the UK, VC money is much more targeted on start ups with a plan to profitability.
I'm not sure how the bankruptcy laws come into this though? Limited liability corporations exist everywhere, and there's mostly no suggestion of piercing-the-veil fraud or dishonesty.
This isn't to say that they don't have funding, but the funding takes a more strategic approach of requiring real developments and profit, whereas a lot of US talent is tied up in adtech giants who cut products or in VC companies with no real path forward.
Switzerland won’t give you a visa if you’ve ever had a bankruptcy. In some countries bankruptcy is a crime.
In the case of this particular tweetstorm, the business was likely not incorporated as the author kept feeding it from his own bank account.
Also note a parallel comment referring to the consequences of corporate bankruptcy in the UK. I used Switzerland as an example. The US is an extreme outlier; this has long been cited by many people as a factor in its success (though the belief is hardly universal or there would by now be many others who copied the example).
That is a terrible assumption. Of course the business was incorporated. There is nothing stopping you from investing money into an LLC or corporation. That's how VC funding works.
Investors always look for the best risk weighted return. Startups are risk-apetite constrained not money constrained.
Also, it's a big employment program. Think of it like that. The central bank injects money into the system, it gets allocated based on expected risk-weighted returs (adjusted for some other factors like social hierarchy, access, ESG, etc).
The formula is the same. Simple product sectors (where there are no network effects, and no other kind of moat either) are basically pay to own markets. Now in cheap money world it's an endless fight between companies with enormous warchests.
Still, as others mentioned in the twitter thread there are bootstrapped successful apps (eg. todoist), but they are completely at the mercy of user preferences. When a next such app comes some of their users will switch over. Sure, maybe the market is stable enough for them to have a small slice for the foreseeable future.
Asana is useful. That’s why it’s growing.
The company continues to lose money not because the product isn’t useful, but because it’s so useful and popular that the investors choose to spend more money capturing market share than organic growth would allow.
So is the use of opiods and painkillers, at the right scale.
VCs and the Softbank's of the world willing to spend so much of "other people's money" like they have a never-ending fountain of it make it really hard to find out what is the right scale of things.
Even with Amazon which is often criticized for not paying dividends or running without profits for so long, they knew that the revenue was there and that Bezos could turn a few knobs whenever he wanted to slow down on growth investment and start collecting some profits. Is that true for Asana? How much more market share do they need to get to actually being profitable? What would happen if they slowed down their marketing spending?
Lemonade stands are a perfect example to illustrate business concepts.
Case in point: continuous data protection. If you were around ca. 2004 you might have heard of this. Like backup, only to any second in the past. Nowadays we might say git for your entire storage system. Anyway, I was a fairly early employee at one of the original companies in the space. It was our marketing VP who coined the term. We worked really hard to promote the idea, and often collaborated with our competitors in that (much like Asana in this story).
Of course, that initial spirit of shared mission eventually disappeared. At that point, VC-backed and BigCo competitors were all spinning up their own products, backed by many times the engineering and (even more importantly) marketing budgets. They didn't actually win head to head, because they didn't actually have any products, but they totally froze the market. Storage is a hard market for a startup in the best of times, and these weren't the best of times, so that company ended up in a fire sale to Veritas/Symantec. End of story. It's pretty unremarkable in itself, except that I could tell almost the same story about half of the other startups I worked at.
None of this is necessarily bad. Just "creative destruction" and all that. In the end good ideas do get implemented and benefit users and make someone a lot of money. Unfortunately, those people are rarely the ones who innovated. When it happens over and over and over throughout the industry, it starts to seem like VCs are setting up incentives to be a copier (at best) rather than an innovator, and I'm not sure that's healthy in the long term.
That is in fact exactly what I called it when I wrote about this on my blog. It's definitely a part of how things happen "naturally" but that's also why I think VCs should act to counter it instead of magnifying it.
I'm not sure where along the line IPOs changed from "profitable company raises money from the public" to "private investors parachute out and dump their losses on Joe Schmuck".
Private investors "parachute out" only 20% of their stake in an IPO to investors who willingly buy into the story because they believe (rightly or wrongly) in the upside.
It's not exactly like Joe Schmuck is unwillingly forced to hold on a hot potato
But the underlying point is that the markets are disconnected from reality, and - fair play to them - the VCs are capitalizing on it.
One day I'll actually set aside a few hours to go through a list of all tech companies that IPO'd in the last 5 years, and see which ones have actually made a profit. Gut feeling is that the "flashy" ones are still burning through cash reserves (Asana/Slack/Uber), but the more boring ones (Rackspace/Pivotal/etc) are probably sitting pretty.
You might find site helpful. https://postipononprofits.com/
This is outdated a bit in terms of numbers (doesn’t include recent years and excludes many companies), but the broad point remains. You are right, there are ton of companies built around the idea of dumping it on someone else before turning a profit. This has become the ‘formula’ for building companies, unfortunately.
Though such language and sections aren't solely about cynical "legal CYA", but valuable warnings to investors. I would not want to take money from investors who think they are getting a sure thing, only from people who understand the risks.
I wonder how many more mobility startups we can dump money into before accepting that it will fail like the five identical companies before it.
I always joke that my humble little website is more profitable than Uber, Airbnb, Lyft, Pinterest, Slack, Dropbox and a few other companies combined, and was so since day 1. (E: not Twitter)
Maybe I think too small, but when I divide these companies' losses by their number of users, I can't imagine how they could possibly work if they weren't sustained with massive amounts of money.
Also consider all the secondary effects as hopeless companies pay for B2B services from other companies in the chain. I think the value of ads and tracking is vastly inflated as a result of this bubble.
It's trivial to send an auto manufacture into a financial tailspin. Frankly, it's amazing that so many manufactures have survived for this long.
And Facebook wasn't profitable once, too.
Here is Facebook's early financial history (2004, 2005, 2006 all showed losses):
2007 | $153m sales | -$138m net income
2008 | $272m sales | -$56m net income
2009 | $777m sales | $229m net income
2010 | $1.97b sales | $606m net income
2011 | $3.71b sales | $1b net income
By the time Facebook was 13 years old it was running at ~$16 billion profit.
My point was exactly this really.
Both Twitter and FB were founded at roughly the same time and went public at roughly the same time.
One was a huge success, one wasn't.
Asana hadn't been a big success, but Trello was.
There is some luck involved here, but the VC game is about trying to find the outsized returns, not avoiding losses.
EDIT: Yes, it's apparently up ~53 million now. I replaced Twitter with 5 other giant companies that are losing money.
Profits are just money a company has been unable to invest in growth.
The fact that it is bootstrapped prevent it to operate without being profitable. That is tied to the definition of bootstrapped.
On a more nuanced tone. You can be bootstrapped in the note-taking space. Yeah this specific guy did not manage to do it. But he is a specific case (Excluding the fact that he had 10M of cash, who has that ?). He wanted the differentiation point of his company to be the product and only product. This is a pretty risky strategy to follow. Usually you want to differentiate yourself in several areas.
Seriously any company that goes out of business because of another company doesn't tell you the full story. There are very very few areas in which you will go out of business because of another company competing with you, and certainly note-taking, a space populated with thousands of companies
What ways can you differentiate yourself? I mean he admits that Asana was VC funded and started with a crappy product that later became fleshed out to be better than his by hiring better devs, better designers, etc. While he was focusing on marketing and whatnot, Asana was burning VC money for marketing and hiring a better team. So yeah, honest question, did I miss out on any other factors?
And just as the twitter thread demonstrates users will ask for more features and you need a load of cash to deliver. And Flow is still around.
The problem is not diversity, it's productivity of startups and more directly the cost of product development (which is of course itself inflated due to endless money).
This is the state of play in the SaaS business.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1640147/000162828020...
If you're doing it out of your own bank account, you'll bankrupt before realising this return: it's not a lifestyle business.
There is volume discount as you grow.
There is upsell potential on the customers you've signed.
As your signed customers grow their pockets grow to spend more on the solution.
Takes about 3-6. If I use Snowflake today at company X without issue and I switch jobs in a couple years to a new company that hasn't picked their platform, what do you think most people will pick?
Basically yea. This effect is just assumed in the world of physical products. As long as you're growing you're nearly out of business because you need to use N revenues to buy your next N+1 of stock.
And could well be priced as a loss-leader purely to upsell the rest of their ever growing stack in the future.
I wouldn't be betting on Asana surviving such a direct, sustained attack from a well capitalised company.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/16/technology/moviepass-econ...
But from a broader social consideration of allocation of capital, I think it’s terrible because (as another comment says) it’s not sustainable. Eventually the market will find the way forward, this is the exuberance period of free markets. We don’t know of a better system imho. But it doesn’t make it any less terrible.
We should try to get (back) to the point where companies actually need to make a profit in order to survive.
It's a depressing thought, really. There is no use in attempting to play by the rules and building something useful for an effort that can justify the results. Governments don't care about that. What they care about is that you're doing something. Exactly what you're doing, doesn't matter.
I had this happen with a company called Spotlife that competed with us in a niche (live video over the internet for consumers, something we now consider to be common and easy, but which was neither back in the day). Fortunately we had some very loyal customers and held on until they died but it was pretty ugly.
I'm pretty sure the majority of all acquisitions in the VC-backed startup space are like this. They aren't real in the sense that they'd be happening independently. They're the VCs bailing themselves out.
This is interesting to hear. From my research last year, it’s more expensive compared to Jira. I had to use Asana at work for high-level planning and it was, in my experience working as an engineer, an inferior product compared to Jira. The only upside I could see is the reporting/project overview and search. But these features are only useful to the manager. For me, it’s just a cumbersome tool. I’ve tried to get used to it, but I wasn’t sold.
Some things that made it difficult to use Asana: - No markdown support for the longest time. - No code block formatting. - Old comments collapsed by default, which hides the full context. This caused people to miss information and ask questions that were already answered.
I do realize Jira and Asana are not trying to address the same problem space. But to manage a team of engineers I would pick Jira every time.
I mean... _years_ without profitability. That's a long time.
If you try to bring rationality to money you're going to lose. None of it really makes sense and the rules get rewritten all the time.
We do not expect to become profitable in the near future, may never achieve profitability, and have incurred substantial net operating losses, or NOLs, during our history.
This is the price of cheap money. VC-backed competitors can simply outspend a bootstrapped company on customer acquisition, marketing, development and hiring, and cash out without the company ever actually making a profit.
In the current environment, a bootstrapped company should ideally be: (a) niche (and therefore outside the traditional VC market crosshairs) (b) profitable from day one.
A to-do list doesn't fit that mould at all, which this guy found out the hard way.
[0] https://sec.report/Document/0001193125-20-228462/