News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by pedalpete on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:02AM (#2660547)
As guelo points out, this is part of the propaganda campaigns,but who's propaganda.

I say go with your gut and do what's right. We know that burning gasoline and coal releases carbon and are dirty.

We know we should be clean.

Strip mining, not clean. Recycling, clean. Wind looks cleaner than a smokestack, go wind. Solar, well, if the panels are made from plastics are they really cleaner than gas? I think so, go solar, etc. etc. etc.

It gets confusing when you get down to the level of ethanol, but I think for the most part you know in your gut what's right.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by ars on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:21AM (#2660586)
Except your gut is wrong. Recycling is not really clean. For some things maybe but not for everything (it uses far too much water).

Solar? Not clean at all. (For photovoltaic which is what most people mean. Solar thermal is good though.)

And just because they are made from plastic means nothing. Plastic is cleaner than wood you know (i.e. uses less energy to make and use).

There is a fact that no one wants to acknowledge: In timeframes of under 20 or so years there are NO energy technologies that are clean. None. For timeframes longer than 20 there is exactly one: Nuclear. There is nothing else.

A solar cell will probably fail before it manages to return more energy than it took to make (it's hard to say for sure though how long they will last, none have been around long enough yet). Wind can never be more than a minor part of the energy supply. Hydro is fully tapped out. Geothermal causes earthquakes. What else is there? Maybe solar thermal, but that requires a huge amount of electrical wires (the energy source is very far from the consumption point), too much apparently since no one is doing it except for some tests.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by varjag on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:51AM (#2660641)
Fusion. The ultimate, clean energy generation potential.

Also, don't discount wind that fast. The typical "it will have to whole country with these 1-2 MW turbines" line of argument is old. Modern offshore turbine designs are 6MW, getting to 10MW by 2012 and 20MW designs are in the works now. Advances in the field have been massive just in under a decade, with higher output efficiency (gearless designs) and less overall maintenance effort.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by ars on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:11AM (#2660664)
The trouble with wind is the variability. And even if you assume that there is always good wind somewhere, the energy grid just can't handle shifting power back and forth so quickly.

It takes time for the other generators to change output levels, so during high speed wind turbines tend to get disconnect from the grid because of the harmful effects they have on it.

The net result is that they don't produce out as much energy as expected.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by varjag on Thursday June 16, 2011 @07:18AM (#2660775)
> It takes time for the other generators to change output levels, so during high speed wind turbines tend to get disconnect from the grid because of the harmful effects they have on it.

Traditionally, a wind turbine generator works only in narrow range of speeds (say, 2000 rpm). In older designs the variable speed of wind was addressed by using a (massive) gearbox, not unlike what you have in your car. The newer designs (e.g. what Siemens Windpower is churning out now) are gearless, don't suffer from that problem, and have in ballpark of 40% better energy efficiency.

The cap/penetration effects of wind power on the grid are being studied, but on levels below 1/5th of total consumption it is believed to not cause any substantial problems. Most of the existing grids can accommodate that. I think no country approached the 20% wind power penetration yet.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by sethg on Thursday June 16, 2011 @09:06AM (#2661060)
I forget the name of the company, but some guy is working on electric cars with swappable batteries: the idea is that instead of plugging your car in overnight to “refuel” it, you would take it to a service station and change the discharged batteries for charged ones.

Now imagine that the outlets for charging those batteries were connected to a wind-powered grid, where the power company charged a lower rate in exchange for less reliable availability. That kind of service would suck for running, say, an Internet data center, but it would be adequate to make sure that all the batteries that came in by 6:00 pm were fully charged by 6:00 am.

Voilà! Two problems solving each other.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by dagw on Thursday June 16, 2011 @09:23AM (#2661115)
Most of the big car companies are experimenting with some sort of battery swapping concept. The problem is that they all have to get together and agree on some sort of standard interface, power ratings and dimensions. If a service station has to stock dozens of different models of batteries then the idea has basically failed before it even gets started.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by jberryman on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:53AM (#2661762)
So, energy is hard, let's go shopping?

Yes, we need a smarter grid, we need a breakthrough in battery technology, etc., etc. The way forward is going to be hard and take serious investment in technology, but what else is new?

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by matwood on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:36AM (#2660964)
I would love to see some offshore wind turbines, but as soon as that's brought up the rich people from both the left and right decide they don't want to ruin the views from their beach houses.

It seems like so many people want everyone else to be clean while being dirty themselves.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by sethg on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:56AM (#2661034)
The “Cape Wind” project saw massive opposition from residents of Nantucket... but they failed to block its approval.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by AlisdairO on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:57AM (#2660652)
Thorium molten salt reactors are potentially a good option - nuclear that doesn't produce much in the way of dangerous byproducts, and can't melt down. China's investing quite heavily in them iirc.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by ars on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:08AM (#2660662)
Those aren't quite ready for primetime yet though. It'll be decades before we are getting energy that way, even if there was concerted research.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by randallsquared on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:08AM (#2660888)
Except your gut is wrong. Recycling is not really clean. For some things maybe but not for everything (it uses far too much water).

Well, recycling might use too much energy to be clean (depending on how we get the energy), but using too much water doesn't seem a useful complaint, since cleaning and reusing water is just a matter of more energy.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by dhs on Thursday June 16, 2011 @12:09PM (#2661861)
Energy which, the parent argues, comes from un-clean sources - that's the complaint. How is this complaint not "useful", as long as you don't rebut it by listing those possible energy sources which you consider "clean"? Then I might be convinced and say: "He's right, dirty water doesn't matter, since we can just clean it, using this guy's clean energy sources."
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by randallsquared on Thursday June 16, 2011 @02:04PM (#2662440)
The parent was arguing that recycling processes use too much water, which implies taking in fresh water and tossing it after "use". I didn't infer that the later energy discussion was part of that, since it seemed clear that filtering or distilling the water to clean it wasn't part of the assumed cleanliness of recycling. It would, of course, make it more expensive, but reducing externalities by such means makes the price reflect the true cost better, so that's all to the good, whether or not it turns out that recycling is really a good idea for a given material.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by jberryman on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:46AM (#2661725)
> There is a fact that no one wants to acknowledge: In timeframes of under 20 or so years there are NO energy technologies that are clean. None. For timeframes longer than 20 there is exactly one: Nuclear. There is nothing else.

I'm skeptical of this figure, but it's not particularly relevant. The issue is whether directing energy towards renewable energy production has a better environmental impact vs directing that same amount of energy towards fossil fuel energy production.

Total evaluations of the costs (in dollars, to the environment, etc.) are extremely important in comparing energy production methods, but your 20 year figure is fairly meaningless on its own.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by Luc on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:23AM (#2660590)
> for the most part you know in your gut what's right.

For complex issues, that is the worst advice possible. Humanity is barely rational as it is. The last thing we need is politicians (and those who elect them) 'going with their gut'. This really is an anti-intellectual stance.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by j_baker on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:16AM (#2661592)
No it's not. Something like "Stupid academics and their ivory tower global warming theories" is anti-intellectual. The grandparent just values intuition above hard data. I don't necessarily agree, but don't go calling the grandparent anti-intellectual and rant about humanity's lack of "rationality" just because you disagree with them.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by Luc on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:43AM (#2661709)
> No it's not.

Well, yes it is, by definition.

Paraphrased from Wikipedia: Anti-intellectualism is a mistrust of intellect, and the derision of science as impractical. Gut feelings are emotional reactions, generally regarded as not modulated by conscious thought, and as a reflection of intuition rather than rationality.

That seems pretty clear to me, so I will gladly call this advice to follow the gut anti-intellectual.

Furthermore, I think it's to be actively opposed in the public sphere. Politics in general is all about the gut feeling, and favouring non-rational solutions to complex issues is simply dangerous, especially far-reaching ones like this one. If that is 'ranting' to you, then so be it.

Lastly, I am not disagreeing with his opinions (I agree with several of them, though that's not relevant), I am disagreeing with the 'go with gut feeling' stance.

Just in case you were not trolling...

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by dodo53 on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:14AM (#2660570)
The problem is that climate change and green energy are so complicated and political, it's hard to tell what is propaganda (and there's strong incentives in many different directions for the results to come out in a given direction). Ethanol used to sound like a good idea; now it sounds like it's mostly a corn/sugar-lobby way of getting money and not practical (although I'm sure it's not that straightforward).

For 'wind looks cleaner' - the Register argues that mostly it'll end up making energy more expensive without being much cleaner (in this one case in the UK), due to perverse incentives: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/06/14/national_grid_2020/

I think 'gut feeling' is exactly what we don't need. Things are not always intuitively obvious.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by david927 on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:38AM (#2660617)
climate change and green energy are so complicated and political

There isn't much complicated about it climate change: the full consensus is that it's happening because we're burning too much oil.

The politics? Less than 10 years ago, the world's largest industry was oil when the price was roughly stable at around $20 a barrel.

Today a barrel costs $100. For something the world consumes at a thousand barrels a second, that's huge. At the price a couple weeks ago, it was a better investment to buy the world's biggest commodity than Google when it IPO'd. You might want to read that again.

Climate change is a force of urgency in the switch away from oil to green energy. You can be sure it will be fought every step of the way with every tool available.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by ars on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:13AM (#2660669)
It's not oil, it's coal that is the main source of CO2.

And green energy does not exist, so good luck switching to it.

People tend to assume "it will be fought every step of the way" because they refuse to believe the truth: it does not exist.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by bjelkeman-again on Thursday June 16, 2011 @09:47AM (#2661202)
Green energy does exist.

If by “green energy” you are referring to energy production that is renewable or doesn’t produce significant CO2 emissions, then it does exist.

Here are some examples from Sweden:

District heating systems in Sweden has switched from being nearly entirely fossil fuel based (oil mainly) in the early 70s (15 TWh) and following decade (35 TWh) to be nearly entirely renewable energy in 2009 (59 TWh total of which biofuel, waste, peat, heat pumps and waste heat make up more than 45 TWh). [1]

District cooling has gone from zero in the early 90s to supply 800 GWh in 2009. This includes using sea or lake water in district cooling systems, where the system in Stockholm makes up for nearly half of that production. [2]

Swedish total energy use in 2009 is about 568 TWh. [3] Sweden has increased its renewable energy use from about 34% in 1990 to 44% in 2009. [4]

Electricity production in Sweden is about 49% large hydro, 1.9% wind, 37% nuclear (adds up to about 89%), most of the rest comes from combined heat and electricity production, which uses primarily biofuel, but also some coal, oil, gas and peat.

Sweden has a policy to promote renewables and over the years this has paid off. You can do the same.

---

[1] Department of Energy, Energy in Sweden 2010, Figure 30, page 87. http://webbshop.cm.se/System/TemplateView.aspx?p=Energimyndi...

[2] Department of Energy, Energy in Sweden 2010, Figure 31, page 90.

[3] Department of Energy, Energy in Sweden 2010, Figure 8, page 53.

[4] Department of Energy, Energy in Sweden 2010, Figure 11, page 58.

[5] EkonomiFakta, Electricity production in Sweden, http://www.ekonomifakta.se/sv/Fakta/Energi/Energibalans-i-Sv...

Edit: layout and one missing reference, grammar

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by istarex on Thursday June 16, 2011 @11:22AM (#2661617)
A nit: aren't biofuels, waste and peat only "green" in the sense that they are renewable. In terms of climate change (which is the point of this discussion), these sources still release CO2, no?
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by bjelkeman-again on Thursday June 16, 2011 @04:40PM (#2663152)
Indeed. There is a campaign ongoing in Sweden to classify peat as fossil fuel as it takes thousands of years to recreate a peat bog. However that is how it happens to be classified in Sweden at this moment. If we didn't make waste out of oil, such as plastic bags, but paper bags etc. then waste would be "more"green than it is today. Of course a true recyclables would be preferred.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by ars on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:16PM (#2663819)
Except paper bags are far worse for the environment than plastic. The use more water, more energy to make, more energy to transport, more energy to trash, and more energy (and water) to recycle. They also can not be reused.

They have only one advantage: No litter.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by bjelkeman-again on Friday June 17, 2011 @04:43AM (#2664855)
Interesting, I hadn't looked for the numbers. Washington Post has an informative infographic on the subject.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/graphic/2007/10...

I personally use very few bags as I have cloth bags with me when I am shopping for food etc. A nit, paper bags can certainly be reused, I do it all the time for our recycling, which is kept in paper bags i the garage and sometimes for shopping.

More energy and water use in Sweden is less of a problem, as our energy is largely biofuel, hydro or nuclear, but of course it is better to use less energy. Water we have quite a lot of.

Plastics isn't biodegradable and paper is, but yes, you are right, this is not an easy good/bad choice.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by dodo53 on Thursday June 16, 2011 @05:54AM (#2660646)
I think the greenhouse effect is totally uncontroversial. To what extent the climate will change due to that is slighlty more scientifically controversial, but as uninformed lay person I'd say is fairly broad consensus.

Which green energy choices are economically feasible is much more controversial - there's counterintuitive things like - is it better to subsidize solar/wind while not really feasible to subsidize technology development or build natural gas plants (which are proven to be economically feasible and cleaner than oil I believe - but obviously still a fossil fuel).

Edit: tried googling for gas-is-cleaner-than-oil citation, and found - http://www.propublica.org/article/more-reasons-to-question-w... saying earlier studies may be wrong and it's actually dirtier than coal.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by yters on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:20AM (#2660922)
For some reason the global warming crowd doesn't talk about the fact that the primary greenhouse gas is water vapor. CO2 only makes up something like 10%, and the human caused part only about 4% of that, which is 0.4% overall.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by sethg on Thursday June 16, 2011 @08:54AM (#2661022)
At least according to the Wikipedia “Greenhouse gas” article, it’s hard to measure exactly how much each gas contributes to the greenhouse effect, because different gases absorb and emit radiation at different frequencies.

Regardless of how you work out the proportions, there used to be a homeostasis, where the biological and physical processes that put greenhouse gases into the atmosphere balanced the processes that took them out. The additional CO₂, CH₄, and N₂O from human activity is upsetting that homeostasis.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by yters on Friday June 17, 2011 @06:57PM (#2667413)
Perhaps, but at least proportionally water vapor significantly outweighs carbon dioxide, even more so when you just look at man-made greenhouse gases:

http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/greenhouse_data.html

When you take water vapor into account, man-made greenhouse gases only account for 0.28% of all the greenhouse gas in our atmosphere.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by david927 on Thursday June 16, 2011 @10:57AM (#2661498)
global warming crowd

I don't know if that's the bes term, since I think you'll find it's the same as the evolution crowd and heliocentric crowd.

Your argument is specious -- we're also only talking about it getting a few degrees warmer. If you investigate, you'll find why that's a problem.

Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by vixen99 on Thursday June 16, 2011 @04:05PM (#2662992)
But is it? Where for instance does Doug Keenan go wrong? http://www.informath.org/media/a42.htm (an essay originally published in the WSJ 'What is arguably the most important reason to doubt global warming can be explained in plain English.'.
Re:New ice age? Don't count on it by majmun on Thursday June 16, 2011 @06:51AM (#2660731)
if this is propaganda then this reporter that wrote this: (Michael Marshall, environment reporter) and newscientist works for whoever pay the propaganda. make mental note. (for future reference)